Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

You be the Judge here......what say you?

who's talking here?

JDB2 1
Lilteapot 1
RRay 1
buzzingo 1
Anderson 1
lLackCreativity 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

RRay --- 20 years ago -

LAWNMOWER MAN by Randy Cassingham By any measure, it was a tragic accident. In April 2004, Orvil Reedy was mowing the lawn with a rider mower in front of his house in Daleville, Virginia. Reedy and his wife, Roberta, operated a day care facility from the house. One of their charges was Justin Simmons, 4. Roberta was watching the boy, and went into the house to change his younger brother's diaper. She left Justin there, sitting on the lawn, unattended. Orvil kept mowing, heading up a slope. The slope was too steep: the mower rolled backward and stalled. He tried to restart it, but then noticed two tiny legs sticking out from under the multi-bladed mower's deck. He screamed. Roberta came running, but it was too late: Justin was dead. Is it outrageous for someone whose profession it is to care for small children to allow them to be anywhere near a machine that could easily kill them? You bet. Thus his parents, Ron and Kristie Simmons, sued, demanding $6 million for Justin's wrongful death. The Reedys had insurance: their insurance company apparently immediately offered the full amount of the policy, $100,000, as a settlement. It wasn't enough; it probably wouldn't be enough for most families whose child was killed in such a violent way due to apparent negligence of a day car provider. Of course, the day care providers would never be able to pay $6 million, so someone else was added to the suit. Can you guess who? Take your time to try to figure it out. -v- Since the Reedys only had $100,000 worth of insurance, and the Simmons family wanted $6 million, they also named the manufacturer of the lawnmower to the suit, MTD Products Corp. What did MTD have to do with the accident? The suit complained that there was no safety device to stop the mower's blades from turning anytime the mower rolled backwards. Is such a safety device standard on other brands? No. In fact, NO mower has such a safety device and, according to MTD's attorney John Fitzpatrick, no device like that has ever even been tested. Further, such a device has never even been suggested by any safety agency, or anyone else, before the accident in question. Still, the case went to trial against the Reedys and MTD in June 2006. In the trial, MTD's attorney laid the blame on the Reedys. He pointed out that Orvil Reedy had not attempted to obtain an owner's manual for the 16-year-old lawn mower and had not paid any attention to the warning labels on the mower. Amazingly, just before the case went to the jury for deliberation, the Simmonses dropped the Reedys from the suit. It is unclear whether they had accepted the original insurance settlement or not, but the jury only had to decide the case against MTD. You, dear reader, are a member of the jury too -- you're a juror in the Court of Public Opinion. How would YOU rule in this case? You may throw it out, and even award damages to MTD. Or you may find for the Simmonses, awarding anywhere from $1 to the $6 million they asked for, or even more if you find MTD's conduct to be "outrageous". But you *cannot* order the Reedys to pay a cent: they were dropped from the suit. OK, so how do you rule? -v- The jury deliberated for 10 hours before finding that MTD was at fault for not inventing a safety device that no one else has, or maybe has even thought of before this accident. "We're just hoping that we make a difference," said Theresa Reed, who served on the seven-person jury in the case. "We just want the industry to see that there's a problem that needs to be fixed." "The jury has spoken loud and clear," said the Simmons's lawyer, Brent Brown, after his triumph. "The protection of small children is one of the most important obligations of society." He said the company was sued not to get rich, but to "get the attention" of the mower industry. The jury awarded Ron Simmons and his wife Kristie $500,000 each, and Justin's now-3-year-old brother, Josh, $1 million for a total of $2 million. "I find it incredulous that a jury no longer cares about common sense," complained Brown, MTD's attorney. He promises an appeal of the "nonsense" verdict. I'm sure not going to fault the parents for wanting some justice for their child, but that justice needs to come from a rational source. The mower didn't have a safety device which didn't exist when it was made in 1988. In fact, that safety device doesn't exist NOW. Worse, it's not even clear that the safety device the plaintiff's lawyer came up with after the fact, even if it was now invented, tested and installed on mowers, would have prevented Justin's death. How could a company "reasonably foresee" such a thing? What's the real cause of this accident? The people hired to watch after Justin failed in their responsibility; the child was left unattended near dangerous machinery. Yet the people responsible for watching after him were let off the hook, and a company with deep pockets was made to pay for their failure, even though they could not have reasonably done a thing to prevent the accident. Why is the intentional act of holding MTD responsible any less outrageous than the Reedys unintentional act? 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Sad, sad case for both families involved. As far as the lawn mower manufacturer---they were robbed!! 

JDB2 --- 20 years ago -

This kind of stuff drives me nuts. I would beg to differ on the values these parents hold. It appears to me to be either vengeance or money! I personally know that I would never sue the manufacturer for anything that was completely beyond their responsibility. I personally wonder how much due diligence went into the selection of the day care? Were they licensed? Was this just an accident? If so, take the insurance money for burial and counseling or for lobbying for better safety. Anything more is simply greed in my opinion! The country is far worse off today due to the attitude of "it's all about me!" Makes me sick personally! Thanks for sharing the story though! 

buzzingo --- 20 years ago -

I saw a similar case where a 16-year-old boy that worked at a country club was speeding around a golf cart and crashed into a deck. No mechanical failures or anything. since the parents signed a liability waiver for him to get that job they sued the golf cart manufacturer. Both cases: Not the fault of the manufacturer in any way, shape, or form. Had the operator followed safety instructions and used due care nobody would have died. If the blade came loose from a safety defect I'd understand, but this is completely different matter. Otherwise, people should start suing auto companies for all wrongful deaths from before seatbelts and airbags were invented. 

lLackCreativity --- 20 years ago -

That is so wrong. MTD had nothing to do with what happened to that boy. Recently a part of my family went through a mower accident. My distant aunt was on it, got stuck, she gets off and leaves running...blades engaged. Pushes mower out of rut, it gets loose and heads for the kids, she tries to grab it, she lost her foot. Who was at fault? She was, I love her and feel horrible, but it was her fault not the mowers. Same thing here. 

Lilteapot --- 20 years ago -

Sad when people make it all about money, and who can pay the most. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

justice
vengeance
lawsuits


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground