Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Immigration and the Bible

who's talking here?

Unichic 1
GCan 1
KatieR 1
eterry2 1
RRay 1
bbjones 12
Justwatching72 7
crazyfun2baround 2
Anderson 16
likeke27 11
Stephen Heisler 30
Hardshell 6
mdawg 6
lilmommy 5
jjfingrainalready 1
denhou1974 7
qpc 8
jefe de nada 8
KaIzel79 1
NoNameNoLastName 13
robbie 1
caitlin 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

I was wanting to hear the thoughts of those that are of the die hard 'bible is to be taken literately' group. I found a few bible passages that speak of not oppressing the resident alien and such, but then when I go to check the King James version, all the references of alien, are changed to 'stranger'. So, how do y'all take this passage: Exodus 22:21 Thou shalt neither vex a stranger, nor oppress him: for ye were strangers in the land of Egypt. Now in the other version it has alien in the place of stranger and it would have me think that you are not to oppress or abuse an alien, because god's people were once aliens (slaves) in egypt. Or this passage: Lev 19:34 But the stranger that dwelleth with you shall be unto you as one born among you, and thou shalt love him as thyself; for ye were strangers in the land of Egypt: I am the LORD your God. Again, other version has alien in the place of stranger. So how do the literalists take the meaning of stranger? DO you take it same way as the word alien, meaning a foreigner in your land? Because if so, you should have no problem with them coming over here legally or illegally. Now, some of you will say well god does not address immigration directly in the bible, and therefore gods word is to follow the government's law and the governments law as of now makes crossing the border without following the rules illegal(even if we don't do anything about it). Fine, but don't forget, the pres is going to be signing the amnesty bill into effect here pretty soon. So it will then be law that all the illegal immigrants that are here, are good to go, no fines, no fees, no nothing, they just get to stay. You thoughts? Oh, and no copying and pasting from this website..i used a couple of points out of it, but did not copy and paste. http://www.gotquestions.org/illegal-immigration.html  

crazyfun2baround --- 19 years ago -

Were we not all illegal aliens at one time or another in our family heritage? 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

I don't believe so no, my family came over from Ireland and came into this country legally, signed documents promising to get a job and perform a skill and not be a drain on the economy. 

crazyfun2baround --- 19 years ago -

Good point, JW. 

jjfingrainalready --- 19 years ago -

Were we not all illegal aliens at one time or another in our family heritage NO! Not all immigrants are illegal! Do most of us have heritage that takes us back to another country? Yes But that doesn't mean our ancestors came here illegally! 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

Awww was really hoping bb would comment. Maybe I covered all his points already. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

Steve is right. God also makes it clear that we are to follow the laws of a country unless it will cause you to disobey God. God reveals this to us in Matthew 22:21 when Jesus says "...Then saith he unto them, Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar's; and unto God the things that are God's." and in Romans 13:7 when Paul says "Render therefore to all their dues: tribute to whom tribute is due; custom to whom custom; fear to whom fear; honour to whom honour." 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

God also makes it clear that we are to follow the laws of a country unless it will cause you to disobey God. So, you will be ok with amnesty for the 20 million illegal immigrants that are here now? The pres is getting ready to sign that bill 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

No, I will not be happy about it. The laws of our country allow for speaking in dissent on bad laws and ideas. 

Justwatching72 --- 19 years ago -

But I thought according to the bible you were supposed to support your governments laws, or is it just that you are supposed to abide by them? 

RRay --- 19 years ago -

Bible or no....kick their damn asses out of our house and send them home. They are draining the life out of our country. Previous immigrants had a skill to offer.....something to contribute. The ability to breed like freekin rabbits is NOT a marketable skill... 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

But I thought according to the bible you were supposed to support your governments laws, or is it just that you are supposed to abide by them? JW, I answered that. I did not say support, I said follow. Do our laws allow for the citizens to speak out against bad laws and ideas? Do our laws allow for the citizens to change bad laws? 

GCan --- 19 years ago -

I'm one of 8 siblings. I guess that makes me the offspring of a "freekin rabbit". 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

I think if you ask the native Americans, they will say that we are all illegal immigrants :-) At any rate, I was just reading today about a pizza chain from Dallas that now accepts Mexican pesos. Can you believe that? I think until the businesses get their behinds kicked big time, we will never have a solution for the immigration problem. Their lobby is strong, and at the end of the day, they benefit from the illegals. 

Hardshell --- 19 years ago -

So, how do y'all take this passage: Exodus 22:21 Thou shalt neither vex a stranger, nor oppress him: for ye were strangers in the land of Egypt. The "strangers" were non-Israelites (Gentiles) who did not serve idols and were therefore allowed to dwell among the children of Israel. They were not proselytes in that they accepted the true religion of the Jews, but they were "non-offensive" to the religion of the Jews, so the Jews were not to harass them, assume their goods, or refuse to trade with them or provide shelter. This portion of the text has no relevance to the strangers who were idolators or "law-breakers". In other words, your assumption will not work with this passage. I think that this explanation also applies to Lev. 19:34. These strangers were either non-offensive Gentiles, or true proselytes, who came under the law just as the Israelites. See Exo. 12:48 "And when a stranger shall sojourn with thee, and will keep the passover to the Lord, let all his males be circumcised, and then let him come near and keep it; and he shall be as one that is born in the land: for no uncircumcised person shall eat thereof. One law shall be to him that is homeborn, and unto the stranger that sojourneth among you." In other words, the passages that you have quoted apply to "sojourners" or aliens who were lawful! These passages do not apply to any "stranger" without exception, and they certainly do not apply to the current invasion of illegal Hispanic hobos in the United States of America. Also, you may want to consider the fact that Christ fulfilled the Old Testament law, the whole law (both moral & ceremonial). Attempting to place the yoke back on the ox will only work when addressing legalists. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

Noname, "I think if you ask the native Americans, they will say that we are all illegal immigrants" We are not illegal. I was born here thank you....as were my mother and her mother and her mother and her mother.... And you can't go bring up the past when worlds were still being "discovered" as a case in point. Illegals are not "finding new worlds"..... they are here to get your job, your money....and your social security! Am I bashing illegals for wanting a better life?---no, not at all. But the USA can not take in everyone...we can't stop poverty for everyone. We can't even stop poverty for our own people----we make them dependent on the free handouts, always afraid to get a job because, "I might loose my benefits." 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

Anderson, that was a joke. Calm down... My personal opinion - Corporate America is selling our jobs to illegal immigrants, China and India. It is very profitable - if you think about it, the middle class is paying for the education, health care, etc. of the illegals. Increased profits for the company. To me, corporations are the root cause of the problem - and they have a strong lobby with the lawmakers. We need to make companies accountable when they hire illegals - BIG TIME. The supply is unlimited and hard to address, we need to cut the demand... 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

also need to make other countrys accountable too. do something about them giving maps and handheld gps systems, damn, i don't even have one of those 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

There are things you can control, things you can influence, and things that are completely out of our reach. We can control our laws, so that's where we should be focusing on. Impose heavy fines on companies that hire illegals, so the risk vs. benefit doesn't pay off anymore. Make companies pay taxes whenever they outsource a job to another country - America loses tax revenue whenever they do that, so it is only fair. We should all put pressure on our representatives - maybe they will start listening to the American people more than they listen to the lobbyists, although I'm always skeptical when it comes to politicians... 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

Corporate America is selling our jobs to illegal immigrants, China and India. And it will get worse when they raise the minimum wage. Not much incentive to keep jobs in this country when you have to pay unskilled people as well as union workers (whose pay is linked to the minimum wage) even more money. 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

qpc, "And it will get worse when they raise the minimum wage." You got that right! It's a huge increase....unbelievable! It makes everyone elses dollar shrink as well....increasing the minimum wage decreases the value of the dollar. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

It makes everyone elses dollar shrink as well....increasing the minimum wage decreases the value of the dollar. Yep...get ready for higher prices, everyone. I've already seen it happen the last few months in the grocery store, and food suppliers for my husband's business are raising some of their prices already. When it goes into effect, just watch out. It happened when gas prices went up.....it will happen even more so when this happens. And so the people that it is "supposed" to help will be right back where they started. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

I'm sorry, but I don't think rasing a stagnant minimum wage is the source of our problems here. The larger the middle class is, the better off we are as a country. We should do everything possible to lift people up from poverty into the middle class. 

bbjones --- 19 years ago -

I'm sorry, but I don't think rasing a stagnant minimum wage is the source of our problems here. NoName, If you raise the wages which will raise the cost of goods, then you have accomplished nothing but dropping the middle class into poverty! 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

We should do everything possible to lift people up from poverty into the middle class. I heard this statistic on the news...73% of people in poverty don't work at all, and something like 60% of the people making minimum wage come from housholds with an income over $55,000 a year. So how exactly does raising the minimum wage help those in poverty become part of the middle class, esp when it means that everything will be more expensive and more jobs will be lost, either to downsizing or outsourcing? Increasing productivity (usually by increasing skill level) is the way to take people out of poverty....not just a mandatory increase of wages by a government who doesn't have to foot the bill. 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

Increasing productivity (usually by increasing skill level) is the way to take people out of poverty....not just a mandatory increase of wages by a government who doesn't have to foot the bill. be careful with what you say someone might call you a bigot and or racist. haha 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

"Increasing productivity (usually by increasing skill level) is the way to take people out of poverty" Amen sista! 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

The minimum wage has been stagnant for years, I think it is only fair to keep it up with inflation. Also, salaries are only one of many components that make up the price of something. Increasing the minimum wage by x% does not translate in an increase in prices of x%. If I wasn't offered at least the inflation rate in my current job, I would be out there looking for something else. I wouldn't have a problem finding a new job, but for a non-qualified worker, I can see how this approach wouldn't necessarily work. At any rate, this is one of those topics that are not worth discussing. The divide is just too wide... 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

You see, my husband owns a small business. Roughly 25-30% of his employees make minimum wage. Guess what...they are all 16 and younger. Now he also has, for example, an employee that is a single mom. She makes around $9 an hour, which isn't bad for the job that she has. If she continued to work for him and did a good job, he would continue to increase her salary so that she would be making more of a "middle class" wage, but when the minimum wage increase happen, and the transient (who usually work for him less than a year) teen gets almost as much as the single mom is getting, he simply can't increase her salary as much or as quickly. There is only so much money to go around and something has to give. So, while the teenager gets closer to the "middle class", the single mom gets further and further away from it all the while, her expenses (food, housing, clothing, etc) rising and her salary NOT rising. Thank goodness that this particular employee happens to be going to school so that she can have a "skilled" labor job, but how many out there don't have the resources to do this? Instead of focusing on wages, spend the money and effort focusing on helping those who truly want to leave poverty to learn new trades or to go to school. That is the answer. Then, those that don't want to improve by learning new trades or going to school stay in poverty because they CHOOSE to! 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

Also, salaries are only one of many components that make up the price of something. Increasing the minimum wage by x% does not translate in an increase in prices of x%. Labor is very far reaching.....it not only affects the final product, but in the suppliers for the company that makes the product. Suppliers raise their prices (because of the min wage) and then the end product gets raised because 1) labor is higher for the end producer 2) suppliers charge more for the supplies to make the product (because their labor costs are raised). Labor+cost to make product are BOTH higher, and I guarantee that prices go up. It is simple economics and any mainstream economist would tell you just that. 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

Making a hamburger involves.....beef farmers, tomato farmers, lettuce farmers, wheat farmers, dairy farmers, packagers of the beef, packagers of the tomatoes, packagers of the lettuce, bakers of the buns, packagers of the buns, producers of the cheese, packagers of the cheese, shippers/suppliers of the beef, shippers/suppliers of the tomato, shippers/suppliers of the lettuce, shippers/suppliers of the buns, shippers/suppliers of the cheese, tree growers, tree cutters (lumber company), paper/hamburger wrapper producers, transport company for wrapper, oil/grease makers/suppliers/transporters and THEN you get to McDonald's who has to pay the employees more to make the hamburger. It involves WAY more than just the end product, and EVERYBODY has to pay people more. The end product is just flat out more expensive to make and the consumer will pay the difference (including those in poverty). 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

It's the same reason that product prices went up when oil prices went up. It costs more to produce a shirt when gas prices are up because transporting goods costs more. We didn't notice as big of a difference then (but it happened) because transoprtation is only one key. Everything has labor involved in it, so raising wages raises costs for everyone...including those in poverty that the wage increase is "supposed" to help. Actually, the greatest sufferers are those that make just above min wage though. They are not usually in "poverty", but more often than not they are not the teenagers or the part time workers either (like the majority of min wage workers are) 

Anderson --- 19 years ago -

Excellent points qpc! 

qpc --- 19 years ago -

If I wasn't offered at least the inflation rate in my current job, I would be out there looking for something else. I wouldn't have a problem finding a new job, but for a non-qualified worker, I can see how this approach wouldn't necessarily work. People who work at a job long enough to get a raise increase usually do, even in the "unskilled" market. The problem is, min wage workers are almost always new to the job, little/no experience, part-time employees, teen agers, or a combination of these. Raising the min wage raises inflation! You don't help those who truly need the help by raisng the min wage. It "sounds" like your being compassionate, but it doesn't truly help those in poverty that are trying to get out of poverty, and in fact, makes things much much harder for them! It DOES help the union worker though....and believe me...they don't make anywhere NEAR min. wage. 

lilmommy --- 19 years ago -

qpc~~ I can support your claim that minimum wage going up will hurt everything. Many, Many years ago I worked for minimum wage and the pay went up .25 cents. Well we had to watch everything in the store go up. Gum that had been .25 went to .30 and cokes went from .79 to .99. While this was happening my father always got a cost of living allowance. He went up 40.00/week.(Union worker) I go up .25 cents and hour and he goes up 1.00 an hour. That's insane. The only person that was affected with the price hikes was me. The lowered payed individual. So I hate the idea of raising minimum wage. It hurts many! Especially small business owners. 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

as a memeber of an union i agree qpc, we don't make no where near min. wage. 

KaIzel79 --- 19 years ago -

Okay, coming to US illegaly is a crime and you can not compare that to the Bible, for the Bible also says to follow the laws. It is wrong for them to cross illegally. However, it will never stop and the gov't will never stop it or send them all back, because they need them, and they work hard and they get paid less that what others ask to get paid. People can complain all they want, but there will always be illegal immigrants here in US. As far as illegals taking your job... lol.. that's a laugh. NO one takes your job. If they are better or are willing to work for what they offer, they get the job. Maybe those who think illegals take their jobs should stop complaining and crying and get out there and work hard. Or better yet, just keep on trying to look for another job. There are many jobs out there. And you are not going to tell me, that jobs are going to run out because immigrants take them, please.... They do construction, yard work, maintenance, and all the work that many don't want to do or want to dirty their hands or feet. Those who say they are not racist, by the way they post their comments.... "They need to go home", "they need to stop taking our jobs", "they need to stop having babies", etc..... Yeah... your racist. If your not, then explain properly why they shouldn't come here illegally, but don't bash them. They too are humans and have a heart and feel. And last time I checked there are many who are here legally or born here in US who have many kids.... Don't judge unless you are in their shoes. It's very hard in Mexico and unfortunately their country doesn't do nothing for them and probably never will. That is why they seek to get a better life. And they are willing to risk themselves, their family and all of it. It's horrible, but they are desperate. And the laws of Mexico don't make it any easier for them to get Visas and permission to work here... because all they do is take money away and promise them visas and never do. People, lets think before we talk.... We all come from immigrants from another country. And trust me... one or maybe even two in your family tree... came illegaly... keep researching... you'll find it. Just my 2 cents. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

KaIzel79, excellent points... Actually, I wonder how many people complaining here have a cleaning lady or someone doing their lawn for a very low price, if you understand what I mean... 

likeke27 --- 19 years ago -

i don't, i mow my own lawn, and i can complain because i was born here. 

caitlin --- 19 years ago -

We do our own yard work and dang I clean my own house. I was born here as well as my great grandparents and yes I can complain. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

religion


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground