Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

100 year old version of BLM -

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
I_won't_tell 6
Dorothy Parker 1
sdanielmcev 1
Emperor of Kingwood 5
AMDG 12

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

So I thought this would be topical. And I think it does bring up some interesting moral questions - that we are dealing with today as well.

The primary moral question is, is violence ever justified in response to evil, and if so, where is that line.

So 100 years ago were the Houston riots of 1917.

In a nutshell there were Black US soldiers stationed in Houston. While they were here they were subjected to the Jim Crow laws - and resentment between them and the police in Houston was growing.

There was an incident between the police and a few soldiers and some other blacks that resulted in a few of the soldiers being beaten and jailed.

Word of this got back to the barracks, and the story was inflated that some soldiers had been killed.

The soldiers in the barracks armed themselves and went into town looking for police.

They inflicted lots of violence - I think 17 people died ( not 100% sure that number)

The soldiers were captured, tried, some hung - some imprisoned for life.

So who was right and who was wrong ?? 

I_won't_tell --- 9 years ago -

Violence should never be tolerated in a civil society.

Laws are laws.
Violence does not change laws.
We have a very clear path - legislation changes laws.

There is not near enough detail for anyone to make a reasonable judgement in your story.

Why were "the soldiers being beaten and jailed"?

"They inflicted lots of violence"

Who is "They" - the soldiers?

Did the soldiers break the law?

Did the police break the law?

There should be significant consequences for anyone breaking the law.

To protect our civil society.

. 

Dorothy Parker --- 9 years ago -

You just can't help yourself, can you, I_won't_tell? You are iced! Follow the rules of the site and stop posting. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

This is like asking if Snowden is a criminal or Patriot. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

This is like asking if Snowden is a criminal or Patriot.

Well only in the ends vs means category

I think that question changes some when you add violence 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Laws are laws.

Are all laws to be obeyed , always ??

Is it ever the morally right thing to do to disobey the law ?? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

I think that question changes some when you add violence

Maybe.

The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants.
-Thomas Jefferson 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

Are all laws to be obeyed , always ??

Depends on who you ask. If you ask someone deeply investment in the establishment the answer is most likely yes.

Is it ever the morally right thing to do to disobey the law ??

Ask our founders that question. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Depends on who you ask. If you ask someone deeply investment in the establishment the answer is most likely yes.

I'm asking you

Ask our founders that question.

Think that = yes - does it ??? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

Think that = yes - does it ???
I think so 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

Depends on who you ask. If you ask someone deeply investment in the establishment the answer is most likely yes.

I'm asking you


As a son of the American Revolution, I am very deeply invested in this Nation and her laws. But, being a Patriot at heart I can make an argument on a case basis for disobeying a law I view as immoral or a violation of the intent of the Constitution. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

so what do you think I wont tell ???

are all laws - laws and should be followed ? 

I_won't_tell --- 9 years ago -

Breaking LAWS when America was part of England led to the American Revolutionary War.

Today if anyone is supporting BREAKING LAWS in an organized way it could lead to a CIVIL WAR. Which I doubt would ever be allowed to happen.

Are things so bad that anyone here would support CIVIL WAR? 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -


Today if anyone is supporting BREAKING LAWS in an organized way it could lead to a CIVIL WAR. Which I doubt would ever be allowed to happen.


So to try and put that in some philosophic context - what I hear is it may be better to live with and follow an immoral law, because of the consequences of fighting/disobeying it

Do I have that right ??

Love THE CAPS !!! 

whatchamacallit --- 9 years ago -

Are things so bad that anyone here would support CIVIL WAR??



Not yet. 

I_won't_tell --- 9 years ago -

I really don't know of an immoral law.
(maybe I am oblivious and/or wrong)

Which laws do you consider immoral? 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Which laws do you consider immoral?

Legal abortion 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Death Penalty 

whatchamacallit --- 9 years ago -

I_won't_tell --- 1 min ago - quote - hide comments
I really don't know of an immoral law.
(maybe I am oblivious and/or wrong)

Which laws do you consider immoral??



What about the laws that extort money from productive citizens, then redistribute it to those who are non-productive? That's theft and definitely immoral. 

I_won't_tell --- 9 years ago -

I am strongly against abortion.

I don't want anyone to be put to death - we need a very strong deterrent.

So I am strongly for the death penalty. Sometimes people self select deserving the death penalty in my opinion by doing something horrific. Some don't deserve our oxygen if they have done something horrific.(murder would be one of the reasons for the death penalty)

Taxes - some need SHORT-TERM help - I support helping SHORT-TERM via our tax system.

Some cheat the system and are leeches. I am in support of natural selection for those - sink or swim. I am confident lots of leeches would find a way to swim and would eventually help pull OUR wagon.

. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Another moral dilemma question -

You are are a concealed carry guy - and you have your gun.

You are protesting against BLM and as the event breaks up you are walking back to your car.

A few blocks away there is a group of Neo- Nazi's screaming racial comments approaching a black mother and say 12 year old boy. They are verbally threatening them - Say they are 20 yards apart and closing fast.

You are across the street between them and you are armed, what do you do ??

What can you legally do ??

What can you morally do ?? 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

I am strongly against abortion.

So in your opinion are laws legalizing abortion moral ?? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 9 years ago -

Think "Nuremberg Laws"- think Sharia Laws- certainly immoral- 

I_won't_tell --- 9 years ago -

"You are across the street between them and you are armed, what do you do? What can you legally do? What can you morally do?"

BLM members moments ago were screaming racial comments and verbally threatening them.

Based on this information - nothing.

No law has been broken.
Neither like/trust/respect each other. OK.

I would intervene (verbally first) if there was violence from either party.

I am a father. I can't understand how anyone that has experienced the birth process (100% of us humans have been exposed to the process) - can conclude that a pregnant mother (at any stage) does not have a child inside her. NO abortion for convenience should ever be legal.

Killing a baby is immoral.

I am only considering and talking about U.S. laws. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

NO abortion for convenience should ever be legal.

Killing a baby is immoral.


so you agree then - the laws allowing abortion (waiting on the semantic police on this one) are immoral. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

I would intervene (verbally first) if there was violence from either party.

OK I wont tell - that group of neo nazis are 5 yards away now - and the one closest to you has a gun in his hand pointing at the ground.

What do you do now ?? 

I_won't_tell --- 9 years ago -

AMDG - I won't comment further.

I expect real-life/real-time/stress/circumstances would impact my actions.

To think otherwise - I think would be naive. 

sdanielmcev --- 9 years ago -

Reading the actual history of it, not even close. A singular incident, vs. a mass movement. A riot over a craps game vs. many riots over thugs getting killed by cops. BTW, the soldiers were convicted of mutiny, not over rioting. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground