Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Stem cell Research using human embryos...what's your thoughts?

who's talking here?

Doublestuff 1
JDB2 3
ilovemykids1030 1
ACwife 2
duflochy 1
sarahandgarett 3
bbjones 21
HIAAK 1
planemom 2
karenact 9
Danabug(BCM) 16
April 3
Anderson 8
likeke27 7
My 3 and Me 2
sniklefritz 3
Darrell 1
sharky 1
Just Tiffany 2
amcade 5
amb07 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

karenact --- 20 years ago -

I struggle with this one because I see the benefit in the research field but deep down I just don't feel right about it. I feel like we are messing with God's plan when we start creating life whatever teh reason whether it be fertility or research, and then when the embryos are no longer needed we disgard them or donate them to science. I doen's rest easy with me. And yet I have known people who have had illnesses where they are using stem cell's to research a cure and I absolutely see how useful this can be. I also know people who have gone through fertility treatments and I would never want to deny them there child that came from invitro but most times more embryos are created then are actually implanted and in a way there is a disregard for that life in the petri dish. I want to be okay with it if it helps us get closer to cures and if it brings beautiful babies into a couploes life but it just doesn't sit easy with me. I suppose it goes against my moral grain. I would love to hear others thoughts on this one. 

amb07 --- 20 years ago -

I think that as long as it is at the blastocyst stage it is morally acceptable. 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

See to me life begins at conception. And if it doesn't happen in the way God intended it to happen then we are playing God. Even though there is that part of me that thinks but hey God gave us our brains and talents which have enabled us to figure these things out so maybe it is okay. As you can see I am realy torn on this one. Go with the moral voice or rationalize it... I think I just answered my own question. It is not always the easiest to go with the moral voice. But I suppose in the end it is the only choice. 

amb07 --- 20 years ago -

So are you also against IUDs and birth control pills that change to lining of the uterus to prevent implantation of a blastocyst? 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

I am against using abortifacents (SP?) And yes IUD's are out for me and my morality. 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

 

amb07 --- 20 years ago -

I think abortion is just gross, but I think stem cell research is okay in some circumstances. 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

see when I think about the research and all the goodness that can come from it I want to say it is okay but I am just not setteled with that. If I remember correctly they can also get stem cells from cord blood. Isn't there a big hype about saving and storing your baby's cord blood? I would have no problem with donating that to science. I think that would be a beautiful thing! 

duflochy --- 20 years ago -

After all this time of hearing about this I still strugle to understand.....Mabe its just going too far..... 

Danabug(BCM) --- 20 years ago -

I don't support it. There may be medical benefits to it, but it doesn't justify anyone creating life, but God, and then just to kill it. They could do stem cell research as babies that were naturaly aborted (miscarriage) without a problem, so I think they should do that if they mother is willing to let them. 

planemom --- 20 years ago -

How about research using cells from the umbilical cord or placenta after birth? Will they work or do they have to be embryos? 

My 3 and Me --- 20 years ago -

To me, it is trading a life for a life. How is it any different than picking up a child from the local elementary school and doing experiments?? If they were using the stem cells from the umbilical cord, after birth, I would support that. But I cannot support them ending the life of a baby, not matter what the stage. I know that at my 6 week appt., my babies already had a heartbeat...that is a living person! 

planemom --- 20 years ago -

They could get placental/umbilical stem cells all day long too. Whenever I've been to the maternity ward it's been full. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

When there are other alternative available for stem cell research----there is no excuse for using embryo stem cells! It is sick and evil that it is even given thought. (oh...my opinion?...lol....NO!) 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

that is what I have thought that you could use cord blood or other avenues to collect stem cells. If there are other options then it makes it that much easier to disagree with. But then what do you all think about folks using invitro fertilization? I can't support that either. Unless every embryo is used and not disgarded or donated to science then maybe I could think about that one. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

karenact, " But then what do you all think about folks using invitro fertilization?" Tough one to answer. While I feel for anyone that is going thru infertility problems and strongly desire children....I do not believe in "creating" multiple lives knowing that "selective reduction" will be performed. Why not just create 2 eggs and implant 2 eggs....maybe even 3. But to create 7-10 lives, implant...let grow for weeks (!) knowing you will "pluck out" those extra later.....is still murder and a type of abortion. 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

Anderson I think for the first time I agree with you. but what if they didn't pluck them out. what if they were all allowed to grow into healthy babies? You are still playing God in a way. I have to think about this one. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

karen, "You are still playing God in a way" No....because God is all powerful and if he didn't want someone to have children----he would not allow them to, even with invitro! I've seen it alot that invitro doesn't work for them. 

Danabug(BCM) --- 20 years ago -

That is true, there is not a life created that God didn't create, so if it is not His will for you to have children you won't no matter what you do to make it happen. 

karenact --- 20 years ago -

hmmmmmm 

Danabug(BCM) --- 20 years ago -

That is what it all boils down to His timing. So many people are in such a hurry that we forget to pray His will not ours. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Steve, "invitro in kind of the same way as Abraham and Sarah" ME TOO! Look at what became of that nation that was created when humans took the matter into their own hands. My sister and her husband have been trying for over 3 years. But you know what? They have faith and take comfort in knowing that God knows and does things in His timing---not ours. So they wait joyfully for Gods great plans. 

JDB2 --- 20 years ago -

Cord blood and Adult stem cells! btw, it would be well over $3,000 for me to preserve my baby's cord. I would gladly have donated it (don't know too many people who wouldn't) 

sarahandgarett --- 20 years ago -

Have y'all ever gone through infertility? Do you know the pain and disappointment of month after month, year after year not being able to have a child? How dare you look down upon fertility treatments and spout off about what is wrong and right and what is God's will, without even knowing all the facts. Anderson, I challenge you to find me a doctor today who will put more than 2 embryos into a woman. Also, they do not IMPLANT the embryos into the unterus. The RE simply sticks them inside the uterus and we pray that they implant. After going through 2 years of infertility and finally getting pregnant through invitro, I cannot thank God or my doctors enough. My little boy is due in the next few weeks and I will never regret going through what I did to get pregnant. If I had listened to you, Steve, and adopted, I would not be about to hold my precious son in my arms. That was a very insenstive comment made by someone who I am sure never had to worry about having their own child. God gave us modern science and the ability to perform infertility treatments and I am going to take full advantage of that gift. I hope that this doesn't come across as an attack on you because that is not what I am trying to do. One of my many goals in life is to educate people on what couples who suffer from infertility go through. It pains me to see so many women suffer through this and not have the support from the community and their families that they should have. 

JDB2 --- 20 years ago -

Sarah -- my family did not go through this and I am sorry you had to. I am very glad that you are going to have your child. However, I do not think it is appropriate for you to use your situation to blanket everyone into your line of thought. There are usually more than one solution to a problem and frankly you come across as expecting everyone to change their views and feel sorry for you. I don't believe that is your intention. I would challenge you to convince everyone that you know what God wants and that anyone disagreeing is incorrect. I would also challenge you to discuss what is wrong with adoption. My most important concern however is to ask you how your situation relates to the original post of stem cell research and why the research cannot be done with adult stem cells and umbilical cord cells. If we simply say that God gave us the ability, don't we pretty much open the door to do whatever we as individuals want to do. I am not trying to pick a fight with you. Obviously you are someone who has a personal interest and someone who very strongly desires to have your own baby. I am very happy for you and glad to hear you don't have long to wait. I would simply ask that you take a look at these other perspectives more with a more objective eye and a more global view. Good Luck with your son! 

sarahandgarett --- 20 years ago -

jbd--I never once asked for anyone to feel sorry for me. I believe that what doesn't kill you, only makes you stronger. Through infertility, I have really grown as a person. What I did ask for was for people to understand that it is not as cut and dry as they may think. It is a very painful process that doesn't always end up with desired results. It is very easy for people who do not have first hand experience to say that it just isn't God's Will if it doesn't happen naturally. I am simply asking them to think about that before it is said to someone. One in five women suffer from infertility and you just never know who you may hurt by saying something along those lines. I know that it is not anyone's intention to inflict pain on someone. Also, I am not trying to blanket everyone into my line of thought. I know that everyone has their own opinions and a lot of times, opinions are impossible to change. I am just trying to give them another view to look at, to consider. If they don't agree with me, that is fine. The world will go on. People are entitled to their own opinions. The only reason I piped in on this conversation is because invitro was brought up in a negative light. I am not the first poster to mention invitro, so therefore I don't see a problem with commenting about it. Afterall, 9 posts dealt with it before I even joined the conversation. In fact, I believe that it was the original poster who brought it up. So, why is it a concern to think that I would follow up on it? As for adoption, I have nothing against it. I fully expected to adopt once every avenue available to us was exhausted. No one knows what God wants. I never pretended to think that. Some people were mentioning God's Will, well why are you not challenging them to "convince everyone that they know what God wants and that anyone disagreeing is incorrect." This is, I guess, what I just don't understand. You are challenging ONLY the person who disagrees with you. So, therefore, it would seem to me that YOU are the one who believes that she knows what God wants. Again, I am just trying to get people to consider other points of view or at least be a little more cautious as to what they say. So many women are going through this and they really don't need the added stress of people saying things that hurt, even if they don't mean them to hurt. 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

Sarah first of all....congratulations on your new baby. Second, this thread was not a personal attack on any one person or persons. It is a discussion of opinions. 

JDB2 --- 20 years ago -

I think you have successfully made my point -- because it pertains to you does not make it gospel. This has nothing to do with whether or not I agree. I don't think I said I didn't. If I had a problem, I would have clearly stated so. The problem that I have, as I stated clearly, is that an individual expressing that anything available is ok, is simply incorrect. My disagreement with you is that you are only thinking about you, not your audience. You said directly that God made it available. You said how dare us....you are doing exactly what you are speaking against. You are only considering yourself in my opinion and although I am happy to discuss invitro fertilization with the forum, my question was regarding how it relates to embrionic stem cell research. I don't know too many people who are opposed to invitro, but I sure know a lot that are opposed to abortion or to embrionic stem cell research. If we all put feelings above thought, we would all need to stop talking, right? We would not be able to have opinions. I do not know God's will on subjects like this one. Unlike yourself, I did not tell everyone that I knew what it was. Again, I am very happy for you! I just don't think it is appropriate to say that you are the only one qualified to speak since you have first hand experience. 

sarahandgarett --- 20 years ago -

jbd, I'm sorry, but I have never claimed to know what God's will is. Please, if I did say that, show me where I "told everyone that I knew what it was." Again, I did not bring up invitro. It was brought up by the original poster and picked up by a few posters after that. Why is it wrong that I commented on it, also? Thank you, Anderson and Steve for the congrats. I agree with you that this is a discussion of opinions. I am voicing my opinion, just as others are. I did not mean to personally attack anyone. I just wanted to make you aware that they do not put back a huge number of embryos and then pluck them out after weeks. I can see why you would think that invitro was horrible if they did do that. I would think it was horrible also. But, that is just not the case. Again, I am not trying to start some huge fight about who is right and wrong. Everyone has their opinion and is entitled to it. 

likeke27 --- 20 years ago -

opinions are like a&&holes, everyone has 

likeke27 --- 20 years ago -

one 

Anderson --- 20 years ago -

and they all stink! LOL 

Darrell --- 20 years ago -

Not mine, smells like gardenias *LOL* 

Doublestuff --- 20 years ago -

First of all, I want to say that I don't think we should use embryonic stem cells for research, especially when so much cord blood could be made available. Second, I just wanted to comment on the in vitro part of this topic. I have two beautiful children that we have due to in vitro. And just to let you know the embryos are much more fragile than the press makes it seem. The first time I went through the process, I had 12 eggs harvested, all fertilized, two were implanted and although I got pregnant, I miscarried at 8 weeks. The second time I had 14 eggs harvested, 13 fertilized and three were implanted and now I have my twins. Never did we reduce. What happens to the unimplanted eggs you may ask? Well in our case they let them continue growing for two more days to see if they would have a chance at being viable. The cell structure in all of the eggs broke down and none were viable for freezing (and would have broken down in the uterus as well). If we had some that were frozen we could have had them thawed and returned to the uterus at a later time without having to have eggs harvested again. I don't feel we were irresponsible to go this route although it is not for everyone. All through the process I prayed about it and felt that God led me in the choices that we made. You may ask why we went that route instead of adopting? I think adoption is a beautiful thing and we are considering it for the future. However, our choice at the time was to try to have our own biological child, and that is our choice whether we were able to get pregnant easily or through in vitro. My belief is that God allowed us to overcome our infertility to have our children through science. 

My 3 and Me --- 20 years ago -

From a very young age, I knew that I wanted children. If for some reason, I was unable to, I would have been heartbroken. I would not give in-vitro a 2nd thought. I would do whatever I had to do. I am against abortions and reductions, but I am not against a loving family having a biological child. 

Just Tiffany --- 20 years ago -

I have gone through infertility and it is a very painful process. The doctors wanted us to try IVF after several failed tries to get pregnant. We prayed about very hard and came up with a plan. We were up front with the docotor and told him exactly what we wanted. We told him that we wanted 5 eggs to be fretilized to be put back in and the rest of the egss to be frozen. He did look at us weird and did not understand why we were making this decision. I told him it was because we did not believe an embryo should be frozen. As soon as it is fertilized we believe that life has begun. He agreed to do it and I became pg with triplets but lost them. Our third try we got pregnant with our son. I was pg with twins and lost the twin. We stuck to Gods plan and was not going to have it any other way. The doctor told us that we were taking a risk by doing it this way. Look what happened we had a healthy boy. 

Danabug(BCM) --- 20 years ago -

I don't think jdb was saying that invitro is wrong. I stated this earlier, if it is God's will for you to get pregnant you will. Lots of women don't get pregnant with invitro, some do. What you need to understand is that even with invitro, God creates that baby, not you not the doctors. God creates the baby no matter what method you use. 

Just Tiffany --- 20 years ago -

BCM, You are exactly right. 

bbjones --- 20 years ago -

BeautiControl Mom You wrote "What you need to understand is that even with invitro, God creates that baby, not you not the doctors. God creates the baby no matter what method you use." od created Adam and Eve perfectly. We do have the genetic code from that perfect creation, however it has been degraded because of sin. He DID NOT create each one of us individually. "Psalms 51:5 Behold, I was shapen in iniquity; and in sin did my mother conceive me." He WOULD NOT create us individually because of sin that has entered the world. Genesis 3:16 "Unto the woman he said, I will greatly multiply thy sorrow and thy conception; in sorrow thou shalt bring forth children; and thy desire shall be to thy husband, and he shall rule over thee." We are born through reproductive conception. We become "perfect" in God's eyes when we accept His Son as Lord and Savior and THEN God creates a new spirit in us and we are "born again". By saying that God creates us all in the womb, we would be comparing our selves to the "immaculate conception" which would put us on par with Jesus - which we are not. In addition, creating "test tube" babies is proof that God does not go into the womb as he did the one time when Jesus was conceived by the Holy Spirit. 

Danabug(BCM) --- 20 years ago -

I am not saying God goes into the womb. I am saying that He is the Creator, it is through Him and Him alone that life is born. There is not one baby out there created that isn't created because of God's will. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground