Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Tank or Tankless Electric

who's talking here?

TinktheSprite 4
andreweggplant 5
sdanielmcev 2
Emperor of Kingwood 4
witchywoman 1
Judas 1
Butterbean 1
them 1
Karras 4
urabunchcats 1
tinnman 1
Ashes 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

Building a house at the beach. Anybody have any experience with tank less hot water heaters versus tank heaters? The energy supply will be electric. 

sdanielmcev --- 9 years ago -

How many people in the house?
Tankless have volume issues. Example, you can't use 2 hot water-using appliances at the same time. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

Thats what I've heard. 

Ashes --- 9 years ago -

The house we are about to move into, has a tankless water heater. Which is new to us, but we were told it's more efficient. I don't know, people have differing opinions. 

Ashes --- 9 years ago -

I hope so bc I take lots of hot baths lol 

TinktheSprite --- 9 years ago -

We are preparing to replace our water heater in the very near future. I also heard there are volume issues and that it takes a number of years to recoup the savings. 

them --- 9 years ago -

I hear that gas is better but have seen houses have several electric heaters throughout the house in each bathroom and the kitchen. That sounds like it'd be expensive. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

I also heard there are volume issues and that it takes a number of years to recoup the savings.

It takes the same amount of energy to raise the same volume of water 35 degrees F no matter what type of heater it is. 

TinktheSprite --- 9 years ago -

It takes the same amount of energy to raise the same volume of water 35 degrees F no matter what type of heater it is.
I meant the regarding the cost differences of the unit itself. Tankless can be as much as three times more than a standard water heater. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 9 years ago -

Tankless can be as much as three times more than a standard water heater.

Doing some preliminary pricing that what I saw as well. I was hoping for somethin that would amaze. 

Butterbean --- 9 years ago -

If it's a part time occupancy, plan your circuits to only have security activated during your absence.That saves a significant amount of power. Today's water heaters are fast recovery and you will not wait long for hot water after you arrive and power up the house.

I think planning electrical use will save more money than type of heater. 

andreweggplant --- 9 years ago -

Tankless have volume issues. Example, you can't use 2 hot water-using appliances at the same time

Don't think that is true with the newer tankless heaters. Because of the location of my water heater as well as the breaker box and what it takes to power an electric heater I am having a gas tankless installed. The flow is 15gpm and I am told you can run three showers and the washer at the same time. The install is not all that much more than it would have been to do the modifications for an electric heater and there is not enough space to put in a gas heater. 

TinktheSprite --- 9 years ago -

I think they may have improved some, But it's still cost prohibitive for us. I think we will replace it with the standard gas tank. 

sdanielmcev --- 9 years ago -


It takes the same amount of energy to raise the same volume of water 35 degrees F no matter what type of heater it is.


This is true. However, in a tankless,the water is flowing, and not stagnant. Time has to be added to the equation. Some tankless heaters have a recirculating system that pre-heat the water. There are also small point-of-use add-ons that can give (almost) instantaneous heat. Eggman is also correct that the newer models, some as dual systems, are less likely to wane. But more expensive. 

Karras --- 9 years ago -

We moved into a house with a tankless.

So far our experience has been ok. The problems we encountered was due to the previous home owner not installing the tankless correctly. So make sure whoever you use knows what they are doing. For Houston I recommend the Hot water guys. The only work on Tankless.

We have a Rinnai and it is bulletproof. There is a competing manufacturer, but the problem is that model has too many valves and more likely to fail.

Rinnai recommend that you get is flushed once a year to clean out any buildup. That runs about $200. We have never had this done. 

andreweggplant --- 9 years ago -

For Houston I recommend the Hot water guys.

Funny, I called them and they refused to install a tankless at my house. Said it was not worth it for me. They wanted me to run a "dufuss" electrical around the outside of my house at an additional cost of $1000 so power a standard electric heater.

I actually found a local plumber that will install a tankless for me me. I have reseached this to the max and Rianni's are no longer the "cadillac". There are others that do not require the special modifications to venting and gas line as Rianni and have a longer warranty. And you can do the maintenance each year yourself 

urabunchcats --- 9 years ago -

andreweggplant -

Please share details about you findings. 

Karras --- 9 years ago -

Again, I would make sure the plumber you are using knows what they are doing. I would call their references.

I had several companies from Kingwood come over to the house to fix a problem, and even though they said they knew Tankless, they didn't. Their standard response was "You need a new one". The HWG diagnosed the problem pretty quick and had it fixed without replacing the unit.

Also, look at the construction of Rinnai vs. the others. I believe Rinnai uses 6 or 8 heat exchangers where one of the competitors uses 32.

This is definitely not a job you want to go cheap on. 

Judas --- 9 years ago -

What a thinks-they-know-it-all and anything and everything. 

andreweggplant --- 9 years ago -

I would make sure the plumber you are using knows what they are doing. I would call their references.

Already done... Plumber is well known and has GREAT referrals.

The HWG would not even come out to the house to look at things. Just a big company that wants to take the little guy for a ride IMO.

It is not cheap but I can tell you right now I know more about hot water heaters of all kinds than I ever cared to know. Rianni is no longer the best and you no longer have to use their, shall I say different for lack of a better term, installation materials etc... The venting alone on a Rianni is ridiculous. 

Karras --- 9 years ago -

The HWG would not even come out to the house to look at things. Just a big company that wants to take the little guy for a ride IMO.

They only have 12 employees, LOL. I would like to hear their version of the story.

As for Rianni, that tankless has been in the attic of this house over 10 years and we've only had two problems. Cracked vent pipe and bees somehow got in the heater.

As they say you get what you pay for. 

witchywoman --- 9 years ago -

It takes the same amount of energy to raise the same volume of water 35 degrees F no matter what type of heater it is.?


This really doesn't address the comment you were responding to but regardless, the difference is that one heats up water as needed and the other not only heats it up but maintains the temp in storage. 

tinnman --- 9 years ago -

I would recommend the Navien tankless.

Condensing tankless water heater which makes it extremely efficient. It's AFUE rating is 95%. That means 95% of the gas fed to the heater is used to heat the water.

It has the highest turndown ratio in the industry....15:1.

Superior product if you ask me. 

andreweggplant --- 9 years ago -

They only have 12 employees, LOL. I would like to hear their version of the story.



REALLY, You don't know me from adam so keep you judgements to yourself.

I called them, I asked them about a tankless heater, they asked me about what I had and my house and told me I should not even consider a tankless. End of story.

SO happy you are happy with your Rianni but they are no longer the best or only one on the market.

Geesh, do you work for them or something 

Karras --- 9 years ago -

No I don't work for them, you trashed a pretty good company because they wouldn't help you out.

I give a company credit for turning down a job if they cannot do it right. There are a lot of contractors out there that will try to fit a round peg in a square hole if for the work. That's all.

Good luck. I hope the contractor and the unit has a good warranty for work and the product. 

TinktheSprite --- 9 years ago -

Karras, you give credit for a company you've recommended for a job stating "They only work on tankless" systems and they turned that job down? Makes no sense. SMH I wouldn't use them simply because they didn't give Andrew an alternative only criticized the system he wanted, the system that is supposedly their specialty. 

andreweggplant --- 9 years ago -

No I don't work for them, you trashed a pretty good company because they wouldn't help you out.

You are so full of s@#%! I didn't trash anyone, I stated a fact. You find fault with everything and everyone. You must be one miserable human being.

When a company tries to sell me something I don't want it is not someone I would recommend or do business with. A lot may have changed in the 10 years since they installed a heater for you. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground