Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Do you think welfare contributes to fatherless families?

who's talking here?

adam 1
FirePrincess 1
Jen 1
Liane 2
KatieR 1
cmi 1
I Love Horses 1
buzzingo 1
planemom 3
Anderson 4
Splendor 1
mdawg 1
lilmommy 2
CyberSage 7
mykidsmom 1
funmom 1
cowboyswife 1
NoNameNoLastName 1
caitlin 1
missym 1
Mygirl01 2
Catgirl 2
lonesophist 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do you think welfare contributes to fatherless families?

Do you think the high rate of fatherless babies is a direct "response" to welfare and other social programs?

Yes Vote
 
 66.0% (35)
No Vote
 
 30.2% (16)
Unsure Vote
 
 3.8% (2)
Anderson --- 19 years ago -

Do you think the high rate of fatherless babies is a direct "response" to welfare and other social programs?  

Catgirl --- 19 years ago -

Yes and/or someone with too many kids. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

Welfare allows men to take no responsibility for their children. The sad truth is women who need welfare don't have the means to sue for childsupport. Or may be since the state will pay welfare it has become the norm to not sue for childsupport. That way daddy won't be mad and might come see his kids. 

adam (Wizard) --- 19 years ago -

welfare means less personal responsibility is required for whoever is the recipient of the welfare. an ideal welfare system would provide assistance without removing personal responsibility. 

Liane --- 19 years ago -

I think that society in general contributes to fatherless families. I am a single parent (have always been, was never married). I agree in part, but think the there would still be unwed mothers and fatherless families reguardless of welfare. AND lots of children being born who would not live without the benefits of healthcare. My son would have died and I am so thankful that I was able to get on assistance. I think our government needs to take a long hard look at our healthcare system. My son is on medication that is medically necessary ($1000 a month)and they are not covering it for the longer months in the year since I get paid weekly through my temp agency I will receive 5 checks in the month of March, Nov, and June and my son will not be eligible for health care, so lets PRAY that he doesnt have any problems with his heart, blood sugar, or Autism and doesnt get sick. People who have abused the system have made it difficult for those of us who just need a little help. Don't lump all of us in the same basket. Life doesn't work that way. My sons condition is pre-existing since he was born with a heart condition. I cannot get him on insurance even if I could get hired on perm. I have tried to apply for CHIPS, but since I dont have a husband, stay at home and have a bunch of other kids we are not eligible. The drug rep for the medicine he needs says that as long as he has coverage for some months they wont help us. So drop your health coverage and we will send you medication...what is wrong with the system? It is a chance I can't take. SORRY TO HIJACK... 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

I think that society in general contributes to fatherless families. That is true. Having a child as a teen or an unmarried women is accepted as normal. Many of the consequenses have been taken away. It is accepted that boys (real men won't abandon their children) don't have to take responsibility for their children. This is across all race and economic groups. 

Splendor --- 19 years ago -

an ideal welfare system would provide assistance without removing personal responsibility. I whole heartedly agree! 

Liane --- 19 years ago -

an ideal welfare system would provide assistance without removing personal responsibility. I agree also 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

I believe that in order to recieve benefits from welfare, you must provide the name or names of the father for the state to test their DNA. If they have a job or have any money then they should pay for the support of thier child. I think it would be cheaper for the state to preform DNA test and get money from some of those men, then the amount of money that is given out and the father has no responsibility for making that child. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

Duh - what a softball question. 

cowboyswife --- 19 years ago -

. People who have abused the system have made it difficult for those of us who just need a little help. That is soooo true!!! 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

People who have abused the system have made it difficult for those of us who just need a little help. I couldn't have said it better myself.... 

FirePrincess --- 19 years ago -

The sad truth is women who need welfare don't have the means to sue for childsupport. Not always true. If you go into the food stamp office and apply for TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families), they will give you an upfront amount of money if you agree to let them sue for child support. Once you get the child support, it's paid back. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

Mygirl, "I believe that in order to recieve benefits from welfare, you must provide the name or names of the father for the state to test their DNA. " I think there is paper work for that...but---the state is so overloaded with cases people want to get to court, that they don't hardly get to the other cases where the woman doesn't care. I have to say---those that abuse the welfare lifestyle know all the tricks of the trade. Who's the babies daddy?---"I don't know" is the most common answer. WHY? Because the boyfriend promises he'll never leave, that he will help her if she doesn't report him as the daddy. Plus, she doesn't want to loose any benefits if he is ordered to pay child support---child support that won't come on a regular schedule like the welfare check does. 

planemom --- 19 years ago -

Well said Anderson. Welfare comes on a regular basis, a bum may or may not work so you may or may not get child support. There are so many ways to get out of paying child support. It is sad. 

missym --- 19 years ago -

I think bitter Ex-wives contribute to fatherless families by brainwashing their children.....I have seen this from 1st hand experience...so sad for the children...Also-ex-wife continues to have said child on Medicaid even though DH & I have always kept good health insurance on this child. Can you say Fraud!!! I do agree that the people who really need assistance should receive it...so sorry for you Liane. Hope you get help! 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

I have tried to apply for CHIPS, but since I dont have a husband, stay at home and have a bunch of other kids we are not eligible. Chips is a joke..... I called once, about 4 years ago, because we didn't have health coverage..... They wanted us to pay 650/month for just two kids...... I found an independent company that covered all of us for 800/month.... I'm grateful nothing really bad went wrong during those three months and we were able to pay cash for doctor visits. But geeeesh...... That's highway robbery for just insuring your kids. 

caitlin --- 19 years ago -

The welfare system needs fixed. Why give a hand out to women who keep having babies. They know who the father is. Go after these fathers and start making them pay the welfare system back for supporting their kids. The system makes it to easy for women to get and abuse it, while the fathers get a free ride and go out and make more babies. That is just wrong. Fix the system, then fix the people that keep having babies to get welfare. 

KatieR --- 19 years ago -

I would say no, of the single mom's I know none have ever been on welfare. Not having the father active in the child's life did not play a factor to collect welfare. On the other hand I know many married couples whom of one spouse or both has collect unemployment benefits, does this count as welfare? Than again most of these women (back to the single mom's) come from the same type of family background. Maybe other backgrounds may not fair so well. Welfare has a place, as caitlin said it just needs to be fixed. 

mykidsmom --- 19 years ago -

I don't think Welfare causes irresponsible people to procreate. 

I Love Horses --- 19 years ago -

My mother has 13 children and only had to go on welfare when she left my dad! she did it to get back on her feet. that was years ago and now she no longer needs it. I definantly think tons of people abuse the welfare system but there are people that really do need it too. I recieved medicaid once when the job i worked at didnt have medical insurance but i was ineligable for anything else and they did file for child support from my ex! went to court and the whole thing but he skipped the country so i never recieved any money from him! 

lonesophist --- 19 years ago -

For a woman to even receive welfare, she has to sign a form stating that the attorney general can go after the father for child support. When the AG is able to get child support ordered and garnished from the father's wages, the state is paid back for any welfare monies given to the mother. No woman can draw welfare and not sue for child support. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

I would say no, of the single mom's I know none have ever been on welfare. ...and unfortunately, statistically speaking, I can likely identify the race of most of the single moms you've known. Sadly, there is a black urban culture in our land than equates female adulthood with parenthood, without marriage even entering the picture. Don't shoot the messenger; rather, work toward changing this attitude. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

Further, we can complete the cycle by saying that the absence of a father - either through divorce or illegitimacy - is the biggest contributor to women and children ending up on welfare. More public assistance leads to more irresponsible behavior, and more children, and more welfare... A culture of dependency ensues, and before you know it, you have 3rd and 4th generations of children (or 35 years - whichever comes first) being born into welfare, growing up on welfare, having children into welfare, etc. Deep down inside, I suspect nobody wants it, but nobody knows how to get out either. If your parents did it, your grandparents did it...it becomes just like sharecropping, coalmining...you do it because it's there. If it all of a sudden weren't there, you'd either starve or get a move-on. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

cybersage, "black urban culture in our land than equates female adulthood with parenthood" This is very true and unfortunately the ideology is spreading to the hispanic community. In south american it is still not widely acceptable to have children out of wedlock---but all of a sudden there is a surge in unwed hispanic girls having babies in the USA. 

Mygirl01 --- 19 years ago -

If they claim not to know who the father is, then no help. they can get a job and support thier kids. My mom had me in HS and nobody offered to help her and we were never on welfare, she was too proud. Her parents threw her out and she made it work, and she was still a kid herself. She did what she had to do to make ends meat! She worked while I was in school and went without a fancy car, new handbags, clothes, hair do's, manicure's, we had food and a roof over our heads and at times it was hard.... I would have to say fess up, or we can't help you...that may just be the kick in the you know what some of these people need to learn how to help themselves. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

It's a bit ironic that among white Gen-Xers there's this tendency to get married and then delay parenthood to the point that it is almost physically impossible to perform the act necessary to produce offspring. Among black women, there is a cultural pressure to have children without even a thought of getting married. Along with living together outside of marriage, all three attitudes are unbiblical, and should be more directly addressed by the Christian community. 

Jen --- 19 years ago -

STUPID poll question-sorry! I raised my son, since his father left me when I was 5 months pregnant. My son is 12 now and not once, did I ever get any benefits from the Government, State or even his school. I have paid for everything he has ever needed. Luckily I had a great job, making enough $ and had insurance. If I had not, I am sure I would have needed help from the "system". **All I can say is, I hope I never need assitance, but IF I did, I would be grateful to have it! 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

I have paid for everything he has ever needed. Good for you - too bad we can't run a country on anecdotes. 

Catgirl --- 19 years ago -

Question: Does the goverment punish mothers who lie about not knowing who the father is, when in fact the child carrys his last name and is stated in the birth papers? 

funmom --- 19 years ago -

i was not married when my son was born he walked away several times before finally leaving for good when my son was 6. it was hard two jobs no insurance but we made it. I got no assistance. but i saw people who did and abused the system. i think it can work if used properly but it also hinders. i made minuimum wage but had a good support system and never needed welfare I lived without cable, phone and a very small grocery bill but he was healhy and had a great roof over his head. i dont get child support since my ex hasnt worked on paper since 2004 he is on the most offender list but if you cant find them they cant pay. he is trying to hide until my ds turns 18 and owes me over 30,000$ in child support.I now have a good job and great insurance If i had to do it again I would have loved to been married but it wouldnt have changed the fact that he didnt want to be a dad..ever.. his loss my son is a happy, healthy almost 17 yr old that makes me proud and is prepairing for college. I raised him myself and didnt need a father for him to do that. i have remarried and my dh taught him the things he needed to know to become the young man he is. 

buzzingo --- 19 years ago -

I believe that in order to recieve benefits from welfare, you must provide the name or names of the father for the state to test their DNA. If they have a job or have any money then they should pay for the support of thier child. Excellent idea, have the government hunt them down and garnish wages. If they're unemployed, they should have a few weeks to get a job until off to prison labor, and if they don't work enough, same thing. Probably won't keep it from happening in the first place, but maybe after 3-5 kids some of these no-good scoundrels that have kids with half the women in town will be too broke and too busy to go spread their genes. I also agree that a few moochers are ruining it for everyone else who might actually need it. Get off the front of the TV, quit yelling at your 20 kids like it's their fault (or dumping them places), and go make an honest living like the rest of us. And an honest living does not consist of suing for your injuries like the lawyer ads on daytime TV would have you convinced. 

mdawg --- 19 years ago -

I am a single parent. My DH has been my childs father figure for four years, but he is not her father. I like to refer to my childs father as a SPERM DONOR. When I had my child the sperm donor quit his job and insisted I go get on the system. I refused, because I am able bodied and capable of making a living and I was not raised to live off the system or take a hand out. I left him 30 days after my child was born. I have never recieved a dime from him - NOR DO I WANT HIS MONEY - I know many people don't understand why I feel this way, but I have MY REASONS. I bust my butt every day trying to be a good parent for my child and while the past years have been bumpy at times, I feel like I am better person for it all and I know my child will appreciate it later on in life. I do agree that people who abuse the system ruin it for those who are truly in need. There needs to be a better way. 

cmi --- 19 years ago -

I didn't read everything, so sorry if I post what's already been posted. When I volunteered w/ needy single moms, they had to go after the father in order to get welfare. Some didn't go on welfare because they didn't want the dad in the picture paying child support. 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

I have never recieved a dime from him - NOR DO I WANT HIS MONEY - I know many people don't understand why I feel this way, but I have MY REASONS. Dependency on the father can sometimes create the same cycle of dependency as government welfare. Teaching your child to move on and not live off someone who doesn't care one bit for you or your child can be a way of keeping your dignity, and a way of teaching personal responsibility. Maybe you identify with this, or maybe I'm just fishing. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

Cybersage, " keeping your dignity, and a way of teaching personal responsibility. Maybe you identify with this, or maybe I'm just fishing. " LOL...I think you're fishing on that comment. The initial question is more about "life style" welfare recipients. If you've not "tricked" the system to get payment by not getting married or denying paternity of your children....then it's not about you. On a personal note, my older son was born out of wedlock. His father signed the birth certificate and the boy got his last name-----but, he weazeled out of child support until my son was 5 years old!!! THe system is screwy! 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

I think it is the other way around - the lack of good social programs contributes to fatherless families. Maybe if sex ed was part of the public school curriculum we would see fewer cases... 

CyberSage --- 19 years ago -

Maybe if sex ed was part of the public school curriculum we would see fewer cases... Are you over 80 years old? Because last time I checked, everyone younger than that would've either had sex ed or their children would've had it. Maybe you just spoke without thinking. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics
polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground