Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Barry Goldwater on Religious Influence in Politics

who's talking here?

wayward1 1
Red Heifer 5
Work in Progress 9
Dorothy Parker 3
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
Butterbean 1
jacobson 5
AMDG 11
TruBluTexan 2
ugly yapper dog 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Red Heifer --- 11 years ago -

Goldwater was a conservative icon and a true believer in conservatism. And Barry Goldwater said this:

On religious issues there can be little or no compromise. There is no position on which people are so immovable as their religious beliefs. There is no more powerful ally one can claim in a debate than Jesus Christ, or God, or Allah, or whatever one calls this supreme being. But like any powerful weapon, the use of God's name on one's behalf should be used sparingly. The religious factions that are growing throughout our land are not using their religious clout with wisdom. They are trying to force government leaders into following their position 100 percent. If you disagree with these religious groups on a particular moral issue, they complain, they threaten you with a loss of money or votes or both.
I'm frankly sick and tired of the political preachers across this country telling me as a citizen that if I want to be a moral person, I must believe in "A," "B," "C" and "D." Just who do they think they are? And from where do they presume to claim the right to dictate their moral beliefs to me?

And I am even more angry as a legislator who must endure the threats of every religious group who thinks it has some God-granted right to control my vote on every roll call in the Senate. I am warning them today: I will fight them every step of the way if they try to dictate their moral convictions to all Americans in the name of "conservatism." 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

Everyone has beliefs, be they religious or not. And everyone votes according to their beliefs, be they religious or not.

So whatever Goldwater said, it's neither here nor there. In a republic, everyone attempts to

influence their law and public policies.

So to answer his question, "who do they think they are?" They are American citizens, who have a long history of voting their conscience and beliefs, their values and their principles. And I would counter, "who are you to question that?"

Goldwater got a lot of things right, and possibly more wrong. 

Red Heifer --- 11 years ago -

sure, but I think Goldwater was saying that a religious litmus test is a threat to governing, and all the more significant because it was a conservative who said it. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

He was ranting because the Conservatives had long since turned on him.

And I think it is a huge problem to see it as a "religious" litmus test and say that it doesn't belong in government. That sets up a scenario that only secular humanism can have influence, and that, in and of itself, functions as a "religion" of sorts.

Like I said, we all have deeply held beliefs, even if we do not refer to them as religion per se. And we ALL seek to influence govt according to our deeply held beliefs. 

Butterbean --- 11 years ago -

The 1981 Goldwater bears no resemblance to the so called "conservative" of today, IMO.

IMO, also, Barry got it right a lot more than he got it wrong. Goldwater cared about the environment as much as he cared about profits. He championed abortion and gay rights. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

I think what BG was concerned about was the pulpit as political stump. This is a real, and valid concern. The pulpit should be used to teach its morality, and then hopefully the faithful will vote morally. It is a very dangerous thing when there is a direct political recommendation from the pulpit. Not 100% and always wrong to do, but a dangerous line to cross.

IMO the fundamental right treads close to the line often of turning from a religion into a political party.

The Achilles heel of democracy, and one the FF were aware of is preventing a tyranny of the majority. Minority views should be respected, and in the case of an individuals relationship or lack there of with God protected.

It is the job of the faithful to evangelize their faith, but not to make it the law of the land. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

as an example -

Iran bans homosexual and devil hairstyles 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

Goldwater was a conservative icon and a true believer in conservatism. And Barry Goldwater said this:

Goldwater's own words proved that he was not a conservative. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

It is a very dangerous thing when there is a direct political recommendation from the pulpit.

That is absolute nonsense.

Minority views should be respected, and in the case of an individuals relationship or lack there of with God protected.

More absolute nonsense. Do you really believe that amoral views should be respected? 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

More absolute nonsense. Do you really believe that amoral views should be respected?

A little semantic, but in a way yes. I think they are wrong, I think they should be challenged, and I think they should be shown the truth. But if they are authentically held, then I respect their right to have them. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Do you really believe that amoral views should be respected?

a question back - should we legislate them away ??? If yes, where do you stop ?

Homosexuality? adultery? Modest dress? Porn? PDA's? Gambling? Alcohol? Atheism ? I don't think fighting these is a job for congress, it is a job of the faithful to evangelize these amoral acts, without the force of government. 

Red Heifer --- 11 years ago -

hoorah. a civil, intelligent conversation. 

Red Heifer --- 11 years ago -

a question back - should we legislate them away ??? If yes, where do you stop ?Homosexuality? adultery? Modest dress? Porn? PDA's? Gambling? Alcohol? Atheism ? I don't think fighting these is a job for congress, it is a job of the faithful to evangelize these amoral acts, without the force of government.

Right. Once you legislate them away, you're Iran. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

The truly sad part is, the growth of relativism that has allowed so many amoral things to creep into acceptance in our society. Our laws tend to mirror our norms, and in many ways the norms of 2015 are disordered. That is the job of the pulpit and the faithful to change. In this chicken or egg discussion I think you have to change the hearts and minds of the people and laws will follow. I don't think you do it the other way.

All that said this is not an absolute position. There can something so evil, so wrong that there is an obligation on the pulpit to speak against it on every level - even political. IMO abortion is such an issue. 

Red Heifer --- 11 years ago -

I agree with you, AMDG, even if I don't agree with your position on the issue. There are some things which, as a matter of conscience, compel us to speak. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

On that, I agree with you. The hearts have to be changed, law alone won't do it.

And self control and law are inversely proportional to each other. The more self control a people has, the less law is needed to control them. God's answer for those who refuse to self control is a tyrant.

I disagree about the pulpit not becoming political though. In a republic, everything is political because the people are the power, pulpits included. They should be weighing in what is Godly policy and what isn't , and Christians should vote to influence that. We ARE supposed to influence our society however we can, because it is a blessing to our society. God's ways are freedom. It seems that in our society, we are trying to silence only one voice--the Christian voice. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

a question back - should we legislate them away ???

Silly question.

I don't think fighting these is a job for congress, it is a job of the faithful to evangelize these amoral acts, without the force of government

Once again, your thoughts are incorrect, especially for someone who professes to believe in God.

God INSTITUTED government. Without government we would have a lawless society. 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

Christians should vote to influence that. We ARE supposed to influence our society however we can, because it is a blessing to our society. God's ways are freedom.



This is one of the scariest things I've ever seen written. "God's way" may be freedom TO YOU and your belief system. In a free country where we are free to belong to any religion or not belong at all, to think ONE RELIGION should rule all, is wrong on all levels. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

DP, it doesn't surprise me in the least that you misread, misunderstood, then added to what I actually wrote. It seems to be your way. No worries. 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

Please point out where I misconstrued what you said. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

oh yes, liberals lack the ability to compare/contrast. I forgot.

Where did I say one religion to rule all? (Hint, I didn't.) 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

DP, does your vote influence your society? If you say no, then why do it? 

Dorothy Parker --- 11 years ago -

Do I have a separate society from you? I'm confused by your question.

You want to elect politicians based on their religious beliefs and that they'll incorporate those beliefs into law, which affects everyone, whether they're Christian or not.

That is wrong. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

How do you pick the people you vote for, DP? 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

WIP - I have been both accused and complimented on here for seeing shades of grey in issues. I think both my accusers and complementers are correct. Not all issues are black and white, many are, but some choices involve judgment. This issue is one of them.

There is nothing at all wrong, in fact it is an obligation of the clergy, to teach clearly on moral issues about human life and dignity, marriage and family, war and peace, the needs of the poor and the demands of justice.

And as faithful citizens we should bring our moral convictions into public life. These do not threaten democracy or pluralism. The separation of church and state does not require division between belief and public action, between moral principles and political choices, but protects the right of believers and religious groups to practice their faith and act on their values in public life.

But there are some dangerous lines to cross when the pulpit is used to directly support, or unequivocally direct the congregation to support a particular person or party. Two of these major issues are:

The honest preacher, where the action needed to correct the moral wrong is not clear, or there may be multiple solutions. As an example - If a preacher tells the congregation, Jesus wants us to feed the poor, and candidate X is strongly in favor of increasing government programs for the poor, you should all vote for him. That preacher has crossed the line from moral teaching to political endorsement.

The second is when there is a gain of power, or money, or glory available to someone, even the preacher or priest, for using the pulpit to directly support a candidate of party. This can set up a moral hazard where the motivations of the pulpit can be more about personal gain, than moral teaching.

So that is why this is a sticky issue to me. Anytime the power of the pulpit can be used for someone?s personal gain ? such as getting elected - there is a great need to protect that the use is morally correct, and the motivation is not disordered. 

TruBluTexan --- 11 years ago -

IMO, people who need their religious laws enacted into city, state, or federal laws lack FAITH.

How meaningful is it for a Jew or Muslim to abstain from eating pork if pork was outlawed for everyone? Not very.

How meaningful are the blue laws we already have? 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

As an aside, Pope Francis is about to publish an encyclical on protecting the environment. Will have to wait to read it of course for final judgment - but it surely has the possibility of getting close to a dangerous line. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

AMDG. I agree that abuses can be made from the pulpiit, but I don't think it should be illegal because abuses can be made. I think that the intention to separate all political activity from non-profits is already causing abuse because it isn't followed. Many "non-profits" ARE political organizations masquerading as something else. It seems that removing that particular provision, which I believe wasn't even put in until Johnson (at least the church part), would just allow everyone to be up front about their motivations. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

In general I agree with you. The key thing to look for, for me, is when the organization stops talking about an issue, and starts talking about a particular candidate or party. 

TruBluTexan --- 11 years ago -

But we are called in the Bible to care for all Creation. I think it is within the Pope's purview to do that AMDG.

It might rankle some politicians but the topic of environmental protections is entirely legitimate. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

But we are called in the Bible to care for all Creation. I think it is within the Pope's purview to do that AMDG.

It might rankle some politicians but the topic of environmental protections is entirely legitimate.


Agree - completely will be interested to read it. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

Another aside - It is really hard to find any one candidate that lets me vote my faith - every election involves some compromise.

I need a candidate that is:

Anti abortion
Anti same sex marriage
Anti death penalty
Pro immigration reform
Pro social programs for the poor

Would be nice it he/she were
married, never divorced and

never involved or confirmed to be
an adulterer.

No hint of ethical issues or concerns.

and after all that, we need to align on all the "non-moral issues"

I haven't found that candidate yet. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

The separation of church and state

There is no separation of church and state called for in our Constitution. 

jacobson --- 11 years ago -

Anti death penalty

Why would you want them to go against God? 

wayward1 --- 11 years ago -

There is no separation of church and state called for in our Constitution.?

This is true. They only talked about the State part. 

AMDG --- 11 years ago -

sorry should have said "does not violate the establishment clause of the first amendment to the constitution."

sorry for the imprecision, can understand how confusing that must have been. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 11 years ago -

The extremists, and both sides have them, ruin our political processes. It's not so much their beloved positions as much as it is the lack of negotiation that comes from not seeing you can't always have your way. That's it's honorable to take a stand for what you believe but negotiation is paramount to getting things done. Respect and kindness towards one another would please God greatly, bc in the end, He is much more concerned with how we treat people as believers, and how hearts and souls Are being affected by our actions and witness than He is budget reform or the illegal alien dilemma. 

Work in Progress --- 11 years ago -

There will not be a perfect govt. until Christ returns. Until that, we will have an imperfect govt. run by imperfect, sinful people. Attempting Utopia is the quickest path to hell on earth. I am not seeking perfection.

But I am seeking to conserve (hence why I am a conservative) the best parts of our govt and our whole society. I want to keep what works--which has always been that a people who wants to be moral does not need a tyrannical law to keep them in check. But we are presently watching the breakdown of self-control, and are reaping the consequences thereof--a bigger and more threatening state to keep tabs on us. 

ugly yapper dog --- 11 years ago -

The only books more anti government than the Bible are anarchist books. God is VERY anti government.

Government should treat all citizens the same. The only purpose of government should be to protect us from each other and protect us from outsiders. Anything else is going to senselessly infringe on rights of others.

But thats what politics is all about I guess, how to control other people for no reason. By democrats and even by these new age socialist-republican types that call themselves conservatives. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground