Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Statistics speak for themselves........

who's talking here?

NoNameNoLastName 1
robbie 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

robbie --- 20 years ago -

1. First the data compiled in the table below shows that there is no proof that Republican Presidents are better for the U.S. economy than Democratic Presidents. Indeed, the data indicates the opposite is likely true. 2. There are multiple other facts in addition to this data that show that the superficial argument about taxes is just that: superficial. For those arguments, click here (or scroll down below the table). NOTE: If you have challenges to the data below or further independent confirmation of the data, do let us know by emailing us at feedback-at-eriposte-dot-com. If you feedback is data-driven (as opposed to mere assertions or beliefs), we will be willing to provide links to it, as appropriate. Critiques and responses to critiques are here. MAILING LIST: If you want to get on my mailing list for notifications on updates to this page, let me know by emailing me at feedback-at-eriposte-dot-com DATA TABLE. Acronyms: BLS = U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics; BEA = U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis Metric Source of data/ analysis Average under Democratic Presidents/ Administrations Average under Republican Presidents/ Administrations Who measured better on this metric? (See critiques page) Average Ranking (lower the number the better) for highest GDP growth, real disposable personal income, employment/ unemployment, deficit reduction 1953-2001 Average rank calculated from ranking data from Dan Ackman, Forbes.com Overall rank: 4.58 (top 3 are Democrats) GDP rank: 3.8 Real Disposable Personal Income rank: 5.0 Employment rank: 4.6 Deficit Reduction rank: 4.2 Overall rank: 6.44 (Reagan is #4) GDP rank: 7.2 Real Disposable Personal Income rank: 6.0 Employment rank: 6.4 Deficit reduction rank: 6.38 Democratic Presidents [Also see this data comparison from Michael Kinsley in the Washington Post] Real Disposable Personal Income Growth per year 1953-2001 Dan Ackman, Forbes.com 3.65% 3.08% Democratic Presidents Employment gains per year 1953-2001 Dan Ackman, Forbes.com 1.684 million/year 1.279 million/year Democratic Presidents Unemployment: 1962-2001 P.L.A., using data from the BLS 5.1 % 6.75 % Democratic Presidents Unemployment: 1947-2001 Assuming that each President's policies took effect 1 year after his inauguration Larry Bartels, Los Angeles Times 4.8 % 6.3 % Democratic Presidents (trend similar if 2 year shift assumed) Unemployment: 1948-2001 Assuming Presidents are also responsible for economic performance 3-5 years after they leave office CalPundit, using data from the BLS 3-yr lag: 5.06 % 4-yr lag: 5.04 % 5-yr lag: 5.01% 3-yr lag: 6.16 % 4-yr lag: 6.18 % 5-yr lag: 6.21 % Democratic Presidents Average After-Tax Return on Tangible Capital: Jan 1952 - June 2004 Roger Altman, Wall Street Journal (data from Federal Reserve) 4.3% 3.2% Democratic Presidents [For a Bush I + Bush II vs. Clinton comparison, see here] GDP growth: 1962-2001 P.L.A., using data from the BEA 3.9 % 2.9 % Democratic Presidents GDP growth: 1948 - 2001 Assuming Presidents are also responsible for economic performance 3-5 years after they leave office CalPundit, using data from the BEA 3-yr lag: 3.56 % 4-yr lag: 3.78 % 5-yr lag: 3.71 % 3-yr lag: 3.35 % 4-yr lag: 3.16 % 5-yr lag: 3.21 % Democratic Presidents GDP growth: 1930-2000 Carol Vinzant in Slate 5.4% 1.6 % Democratic Presidents Inflation: 1962-2001 P.L.A., using data from the BLS 4.26 % 4.96 % Democratic Presidents Inflation: 1948-2001 Assuming Presidents are also responsible for economic performance 3-5 years after they leave office CalPundit, using CPI data from Economagic 3-yr lag: 3.33 % 4-yr lag: 3.07 % 5-yr lag: 3.20 % 3-yr lag: 4.36 % 4-yr lag: 4.60 % 5-yr lag: 4.48 % Democratic Presidents Percentage growth in Total Federal Spending: 1962-2001 P.L.A., using data from the U.S. Govt. Budget 2003 6.96 % 7.57 % Democratic Presidents if lower Govt. spending is better; Republican Presidents if higher spending is better NEW Note, however, that total spending other than for Medicare and Social Security has been dropping since 1983 (CalPundit using U.S. Govt. Budget data). The decrease was more significant in the 90s under Clinton. Percentage growth in Non-Defense Federal Spending: 1962-2001 P.L.A., using data from the U.S. Govt. Budget 2003 8.34 % 10.08 % Democratic Presidents if lower Govt. spending is better; Republican Presidents if higher spending is better NEW Note, however, that total spending other than for Medicare and Social Security has been dropping since 1983 (CalPundit using U.S. Govt. Budget data). The decrease was more significant in the 90s under Clinton. Non-defense Federal Government Employees: 1962-2001 P.L.A., using data from the U.S. Govt. Budget 2003 Rose by 59,000 (16 % of total rise over 40 years) Rose by 310,000 (84% of total rise over 40 years) Democratic Presidents (assuming smaller Govt. is better) Yearly budget deficit: 1962-2001 P.L.A., using data from the U.S. Govt. Budget 2003 $36 billion $190 billion Democratic Presidents Increase in National Debt: 1962-2001 P.L.A., using data from the U.S. Govt. Budget 2003 See follow-up by P.L.A. solidifying the conclusions Total debt increased by $0.72 trillion (20 years) Total debt increased by $3.8 trillion (20 years) Democratic Presidents Annual stock market return: 1927 (through) 1998 Pedro Santa-Clara and Rossen Valkanov Research Paper, UCLA (via Atrios) Results are "statistically significant" Also reported by CNN Money ~ 11% (value weighted CRSP index minus 3 month Treasury Bill) ~ 2% (value weighted CRSP index minus 3 month Treasury Bill) Democratic Presidents (Delta increases to 16% for equal-weighted case) The study says: "The difference comes from higher real stock returns and lower real interest rates, is statistically significant, and is robust in subsamples. The difference in returns is not explained by business-cycle variables related to expected returns, and is not concentrated around election dates. There is no difference in the riskiness of the stock market across presidencies that could justify a risk premium." Annual stock market return: (1900) 1927 - 2000 Carol Vinzant in Slate 12.3 % (S&P 500) 8.0 % (S&P 500) Democratic Presidents Annual stock market return: (1900) 1927 - 2000 Carol Vinzant in Slate Democratic Senate 10.5 % (S&P 500) Democratic House 10.9 % (S&P 500) Republican Senate 9.4 % (S&P 500) Republican House 8.1 % (S&P 500) Democratic Senate or House (but see article for qualifications) Annual stock market return: (1900) 1927 - 2000 Stock Traders' Almanac as reported by Carol Vinzant in Slate 13.4 % (Dow) 8.1 % (Dow) Democratic Presidents Rankings for highest GDP growth, biggest increase in jobs, biggest increase in personal disposable income after taxes, biggest rise in hourly wages, lowest Misery Index (inflation plus unemployment), etc. (until 2001) Arthur Blaustein, Mother Jones N/A. But all these best case metrics were under Democratic Presidents N/A Democratic Presidents . . . . . District spending by Congress: 1995 - 2001 Associated Press report: 1, 2 Democratic districts: $3.9 billion in 1995 to $5.2 billion in 2001 (34% increase) Republican districts: $3.9 billion in 1995 to $5.8 billion in 2001 (52% increase) Hard to say who is better but certainly not Republicans, who shifted spending to RICHER districts from poorer. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 19 years ago -

This is real data that cannot be questioned. I hardly believe you will get any comments from a republican here. Also, if you compare blue vs. red states, it is obvious that the blue states are much better off - including items such as lower divorce rate, abortion rate, etc. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground