Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Contractor Advice

who's talking here?

Warren Peace 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
Dr Aborto 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
kwgraniteguy 2
ThisLady 1
Not KU 1
Eclipse 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Contractor Advice

3 years ago I had half the siding done by Company A. During the process they ended up cutting the AC line. They had an AC line fixed and the original work was completed wonderfully. Fast forward to today. I need to get the other half of the house done. Had them come over for a quote. Quote was almost TWICE what they quoted 3 years earlier. He said it was due to rise of cost for parts and labor. I was thinking he's trying to make up for what he lost fixing my AC. I told him how the new quote for half the house was what he quoted me 3 years ago for the whole house. He re-adjusts the quote and brings it down $1,000. I get a second quote from Company B. His quote is almost the same as Company A's reduced quote. My dilemma is that I liked Company A's work but I didn't like how much he quoted me. Now bringing it down $1,000 makes me wonder if he'll cut corners to make it up. Company B did a house down the street and it looks nice I just haven't done business with them personally. What do you guys think?

Go with Original Company A Vote
 
 57.1% (4)
Try out the New Company B Vote
 
 42.9% (3)
Dr Aborto --- 11 years ago -

3 years ago I had half the siding done by Company A. During the process they ended up cutting the AC line. They had an AC line fixed and the original work was completed wonderfully.

Fast forward to today. I need to get the other half of the house done. Had them come over for a quote. Quote was almost TWICE what they quoted 3 years earlier. He said it was due to rise of cost for parts and labor. I was thinking he's trying to make up for what he lost fixing my AC. I told him how the new quote for half the house was what he quoted me 3 years ago for the whole house. He re-adjusts the quote and brings it down $1,000.

I get a second quote from Company B. His quote is almost the same as Company A's reduced quote.

My dilemma is that I liked Company A's work but I didn't like how much he quoted me. Now bringing it down $1,000 makes me wonder if he'll cut corners to make it up. Company B did a house down the street and it looks nice I just haven't done business with them personally.

What do you guys think? 

kwgraniteguy --- 11 years ago -

Is the siding being done now second story vs previous 1st? If so expect 2 to 3 times for 2nd story than 1st for same sf. He's mot feeding you a line. Both materials as well as labor have shot up.
If you were happy with his previous work and he came off a grand this go around I would stick with A. As for the A/C line the sub likely ate that cost. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 11 years ago -

Get 2 more quotes. The more info, the better.

If you're happy with A and the other quotes are reasonably close, go with them. But walk around and watch what they do. I'm just wondering what the variety of siding is like as in cost and degree of quality? Or is there like 2 products and everyone is using the same stuff? 

Warren Peace --- 11 years ago -

I agree with graniteguy about the difference if the 2nd half is an upper floor.

I'm sure there's some dishonesty in his estimates (seems to be common with independent contractors), but I don't see why you can't just ask him if he'll be using the same materials as he used last time and getting the itemized list of materials and quantities in writing. Go with him again if it appears to be the same and compare the quality of old materials versus new as the work progresses. In my opinion, using a new contractor carries more risk than using a contractor you previously used and were satisfied with.

My experience has been hit and miss with contractors. When I recently had some exterior work done that included siding, the contractor claimed that he wasn't making any money due to unforseen costs such as not properly estimating his cost for three different paint colors instead of two. It struck me as an attempt for sympathy, but in my mind it also caused me to lose faith in him as a business owner. I had some other issues with him that I won't get into (he advertises on KU), so I won't be using him for any large projects again. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

Fyeah- it would be hard to cut corners when you. Can compare the product and quality to the old half of your house- 

kwgraniteguy --- 11 years ago -

Dr A, Your contractor A sounds like a stand up guy, would you share who he is? PM is ok. Right now the only general in KW I put much faith in is Brian Green of North woods Remodel. It would nice to know of another local GC in KW that is a good guy. We have some local GC's that leave me SMH. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

Angies List 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 11 years ago -

I got an electrician from there- awful, and way too expensive. 

Eclipse --- 11 years ago -

I use Home Advisor (it's free, too) and I've never been disappointed. 

ThisLady --- 11 years ago -

Go with the one you know did a good job and will fix something if it goes wrong from his doing. The prices are comparable and you don't know the other guy from Mars. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground