Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

ipod vs. creative zen

who's talking here?

unknown 1
Terry 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Terry --- 21 years ago -

Well, I have been looking at these for a little while now. I am getting SO MANY people saying great things about the ipod and then I get some who say no way, go with the Zen. Others are saying well, the Zen is not as popular and so on...... I know there was another thread about this, but I would really like everyone's opinion on which one they have, if there have been any problems with them, how easy it is to download songs, can you download from anywhere, battery life, how long it takes to recharge the battery...etc....... I want to get my daughter one for Christmas. Best Buy is running a special right now for the Zen, you get a free $50. gift card........ I haven't really seen any specials on the ipod yet. 

unknown --- 21 years ago -

Terry - here is the scoop (as I previously posted)

Apple charges $1 per song to download and you can only download from their site; they are not very stable - read - they break easily; when the battery goes out, you have to send it back to Apple and they charge you about $100 to replace it.

As the guy at best buy said - they have the "hot" item and they are taking advantage of it. Fine, that is how free enterprise works. However, I like to get a little more for my hard earned cash and not necessarily what's "hot".

I asked the best buy techie his opionion on what was the best thing out there (not the coolest) then I checked out his recomendations online, etc. and discovered he was right and ended up going with it.

His recommenation: a Nomad jukebox zen extra by Creative......... it is a little bit bigger than a regular Ipod and it isn't available in all those cute colors. However, for about $200 it holds about 3000 (yes, three thousand) songs; you can download from any site, you can even upload your favorite CD to your hard drive and then download to the nomad; when the battery goes, you can replace it yourself with one readily availableand not expensive; very stable; has lots of bells and whistles that you don't get with Ipod - I can't remember what they are at the moment 'cause of brain fog.

In a nutshell, my 13 year old absolutely loves it. She has had it for about 6 months now and it goes EVERYWHERE with us. We haven't had any problems and she is no where near capacity and she is a music fiend!

So if your kiddo's wants it to be "cool" and because it is the hot thing to have, go with the Ipod, but if they are like my daughter and really into the music, this might be a better route for you. My daughter is so glad that we did a little research and didn't just buy an Ipod becuase that is what everyone else had. She wouldn't trade her Nomad for anything.

So, basically all the Ipod has going for it is that it is popular........
When my daughter gets home from school today, I will check with her on how long it takes to charge and all that and I will post it later. I think it plays for about 12 hours without needing to be charged.

If best buy is running a special, I would just go get one. I think as more people learn about the Creative one, it will become the "one" to have, especially with older kids who will want all the music and the flexibilty and not just the pretty colors............

Good luck........... 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground