Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is this enough evidence for the Death Penalty

who's talking here?

sunshine1881 2
SoupIsGoodFood 1
Work in Progress 1
Dorothy Parker 1
Emperor of Kingwood 3
DVaz 4
a889324uu 2
Not KU 1
Butterbean 1
AMDG 7
Eclipse 3
Proud American 8
Max01 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Texas is scheduled to execute Lester Bower today after 30 years on death row. Lester was convicted of killing 4 men in a hanger in Dallas to steal a plane. He was convicted based on parts of the plane were found at his house, and he had called one of the murdered men. There was no finger prints found at the scene, and a murder weapon was never found. Lester was middle aged worked for a chemical company, and had no prior arrests. Lester has steadfastly claimed his innocence.

Is he guilty?? Maybe Is this enough evidence for the death penalty
- I don?t think so. 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

From what you have said, no.

But I don't know the facts if the case.

The death penalty should not be in the table for circumstantial evidence. 

Not KU --- 11 years ago -

The death penalty should not be in the table for circumstantial evidence.

agreed 

Max01 --- 11 years ago -

So after 30 years no one was able to clear this guy?

Also, is this case more important because Lester is white? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 11 years ago -

I'm sure there was more evidence presented in the trail. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

So after 30 years no one was able to clear this guy?

My issue isn't guilt or innocence, it is the punishment. We obviously don't kill all convicted murderers, just doesn't appear to be the quality of evidence in this case to be very sure you are not killing an innocent man.

Just one more case of the arbitrary nature of how the death penalty is implemented. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

I'm sure there was more evidence presented in the trail.

Yea maybe - don't know 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

just doesn't appear to be the quality of evidence in this case to be very sure you are not killing an innocent man.

But you haven't presented any evidence to the contrary. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

But you haven't presented any evidence to the contrary.

Not sure I get your point. Again not saying he is not guilty - may well be.

Question is, if should someone convicted of murder on circumstantial evidence alone should the death penalty be an option ?

I don't think so. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

But you don't know if the evidence was purely circumstantial. There may have been other evidence you don't know about. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

But you don't know if the evidence was purely circumstantial. There may have been other evidence you don't know about.

True - but let's just say that the story is true - and it is just circumstantial. What do you think? 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 11 years ago -

Well there's two questions there, 1. Should a person be convicted of capitol murder and receive the death penalty soley on circumstantial evidence. My answer is probably not. Operative word here is SOLEY.

The second question is about the individual case on which I have no knowledge and can't comment. 

DVaz --- 11 years ago -

I'd have to read the entire court transcripts and view all the evidence! 

Eclipse --- 11 years ago -

Without having read the entire conviction report (which is pretty lengthy) in part it reads;

"There is no question in my mind that Bower is guilty," said Ronald Sievert, a federal prosecutor named as a special prosecutor to assist in Bower's trial.

Sievert is now a professor of national security law at the University of Texas Law School and the Bush School of Government at Texas A&M. He and Grayson County District Attorney Stephen Davidchik, who has since died, built a circumstantial case surrounding Bower's purchase from Grayson sheriff's Deputy Philip Good, 29, of an ultralight airplane stored at the hangar owned by building contractor Bob Tate, 51 ..."

So, according to the prosecutor it was based on circumstantial evidence ... 

Proud American --- 11 years ago -

If we are going to question the appropriateness of capital penalties in circumstantial cases, we should be questioning all cases. Define circumstantial? I don't think we should reward people for wiping off fingerprints.

I don't believe this guy would still be on death row if they were not certain of his guilt. Don't you think some of these groups that get people off of death row would have jumped on this one if his guilt weren't obvious?

Consider the source of what you are reading too. Unless you sit through the trial, you can't see all of the evidence.

I think we should be more swift in our decisions and have conviction in our punishment. There should be a limit to the time that is allowed to pass and the punishment should be publicly available. We should use it like a deterrent so it will actually work like one! 

Eclipse --- 11 years ago -

I don't believe this guy would still be on death row if they were not certain of his guilt.

I'm not sure I agree with this.

There are many cases of people who were on death row, only to have been found innocent of their "alleged" crime later.

Unfortunately, for some it was too late and they'd already been executed. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Define circumstantial?

Circumstantial is non-direct evidence, it requires an assumption to be made by, in this case, a jury.

Example.

Joes says he saw Bill shoot Tom. That is direct evidence, if you believe Joe is credible, than Bill shot Tom.

Joes says he saw Bill and Tom go into the other room, and he heard Tom scream, and Bill walked out of the room. Tom is in the room dead with a knife in him. If the jury believes Joe, they must still make an assumption that that Bill killed Tom. 

sunshine1881 --- 11 years ago -

Having sat through every moment of several capital murder cases in two different states and seeing the jury decisions firsthand, all I can say is I would never ever ever want my life to be in the hands of a jury.

Juries mishear evidence, don't double check facts, make emotional decisions, can be swayed by the effectiveness of a defense attorney or a prosecutor (totally outside of any presentation of evidence), can be swayed by their own prejudices, etc. etc.

Lay jurors should never hold someone's life in their hands. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

From a judge in my past: "Juries are never wrong."

She pointed out that it is the system of justice that we (Americans) have in place.

Justice is not always just. A jury decision is never wrong. 

sunshine1881 --- 11 years ago -

From a judge in my past: "Juries are never wrong."

She pointed out that it is the system of justice that we (Americans) have in place.

Justice is not always just. A jury decision is never wrong.


I absolutely disagree with this. 

Proud American --- 11 years ago -

There are many cases of people who were on death row, only to have been found innocent of their "alleged" crime later.Unfortunately, for some it was too late and they'd already been executed.

so far, none of them have been there anywhere near this long. As far as executing innocent people, there are no proven cases in recent history to indicate that any innocent people have been executed. 

Proud American --- 11 years ago -

Circumstantial is non-direct evidence, it requires an assumption to be made by, in this case, a jury.

personally I have a problem with eye-witness testimony. I am not sure there are many cases where you could say with 100% certainty that the convicted is guilty. How do you determine who has credibility? There are more cases of folks losing credibility over time or being determined to have been fraudulent. There is no doubt that attorneys will do what they need and want to do to win in most cases. I'm not sure there ever will be a completely objective standard...at least not one that can be met.

Do you want the jury forming an opinion based on the credibility of someone they don't know? Have you been through the jury selection process?

I think the best system is the one we have in place. It is certainly better than others we've seen. What needs to be different is the disbursement of punishment in my opinion. There should be more consistency in sentencing. Prior records should factor into sentencing. We need to (subjectively) determine whether one can be rehabilitated and divide criminals by that determination. If rehabilitation is the goal, provide education. If punishment is the goal, punish. If one is guilty of murder, have a standard punishment. If they are guilty of multiple murders, execute them. Seems pretty simple to me.

I think we can do better if we get back to the basics...what do we hope to accomplish? Hold everyone to the same standard regardless of their background, color or anything else. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

They were able to trace the parts of the plane to that specific hangar? That proves he was there. And it proves he took things from the hangar, most likely because the men who would have stopped him were dead by then. He called one of the men? That proves he knew them, and it can probably also place his position on the day of the murder.

That doesn't seem that controversial to me. 

Proud American --- 11 years ago -

Having sat through every moment of several capital murder cases in two different states and seeing the jury decisions firsthand, all I can say is I would never ever ever want my life to be in the hands of a jury.Juries mishear evidence, don't double check facts, make emotional decisions, can be swayed by the effectiveness of a defense attorney or a prosecutor (totally outside of any presentation of evidence), can be swayed by their own prejudices, etc. etc.Lay jurors should never hold someone's life in their hands.


I believe that! However, in almost all cases, you determine if your future will be in the hands of the jury...do the right thing, stay out of bad places...remember daily that you don't want to be judged by your peers. 

Proud American --- 11 years ago -

They were able to trace the parts of the plane to that specific hangar? That proves he was there. And it proves he took things from the hangar, most likely because the men who would have stopped him were dead by then. He called one of the men? That proves he knew them, and it can probably also place his position on the day of the murder.

he said he purchased the plane but there is no proof of that...no receipt, no checks or wires... 

a889324uu --- 11 years ago -

Are you serious? There HAVE been cases.
Several. Recently. As in the 21st century.
Some in the 80s and 90s.

Over 100 inmates on death row have been exonerated as well.

There are studies and peer reviewed journals you can reference. 

Eclipse --- 11 years ago -

I am not sure there are many cases where you could say with 100% certainty that the convicted is guilty

Many?

One is too "many" ...

A quick search on Google will produce "many" cases of someone who was executed and later found to be innocent for a crime they did not commit. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

They were able to trace the parts of the plane to that specific hangar? That proves he was there. And it proves he took things from the hangar, most likely because the men who would have stopped him were dead by then. He called one of the men? That proves he knew them, and it can probably also place his position on the day of the murder.

That doesn't seem that controversial to me.


You may well be right but -


They were able to trace the parts of the plane to that specific hangar? That proves he was there

actually it does not directly prove he was there, what it directly proves is he has possession of stolen property from a murder scene, it takes an assumption on your part to place him there.

He called one of the men? That proves he knew them.

Well it proves he knew his phone number. I have called people I don't know. I have also called people and not killed them

Is is way more than likely he is the killer - absolutely -

Is it possible he is not the killer - absolutely. 

Proud American --- 11 years ago -

Many?One is too "many" ...

that standard would mean to do away with capital punishment...you will never be certain unless you see it with your own eyes...even then, we've all seen illusions. We have to use good judgment. Most of these cases are very obvious...we can't exactly take most of these folks at their word. If you want to protect yourselves and the rest of us, you have to have a standard. Implementation of the standard is the problem.

There has not been one documented, undisputed case of an innocent person being executed since capital punishment resumed. You guys are reading bad information...there isn't one!

After 30 years, don't you all think some up and coming lawyer would have tackled this one if the guy could be gotten off? These guys thrive on getting guilty people off (Casey Anthony and OJ Simpson)..don't you think they would make a name for themselves with the low hanging fruit?

AMDG - you are making my point. At some point we have to make decisions. We have to have confidence in our legal system and we have to make judgments. In this particular case, I am fairly confident there is far more evidence. 

Proud American --- 11 years ago -

I should have stated U.S. executions, since resumption of capital punishment and carried out by the government...plenty of innocent people have been executed...by the bad guys some of you want to defend. Nobody who has been executed has gone on to commit further crimes though! 

DVaz --- 11 years ago -

As far as executing innocent people, there are no proven cases in recent history to indicate that any innocent people have been executed.?

Yeah, OK buddy. Your blind faith in the criminal justice system is disturbing. 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

The Death Penalty should only be on the table with cases that have hard evidence of guilt and heinous enough to merit death. 

DVaz --- 11 years ago -

The Death Penalty should only be on the table with cases that have hard evidence of guilt and heinous enough to merit death.?

Only 2% of convicted murderers actually get the death penalty. An eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth IMO.

BTW, 99% were convicted without any REASONABLE DOUBT. 

Proud American --- 11 years ago -

Yeah, OK buddy. Your blind faith in the criminal justice system is disturbing.

Only 2% of convicted murderers actually get the death penalty. An eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth IMO.BTW, 99% were convicted without any REASONABLE DOUBT.

contradict yourself much? I do not have anything remotely close to blind faith in the legal system. I understand the need to make decisions and I understand the consequences for doing things right or doing things wrong. I know there is no perfect system and I know that society doesn't see much of the evidence...nor do they see the other bs that goes on in the court room. 

DVaz --- 11 years ago -

I think I quoted the wrong post. I was up way to late and zonked out right after (as far as I can remember). 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground