Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Concealed gun permit holder fatally shoots suspected robber during Chicago stick-up

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
SoupIsGoodFood 2
Warren Peace 4
Judas 1
Prolix Raconteur 1
AMDG 3
them 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

them --- 11 years ago -

Concealed gun permit holder fatally shoots suspected robber during Chicago stick-up


On Saturday evening, a man wearing a mask walked into a South Side Chicago bodega, pulled out a gun and announced a robbery.

As the alleged robber pointed his gun at the store?s employees, however, a customer pulled out his own gun.

The robber?s gun, it turns out, was fake.

The customer?s was not.

Now the robbery suspect is dead, gunned down by the concealed-weapon-toting customer.

The case is the latest in a string of incidents across the country in which bystanders have pulled out their concealed weapons and used them against suspected criminals. Some cases have drawn heavy scrutiny, such as an Oct. 6 incident at a Home Depot near Detroit when a woman with a concealed weapons permit fired at fleeing shoplifters. She was charged with recklessly using her handgun.

A shoplifter sprinted across the blacktop of a Home Depot near Detroit on Oct. 6, pushing a cart full of stolen goods worth more than $1,000. After this surveillance footage was shot, a bystander pulled out a gun and fired shots at the suspect. (Facebook/Auburn Hills Police Department)

In Saturday?s shooting, however, police have said the customer had a valid concealed carry license and that charges against him ?do not appear likely,? according to the Chicago Tribune.

Nonetheless, the Chicago shooting is also raising questions, primarily from the family of the robbery suspect, Reginald Gildersleeve.

?Something doesn?t seem right,? said Igbinosa Oronsaye, whose mother married Gildersleeve three years ago. ?He didn?t deserve to get shot multiple times.?

The incident is all the more mysterious because it occurred on Halloween and involved a man in a mask with a fake gun. Various law enforcement sources told the Tribune that the gun was either a toy or a paintball gun.

Oronsaye told ABC7 that Gildersleeve was a former employee of the store and knew the owner well.

Was the shooting a Halloween prank gone horribly wrong?

Cops don?t think so. They believe Gildersleeve actually was trying to rob the store when the customer, feeling threatened by a masked man waving what appeared to be a real gun, opened fire.

That explanation is bolstered by Gildersleeve?s ?lengthy? arrest history, including at least one robbery, a Chicago police spokesman told the Tribune.

Either way, the shooting marked a strange end to a seemingly contradictory life.

Gildersleeve, 55, was a tall and powerfully built man with a strong jaw and a beaming smile. His Facebook page shows him in a suit and tie proudly posing with his wife in one arm and a Bible in the other. He often posted photos of his family, including a grandson.

Court records, however, reveal another side of Gildersleeve. They show he had been arrested at least half a dozen times dating back to the 1980s. Several arrests had to do with narcotics, but most of the incidents involved theft or robbery. He was in and out of prison, with burglary convictions as recent as 2005.

From his Facebook page, it appears as if Gildersleeve tried to turn his life around. He got married, posted inspirational photos and quotes, and once wrote a lengthy tribute to God and the redemptive power of grace.

?Love is that force that uplifts and inspires mankind,? he wrote a year ago, adding ?It can lift a wretched human being from the miry clay of despair and set feet upon the solid rock respectability and service.?

Ultimately, however, it seems Gildersleeve?s old life overtook his new one. And on Saturday night, as candy-hungry children donned costumes and took to Chicago?s streets, Gildersleeve donned a mask of his own ? but for very different reasons.

At around 7 p.m., Gildersleeve edged his broad frame through the door of a Mexican bodega in Gage Park, a neighborhood in southwest Chicago. He then pulled out a realistic-looking handgun and pointed it at the store?s employees, demanding money, police told the Tribune and the Associated Press.

As Gildersleeve allegedly tried to rob the bodega, a customer inside the store pulled out his concealed weapon and shot the would-be robber several times, including at least once in the chest, police told the Tribune. Gildersleeve was pronounced dead at 7:10 p.m., the newspaper reported, citing the medical examiner?s office.

Unlike the Oct. 6 shooting at the Home Depot near Detroit, however, authorities appear to believe the bystander was justified in his use of force.

Police have referred the case to the Cook County state?s attorney?s office to ?determine if there?s any reason to charge? the 44-year-old male shooter, a police spokesman told the Tribune. But charges were not filed Sunday and ?do not appear likely,? Chicago Police said in a statement.

America?s long-simmering debate over gun control and concealed weapons boiled over last month after an Oct. 1 mass shooting at a community college in Oregon. After the incident, in which a lone gunman killed nine other people and then himself, many gun rights advocates and several GOP presidential candidates argued that the massacre could have been prevented had the victims been armed.

Saturday?s shooting appears to have stoked that fiery debate once more.

Oronsaye suggested Gildersleeve could have been apprehended without being killed, and appeared to call for charges against the shooter with the concealed weapon.

?Some people don?t actually know how to use guns,? he told the Tribune. ?They go to firing ranges, but it?s not the same as a bullet going into someone?s body, it?s not the same as a bullet going into flesh. They should be able to wound first, kill next. He didn?t deserve to get shot multiple times.

?You just took a brother, you just took a father from a lot of people. Somebody?s got to answer for that.?

Some online commenters agreed.

?The shooter should be arrested and tried for murder,? one wrote. ?A conceal carry doesn?t give you the right to act all Wyatt Earp. He wasn?t in danger.?

Many others, however, sprang to the defense of the shooter.

?You can?t know that a gun is real or not when someone points one at you,? one wrote.

?He deserved to die,? added another, ?and sorry but when you are saving lives and protecting yourself you shoot to kill.? 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

Local prosecutors seem to be making the right call, based on available information. Citizen outrage at the shooter seems unreasonable to me. But the presence of citizen outrage helps make a broader point about much of the outrage that occurs when a law enforcement officer is the shooter.

Many that are outraged seem to have a different view of what a reasonable response is during a life or death moment that requires a split second decision. There's a difference in the legal standard used by courts and those of a dissenting vocal minority who are less educated about legal standards and may also be eager to redefine appropriate standards.

Even if the citizen shooter was a law enforcement officer, the available information suggests the shooting would have still been justified. The point in saying that is that courts typically hold citizens to a lower standard than trained law enforcement. So even though it's easy to think much of the public reaction to previous incidents of an officer's use of deadly force are simply anti-cop mentality, this scenario with the similar circumstances playing out without trained law enforcement intervening, still results in some degree of public outrage. It may obviously be the effect of having such safe communities that citizens are more likely to judge the outcome based on what they see from Hollywood script writers and actors than what actually takes place when this occurs in real life. Of course there is a more cynical explanation. 

Judas --- 11 years ago -

Capitol punishment for a non capitol crime. It wasn't even armed robbery. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Clueless, Judy.

In the past, there had been considerable uncertainty as to what constitutes use of a dangerous weapon or device under 18 U.S.C. ? 2113(d). Clearly, a loaded, operable firearm is a "dangerous weapon." However, uncertainty arose where, for example, the dangerous weapon or device turned out to be a toy gun, a hoax bomb device, unloaded or inoperable firearm, or where law enforcement officers failed to recover the weapon.

This uncertainty was partially clarified by the Supreme Court's decision in McLaughlin v. United States, 476 U.S. 16 (1986), which held that an unloaded handgun is a "dangerous weapon" within the meaning of ? 2113(d). The rationale of the McLaughlin decision can be extended to situations involving simulated weapons such as authentic appearing toy guns and hoax bomb devices

Source 

whatchamacallit --- 11 years ago -

In a situation like this, no one has time to discern intent or to be sure if the weapon of the perpetrator is real or fake.


That would be like waiting for someone to bust your door down and then ask them if they are just there to rob you or if they want to rape or murder you too. No, just shoot them, why risk your life!

He made the decision to rob a store. He made the decision to pull the (fake)gun, he acted as if her were armed.

Good enough reasons for him to be dead. 

them --- 11 years ago -

If fuzzyJudy wrote the headline it'd read:

Another innocent armed career criminal murdered by crazy gun nut 

Prolix Raconteur --- 11 years ago -

Concealed gun permit holder fatally shoots suspected robber during Chicago stick-up

Good. Social Darwinism works. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Some cases have drawn heavy scrutiny, such as an Oct. 6 incident at a Home Depot near Detroit when a woman with a concealed weapons permit fired at fleeing shoplifters. She was charged with recklessly using her handgun.

This woman should have her permit pulled, this was irresponsible, and no one was in any kind of danger until she started to shoot.

As Gildersleeve allegedly tried to rob the bodega, a customer inside the store pulled out his concealed weapon and shot the would-be robber several times, including at least once in the chest, police told the Tribune. Gildersleeve was pronounced dead at 7:10 p.m., the newspaper reported, citing the medical examiner?s office.

This sounds better, if the gun , toy or not was pointed at someone he was justified, probably, have to say that the Halloween thing matters some to me, gives it at least a more reasonable case to where a mask and carry a toy gun. If the gun was not pointing at someone, than he should have asked him to drop it, and then shoot on any move of the gun toward anyone.

They should be able to wound first, kill next. He didn?t deserve to get shot multiple times.

That's in the movies. Don't take out your gun unless you are willing to shoot it, and don't shoot it unless you are willing to kill.

All that said, this is another case where a gun changes everything - you can argue, that without the "real" gun there - this becomes a property crime, and no one dies.

I know that is Monday am qb'ing and given what I know the shoot is prob good - but that is not the point - I still think more guns on the streets means more people die. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Warren - wondering your take. A bunch of guys I was in the service with - eventually went into law enforcement - they are all long retired now - but my memory says they were pretty anti concealed carry, even kind of anti pistols for civilians in general - what is the general take of folks in LE these days. 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

Judas --- 2 hours ago - quote - hide comments
Capitol punishment for a non capitol crime. It wasn't even armed robbery.?


Well now Judy, much like with MrMark, we all know you're not exactly a threat to split the atom and are more likely to just threaten the atom and split, but do you really think you are making a point that needs to be made? Illinois state law may define armed robbery differently than other states, but that's not really relevant to a citizen's legal right to protect himself and others from death or seriously bodily injury is it?

If you're going to post a response that insinuates you know the law, why not have the courage to actually post it?

FWIW, with basic Google skillz, I see Illinois State Law explicitly allows what this citizen did.


Late edit: I see Soup already plugged Judy's leaky hole. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

Judy continuing the daily KU fails. 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

Warren - wondering your take. A bunch of guys I was in the service with - eventually went into law enforcement - they are all long retired now - but my memory says they were pretty anti concealed carry, even kind of anti pistols for civilians in general - what is the general take of folks in LE these days.?

Among the LEOs I've been associated with over the years, they are generally in favor of concealed carry laws. During my years in law enforcement the only ones I encountered who were opposed to citizens carrying guns were those who viewed their own jobs as more akin to social workers (back when I was a State PO). From my perspective, it came down to their own nervousness about being around guns. They viewed their own worry as rational and seemed to believe that their own discomfort and lack of skill and judgement was representative of the general population including those authorized to carry. If I rack my brain hard enough I may be able to think of a few elitists with authoritarian leanings that were opposed, but I'd hardly characterize that as the norm. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Thanks Warren - your description of the folks in le who are anti carry these days has no resemblance at all to the guys I knew. They were near anti social, especially when they were in the real world, And they were all very very comfortable with weapons.

Times change. 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

The first set of persons I identified is different. But I would say our descriptions of the other set I referred to is very similar. My characterization of them as elitists with authoritarian leanings is not unlike your description of them as being antisocial and comfortable with weapons. I call them elitists because of their comfort level with weapons - they believe only they are good enough to use proper judgement. The antisocial part of your description pairs with my characterization of them as authoritarians. The authoritarian personality characteristic describes a person who does not respect another person's freedom. Is that not anti-social? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground