Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Rachel Maddow humiliated over tax return "scoop"

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 3
jackass 1
Let Logic Prevail 1
sheddy 1
BuiltinTX70 6
sdanielmcev 2
Prolix Raconteur 3
RayofHope 2
AMDG 2
them 1
dkeller 1
JustWatching 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

them --- 9 years ago -

Trump paid 25% tax rate.

Obama 19% tax rate.

Bernie 13% rate.


Rachel Maddow Turned a Scoop on Donald Trump?s Taxes Into a Cynical, Self-Defeating Spectacle

By Willa Paskin
maddow_1
Rachel Maddow had the goods, but she oversold them.
MSNBC

At 7:36 pm Tuesday night, Rachel Maddow tweeted ?BREAKING: We've got Trump tax returns. Tonight, 9pm ET. MSNBC. (Seriously),? sending the internet into a frenzy of theorizing. Did Maddow have Donald Trump?s tax returns or just one of the Trumps? tax returns? Could this be it, the tax return that would bring down the Donald? If this was it, why wasn't MSNBC cutting into its programming, instead of running a countdown clock to Maddow?s show? By 8:24, Maddow was tweeting that the tax return in question was Donald Trump?s 1040 from 2005. By 8:30, still half an hour before Maddow started airing, the White House had responded to the MSNBC report, saying that Trump had paid $38 million on income of $150 million that year. An hour later, about 20 minutes after The Rachel Maddow Show started, Maddow would confirm these numbers, turning her big scoop about Donald Trump?s long-missing tax returns into a cautionary tale about over-hype. Rachel Maddow, you played yourself?and us too.

?It?s been a little bit of a hullabaloo around here this evening, I apologize for being flustered,? Maddow said at the top of the hour, before confirming that her show had copies of Donald Trump?s federal tax returns, obtained by the reporter David Cay Johnston, to share with her audience. ?In just a second we?re going to show you exactly what it is we?ve got,? she said, before launching, instead, into a 20-minute monologue. Maddow seemed uncharacteristically nervous as she wended her way though what could kindly be described as context and which I am unkindly describing as word salad, a long meander that was difficult to follow even without the distracting promise of a revelatory tax return at its end.

The monologue started contextually enough, with a long-winded skewering of Trump?s refusal to share his tax returns that touched on Richard Nixon, the Clintons, and his unaudited tax forms, before veering off conspiratorially. ?Whether or not you are a supporter of Donald Trump,? Maddow said, ?It ought to give you pause that his explanations [for not releasing his tax returns] have never made any factual sense .? When you get an excuse from them that doesn't make sense, you have to look for another reason. What?s the real explanation? Well, choose your own adventure.? She then launched into a long hypothetical about a particular Russian oligarch?s possible relationship to Trump that touched on Florida real estate, Deutsche Bank, and Preet Bharara, that Trump?s tax returns?though not, as it would turn out, the ones she actually had?could conceivably clear up.

The longer Maddow went on, ever deeper into a conspiratorial thicket, the clearer it became that whatever tax returns Maddow had, they weren?t as juicy as the ones she was talking about. If she had anything that damning, she would have shared them from the start. TV is a ratings game, but an entire episode about highly damaging tax returns is just as likely to get you great ratings as milking the possibility that you have highly damaging tax returns, and less likely to get you compared to Geraldo. Maddow even went so far as to hold the tax returns back until after the first commercial break, as if we were watching an episode of The Bachelor and not a matter of national importance?because we weren?t, in fact, watching a matter of national importance, just a cable news show trying to set a ratings record.

After the first break?at which point the tax returns were already available on the internet and glossed by the Daily Beast?Maddow was joined by Johnston, and she began by asking him how he knew Trump hadn?t sent the returns himself. Johnston said that he could have. A few hours after Maddow finished airing, this has become a popular conspiracy theory, simply because, if Donald Trump were to share any of his tax returns, the 2005 1040 seems like a good candidate. Trump paid taxes at a rate of around 4 percent, but because of the alternate minimum tax, he also paid an additional $31 million. The form revealed that, rather than not paying taxes and making no money, Trump paid $38 million on $150 million in income. Maddow promised to pull a sordid revelation out of a hat and instead plucked out ? Trump?s credibility? Maddow was soon parsing, asking Johnston to explain that Trump is currently trying to do away with the AMT, which, unfair as it may be, still wouldn?t change the amount he paid in 2005.

As the show went on, it became clear that Maddow knew she didn't quite have the scoop that had been promised. ?What would we have to see, what would we hope to get in mail,? she asked Johnston, ?if we were going to get to the real meat of Donald Trump?s foreign ties???i.e. what would be more meaningful than the tax form that we have? Speaking to Chris Hayes and Johnston, she said, ?The story here to me is, a) we have obtained this [tax form], b) that this stuff is obtainable.? ?BREAKING: Trump?s tax returns theoretically obtainable. Tonight, 9pm ET. MSNBC. (Seriously)? does make for a less rousing tweet.

Trump?s tax returns, whatever information they happen to contain, constitute a major scoop. Maddow?s social media team ensured the highest possible ratings for that scoop. But if ever a story should have been delivered in a stentorian, fuddy-duddy, nonpartisan manner, this was it. In positioning it as a grand revelation, a vital step in comprehending Trump?s corruption, MSNBC created an exceedingly cynical spectacle. By playing into the network?s loyal liberal audience?s fantasy that there exists a Trump silver bullet, it instead delivered Trump a positive news cycle?the guy pays taxes! Who knew!?amidst the debacle of the AHCA, along with more evidence that the media is aligned against him. The lesson? Don?t tell us you have news, just tell us the news. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 9 years ago -

The whole "scoop" thing was ridiculous, at least from her perspective.

Not many people care about how much in taxes Trump paid.......if he tried to pay the least amount, good for him. EVERYONE does that. EVERYONE.

The real "scoop" needs to be who is DJT doing business with. That's the real reason, and legit reason, people want to see his tax returns. 

Prolix Raconteur --- 9 years ago -

Maddow is the newly crowned queen of fake news after that epic fail. 

RayofHope --- 9 years ago -

Sorry Rachel, you have to be a really stupid reporter. There is speculation that Donald Trump himself put them in Rachel's mail box. She took the bait and used it as a story.

Imagine Rachel featuring a series of stories telling the world that Donald Trump made a lot of money and paid more taxes than Obama.

The Democrats must be shaking their heads in disbelief. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 9 years ago -

Wasn't really fake news, it was in fact legit. At the very least it could be considered interesting. Although it was from 2005......... 

RayofHope --- 9 years ago -

Wasn't really fake news,

I understand why you might say that, but think about it. She (Rachel) tried to use the 2005 tax returns to accuse Trump of other (hypothetical) acts.

She created a fake news story based on Trumps 2005 tax return.

MSNBC is going down the tubes. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 9 years ago -

I would have advised her to show it, but not make it her entire show - as if it were breaking news. As soon as I saw the preview, I figured it was going to be some kind of "knock off".

It was from 2005, that's 12 years ago.

His tax return from the last few years is much more relevant, and what people really want to see.

She has a tendency to draw things out in her presentation, and it's one reason I don't like her show. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 9 years ago -

I understand why you might say that, but think about it. She (Rachel) tried to use the 2005 tax returns to accuse Trump of other (hypothetical) acts.

The only thing I'll say about that is, that's how most of the news is today. We don't have a guy behind a desk reading the news. It's more project/debate/discuss with guests and panels. And with that, you're going to get hypotheticals that ultimately cater to the host.

The days of Headline News (remember that) are long gone!!! 

Prolix Raconteur --- 9 years ago -

Granted it wasn't "fake" in the sense that it was false, but more "fake" in the sense it is not really news and that she hyped it for hours on social media prior to the show as a bombshell and proceeded to play it up for the first 30 minutes of her show before showing a simple 1040 form that actually showed Trump paid more taxes percentage wise than Obama, Bernie or even her employer.

It was an EPIC FAIL on her part and even other liberal media outlets are calling her out on it, saying she only added credibility to Trump and knocked the wind out of the anti-trumper's sails. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 9 years ago -

Yes....I agree...it was classic bait and switch, so to speak.

If I were her producers, I would have said show it, but only make that a small part of the show (with hopefully more to come later).

As I said, she's usually long winded and this didn't dissapoint. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

For profit media's first objective is to make a profit. The line between "news", "opinion", and "entertainment" is very fuzzy these days. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 9 years ago -

Journalistic suicide.

(If you can even really call him a journalist) 

sheddy --- 9 years ago -

I don't care about his tax returns. I know the IRS has looked into his returns and if they haven't found anything, I have a feeling there is nothing to see. 

jackass --- 9 years ago -

"Client Copy"



That says it all. LOL 

sdanielmcev --- 9 years ago -

The liberals' slow ascendency into oblivion. 

BuiltinTX70 --- 9 years ago -

The liberals' slow ascendency into oblivion.

Healthcare answer bringing Pubs right behind!!!!! 

dkeller --- 9 years ago -

Healthcare answer bringing Pubs right behind!!!!!?

Yes, that is turning into a mess with Trump acting like Obamalite is perfectly a fine place to start. Oh that's right; he didn't know how complicated it was. Jeesh...what a moron. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 9 years ago -

LOL............ This was Maddows "Geraldo Rivera" moment. 

JustWatching --- 9 years ago -

The media bias is really becoming apparent. 

Prolix Raconteur --- 9 years ago -

Maddow's spin today is that the reason the 2005 return made him look good is because Melania was seeking citizenship around that time and apparently in Maddow's world that's the only reason he paid taxes that year. She just pulls stuff out of her a## and proffers it as news. She redefines media bias. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Public Service announcement -

News does not equal Critical Opinion

Critical Opinion ( scientific, judicial, editorial) does not equal thoughtful, reasoned, or supported Opinion

Supported Opinion does not equal Opinion

what 99% of this "fake news" or "biased media" is, is just opinion - from both sides - usually stated for some self serving purpose. 

sdanielmcev --- 9 years ago -

it's critical analysis, not critical opinion.
It's fake news when it is presented as factual. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 9 years ago -

WOW.......... AMDG even spins for MSNBC.

You've come a long way! 

Let Logic Prevail --- 9 years ago -

It's clear Trump released that specific tax return on his own as a distraction and chose the best out of the bunch. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground