Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Businesses and services on KYS?

who's talking here?

purple people eater 1
blessed 1
mugglemom 1
Frozen Margarita 3
TexasStar 2
harpo 1
angel 3
Sandyr911 2
BeeDubYa 1
outermaga1203 1
Margo 4
c q 5
smartypants 1
Scottie's Hottie 4
grandma again 3
justmy2cents 3
Loni 8
Anderson 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

purple people eater --- 20 years ago -

OK, folks, we need your insight. Over the last two years, we've had many complaints about businesses (and home-based businesses) posting on KYS, as it's a cheap and effective advertising medium. Some of the more "famous" ones have been evil reposters.....

Recently, it seems the complaints have grown, so we wanted to ask you what you thought, what suggestions you had. Should we ban them all together? Charge them more money? We really need your thoughts on this.

Thanks,
Austin and Adam 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

you can't ban them....secondly, let the people try and market their home based businesses....I think it's neighbor helping neighbor (so long as it isn't in direct competition with KYS).....and as long as they are LOCAL to the area....not people from Utah or Iowa! 

blessed --- 20 years ago -

It's never really bothered me. I don't read what I am not interested in. As long as the advertiser keeps it under control and not advertise again and again the same day one post or announcement after another. Know what I mean? I am so tired......need to go to bed..... 

grandma again --- 20 years ago -

Anderson, I agree with you. Some people run home based business because they have to. Most of them realize very little profit and it is a service to neighbors more than anything. Now if it were Wal-Mart that might be a different story. They have big bucks for advertising. I really see very few people getting carried away on KYS with this. All we have to do if they annoy us is move on to the next listing and not buy from them. It is as easy as a click on the keyboard or mouse. I do, however, think all the reposting gets bothersome from time to time. I do not think KYS rates should increase. Lots of businesses are probably trying to realize some profit so they can eventually advertise and link with a webpage...it just takes time. I LOVE KYS and KU and all the people have been great that I have personally dealt with. It amazes me so many people in our community know nothing about it. I just keep spreading the word in hopes it will help SOMEONE sell SOMETHING and I consider that advertising for everyone but I don't charge them for sending someone their way. Did I really confuse you with that?? Hope not. 

c q --- 20 years ago -

You mean like the realtor who's posted a gazillion "items" tonight??? Man, they are really getting on my nerves! 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

oh....well that is a profession.....I think the realtor should let people know she's here if you need her....but to post a bunch of houses??? Heck no! That is poor internet etiquette!! LOL

But again....how can you say yes and no??? It gets tricky I think....I just ignore those types of postings. 

grandma again --- 20 years ago -

Right on! That is going a little overboard on their part. They should just let everyone know they have the service and then let people contact them if they need their service. Rats, I am so agreeable tonight...guess it is time to go to bed, huh? I must really be tired! ha-ha 

Frozen Margarita --- 20 years ago -

In a way I think everyone's trying to make a buck or two.
I'm a small home based business and never try to annoy anyone.
I might be making the same profit as anyone else can in kys.
All I'm happy to get it's leads and contacts because from what I can make out of a single item I sell on kys it's not really much. It's the shows which leave me a profit and that I don't get from kys, I get it from passing the word. What I sell on kys are displayed items or discontinued items that I cannot make much $ of.
I know of a kys member who makes more profit than I do and she's not a business, she's only a member.
But don't get me wrong I am very thankful to KYS for the leads and for the wonderful friendships I've made, man! I even found one of my cousins on kys.
Anyway, just bringing my2cents hoping not to be annoying. 

smartypants --- 20 years ago -

hi admin. i like the links on the home page for businesses and services. it is easier for me to choose btw. yard sale items, and other items. i think it would b a nice compromise to find a way to separate home based businesses and yardsale goods. people looking for yardsale items would have less reposting to look at, and people promoting their business would continue to have a great way to reach a large number of people in their community. ty for asking! 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

I think selling a product is very different than offering a service. We buy "products" everyday off of KYS but a service is different. Whether it is lactation service (which their ads do NOT belong on the announcements boards), yard services, repair services, realtor services, etc. These people should have to pay more than 7.95 a month for a premier account. These are commercial businesses that are looking to sell their services and they should pay more.

Admin: call newspapers, check into other websites, tv, etc. They ALL charge businesses more. That is the cost of doing business. 

justmy2cents --- 20 years ago -

ADMIN: If they were to advertise in the Chronicle it costs about $250+ for a business add compared to $20 for a personal ad - just to give ya an idea of what their free advertisement is costing you - you should charge them more - it is only fair. AND after all, isn't this a yard sale! 

Loni --- 20 years ago -

I advertised our auction when we had it in Humble, and I hope it didnt offend too many people.. I will say I had requests from over 70 people asking about the auction, and they came and got great deals, so I knew they were not offended... I hope this is something you continue to allow..
As long as the company is from the Kingwood area its neighbor helping neighbor... May a seperate section for business???? Just a thought.. 

mugglemom --- 20 years ago -

How do you determine between someone running a business and someone just earning some extra $$$? Do you ask if they have a tax ID? Some are more obvious, but other's like, for example, a Mary Kay rep, would that fall into the business category? I just think that there are a lot of gray areas in determining which are businesses and which are just people trying to earn a little extra money. 

Loni --- 20 years ago -

I agree with mugglemom78 - We do have an auction business as a way of making extra money.. We both work other full time jobs.. The auctions are only a few time a year and I only advertise on KYS when the auction is going to be in the Humble Kingwood Area... I am not opposed to paying a little something for the ad if it comes down to it..

I just think this is a neighborhood site with friendly neighbors , and you guys offer a great service.... How bout lost dogs?? Thats not a "sale" but it is a good neighborly service... Dont take away what makes this site special!! 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

I think services and commercial advertisers should pay more. When you place an ad in the newspaper ( I worked for the sun - now the observer) even if you were offering babysitting it was commercial. Lost and found pet ads were free.

Admin: Why don't you ask other people who run sites if they charge everyone the same? I guarantee you they don't. It is just smart business. People are going to complain no matter what you do but they will always come back to KYS. Kind of like taking away Sundays. I didn't like it but it hasn't stopped me one bit from coming to KYS. 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

Major commercial businesses advertising repeatedly I dont like.
IE: The realtor posting homes.

They should be charged more but then again you are back to how do you know the difference between a stay at home mom and a commercial business type deal.

Reposters will always be here but maybe they can be reminded that constantly relisting things doesnt gain them any business. 

angel --- 20 years ago -

I don't think it is fair to charge more. How do you determine how much to charge? I have a neighbor who actually uses KYS to sell things from her home that the kids have outgrown,etc but occasionally she does advertise her husband's home based business. She does not do it all the time and most of the time she is selling "yard sale" type items. Would she be forced to pay more for her membership because she occasionally wants to advertise and help her husband out? I don't really see how that is fair.
I agree that maybe businesses should not use the announcements section as maybe that does irritate others but just post that under the rules and regulations and if one does come up then admin can delete it (if anyone complains).
I'm all for all the stay at home mom's making an extra buck where they can. I don't read most of the business ads that come across but when I see one that interests me then I will open it up. We don't all just know an Avon person personally so it is nice to be able to find their ad when I am out of lipstick.
Also, maybe there can be a rule that requests that businesses post no more than once a day as a courtesy to others. Maybe if we ask nicely they will comply. 

justmy2cents --- 20 years ago -

ADMIN: Maybe it would be more work but ALL business and services should post on an alternative site - maybe you can set something up like "kingwoodunderground" for them.

We need to go back to the roots of KWYS - it is a yard sale a garage sale. That means people need to sell merchandise - like a yard sale - we do not need to be sold services as that is what the chronicle and flyers are for!

If you continue to let them post charge them 10x the amount - it is only fair - that is what any business in the "real" world has to pay, why not them? Small business or not - money is money! 

angel --- 20 years ago -

10X THE AMOUNT???? Come on! There are some of these stay at home moms who have businesses selling Mary Kay, etc and they don't make the kind of profit that they could afford nearly $80 a month for a membership just so that they could try to make a few extra bucks to help pay for groceries. That's just insane!!!! I say if you don't like reading the ads then just skip over it. I really think the best solution is for admin to request that businesses post no more than 1 line item per day and that should solve everything because we wouldn't see multiple listings by the same person and if they decide not to follow the rules then maybe they can be "grounded" from KYS for a week or something. 

Margo --- 20 years ago -

I agree I think that if you want to change the Yard sale site dont make it so that the stay at home moms that do a little advertising on the site for free or at the same cost as the people selling suffer. Make them there own catigory....Like Buisness advertising or something like that. and limit the amount of posts say they advertise or list on there and then only allow them one listing every 5 days. Something like that so it doesnt get out of control. that way when you go through the site you are looking at what people are selling and browsing what people are advertising. The Services site is good but everyone can post on there limit it to just advertising and review all advertisments first before letting them on something like that............ 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

ROFL! Yes, let's ground them!

KYS started as a yard sale site but we all know it has grown into much more than that. I still think that businesses ads should cost more. It isn't free to advertise anywhere and it shouldn't be here either. They should put a banner ad on the top of KYS like they do here and let them bid for it each week or month. Advertising is outrageous and that is all there is to it. You have to spend money to make money. I think KYS could be an affordable way to advertise for all services that people offer. Even if they paid $20 a month it would be more appropiate than allowing them to pay $7.95 and heck, there are a ton of people who don't even have premiere accounts and still post their ads on there. 

Sandyr911 --- 20 years ago -

$80 thats ridiculous.

I like Margo's idea......Let them know they need to post in "business, or services" and no more than once a week. 

Loni --- 20 years ago -

Sandyr911

I agree,,, I for one could not afford 80 plus I never use the pics I just enter a line ad advertising the auction and have them email me for more info... I dont think it hurts anyone... Its obvious what the ad is about theres not pic to click on you just ignore it if your not interested..
I also only do this a few times a year... so a mtly fee would not be feasible... 

Margo --- 20 years ago -

I mean it would easy for Admin to delete anyone who posts and advertisment for services from the yardsale listing.....I just think that One catigory for those who want to advertise services or their buisness should be able to do so. Any further stuff keep doing it on the side with links to their stuff. 

outermaga1203 --- 20 years ago -

As someone that posts a business I would have to agree with Angel and Loni but I don't think we should be charged 10x the amount. That is completely not fair. I could understand a package right about the Premiere that allows you to post in the business section but it cost $10-$15 a month. I could understand that. I don't go crazy re-posting so I wouldn't mind if there was a limit on how many times we can re-post in a day or week but I think that should be the same for everybody not just the Services section of KYS. We have all got families to support so whether we are posting for extra income or just a shopping fund I think we should all be reasonable with each other. 

c q --- 20 years ago -

Loni,

I don't really see how your auction postings 3x a year are any different than someone who has 3 "yard sales" a year and uses KYS to post date/time/place info on the KYS yard sale calendar. Maybe your auction listings would be best suited as a "Yard Sale" post up above the regular listings. In each case, you are inviting people to your place to purchase goods on a very occasional basis. I think what we are trying to get at here are the people who are posting their "business" ads, which are most probably their main source of income, e.g. the realtor listings or those who post yard services or whatever 10x a DAY. These are the people who are really constipating KYS. I really don't think you have much to worry about as far as the business listings go....but that's just my 2 cents....ya know, not worth much. :-) 

Scottie's Hottie --- 20 years ago -

Well said, cq. I agree with your 2 cents. 

Loni --- 20 years ago -

thanks guys, Im really not trying to abuse a situation.. Just make some money on the side...... you know when the kids need new shoes... I agree if you work for a large firm ie remax... you can afford to advertise elsewhere...
Thanks for the support... Hope this works out for everyone!! 

justmy2cents --- 20 years ago -

I completely understand about the stay at home moms. The bottom line is lot of posting are not for stay at home moms - they are actual companies getting free advertisement. The owers of KWYS are not running a charity - they are running a business - they should just set up an alterntative site for the postings. 

Loni --- 20 years ago -

I would not advertise for selling a home or lawn svc ect.. I only advertised our auctions because people go to KYS to get a great deal... And where better to get a great deal than an auction? thats the only reason I listed it, because it would appeal to a large number of the readers..
I didn't break any rules, if admin sets up rules regarding advertising then I will follow those rules. I just dont understand what the huge deal is .. If the ad is a bus you can choose not to read it... If they dont get bus then they will stop posting... Just a thought>>> I will do whatever everyone decides... I can allways advertise on here... since its a chat forum... 

angel --- 20 years ago -

I agree Loni. I just don't read the business ads that don't pertain to me. I think if someone posts too many times then people will start ignoring the ads and they will lose business and stop advertising on here anyway. I know someone who advertises for a lawn business on the site but they only do it about once a week and besides that she is a stay at home mom and this is the only source of income for the family. I think it is great that they can advertise on the site to help build the business so that they can be successful. I'm sure that they would not mind paying a few extra dollars a month for a business membership but there would have to be a way to monitor who has paid. For example, a different font could be used for all business advertising, kind of like it is bolded text for the premiere members. However, would this person then also have to pay the regular premier member fee so that they could also sell "yard sale" type items? If so, I don't see how that would be fair. And how would you stop all those who post a business but choose not to pay any membership fee? Are you actually going to go and flag every single one and make it your daily job? It would take lots of people to do that and you see how that has worked out with people who repost. After a while people get tired of flagging and just forget about it and then the ad stays. I'm not sure there is going to be an answer that will make everyone happy. I think we all just need to enjoy the site as it is. It is ultimately Adam and Austin's site and if the business ads don't bother them then we will just need to get over it and not read the items we don't want to read. 

Loni --- 20 years ago -

Another point... Severices is listed on the left hand side as a sub
catagory.. As is Property... Just an observation. I think admin
does an awesome job... I know they cant make everyone happy, but
if it aint broke dont fix it... I also believe this probuly started by people posting wants... for example Wanted: Prof Car Stero Installer (currently listed) ... Just a thought.. 

BeeDubYa --- 20 years ago -

Good point, Angel. I have a business which is advertised in the banner ad at the top of this page. 99% of the items we sell are sold on Ebay.

But we do get smaller items that will cost more to sell on Ebay than they will make. Those items seem to fit better on KYS, so we list them there.

I believe it would be better to list businesses in a separate category but businesses would have to have premier memberships. Admin could make sure that the business listings accepted only those with premier memberships.

That way businesses would still have to pay something, stay-at-home moms could still list their items for no extra cost, those who were looking for a service would know exactly where to look, and KYS would have lots of happier campers! 

c q --- 20 years ago -

Okay, Okay ~ I have an idea ~ I'm thinking as I write this, so don't start throwing eggs yet! :-()

Here's the deal. You know how eBay has links to separate categories, like eBay motors, eBay live auctions, etc?

Well, from the KYS main page, we could have links to two other "smaller" sites. The separate categories (I haven't thought of any catchy names yet) would be for KYS Tangible Property under say, $3,000. KYS Tangible Property over $3,000 and KYS Intangibles (Services).

Here's how it would work:

KYS Tangible Property < $3,000
(This is KYS as we know and love it....KYS for ordinary folks.) :-)
- Fees remain the same
- Postings for services would NOT be allowed (item must be physically tangible.) The "Services" category would be eliminated from the KYS homepage and moved to the "Intangibles" section.
- Listings for items with a price over $3,000 (or whatever the limit...I've seen bedroom sets listed this high) would be automatically deleted.
- This would enable homebased moms to still post their items reasonably.
- Reposts WOULD NOT BE ALLOWED FOR ANY REASON until 7 DAYS have passed.

KYS Tangible Property > $3,000
(This would be for KYS'ers who have money to blow.)
- There would be a higher fee FOR EACH ITEM LISTED in this category, like say $5.00. This would still allow individual sellers to say, sell their car or living room furniture set at a reasonable cost, but "businesses" who list like 20 houses would have to PAY FOR EACH LISTING.

KYS Intangibles (Otherwise known as Services.)
So if you are looking for a particular service man, you could look here, first.
Fees would also be assesed FOR EACH LISTING, like maybe $2 a listing. That way for the same $8 Premier members pay, you could have 4 listings/month. Nobody wants to see more than that anyway. It would clean-up KYS and eliminate a lot of reposting by assessing a fee on each one. It would STILL be VERY cheap "Advertising."

Of course, for the second two categories, the "seller" or "service provider" would have to authorize an automatic withdrawl through Paypal for each item that got posted, or keep an itemized list like eBay and bill it to Paypal at the end of the month....I'm not sure how difficult the logistics of doing this would be.

Okay, you can start throwing eggs now..... 

Loni --- 20 years ago -

Im not gonna throw eggs, they could definatly consider and "tweak" your suggestions... Im not opposed to your idea... Its still kinda hard to monitor... Since listings with no pics are free do you just have a person monitoring the site deleting business?? I think your idea has potential though....

Admin,
also consider that people who own sm business also have many contacts and if they are advertising on your site, they are also talking about it with all there clients!!!!! Good word of mouth... nothing beats it!! 

c q --- 20 years ago -

True, but there would no longer be a "Services" category on the KYS main page ....so where would they post their listings? 

Loni --- 20 years ago -

well, that makes since but to some people it doesnt matter, they just want it to hit the 1st page. You can see that if you click on the antique category, people either dont know what an antique is or they just dont care.
I hope if they use your suggestion you get free time for it... 

c q --- 20 years ago -

Well no matter what they do, there will be some logistical issues and issues with people being unhappy with this or that, but I do appreciate your vote (and nod for "free" time, of course)! 

TexasStar --- 20 years ago -

Even the SAHM businesses get annoying. If I want a Mary Kay rep, I can go to Mary Kay's web site and find one. Same with any other businesses. I don't want to know when all the cropping dinners are. I go to KYS to sell and buy stuff. It is a YARD SALE. Now, if someone purchases an item from you or if you buy from someone else, sure - feel free to give them your catalog or business card or whatever, but don't annoy everyone else with it. I have actually stopped going to KYS as often as I used to because of all the business postings. 

grandma again --- 20 years ago -

hum....what is a "cropping dinner"? Please educate me. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground