Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

An Old Earth

who's talking here?

freshhell 1
RRay 1
bbjones 64
GHYC 1
Justwatching72 7
likeke27 4
JDaddy 2
OldSchool 4
Eve L. 1
edna balzac 2
AuthorMan 1
Tyrus 3
NoNameNoLastName 39
Zionist NightOwl 1
mommiedearest 1
auraofpeace 53
ChezML 1
catboxcrunchie 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

Yes, I want to start this debate up again. I would like to bring at least a couple other proofs I have that the earth is over 6,000 years old. 1) Nuclides: We all know nuclides are forms of matter that are radioactive. Every single nuclide with a halflife over 80 million years can be found naturally on earth. Nuclides with a halflife less than 80 million years do not occur naturally at any detectable levels. 2) The coral reef at Eniwetok Atoll in the Pacific Ocean: It has been measured at 1,380 meters. Even if you are using an extremely generous growth rate for coral it would had to have taken over 130,000 years for it to grow to such a thickness. 3) It takes thousands of years for temperatures to be below freezing to accumulate a 100 ft layer of permafrost. There are areas of permafrost that are over a mile thick (5280 ft). 4) With the latest mapping of the human genome, all of our genes have been mapped. The following is from Arthur Caplan of the University of Pennsylvania's Center for Bioethics: "The genome reveals, indisputably and beyond any serious doubt, that Darwin was right — mankind evolved over a long period of time from primitive animal ancestors...The core recipe of humanity carries clumps of genes that show we are descended from bacteria. There is no other way to explain the jerry-rigged nature of the genes that control key aspects of our development...The theory of evolution is the only way to explain the arrangement of the 30,000 genes and three billion letters that constitute our genetic code." Your thoughts?  

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The theory of evolution is the only way to explain the arrangement of the 30,000 genes and three billion letters that constitute our genetic code. Please tell us exactly how the theory of evolution explains this. 

AuthorMan --- 19 years ago -

I do not assume to understand the state of matter that an entity I do not comprehend yet has created. The only thing I can understand about creation is someone creating something I am familiar with. I also do not trust a dating technique that says something is a million years old- are there eye witnesses to the creation of that thing. This is the same standard nonbelievers put on us. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

ok, steve..valid points, i suppose..if you use that reasoinbg...and not take into account that the average lifespan of early man was abou 30 years or less...or wars..or famine or the many other things that cut the population. Very nice article as I said, but what about the points I raised? BB...funny you pick out the one thing that i did not say myself, in fact that i stated was a quote from another person. No comments on any of my other points? How utterly predicatble of you. You used to be able to come up with some obscure scientific theorem that would help explain your position, alas, you are not even able to do that any more. Even though you are very predictable, I was hoping for some kind of debate with you. I am sorry that you have decided to give up. You are in my thoughts. are there eye witnesses to the creation of that thing?. This is the same standard nonbelievers put on us. ahh very true authorman, but a couple of points i raised can be measured now, when we can see them..the growth rate of the coral..the amount of time it takes for permafrost to form. Unless water froze at a different temperature back in the good ol days. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

BB...funny you pick out the one thing that i did not say myself, in fact that i stated was a quote from another person. JW I only wrote about the one point because ALL of the points you made were from someone else NOT you. I also did not have any more time right then, so I will answer you now. Point #1 Your post: Nuclides: We all know nuclides are forms of matter that are radioactive. Every single nuclide with a halflife over 80 million years can be found naturally on earth. Nuclides with a halflife less than 80 million years do not occur naturally at any detectable levels. From this website: Nuclides are forms of matter that are radioactive. Each nuclide decays into another form of matter at a certain rate. After an interval of time equal to its half-life, only half of the original material is left. Scientists have found that: Every nuclide with a half-life over 80 million years can be found naturally occurring on earth. All Nuclides with a half-life under 80 million years do not exist naturally at detectable levels. Looks exactly like a JW original thought! Point #2 Your post: The coral reef at Eniwetok Atoll in the Pacific Ocean: It has been measured at 1,380 meters. Even if you are using an extremely generous growth rate for coral it would had to have taken over 130,000 years for it to grow to such a thickness. From this website: The thickness of the coral reef at Eniwetok atoll in the Pacific Ocean has been measured at up to 1,380 meters. Even the most optimistic coral growth rates would require that the atoll be over 130,000 years of age. Looks exactly like a JW original thought! Point #3 Your post: It takes thousands of years for temperatures to be below freezing to accumulate a 100 ft layer of permafrost. There are areas of permafrost that are over a mile thick (5280 ft). From this website: It takes thousands of years of below-freezing temperatures to build a 100 foot layer of permafrost. But large areas in the north are permanently frozen to depths of almost one mile! Looks exactly like a JW original thought! And we already know that point #4 was also not a JW original thought. I see no point in debating this with you. You have no concept of most of what you are posting regarding so-called scientific facts because you have done no studies on this - you just post what you read from someone else. I will say this. God created trees that were fully grown, mature animals, Adam and Eve were adults, etc. Therefore, it is not possible, that nuclides were created at their half-life stage and that the coral reef was created fully developed, and so on? NO ONE was there to prove otherwise. God revealed His creation to us in the Bible and tells mankind the following through Paul in Romans 1:16-25: "For I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ: for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth; to the Jew first, and also to the Greek. For therein is the righteousness of God revealed from faith to faith: as it is written, The just shall live by faith. For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who hold the truth in unrighteousness; Because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath shewed it unto them. For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse: Because that, when they knew God, they glorified him not as God, neither were thankful; but became vain in their imaginations, and their foolish heart was darkened. Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools, And changed the glory of the uncorruptible God into an image made like to corruptible man, and to birds, and fourfooted beasts, and creeping things. Wherefore God also gave them up to uncleanness through the lusts of their own hearts, to dishonour their own bodies between themselves: Who changed the truth of God into a lie, and worshipped and served the creature more than the Creator, who is blessed for ever. Amen." We are also told in 1 Timothy 6:20-21: "O Timothy, keep that which is committed to thy trust, avoiding profane and vain babblings, and oppositions of science falsely so called: Which some professing have erred concerning the faith. Grace be with thee. Amen." My thought on those passages, as based upon other Scriptures, is that God has made it plain to all, that will open themselves to His Word, that what He tells us about the creation of the world is the truth just as everyting else He tells us. He did not tells us EVERYTHING he did "minute by minute" because He wants us to believe Him by faith. also, that void of information, leaves it open for the people who do not want to belive him by faith, to become "vain in their imaginations" whereas "their foolish heart was darkened", and, therefore, "professing themselves to be wise, they became fools" and they " changed the truth of God into a lie, and worshipped and served the creature more than the Creator" Evolution denies there is a creator. It turns the creator into animals just like God said fools would do in Romans 1:25 "...changed the truth of God into a lie, and worshipped and served the creature more than the Creator..." It is idolatry. Evolution denies the words of the creator as he spoke all things into existance. Evolutionists deny the creator and, then, deny their denial. 

Tyrus --- 19 years ago -

This is the same standard nonbelievers put on us. Very true statement. 

OldSchool --- 19 years ago -

JW, since those points are yours - will you expound on them and give us some background data on your arguments for an "old" earth? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

I'd be curious to hear an explanation around how human beings and dinossaurs co-existed... I read somewhere that Dr. Dino claimed that people could kill a T-Rex by pulling one of its little arms from its socket, so it would bleed to death. Not sure the source was reliable, though. I also would like to understand how Noah managed to get a couple of T-Rex & other heavier beasts in the ark. Or were they extinct already? If so, what caused their extinction? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Cute math around the population, however, as JW mentioned, the life expectancy and ability to breed were significantly lower until very recent years. You can't assume that the growth ratio was the same over the millenia. Graph here, although some people don't belive wikipedia... 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

. Or were they extinct already? If so, what caused their extinction? or where they ever really here? 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

Historically and culturally, outside direct accounts of the Hebrew tribes, the Bible is suspect. And even then, it is not exacting in it accuracy. If you want some specifics on this, I can provide, obviously 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I'd be curious to hear an explanation around how human beings and dinossaurs co-existed Before the fall of mankind that resulted because of the sin of Adam, mankind and animals were vegetarian. It is the theory of some creationists that, at some point, because of the curse upon the world, God's perfect animals degraded to the point to where some became carnivores. The believed that this happened right before the flood, because of the extensive fossil record deposited due to sedimentation resulting from the flood. I also would like to understand how Noah managed to get a couple of T-Rex & other heavier beasts in the ark. If God wanted them to survive the flood, then He sent Noah babies. Cute math around the population, however, as JW mentioned, the life expectancy and ability to breed were significantly lower until very recent years. You can't assume that the growth ratio was the same over the millenia. Mankind lived longer and had children well after they were 100 years old for many years after the flood. For example, after the flood Noah lived 350 years and was 950 years old when he died. Shem, one of his sons had his fist son when he was 100 years old and he had many more sons and daughters before he died at the age of 600. Read Genesis 11. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Historically and culturally, outside direct accounts of the Hebrew tribes, the Bible is suspect. And even then, it is not exacting in it accuracy. In it's original manuscripts, the Bible is without error. There have been around 5,000 manuscripts of the Bible found and almost every single one of them say the exact same thing. The differences in the other manuscripts are mainly spelling errors and usage of different names. These manuscripts were found in different places from different times and were found to be exact when compared. The errors, that are claimed to be in the Bible now, have occured since the invention of the printing press. 

catboxcrunchie --- 19 years ago -

Anyone that argues with an ignorant person reduces themselves to their level. You will never win a debate with a religious zealot period. You will not change their beliefs. Who cares when the earth was born?? From a scientific point of view the emperical evidence is overwhelming: Permafrost layers, coral reefs, that big hole we call the Grand Canyon, etc.. Case closed end of discussion. From a faith stand point: Goo and believe whatever you want. I know there is a God and he loves me.. I also believe He has a Son Jesus Christ. Emperical evidence is lacking as to his actual significance here on earth that is why it is called faith.. But it is my faith & I really could give a flying rat's ass if you agree with me or not on this issue.. But I certainly will not FORCE you to believe as I do.. That is how most wars are started and that makes you no better than a Religious fanatic. Healthy discussions breed enlightenment; both scientific & theologic... The problem with this current debate: Science is always growing & advancing to accommodate new data. Faith Based Religion is a fixed constant: God created everything and nothing evolved.. That argument intself is flawed since man has Evolved quite significantly in just 10,000 years. Otherwise we would still be living in huts hunting with sticks, and praying to the gods for a lightning strike for fire.. But you ignorant people go ahead & believe the "World is Flat" if it helps you sleep at night. Both sides should not believe in everything you read or everything you see or feel: People lie, your eyes can be tricked, and you heart can be fooled. God is most certainly amused with this line of debate. I know Galileo, Newton, DaVinci, Socrates, Solomon, et al, are outright laughing at you, and if they aren't: Buddha, Mohamed, and 12 guys that hung out with this really hip dude 2000 years ago are just in stitches over this arguement. The bottom line is: believe what you want, accept people for what they are, And let God be the judge. Our time on earth is but a moment, eternity is just that. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

or where they ever really here? We should ask Dr. Dino about that. He says they were there. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

catboxcrunchie You can believe exactly as you want because God gave us free will, but some of the things that you wrote are not correct and do matter. For instance, your statement God created everything and nothing evolved.. That argument intself is flawed since man has Evolved quite significantly in just 10,000 years. is not correct. What you see as technological advances are not a form of evolution. Mankind did not evolve, he just acquired more toys. Men lived to an average age of approximately 900 years before the flood. Noah lived 950 years. Do you consider it evolving for us to now only live around 100 years? Otherwise we would still be living in huts hunting with sticks, and praying to the gods for a lightning strike for fire. If you have not noticed, there are people on this planet that still do exactly as you described. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Before the fall of mankind that resulted because of the sin of Adam, mankind and animals were vegetarian. There are fundamental differences between the intestinal tract of a carnivore and a herbivore. A carnivore cannot process vegetables. A herbivore cannot process meat. Unless you admit God made substantial changes to creation, your T-Rex was starving in paradise. He sent Noah babies He sent, or did he order Noah to gather them? Big difference. I wonder how Noah managed to go to the rain forest, Antarctica, etc. to gather all the different animals and the appropriate food for them. Probably took him a lot of time. Also, apparently there was no provision for plants, and I kinda doubt they would survive under water for 40 days. Another issue that is not quite right - a balanced ecosystem requires a carnivore to herbivore ratio of about 1 to 100. 1 to 2 or even 1 to 7 won't cut it - upon release from the ark, the fittest would survive, the weakest would perish, which seems to contradict God's wishes 'to keep their various kinds alive throughout the earth.' Not to mention that natural selection is bad, as I read on another thread. Mankind lived longer and had children well after they were 100 years old for many years after the flood. Some argue that there was an error converting between different Sumerian numerical systems, and that Methuselah died at 85, and had his first child at 17. DISCLAIMER - THIS IS CUT AND PASTE - The original Genesis numbers were not written in decimal notation. Instead the numbers were recorded in an archaic, pre-cuneiform, Sumerian number system in sign-value notation, similar in some ways to Roman numerals. About 1700 BC, a Babylonian scribe mistranslated these archaic numbers into cuneiform in the classical Sumerian sexagesimal number system. These were retranslated into Hebrew about 500 BC and became Genesis 5. Except for Noah, each young man in Genesis 5 fathered his first son during his late teens or early twenties, just as young men do today, and they lived into their seventies or early eighties. Makes more sense to me. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

This post is inerrant, and its words cannot be modified. Pigs can fly. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

I just proved beyond doubt that pigs can fly. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Unless you admit God made substantial changes to creation, your T-Rex was starving in paradise. Because of Adam's choice to disobey God, there were many changes to God's original creation after the fall. He sent, or did he order Noah to gather them? Big difference. There is a big difference. I said "... He sent Noah babies." for a reason. That is because that is what god told Noah He woud do. God reveals this to us in Genesis 6:20 when He says " Of fowls after their kind, and of cattle after their kind, of every creeping thing of the earth after his kind, two of every sort shall come unto thee, to keep them alive." The words "shall come unto thee" means that Noah did not have to go out and collect them himself. Another issue that is not quite right - a balanced ecosystem requires a carnivore to herbivore ratio of about 1 to 100. 1 to 2 or even 1 to 7 won't cut it - upon release from the ark, the fittest would survive, the weakest would perish, which seems to contradict God's wishes 'to keep their various kinds alive throughout the earth. Why would there need to be a balanced ecosystem? You are leaving the power of God out of the equation. God provided for the animals as Jesus tells us in Matthew 6:26 "Behold the fowls of the air: for they sow not, neither do they reap, nor gather into barns; yet your heavenly Father feedeth them. Are ye not much better than they?" The original Genesis numbers were not written in decimal notation. Instead the numbers were recorded in an archaic, pre-cuneiform, Sumerian number system in sign-value notation, similar in some ways to Roman numerals. That is total nonsense. That quote came from a book Noah's Ark and the Ziusudra Epic: Sumerian Origins of the Flood Myth where Robert M. Best is trying to prove that THE Flood was a myth. The Old Testament Genesis account was NOT recorded by Moses in Sumerian. It was recorded in Hebrew. Also, the number of years that They lived were not recorded as numerals, they were recorded using Hebrew words. And yes, they did have a word for hundred. It is "me'ah" and it means hundred. God did not create a stupid mankind, they could count. This post is inerrant, and its words cannot be modified. Pigs can fly. Wat a crock! First of all, you are NOT God and are not inerrant (which is shown by the next two points). Seondly, the words can be modified, which makes your statement a lie, and therefore NOT inerrant. Adam could easily do it. Third, pigs can NOT fly which makes your statement a lie, and therefore NOT inerrant. The only thing that you proved is that you can write a lie. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

In it's original manuscripts, the Bible is without error. There have been around 5,000 manuscripts of the Bible found and almost every single one of them say the exact same thing. The differences in the other manuscripts are mainly spelling errors and usage of different names. These manuscripts were found in different places from different times and were found to be exact when compared. The errors, that are claimed to be in the Bible now, have occured since the invention of the printing press. This would actually be another discussion (the points you bring up) that would involve everything from a discussion of the Council of Trent, the influence of Constantine, and even the primary influence of Paul (a Roman citizen) in the New Testament over Peter ( a Jew and a Disciple) in the Gospels approved and disapproved as Holy Canon. But, we are more along the discussion of the Old Testament. Hang on a bit and give me some time to type some things up..... 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

I will present two basic and simple cases. Both a bit different, and the easiest one first, although they are both very simple to understand. The first deals with the Book of Job. This story actually predates Abraham, as most, if not all, Biblical scholars will agree. The style it is written in, as can easily be determined by simply readinng the story, points to it being narrative story, almost like a play or an act. It has a simple protaganist, a "Greek Chorus" (although it is not Greek, just that style of characterization), and the themes and characterizations presented predate the Hebrews, so must have come from a culture that was (obviously) not a "Jewish" culture, and probably predates the Egyptians. It is just one of those simple tales that gets passed around and fitted to the common culture of the time, much like "Flood stories" that are part of Genesis that are found in many other ancient texts. Genesis merely puts a particular cultural spin on a common theme. The "Golden Rule" that Jesus speaks of was also a common bit of homey wisom known, and spoken of, in many ancient cultures. Anyhow, noene of this speaks of Biblical errancy, but does speak of interpretational errancy, as many Christians beleive that the Book of Job is a stand alone piece to be taken literally in Judeo-Christain terms. Now, when you look into the Book of Exodus and the story of the Egyptians and Hebrews, you will find this particular passage: Chapter One 20 So God was kind to the midwives and the people increased and became even more numerous. 21 And because the midwives feared God, he gave them families of their own. 22 Then Pharaoh gave this order to all his people: "Every boy that is born [b] you must throw into the Nile, but let every girl live." The Egyptians were very religeous people, as is obvious. As well, the personified many things into their personal Gods. And one of those things was the Nile river. The Nile was amny things to them, and a part of their life cycle, from the water it provided for irrigation, to the flood cycle, to just being part and parcel of their everyday existence. Without the Nile, they would not exist as a nation. Now, to pollute the Nile, by decree, with thousands of corpses would be sacreligeous, blasphemous, and patently insane by any reasoning. If you were going to do such a thing, much smarter to simply take the corpses into the desert and burn them. As well, the murder of innocents in such a manner would not put the Pharoah in good standing in his afterlife. The soul of an Egyptian had to be weighed against a feather for its sin (sin is not a Christian concept only, by the way). Blatant mass murder against slaves would not have been well received, politically, by local industry, either, particulalry male slaves. If you look at the history of the Jews at that time, they were a nomadic tribe of hunters and raiders that had lived and co-existed with the Egyptians for some time. More than likely some sort of drought or similar issue, or a sense of enterprise, had led them to become basically indentured servants to various Egyptian families and industries. SOme, as is noted, actually rose to postions of influence and power in Egyptian social and governmental life, which is hardly the role of a beaten and horsewhipped culture. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

The only thing that you proved is that you can write a lie. Nope. The post is self contained. It references itself. It self-proclaims to hold the truth. And it proclaims that its words cannot be changed. So, it basically does what the Bible does - it self-proclaims. The difference? You have faith on the Bible but not on my post. My faith tells me that the Bible is inerrant on matters of faith and morals. Your faith tells you that the Bible is inerrant on everything. We can argue to death here, but at the end of the day: 1. It is a matter of faith. 2. It cannot be proven. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

auraofpeace, I do not really know what point you are trying to make with your first case. I really do not see how culture has anything to do with the Truth of God and how He communicates with us. Cultures change, but God does not. If you look at the history of the Jews at that time, they were a nomadic tribe of hunters and raiders that had lived and co-existed with the Egyptians for some time. More than likely some sort of drought or similar issue, or a sense of enterprise, had led them to become basically indentured servants to various Egyptian families and industries. SOme, as is noted, actually rose to postions of influence and power in Egyptian social and governmental life, which is hardly the role of a beaten and horsewhipped culture. Your recollection of history is not quite right. Joseph was sold into Egyptian slavery, and through His belief in God, Joseph became a man of great importance, in fact, second only to the Pharoah. Joseph had interpreted a dream for Pharoah, whereas there would be 7 years of abundant harvests followed by 7 years of famine. Pharaoh gave Joseph the authority to prepare for the famine. When the famine occured, Joseph brought his family, his father and brothers to Egypt to escape the famine in Canaan. When Pharaoh gave the order of 1 Exodus 22 "And Pharaoh charged all his people, saying, Every son that is born ye shall cast into the river, and every daughter ye shall save alive", he was a new Pharaoh in Egypt who " knew not Joseph" (Exodus 1:8). After their flight to escape the famine in Canaan, the twelve sons of Israel (Jacob) had grown into a sizable minority within Egypt (1:6-7). The presence this large group of potentially hostile aliens residing within the borders of his country would understandably have given the new Pharaoh cause for concern (Exodus 1:10). Pharaoh's first attempt to deal with the threat resulted in the persecution of the Hebrews in an attempt to crush them into submission (Exodus 1:11-14). then he tried genocide. Pharaoh's first attempt at extermination was aimed at working secretly through the midwives, having them kill the baby boys as they were born (Exodus 1:15-16). When that failed, he decided to have the Egyptian people themselves participate in the genocide by having the Hebrew sons thrown into the Nile. Now, to pollute the Nile, by decree, with thousands of corpses would be sacreligeous, blasphemous, and patently insane by any reasoning. If you were going to do such a thing, much smarter to simply take the corpses into the desert and burn them. The Nile river was the lifeline of ancient Egypt and was personified in the Egyptian god Hapi, the essence of the life giving water. Seasonal festivals were observed along the banks of the Nile in honor of Hapi and occasionally human sacrifices were offered to the river to insure the annual flood which was needed for their agriculture to flourish. Why would the bodies of babies pollute the Nile? The Nile is populated by crocodiles that were revered (in Ancient Egypt crocodiles were mummified) and worshipped. Do you not think that a baby would be a tasty sacrifice to the river and its gods? As well, the murder of innocents in such a manner would not put the Pharoah in good standing in his afterlife. The soul of an Egyptian had to be weighed against a feather for its sin (sin is not a Christian concept only, by the way). Blatant mass murder against slaves would not have been well received, politically, by local industry, either, particulalry male slaves. Why would you believe that? In Egypt, the Pharaoh was the absolute monarch in the country and was considered to be the incarnation of the falcon-headed god Horus or the sun god Ra, therefore, his word was law. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The difference? You have faith on the Bible but not on my post. You are wrong here also. My FAITH is in God, therefore, I BELIEVE in what the Bible reveals to us. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

Your recollection of history is not quite right. well, the problem you are running into with the history you present after that statement (in your post above) is that you are using the source in question to "prove itself". I have no problem or issue with your reliance on the Bible or your Faith. None of that is being questioned by me. But, in terms of what your are doing, you are using the "document in question", which has been alleged to be faulty, to prove itself as not being so. It doesn't really work that well for your argument. Why would the bodies of babies pollute the Nile? The Nile is populated by crocodiles.... Do you not think that a baby would be a tasty sacrifice to the river and its gods? Not the wholesale slaughter of them, no. Sacrificng a few people and tossing them into the river is one thing. Putting one or two hundred corpses a day, for a period of weeks or even months, would not be anything but a mess. The Egyptians were not stupid, and I do not think they engaged in ritual human sacrifice anyhow. Killing babies for that specific reason would not have met any sort of criteria as a "holy sacrifice" to say the least. If ti was going to be done, better to just knock them in the ehad and get rid of the bodies quickly and effienctly, not have them wash up, whole or in parts, along the banks of the river for a few weeks. Why would you believe that? In Egypt, the Pharaoh was the absolute monarch in the country and was considered to be the incarnation of the falcon-headed god Horus or the sun god Ra, therefore, his word was law. Most Kings in that era, and for a long time following, were considered Gods. Certainly the Romans continued with the deification of their rulers. But all Kings, even "immortal manifestations on Earth of the revered Godhead" worry about assasination and being deposed and the like. As much as they make themselves GOd, fellow noblemen and courtiers and generals and the like pretty much understand that they are men (or women) with all the frailties and weaknesses of the same. If it is politcally expedient to put a particular king back in Heaven where he belongs because he is wrecking the economy or because a new King will handle some situation in a more favorable way to some group of influence, they quickly find out they are not as immortal as they think. And, again, the wholesale slaughter of children would be jsut the kind of thing that would start a revolt in the court and populace for many reasons and justifications. That part of Biblical history, as well as a few others, were written to give a certain justification for actions and a sense of "Divine Justice" to some events that didn't transpire quite the way written. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

well, the problem you are running into with the history you present after that statement (in your post above) is that you are using the source in question to "prove itself". The history in the Bible corresponds with the accounts of secular historians of that time. Not the wholesale slaughter of them, no. Sacrificng a few people and tossing them into the river is one thing. Putting one or two hundred corpses a day, for a period of weeks or even months, would not be anything but a mess. I seriously doubt that the Hebrews had 200 boy babies a day, but if they did, the Nile is approximately 3700 miles long and more than 10 miles wide and empties into the Mediterranean Sea. That size in conjunction with predators and discharge into the Mediterranean, would make it very unlikely for even thousands of babies to pollute the river. And, again, the wholesale slaughter of children would be jsut the kind of thing that would start a revolt in the court and populace for many reasons and justifications. You give the human race too much credit. First of all, the Egyptians felt that they were superior to their slaves. Secondly, the majority of the slaves were used primarily for the Pharaoh's wishes, such as building tombs. The general population did not have men as slaves, they would have used women because they were easier to control. Thirdly, the Pharaoh's word was law. Taking those factors into account, there is a very low possibility that murdering boy babies would have caused an uproar within the populace. Genocide is occuring right now in several countries. Do you see any uprisings by the general populace to stop it? That part of Biblical history, as well as a few others, were written to give a certain justification for actions and a sense of "Divine Justice" to some events that didn't transpire quite the way written. That is a pretty big claim from someone who was not there! There has NOT been any account of history noted in the Bible that has been proven wrong by secular historians or archeologists. As an example, it was once claimed there was not an Assyrian king named Sargon as recorded in Isaiah 20:1, because this name was not known in any other record. Then, Sargon's palace was discovered in Khorsabad, Iraq. The very event mentioned in Isaiah 20, the Assyrian Kings capture of Ashdod, was found to be recorded on the palace walls. Every historical event is unique, which derives a unique set of results that could not have arisen under any other set of circumstances. This makes historical events verifiable, and enables the investigation of any historical claim. In addition, historical events are "inextricably linked". Every historical event is interconnected with all others that occur at the same time and place. To deny the historical accuracy of a single event would require a new explanation of all of the circumstances that surrounded its occurrence. Biblical history and secular history are completely interrelated - they are so interwoven with each other that it is impossible to separate them. Because of this, denying Biblical history would entail a denial of what is known about secular history. Historical events are of tremendous relevance to the study of the Bible, which is, after all, a historical book. It contains much information directly relevant to the study of ancient history, political entities, governments, languages, customs, geography, and biography. If the Bible, or portions within it, are forgeries, then the constant references to historical data would contain countless inaccuracies and anachronisms. Since NO forgeries have been found, we are forced to come to grips with the realization that the Bible must be a record of events that actually happened to real people at specific times and places. There has been too much corroboration of Biblical details through archaeological findings and other ancient documents for us to conclude otherwise. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

You are wrong here also. My FAITH is in God, therefore, I BELIEVE in what the Bible reveals to us. Exactly - you BELIEVE, you don't KNOW. Big difference. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Exactly - you BELIEVE, you don't KNOW. Big difference. Okay, I will rephrase. My FAITH is in God, therefore, I KNOW what the Bible reveals to us is TRUE. 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

The history in the Bible corresponds with the accounts of secular historians of that time. no it does not. There si nothing in Egyptian history, for a fact, that corresponds to anything like the 7 plagues. I seriously doubt that the Hebrews had 200 boy babies a day, but if they did, the Nile is approximately 3700 miles long and more than 10 miles wide and empties into the Mediterranean Sea. That size in conjunction with predators and discharge into the Mediterranean, would make it very unlikely for even thousands of babies to pollute the river. It says that "every son shall be killed" not babies born on a particular day. You would assume that they would start by killing the older children (lets say 4 or 5 years old) and then start working their way down over time (you wouldn;t be able to do all of this in one day) until they had claimed all living children, and then start working on newborns. How many were the population? I don't know, but the account itself names them as: 20 So God was kind to the midwives and the people increased and became even more numerous. 21 And because the midwives feared God, he gave them families of their own. which probably means a darm lot of them. I can also tell you know nothing of fluid dynamics when it comes to your assertion that you could "pour" numerous corpses into a river and they all float peacefully to sea. Where do most corpses, even ones found by scavengers, end up if they are drowned within a few miles of the coastline? They end up on shore. Drowned in a river? They end up on the banks. You give the human race too much credit. First of all, the Egyptians felt that they were superior to their slaves. for some reason, that has me laughing. Secondly, the majority of the slaves were used primarily for the Pharaoh's wishes, such as building tombs. The general population did not have men as slaves, they would have used women because they were easier to control. that is untrue. Male slaves would have been used extensively in farming, general labor and construction, and civil engineering. Not for lounging about the palace. "Tomb building" was done by private engineers and artisans. Some slave labor would ahve been used, but the Hebrews were also what would be considered "unskilled labor" for the most part. Doing thing like stoop labor, harvesting, etc. The idea that "women were easer to control and therefore used instead of men" is just plain strange sounding on many levels, but it is meaningless to your point and false. Thirdly, the Pharaoh's word was law. Taking those factors into account, there is a very low possibility that murdering boy babies would have caused an uproar within the populace. He wasn't murdering "baby boys", he was taking private property that could not be replaced. A bit of a difference. And even you say that he needed slaves to "build tombs". Can't build tombs without slaves. Can't have slaves if you slaughter them wholsale. Genocide is occuring right now in several countries. Do you see any uprisings by the general populace to stop it? Do you really want to stand by that statement, or do you need a history lesson in modern eras, and not just Biblical? I mean, if you really want to show your ignorance..... That is a pretty big claim from someone who was not there! Oh, I am so sorry. How stupid of me. Very arrogant, as well. Well, let me sit at your knee and listen to how it was when you were there. Anyway, with all of the stuff you wrote about after that, I will give you this... Yes. Egyptians did exist at the same time, and in the same era, as the Hebrews. The Bible and secular history will both tell you that. You start getting much deeper, and trails begin to diverge in the woods.... 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

There si nothing in Egyptian history, for a fact, that corresponds to anything like the 7 plagues. First of all it was 10 plagues. The Egyptian "Ipuwer papyrus" describes a series of calamities that befell Egypt, including the river turning to blood, men behaving as wild ibises, and the land undergoing extreme turmoil. Do we, in fact, know of any better possible explanation for the release of the Jews from slavery to Egypt? What other factors could have induced Pharaoh to give up the free slave labor that the Egyptians had in the Jewish people? It says that "every son shall be killed" not babies born on a particular day. Again, you need to read what is written. Exodus 1:22 says "And Pharaoh charged all his people, saying, Every son that is born ye shall cast into the river, and every daughter ye shall save alive." Every "son that is born" refers to newborn babies and would coincide with the Pharaohs earlier edict to the midwives when he said " When ye do the office of a midwife to the Hebrew women, and see them upon the stools; if it be a son, then ye shall kill him: but if it be a daughter, then she shall live." When Moses was born and hidden for 3 months, we know that Moses already had a brother, Aaron, who had been born prior to the Pharaoh's edict. If your "assumed" scenario of killing all of the male children was true, then why was not Aaron killed? That is why you have to understand what you read within the context of the whole event. I can also tell you know nothing of fluid dynamics when it comes to your assertion that you could "pour" numerous corpses into a river and they all float peacefully to sea. Again, you do not understand what I wrote. Look back. Did I write that ALL would float to the sea? Today, there is an estimated 250,000 to 500,000 crocodiles in Africa. There were probably more during that time peroid, but lets just stick with 250,000. Say only 1 percent lived near the Egyptian settlements - that would be 2500 crocodiles. Easily each crocodile, which can eat a whole zebra, could eat several babies at one time. that is untrue. Male slaves would have been used extensively in farming, general labor and construction, and civil engineering. Not for lounging about the palace. "Tomb building" was done by private engineers and artisans. Some slave labor would ahve been used, but the Hebrews were also what would be considered "unskilled labor" for the most part. Doing thing like stoop labor, harvesting, etc. Who is showing their ignorance? Who said anything about lounging around the palace? Would lounging around the palace "crush them into submission"? Using them for farming, general labor and construction (and yes they were used for pyramid building) would ALL be at the orders of the Pharaoh. The idea that "women were easer to control and therefore used instead of men" is just plain strange sounding on many levels, but it is meaningless to your point and false. What women generals or even women who began uprisings are you thinking about? And you say I am showing my ignorance? You give the human race too much credit. First of all, the Egyptians felt that they were superior to their slaves. for some reason, that has me laughing. Do not understand why you would laugh at a true statement? He wasn't murdering "baby boys", he was taking private property that could not be replaced. A bit of a difference. And even you say that he needed slaves to "build tombs". Can't build tombs without slaves. Can't have slaves if you slaughter them wholsale. The Hebrews lived in their own settlements. Apparently, you do not understand a "dictatorship". All slaves would have belonged to the Pharaoh. Since there were many Hebrew men available at the time, slowing the growth of their population would not hinder the slave labor. Babies could not work anyway. In the future, as some of the older Hebrews died off, then the Pharaoh could rescend his edict so that more males would be born. Problem solved! Genocide is occuring right now in several countries. Do you see any uprisings by the general populace to stop it? Do you really want to stand by that statement, or do you need a history lesson in modern eras, and not just Biblical? I mean, if you really want to show your ignorance..... Yes I really want to stand by that statement. I do not know about your revision of history, but large scale genocide is occurring in Darfur right now and occurred in Rwanda and Bosnia in the 1990's. It is occurring on a smaller scale in other countries. Was the populace able to stop that genocide? Oh, I am so sorry. How stupid of me. Very arrogant, as well. Well, let me sit at your knee and listen to how it was when you were there. Again, you do not comprehend what you read. Where did I write that I was there? History was recorded by historians and by the Bible. The Bible is a record of events that actually happened to real people at specific times and places. There has been too much corroboration of Biblical details through archaeological findings and other ancient documents for us to conclude otherwise. You start getting much deeper, and trails begin to diverge in the woods.... Where is YOUR proof of that? 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

First of all it was 10 plagues. yes it was, I had my mind on something else when I typed "seven". I apologize. The Egyptian "Ipuwer papyrus" describes a series of calamities that befell Egypt, including the river turning to blood, men behaving as wild ibises, and the land undergoing extreme turmoil. Do we, in fact, know of any better possible explanation for the release of the Jews from slavery to Egypt? What other factors could have induced Pharaoh to give up the free slave labor that the Egyptians had in the Jewish people? The Ipuwar Papyrus corresponds to a differnent era than that mentioned int eh Bible. The only person who has tried to link them is a guy named Rohl, and his theroies have been rejected by Egyptologist pretty much out of hand. He seems to be a Christian Apologist and a young earth Creationist, which explains his bias. Again, you need to read what is written. Exodus 1:22 says "And Pharaoh charged all his people, saying, Every son that is born ye shall cast into the river, and every daughter ye shall save alive." Every "son that is born" refers to newborn babies and would coincide with the Pharaohs earlier edict to the midwives when he said " When ye do the office of a midwife to the Hebrew women, and see them upon the stools; if it be a son, then ye shall kill him: but if it be a daughter, then she shall live." you are linking two different events in that. Basically every son born to a Hebrew was to die. That means the children. Not babies born today. Again, you do not understand what i wrote. Look back. Did I write that ALL would float to the sea? Today, there is an estimated 250,000 to 500,000 crocodiles in Africa. There were probably more during that time peroid, but lets just stick with 250,000. Say only 1 percent lived near the Egyptian settlements - that would be 2500 crocodiles. Easily each crocodile, which can eat a whole zebra, could eat several babies at one time. you are really sticking to the "feed the crocodile" theory, aren't you? So, you are saying that there would be 2500 crocodiles to eat all the babies that would float to shore in a 5-6 mile stretch of the Nile from where they were dumped? What women generals or even women who began uprisings are you thinking about? And you say I am showing my ignorance? I am not sure where I talked about women generals or women beginning uprisings. Not that their have not been women leaders, just that I did not discuss them here. The Hebrews lived in their own settlements. Apparently, you do not understand a "dictatorship". All slaves would have belonged to the Pharaoh. 9: And he said to his people, "Behold, the people of Israel are too many and too mighty for us. 10: Come, let us deal shrewdly with them, lest they multiply, and, if war befall us, they join our enemies and fight against us and escape from the land." 11: Therefore they set taskmasters over them to afflict them with heavy burdens; and they built for Pharaoh store-cities, Pithom and Ra-am'ses. sounds like the Bible speks of ownership by people, not singularly. As well, the Egyptian Pharoah was not a dictator. Yes I really want to stand by that statement. I do not know about your revision of history, but genocide is occurring in Darfur right now and occurred in Rwanda and Bosnia in the 1990's. Was the populace able to stop that genocide? Thanks for making my point for me. For the sake of this discussion, stopping genocide or not makes no difference. Only that there was or is an uprising. Actually the Jews have had several notable uprisings, one in a Polish (Warsaw)ghetto during WWII. Anyhow, you are starting to twist your own facts now, and revise earlier statements. Twice it has been poinjted out so far. Again, you do not comprehend what you read. Where did I write that I was there? you didn't. You just asserted that you were right, and I wouldn't know because I wasn't there. One would normally assume if that statement was made, the person making it WAS there. I was just ready to hear you tell of the events you saw. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

The Ipuwar Papyrus corresponds to a differnent era than that mentioned int eh Bible. And where exactly is your proof of that. The only person who has tried to link them is a guy named Rohl, and his theroies have been rejected by Egyptologist pretty much out of hand. You are wrong here also. By George Konig "Remarkably, this ancient papyrus parallels the history of the Exodus account as found in the Scriptures. This manuscript recorded the writings of an ancient Egyptian named Ipuwer. The papyrus manuscript, now called the Ipuwer Papyrus, was discovered by someone named Anastasi in the area of Memphis, near the pyramids of Saqqara in Egypt." "A comparison of several key passages from the Biblical Book of Exodus with the ancient Egyptian papyrus reveals remarkable correspondences and parallels that point to a real historical catastrophe. 1. The Plague of Blood In Ipuwer Papyrus 2:5-6, it says: Plague is throughout the land. Blood is everywhere. Compare this with the Book of Exodus 7:21: There was blood throughout all the land of Egypt. In Ipuwer Papyrus 2:10, it says: The River is Blood. Compare with Exodus 7:20: All the waters that were in the river were turned to blood. In Ipuwer Papyrus 2:10, it says: Men shrank from tasting...and thirst for water. Compare with Exodus 7:24: And all the Egyptians digged round about the river for water to drink; for they could not drink of the water of the river" "In light of the ample evidence accumulated from ancient Jewish and Greek historians, together with the Ipuwer Papyrus that parallels several of the 10 Biblical plagues, it is clear that there is compelling non-Biblical evidence to confirm the scriptural account about the Exodus of the Jews from Egypt. Further proof of the Exodus is the fact; the Jews have annually celebrated three great festivals in commemoration of their Exodus (Passover, Pentecost, and Tabernacles) for 3500 years. Therefore, logically, the public observance of the Exodus Passover festival can only be explained if the Jewish people actually participated in these historical events as recorded in the Torah, the first five books of the Bible." Read the rest here. you are linking two different events in that. Basically every son born to a Hebrew was to die. That means the children. Not babies born today. Who said anything about today? And the edict WAS for baby boys born from that point forward. If not, then explain how Aaron survived. READ it in context. you are really sticking to the "feed the crocodile" theory, aren't you? So, you are saying that there would be 2500 crocodiles to eat all the babies that would float to shore in a 5-6 mile stretch of the Nile from where they were dumped? There would not be that many babies since it would only be for newborn baby boys from the time of the edict. If you want to stick with your "every son" scenario, just remember, every male is a son. sounds like the Bible speks of ownership by people, not singularly. As well, the Egyptian Pharoah was not a dictator. Not one of those passages speaks to ownership. The Pharaohs were like dictators - their word was law. Only that there was or is an uprising. I believe the point to be made is that there is NO uprising to STOP the genocide! You just asserted that you were right, and I wouldn't know because I wasn't there. One would normally assume if that statement was made, the person making it WAS there. Why would you assume that since I referenced historical documents whereas you did not? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

My FAITH is in God Precisely. Faith, not knowledge. You can't prove God exists... 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

and you can't prove that he doesn't!! 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

and you can't prove that he doesn't!! I haven't followed the debate very closely (as an ogoing thing over weeks), but I am not sure anyone has said that "God doesn't exist", or if someone has, I don't think it has been made a focal point in the ongoing discussion. I think what HAS been said a lot is "if you don't beleive in the Bible as literal truth you are deluded." 

auraofpeace --- 19 years ago -

You are wrong here also. By George Konig "Remarkably, this ancient papyrus parallels the history of the Exodus account as found in the Scriptures. This manuscript recorded the writings of an ancient Egyptian named Ipuwer. The papyrus manuscript, now called the Ipuwer Papyrus, was discovered by someone named Anastasi in the area of Memphis, near the pyramids of Saqqara in Egypt." Okay, so I can't keep up with all of the Young Earth Christian Apologists. For that, I won't apologize. And Konig is defintely a Christian Apologist with that agenda. Nothing wrong with that, but it is an agenda. Who said anything about today? And the edict WAS for baby boys born from that point forward. If not, then explain how Aaron survived. READ it in context. Good point. I will answer that one when you answer how it was that Joseph and Mary fled to escape the edict by Herod that all children be killed, and yet John the Baptist, then a child as well, did not flee (or his parents did not with him) and yet he was not killed. If you want to get into inconsistencies in the Bible of that nature, we will have a LOOONNNGGGG thread going. There would not be that many babies since it would only be for newborn baby boys from the time of the edict. If you want to stick with your "every son" scenario, just remember, every male is a son. As well, in Jewish culture, every man is a "Son of God", not just Jesus. If you read the New Testament, as a Jew, and see Jesus calling, or being called "Son of God" or "Son of Man" and knowing HE was a Jew, you read it a lot differently than a European would. If you want to get into specific vernacular and cultural language use, we can have another good thread going. Not one of those passages speaks to ownership. The Pharaohs were like dictators - their word was law. Not really. There was a system of common law, and courts and magistrates and all of that. It was something that existed, as it does in all lands and cultures, no matter what the overall system of government is. It has to, else the king or whatever has to decide every single thing, which is impossible. (Even Solomon said so!, and God got mad because the people asked for Kings to be put over them!) And you said he was a Dictator, and now you say he was like one. Actually he was not, a Dictator is something quite different than a King in a Theocratic Monarchy. Why would you assume that since I referenced historical documents whereas you did not? mentioning a historical document and cut and pasting it into your post is not the same as referencing it. If you want to reference it, you need to place it in context of your post in support of some argument. All you have done is give us the internet version of a Chick Smith tract amd said "see there!" Using Christian Apologists to support Christian agendas is convenient, but really doesn't fly anywhere outside the church pew. Which is fine, but doesn't hold much water anywhere else. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

and you can't prove that he doesn't!! Of course I can't. Nobody can prove one way or the other, although some people claim they can... A God whose existence can be mathematically proven is not worthy of adoration. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

If you want to get into inconsistencies in the Bible of that nature, we will have a LOOONNNGGGG thread going. Oh, yeah... Some people here belive the Bible is inerrant in every single word, and they regard it as a science book. I believe the Bible is inerrant in matters of faith and morals. Minor inconsistencies don't bother me, and I have no problem reconciling my faith with a unverse that is billions of years old... Bottom line, auraofpeace, you do bring excellent points to the discussion. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

auraofpeace, I do not really know what point you are trying to make with all of your bizarre statements. Where exactly are you coming up with all of this nonsense? Good point. I will answer that one when you answer how it was that Joseph and Mary fled to escape the edict by Herod that all children be killed, and yet John the Baptist, then a child as well, did not flee (or his parents did not with him) and yet he was not killed. How do you know that John the Baptist and his family did not flee also? What source are you using to obtain your info? It is not recorded in the Bible as to whether they did or did not, so just how do you know that they did not flee? If you want to get into inconsistencies in the Bible of that nature, we will have a LOOONNNGGGG thread going. There are no inconsistancies in the Bible, so bring it on. As well, in Jewish culture, every man is a "Son of God", not just Jesus. If you read the New Testament, as a Jew, and see Jesus calling, or being called "Son of God" or "Son of Man" and knowing HE was a Jew, you read it a lot differently than a European would. That, without doubt, has to be the most ridiculous statement that you have made to date. The "sons of God" referenced in the Old Testament were angels. The "sons of God" referenced in the New Testament are people who receive Jesus Christ, being led by the spirit of God. Jesus is the ONLY "Son of God". If all Jewish men were considered to be a "Son of God", then why did the Jews accuse Jesus of blasphemy when He said that He was the "Son of God" and that He and the Father were one? They tried to stone Him and later put Him on trial for this supposed "blasphemy" or did you forget to read that part of the Bible? Not really. There was a system of common law, and courts and magistrates and all of that. It was something that existed, as it does in all lands and cultures, no matter what the overall system of government is. Who had the final say? The Pharaoh, of course. And you said he was a Dictator, and now you say he was like one. Actually he was not, a Dictator is something quite different than a King in a Theocratic Monarchy. Being a dictator and being like a dictator are the same thing. What is a monarch? One who reigns over a state or territory, usually for life and by hereditary right, especially a sole and absolute ruler. What is a dictator? An absolute ruler. Looks pretty much like the same to me. What does everyone else think? mentioning a historical document and cut and pasting it into your post is not the same as referencing it. Where did you get that definition from? You have to refer to a document to "copy and paste" from it? To help you understand, the historical documents that I was refering to was the Bible and to secular historical writings - not the article written by George Konig. 

page 1 2 3 4 5
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground