Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

When You Get a New Credit Card, Should You Sign It or Not?

who's talking here?

QueenCassie 1
gking 4
CBD 1
Syrah1214 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

gking --- 19 years ago -

by Brian Chow When you get your new credit card, such as American Express, MasterCard, and Visa, in the mail, do you immediately sign on the back of it? Many would sign on the signature panel because the welcome letter instructs you to sign in order to protect your card and validate your credit card. Plus, a signed credit card would allow the retail clerks to compare your signature to the ones on the receipts. It sounds reasonable, or does it? Have you ever thought that if a thief steals your credit card, they would have your signature? They could imitate it in a shopping spree. If they steal your checks as well, they could sign your checks and drain your bank account. Others have thought about this scenario, so they recommend you to keep the signature panel blank, so that the clerks will always ask for your photo ID to verify your identity. But wait, look at the back of your credit card, and you will see a statement, “not valid unless signed.” If you do not sign it, then your credit card is deemed invalid by the merchants and your card issuer. Moreover, a blank signature panel would allow a thief to sign their signature and still charge to your account. What should you do? Here are the recommendations of different online sources. According to the staff at The Straight Dope, you should not sign it at all because the signature is “useless as a deterrent.” Instead, write “Ask for Photo ID” in the signature block and “be prepared to back that up someday when you’re in a hurry and the clerk wants to see a driver’s license as well as the card.” However, writing just “Ask for Photo ID” does not validate your credit card; it needs your signature. Herb Weisbaum, the consumer reporter from KOMO 1000 News Radio, says, “You can write ‘See ID’ on the card, but you still need to sign it… If the card is not signed, the rules from Visa and MasterCard say the clerk is required to ask you for picture ID and have you sign the card on the spot.” On the official Visa site, it informs the merchants that a signature must be on the signature panel. According to Museum of Hoaxes, your signature not only helps to verify who you are, but also “demonstrates that you’ve agreed to the terms of the contract with the credit card company.” These sources suggest adding “See ID” to your signature can improve the protection of your credit card and are acceptable to the card issuing companies. Melissa Wolff, the loss-prevention and compliance manager for the Washington State Employees Credit Union, confirms that it is acceptable for having both elements on the signature block. But, how effective does “See ID” work in the first place? Do you find that many clerks do not bother checking the signature anyway? To illustrate this phenomenon, John Hargrave at ZUG pulled “The Credit Card Prank.” In the prank, he tried to sign his signatures differently whenever he used his credit card. His signatures ranged from simplistic, to messy, and to non-sensical: “I stole this card” and “Please Check ID.” With these signatures, he was able to pay almost all of his purchases. His experiment shows that the many clerks did not check his signatures at all. The result of this experiment indicates that adding “See ID” to the signature block offers only a little extra protection than just a signature alone. You still need to employ other methods to safeguard your credit card. These methods are available from authoritative financial sources, such as Visa and MasterCard. __________________ 

CBD --- 19 years ago -

you don't have to sign the back they say to but you don't have to they still work just fine 

gking --- 19 years ago -

CBD - According to the credit card issuers - you do. It's the lazy and ineffective merchants that aren't enforcing this. THAT is why "they still work just fine." It is inaccurate to say that you don't have to sign them. I quote from the above article: your signature not only helps to verify who you are, but also “demonstrates that you’ve agreed to the terms of the contract with the credit card company.”  

Syrah1214 --- 19 years ago -

I did this once, and one day, a merchant told me I had to sign it before they could take it... not to mention, 99% didn't ever ask for my photo ID. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

not to mention, 99% didn't ever ask for my photo ID. Asking for a photo ID is not required by the credit card issuers. This is a measure that merchants have implemented in an effort to reduce fraud and risk on their end. If you want to start a ruckus - as long as your credit card is indeed signed, you are not required to show any other ID in order for a merchant - sporting that card's logo on their door (or window or cash register) - to accept your card. If they ask for an ID, it is in violation of the credit card issuer's terms, and you can refuse. If the merchant then refuses to accept your card - it's been properly presented to the merchant (i.e. signed) mind you - then you call the number on the back of the card and raise hell. They'll end up accepting your card or dealing with problems with Visa or MC, etc. for "making" one of their cardholders do something they are not required to do to be accepted. NOW - on the other hand, it kind of brings me comfort to know that a merchant is taking steps to prevent fraudulant use. They are more interested in reducing their own risk than yours, mind you - but, if they are actually affirming an ID and not just eyeballing my personal information for no productive reason, or writing down numbers they don't need - then I welcome it. 

QueenCassie --- 19 years ago -

My Mom daoes not sign any of hers,just has printed "See Photo ID" written in big print on the panel. 90% of merchants never even look or ask for ID! It amazes me.And now most merchants have the machines where you swipe your own card,which gives you no security at all. 

gking --- 19 years ago -

90% of merchants never even look or ask for ID! Not surprising. I suspect we'll be seeing some new "terms" of use and acceptance pretty soon. Especially with the self-serve and online purchasing that has become so prevalent. I'd like to see them start including fingerprint readers on all computer keyboards and "self" check out machines. That might be one way to make everyone - but the thieves - happy. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground