Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

New and have a question - hi everyone!

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 6
*LOL* 2
needsleep 2
sdanielmcev 1
Judas 1
Butterbean 1
Leila 1
AMDG 2
fuzz81 2
dkeller 13

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

dkeller --- 9 years ago -

Good evening everyone! I'm new to posting here- though I have had family members that have been here before-and I hate to start out with a question but I figured this would be a good place to ask.

Okay, here goes. I don't know a lot about work visas or green cards but I've been wondering this for a long time. I thought those work visas were for people that fill jobs that can't be filled by Americans. How do we get fast food workers that don't speak a word of English. The reason that I am asking is I went into the Taco Cabana here in Kingwood the other day and two of the workers didn't know a word of English. Now, I like that this location has really improved their service and I certainly don't want for their flautas to be so expensive I can't enjoy them :) but I don't understand this. What am I missing? Is there a lack of workers for fast-food; don't we have plenty of teens here in KW that can fill these jobs? I tried to read up on requirements for work visas but all I found just reiterated that those visas are for people that fill jobs no one here wants. So, if someone can finally enlighten me please tell me. 

Leila --- 9 years ago -

I don't know anything about the visas you are speaking of but I do know it is hard to fill minimum wage jobs around here. During the school year a lot of teen's parents want them to study and participate in after school activities and that means not working after school in many cases. A lot of workers for these lower level jobs come from outside of this community.

Some companies (ChikfilA comes to mind) have incentives such as scholarships to attract teen workers and perhaps better working conditions. 

dkeller --- 9 years ago -

The scholarships are a good idea and it probably makes the kids feel better about their jobs. I didn't realize there was such a problem in this area finding workers. And because I see only some places filled with workers not speaking English I figured managers were purposefully hiring them and I didn't quite get it. Of course it is the manager's right to hire whomever they want. 

*LOL* --- 9 years ago -

What position did these workers have? I assume they were not taking orders or have a job that would require a lot of customer interaction. So I guess I am curious where you have been..under a rock? You can find workers all over the place that speak little or no English and I'm not just talking about Hispanic workers although I assume that is what you are pointing to.

Back to your point. Just because someone does not speak English or at least to knowledge they don't does not mean they are not here legally and that doesn't mean they had to have a work visa. There are many paths to a green card and some may (surprise!) even be citizens. 

dkeller --- 9 years ago -

I don't eat at fast food places a whole lot. If I splurge to go out I prefer something a bit different than fast food. I didn't first think they were here illegally- actually I didn't really know what to think- I was trying to understand by which legal route they were here and when I Googled and read on the different mechanisms they use to come here to work I was even more confused as to how their specific labor was needed here. I'm still reading in my other window. I'm not from Texas and where I came from didn't really have a large immigrant population so I am still observing and learning. What did you mean by there are many paths to a green card and some may even be citizens. Why would citizens of the U.S. need a green card? 

dkeller --- 9 years ago -

I found my answer! It's a huge category. "Green card through family route".

https://www.uscis.gov/green-card/green-card-through-family

Now, I get it when people say, "They stayed here after their green card expired". This is different from a work visa. The tech companies are worried about work visas not green cards. So there isn't a need for immigrant fast food workers. They are here because anyone with a family member already here can get one. That's a lot of people.

We had migrant crop workers where i came from (Indiana) so i just didn't get why Texas needed all these fast food workers from across the border. 

sdanielmcev --- 9 years ago -

Really, the difference between those that come here illegally, (those smuggled or enter illegally) and those over-staying their work visas are two different subjects.
Over-stayeds, while here illegal now, usually come here legally. They are not in minimum wage jobs, and can simply return to their consulate to renew their visa in most cases.
The illegal entry persons are the problem, and take what would be entry-level jobs from kids and those that need work to get off the welfare rolls. 

dkeller --- 9 years ago -

You said the over-stayeds come here legally and are illegal now and aren't in minimum wage jobs. But that would mean the ones here illegally are all these restuarant workers! I don't think that can be accurate; that's a huge group that would have to be working in restaurants that aren't here legally. That doesn't sound right. Do you really believe that all the green card holders are NOT getting minimum wage jobs? Then they would be using work visas to show they are needed in these better paying jobs right, not green cards. I am finding that the majority of Mexicans here are on green cards not work visas which cleared up what I was trying to figure out. You see I am from Indiana and we have groups that are there on work visas; not green cards. Here it seems there is a huge infux but using the green card route not the work visa route. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Pardon me if this is repetitive. Green cards and work visas are completely different things.

A green card is an ID that you have permanent residence status in the US. Most of these I think are family driven - ie: Spouse of a US citizen, etc., not 100% sure of other avenues. But has nothing to do with employment.

Work visa's are completely tied to work. And in general the employer must make a reasonable case why the job can not be filled by a US citizen. Different countries tend to have different quotas of allowed work visas. And it varies over time. Not 100% sure what drives the numbers allowed.

Green card holders - are free to take any job they can get, or are qualified for. From CEO to dishwasher.

Work visas are tied to a specific job - with a specific company - and if the employee leaves or is dismissed - they are supposed to leave the country. 

Butterbean --- 9 years ago -

Troll. 

AMDG --- 9 years ago -

Work visas are a moderately expensive process for the employer - well into a few thousand dollars - and almost always require an immigration lawyer to expedite the process.

No one is getting a work visa to work fast food. 

dkeller --- 9 years ago -

You are not being repetitive; you are being accurate. I didn't understand why sdanielmcev felt that green card holders weren't in low paying jobs. I felt that couldn't be right. One poster said that those that work in fast food restaurants were filling a need and that didn't sound right. Not many green card holders in Indiana; yes to work visas. It is reversed here. Many here on green cards and I have discovered that some immigrants don't know what a work visa is for because they assume migration via green cards. 

needsleep --- 9 years ago -

Green card holders are granted permanent residence in the US. Usually they are good for 10 years. Work Visas are temporary. Say x person has a green card and leaves his or her work at taco cabana, he can find another job and stay here. Work visas are sponsored by the employer if X employee quits gets fired etc he / she has to have another employer sponsor them otherwise they no longer have legal status based on that work visa. They can change the type of visa they have. I think it is inaccurate to say most overstay their green card. Most actually overstay their Visas. The most common tourist visas and student visas. From about 2005 to 2008 Texas DPS issued DL and ID cards for the same length of time as Reg citzens. I know this for a fact because we had sponsored person staying in our home. I was shocked their DL was good for 3 years and ID was good for much longer. No our sponsored person did not overstay their visa. DPS changed their system and now issues the DLs and ID cards specific to the expiration of the issued visas. Usually 1 year. The visa holder may also be issued a social security card. During my experience of this the Social security card had certain verbiage that it was tied into the validity and expiration date of the visa. If the person goes back to their country or renews their visa they can get another social security card, they will issued the same number to correspond to the new visa date. There are many types of Visas. Green card holders are allowed to renew and is fairly reasonable to do so. The card expires not usually their residency. A green card holder can petition their relative. A person on a student Visa can not. I know that for sure. Now other Visas that are issued I am not sure of. Receiving a green card is a closer path to obtain citizenship. It is common for someone to be on a work Visa have it renewed then apply for permanent status a green card then apply for citizenship. Green card holders do not have to be holders of entry level jobs. Example child had greencard allowed to renew enters college graduates college and now holds a professional job and degree and possibly still have a greencard. 

dkeller --- 9 years ago -

I was not aware that "the visa holder may also be issued a social security card." What do you mean that "Green card holders are granted permanent residence in the US. Usually they are good for 10 years." How is it considered permanent if they are good for a limited time? Thanks for sharing all you know. 

needsleep --- 9 years ago -

The expiration date on the card itself is for 10 Years. That does not mean the person is kicked out of the country. The person may just renew the green card. Just like our drivers license. As long as we don't have the priveledge to drive revoked we can just reapply. I can't remember if it is a J1 or J2 visa where the person can lawfully work in the US this is where the social security card comes into play. 

dkeller --- 9 years ago -

Got it! And that clears up something else I didn't understand. Someone on the Yahoo forum the other day said the easiest way to deal with all the immigration from Mexico was to NOT renew their green cards but I kept switching it in my head to "work visas" because like I said previously immigrants here on work visas is what we were familiar with. And permanent means a conditional permanence. Permanent if they get renewal approval and as you said it is termed "permanent" in that situation. It's always best to hear from someone who has first hand knowledge of the process. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 9 years ago -

Definitely a troll. 

dkeller --- 9 years ago -

Rude on this thread too? Who is a troll? You didn't even respond to this thread. Do you have any insights and feedback on this subject? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 9 years ago -

Troll, troll............ troll yer boat. 

dkeller --- 9 years ago -

So no insights on this topic? How about an opinion on the subject; almost everyone has an opinion on immigration. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 9 years ago -

I'll pass. 

dkeller --- 9 years ago -

I understand. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 9 years ago -

Do you?

You know how Google works? 

dkeller --- 9 years ago -

What are forums for if not connecting with people's first hand experience and viewpoints and hearing out what they think. Do you know how a forum works? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 9 years ago -

Carry on. 

Judas --- 9 years ago -

During the school year a lot of teen's parents want them to study and participate in after school activities and that means not working after school in many cases



Cause this is Privilegewood. In my day we could go to school, do our HW, participate in extracurricular activities and still hold a job for a little spending money and because parents back then thought it was good to teach their kids to earn their own way. Not today. We have a generation of entitled republicans entering adulthood with lazy ethics who want to do nothing. 

dkeller --- 9 years ago -

did you really mean to say "republicans" as in those of the Republican party? just curious 

*LOL* --- 9 years ago -

lol 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 9 years ago -

We have a generation of entitled republicans entering adulthood with lazy ethics who want to do nothing.

LOL.......... You just described the modern liberal millennial.

You know. The ones that take years of worthless college courses that don't translate into real world jobs and expect everyone to pick up the slack for them when they fail to succeed from putting in the proper effort into making themselves successful. 

fuzz81 --- 9 years ago -

Most of these I think are family driven - ie: Spouse of a US citizen, etc., not 100% sure of other avenues. But has nothing to do with employment.

Not entirely true. There are employment sponsored based green cards, and people must possess a different type of visa and be here for a period of time before being eligible for permanent resident status. It's one of the things in the long list of things towards naturalization.

It takes many years to get a green card, and t can extend the allowed stay of other visa types such as H1 (which have a 6 year maximum) 

fuzz81 --- 9 years ago -

I can't remember if it is a J1 or J2 visa where the person can lawfully work in the US this is where the social security card comes into play.?

There are many types of visas, of which any of the employment types allow someone to get a SSN.

I got an SSN after a week of entering the US on my first visa, and it's my SSN for life. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

help


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground