Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

which car seat to choose?

who's talking here?

Sweetie Pie 1
Momoftwo 5
H and J 1
planemom 1
Pixel Giggles 1
GRL 3
Syrah1214 1
m•t•v 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

GRL --- 19 years ago -

Based on all the great reviews I have read from all the parents on KU, I would love to get the Britax Marathon. Unfortunately, my DH says that spending that much on a car seat is out of the question. So, what do we get that is 2nd best? 

Pixel Giggles --- 19 years ago -

I was a TRU in Humble the other night and actually they had alot of carseats that went to 100 lbs in all price ranges. When we went to BRU they only had 2 choices and one was $100 the other $250 

Momoftwo --- 19 years ago -

Britax doesn't necesarily make the BEST carseat. They do put their seats through alot of extra testing, seats are comfier than alot, etc. The one big thing that I have learned over the last 5 years is that the Britax Marathon would have been a better seat for MY kids. They are both tall and on higher percentage of weight. Most of the carseats on the market only harness to 40 lbs and aren't for taller kids. With that said, both of my kids started out in a Cosco Alpha Omega seat. My daugter was in it til she was 3. My son is now in it and he's 25 months (he is 34 inches). I can see that he will outgrow the Alpha Omega heightwise pretty soon. I don't think the AO was a bad choice, but it would have been better for me to have went ahead and spent the money on a marathon in the beginning. I didn't realize that my kids would be so tall :) THe marathon does harness longer (65 lbs) and accommodates tall kids longer. My 5 year old would probably just now be moving out a marathon. Hindsight is 20/20 though, right? lol. I guess my point is that the best choice for you will depend on the size of your child, their age, how long you want to keep them harnessed for, etc. It's hard to say that one seat is safer than another. A cheap $40 carseat installed correctly that fits correctly to the child, is just as safe as a $269 carseat. If the $269 carseat is installed wrong or doesn't fit the child right, then it's NOT safe. Am I making sense at all? lol. I just bought my first Britax (a regent) a couple of months ago. I am impressed with the quality. BUT, I have also been impressed with the 3 Alpha Omegas I've owned as well. I think there are other good seats out there,you just have to do alot of research. If you are set on the Marathon, there is a Fisher Price Seat that is the same, made by Britax but under the name Fisher Price. This seat is a bit cheaper in price (by about $70-100, I believe). I cannot remember off the top of my head what it's called. I will look for it though if you are interested. I use this message board alot when I am researching carseats. Carseat info 

Momoftwo --- 19 years ago -

BTW, you can tell your DH that I use to think just as he does...that spending that much on a seat is out the question :) WELL, I have spend about $120 on each alpha omega convertible seat that I used til they out grew it heightwise, then spent $45 for a high back Evenflo Comfortsport harnessed booster, and am now on using a $269 Britax Regent for my 5 year old b/c I don't want to move her to seat belted booster. In my mom's car I had to make the switch though and just spend $70 for a seat belted booster. In the end, I have spent just as much as one Marathon would have cost in the beginning and would just now be running out room. The life of a marathon is 6 years and you will more than likely be able to use it for 6 years if you start out using it for a small child. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

GRL, is anyone throwing you a shower? How about asking for the seat as a group gift instead of a bunch of smaller gifts. 

GRL --- 19 years ago -

Momoftwo- Thanks for the info/suggestions. Please let me know once you've found the Fisher Price one. I am definitely interested. :) The life of a marathon is 6 years and you will more than likely be able to use it for 6 years if you start out using it for a small child. This is important to me and one of the reasons I am for the Marathon. My DH is tall and I think my DD will be as well. Is the Fisher Price the same as the Marathon for height and long lasting (6 years)? 

GRL --- 19 years ago -

planemom-I already had a shower but that would have been a good idea. :) My DD is 10 months old now and it's time to get a new car seat for her. Can't put it off any longer. 

Momoftwo --- 19 years ago -

Fisher Price Safe Voyage If you go to this link, you will see alot of comments and info about the FP version. It looks like it goes 10 lbs lighter (55 lbs) than the marathon. It may be worth checking in to. I do know Burlington Coat Factory carries them if you want to look at one. Good luck in your choice :) If I had it to do over again and mine were 10 months old and I wanted to keep them harness for atleat 5 years, I would go with the marathon or the FP version. I think it would have saved me alot of heardache and time in the end! I have stressed SO much over seats for my 2 kiddos. Heck, now that I am nearing the end of carseat days I feel like I am half way figuring this mess out :) It's not easying buying seats. 

H and J --- 19 years ago -

A lot of my friends have an Evenflow Triumph and love it. It was rated very high (maybe even #1) on Consumer Reports (higher than the Marathon). It seems very nice, soft, comfy, and safe. I think it retails from 99 - 139 depending on where you get it and which version you get. I love the Britax Boulevard (we have the wizard which is the precursor to the Boulevard) and it is pricey... but my dd sleeps in the car and those head wings are great for her to rest her head on. 

Momoftwo --- 19 years ago -

Epinions on the Fisher Price Voyage Deluxe 

Sweetie Pie --- 19 years ago -

I hear that Sears has some Britax, 2 discontinued models, on sale, in store only. I think it's the one that starts with a P ? and the Boulevard but I'm not sure. I heard they were under $100.00. I wasn't paying too much attention since my youngest is 3 and in the Britax (big one for toddler size). I'm bad with the models. I hope this ranting post helps somebody, LOL! 

Syrah1214 --- 19 years ago -

Britax Boulevard for under 100 bucks?! I paid over 300 for each one of mine!!! Those things go for a lot on ebay, that's worth a buy and sell for profit! 

Momoftwo --- 19 years ago -

I bet it is the Parkway, which is the seat belt booster if it's around $100. I cannot imagine the convertible carseat being that cheap :) My DD throw a fit over the Parkway, it was way too padded and had too much of a head side wing that made her sit forward. I wasn't impressed with the Parkway at all. 

m•t•v --- 19 years ago -

I totally understand where you're dh is coming from... we went with the Evenflo Triumph DLX because it was rated second only to Britax (I'm a safety psycho!!!), but was half the price... and I know I've seen them @ Wal-Mart... Good luck! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children
parenting
recommendations


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground