Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Milk~good for you or bad for you?

who's talking here?

blessed 5
Melanie 1
Unichic 2
Sandyr911 3
JG33 7
justme 1
The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 1
MissT 3
Margo 2
ilovemykids1030 1
Scottie's Hottie 1
Loni 1
star7827518 1
Anderson 4
schitphuck 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

blessed --- 20 years ago -

I have a 2 year old girl who is crazy about milk. She would rather have milk to drink instead of juice or water. I have heard many people concerned about milk and other foods.....hormones and junk added to our milk and foods to make it all last longer. I see so many girls these days developing so early in age now. That is what makes me wonder about my little girl drinking sooooo much milk. I need to be more educated about this topic if I am so concerned. Any imput from anyone? 

Melanie --- 20 years ago -

Everyone in our house drinks milk. I drink 1/2 % my kids drink 1 % & my 2 year old granddaughter drinks whole milk. I see all the "Got milk" ads & figure it can't be that bad. I have been drinking milk for a very LONG time (we don't need to go into how long) & do not have any health problems. I love milk! 

justme --- 20 years ago -

I was wearing a bra by 8 and started my period when I was 10...

I didn't drink milk because I couldn't (and still can't) stand it... 

ilovemykids1030 --- 20 years ago -

milk is milk..ya know? i think we eat so many other processed things nowaydays...milk is probably the healthiest processed thing we drink/eat...IMO 

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 20 years ago -

just me, i'm the same way!

blessed, my daughter is the same way as yours. she's 2 also. the only thing that i see as a result of too much milk is she gets constipated from time to time. but we give her juice for a week and she's back to normal. 

Loni --- 20 years ago -

I have allways drank lots of milk, whole milk... I have never had a broken bone or a cavity... Calcium is good..
I beats the heck out of sodas!!!
(now that im older, I have cut back and drink more water) 

Margo --- 20 years ago -

Question of the Week
Q. My son is 21 months old and I am concerned that he may be drinking too much milk. Is this possible? He is a good eater and eats very healthy but he loves milk (he is on homogenized milk). He can drink anywhere from 4-6 8oz sippy cups of milk per day. I was not too concerned about it at first as he was a big baby at birth weighing in at 10lbs 3oz and continued to be above his growth chart, but now that he is older I am concerned. I have researched your site and other articles and all of them give the recommended daily intake but there is no information on the effects of drinking too much milk. I am concerned about his digestive system and if too much milk can harm him. Can you please give me some information on this subject? Jennifer, Canada



A. Milk is usually considered to be very good for you, and it is a good source of protein, fat, and calcium, at least for those children who don't have a milk protein allergy or lactose intolerance.


But you can get too much of a good thing.
Infants and toddlers who drink much more than 16-24 ounces of milk each day can have problems with constipation, but the biggest problem is usually all of the extra calories that they are getting from the milk they are drinking. These extra calories usually either cause a child to be full and not want to eat many other nutritious foods and become underweight, or if they are still eating well, then all of the extra calories can lead to their becoming overweight.

Consider that he is drinking 32 to 48 ounces of milk each day, which at 19 calories per ounce, means that he is getting about 600 to 900 calories just from milk. And that is 1/2 to 2/3 of the estimated 1300 calories that a toddler needs each day.

Plus if your child also drinks a lot of juice, he could be getting almost all of the calories he needs from the milk and juice he is drinking, even though that wouldn't provide him with the right mix of fat, protein, carbohydrates, vitamins, and minerals.

Another big problem is that toddlers who drink too much milk are often at risk for iron deficiency anemia. This is usually because milk doesn't have any iron in it, and because if they fill up on milk, then they don't eat many other foods with iron either.

I recently saw a toddler with severe iron deficiency anemia, who ended up requiring a blood transfusion, and the problem ended up being that he was drinking too much milk and not eating enough healthy foods. The Pediatric Hematologists in our area say that they see it very often too.

On the other hand, if your child doesn't have an iron deficiency (your Pediatrician can do a blood test to check for anemia), eats well, isn't constipated, and is gaining weight normally, even if he is off the charts, then drinking so much milk isn't as concerning.

If you decide that it is necessary, an easy way to cut back on his milk intake is to simply not fill up his sippie cups. Instead of 8 ounces in the cup, just put 5 or 6 ounces. And then maybe stick to just 3-4 cups per day. 

JG33 --- 20 years ago -

I've only ever given my kids organic milk and they love it. It is more expensive but worth it because it is guaranteed free of hormones and antibiotics. The cows are also usually fed grass only.

Here are seven reasons why kids should drink organic milk only:

http://www.organicconsumers.org/organic/seven052505.cfm

In Texas I purchased Horizon Organic or Organic Valley:

http://www.horizonorganic.com/

http://organicvalley.coop/

Read about their farms and you'll see that it is worth it to support farmers of this nature.

My son drank goat milk and ate the cheese for a while but now he loves regular milk only (won't touch the goat milk). My kids only drink milk or water. Occasionally they have a treat of juice or chocolate milk and they think that's the greatest thing ever. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

My aunt had a 300 head dairy farm when I was growing up.....it was so much fun to spend a week there.

But 2 summers ago I went to my gf's house up in Pennsylvania and we went to a neighbors that had a dairy farm with the kids for something to do. I have never in my life seen cows so pumped up on steriods....I kid you not!! Those cows backs were as high and some higher than the top of my head....their udders were huge, about the size of a dorm refrigerator..no joke!!

I was so shocked...I have pics somewhere but not digital. Anyways, we stopped drinking regular milk and switched to organic!! 

JG33 --- 20 years ago -

Scary!! If you can, show us the pics! 

Unichic --- 20 years ago -

Just me wrote:I was wearing a bra by 8 and started my period when I was 10...I didn't drink milk because I couldn't (and still can't) stand it...

Milk is just ONE thing that contributes to xenoestrogen intake. Do you eat beef? Chicken? Why else do you think girls are going through precoscious puberty. It used to be a rarity when I was 10 for girls to have breasts and periods, now it's getting to be the norm.

Blessed, I agree with Anderson. Drink organic. Raw is even better, but I myself can't do it, so I don't drink milk except the ocassional organic chocolate milk. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -



Look at those muscles!!! BTW, this is not a milking cow....but still cows are not suppose to have muscle definition. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -



This is not a pic from my visit to the dairy farm. But this is exactly what I was talking about. There is noone in the picture to give you a sense of how large these cows are....but they are huge!! 

JG33 --- 20 years ago -

REPULSIVE!!!!!!!!!! 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

That poor cow.....I feel sorry for her. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

yep....if I stood on the other side of this dairy cow at the shoulders...you would not be able to see me! And I am not short, I'm right under 5'7" 

Margo --- 20 years ago -

OMG that is awful Anderson......... 

star7827518 --- 20 years ago -

I was told by my daughter's doctor that it is healthier for her to drink flavored milk than juice. He said juice is just empty calories that there is hardly any nutrition to it. Milk on the other hand is very good for you even the fat is essential for a child's brain development. I'm sure that like everything else milk could be bad for you in large quanities. I believe for a 2 yr old the recommended amount of milk is 24 to 30 oz per day. 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

I was told the same thing by my doctor about juice being bad. That is why I try so hard to encourage milk instead of juice but it really isn't working for me. Trust me, blessed, I would be glad she wanted milk! 

Unichic --- 20 years ago -

Water is even bette :). 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

milk servings = 2 or 3 per day (does not have to be liquid...... cheese, yogurt and other dairy products also count)

check out www.mypyramid.gov 

blessed --- 20 years ago -

JG33 and Anderson, Thanks so much for confirming my worries. It is not that I am against milk....it is what they do to the milk to perserve it. Altho it is painfully expensive to buy organic, I think we will stick to that for when milk is desired. I hate wasting organic milk on cereal. What are your thoughts about Organic Rice Milk? Does it have a good amount of calcium? I hate to seem cheap, but I have 5 kids and that can get REALLY expensive when it comes to buying organic milk for a family of 7. 

blessed --- 20 years ago -

JG33, I went to visit with Alice and Miranda today. Miranda was in town and wanted to see the babies born recently. =) 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

I have also switched my son to SOY milk. He likes the chocolate and vanilla flavors... He doesn't get stomach aches anymore and his behavior has improved... imagine that!

Human bodies were not made to digest COW's milk. Breast milk is so mild and then BOOM, when they turn a year old, we switch them to cow's milk.... that just doesn't make any sense if you think about it..... Cows' stomachs are much stronger than human stomachs..... 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

Hmmmm.....Wonder if my kid would try Soy milk?
She was lactose intolerant for the first 2 years of her life.
Now she doesnt care much for milk. May have to try that.


MissT what brand do you buy? 

JG33 --- 20 years ago -

Blessed, That is so wonderful!! I will always love Alice and Miranda. They did an amazing job with me! Both times! I wish they were here! Where did Miranda move to?? Where are they practicing now?? I would love to have an update. And as far as the milk, I know it's expensive! I can't imagine buying organic for five children! Yikes! You can get coupons on ebay for all kinds of organic foods. Also, when my husband and I first got married, I called all the organic food companies that I bought from and requested coupons or comp certificates. Every single one that I contacted sent me a packet of coupons or free coupon tickets. It was time consuming but it really saved us a ton of money! Also, rice milk is good but be careful with Soy as there are mixed reviews on the safety of it. 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

Hmmm chocolate rice milk.....THAT sounds nasty. 

MissT --- 20 years ago -

MissT what brand do you buy?

He seems to like the SILK brand, but the other day I bought the Randall's brand and he liked it just as well (a little cheaper, too) 

JG33 --- 20 years ago -

You're too funny Sandy911. It does sound nasty but it's not too bad. Almond milk can be a delightful treat as well...I prefer good ole full fat, Vitamin A and D milk, just like my Grandpa used to drink! Organic of course :-) 

blessed --- 20 years ago -

JG33~

Miranda is in Seattle now. She got married last June. Her wedding was BEAUTIFUL. Alice has a new birth center downtown Humble. I can't remember the street name. Her birth center had burned down 2 years ago and it was rebuilt. LOOOOONG story. Miranda had gotten pregnant shortly after she got married, but had a miscarraige. She has not gotten preg. again so far. She flies in to help out Alice apprx. every 3-4 months or when they are really busy. Alice really misses her.

I have heard the mixed reviews about Soy. I acutally like the taste of Rice milk over the Soy anyway. I love the idea of calling the organic companies for coupons! That is a GREAT idea! Thanks for your imput. I really appreciate it. 

JG33 --- 20 years ago -

No problem!

I've missed so much! I can't believe Miranda got married and moved back to Seattle. And I am so sorry about the miscarriage! Of all people! I did hear about the center burning down but I never knew if they got another one built or going. I was there when it was the Baby Cottage with the Chiropractor and right after that they bought a new center. I guess that is the one that burned down. Awful! 

blessed --- 20 years ago -

I saw them at the Baby Cottage around that time too! We probably crossed each others paths back then. =) 

JG33 --- 20 years ago -

We probably did! They have touched so many lives! 

schitphuck --- 18 years ago -

 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground