Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Logic and New Earth - if you are tired of this topic - please don't open

who's talking here?

RiteWingKing 1
Work in Progress 3
Texan65 3
Commoner Sense 1
jacobson 6
AMDG 6
Big D 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Here is a structured, and logical approach to this topic. Let me know what you think.

Fact 1: The following sciences and disciplines exist. Geology, Astronomy, Physics, Paleontology, Biology, Chemistry.

Fact 2: The overwhelming majority of these sciences and disciplines agree that age of the earth is significantly older than 6 or 7 thousand years old.

Supposition 1: God created the world. For this argument, this is a supposition assumed to be true.

Proposition 1: The world is less than 10,000 years old.

If proposition 1 is true, one or more of the following must be true.

The unique error theory
Although scientific knowledge and advancements have explained correctly, most of what we know
to be fact about the natural world. On the topic of the age of the earth all the major sciences have independently arrived at a consistent, but incorrect answer to the age of the earth, by a magnitude of millions upon millions of years.

The great conspiracy theory
Scientific research actually does show that the earth is less than 10,000 years old, but the entire scientific community has an organized and coordinated effort to suppress this research, and they are in an organized conspiracy to put forth a knowingly false theory.

god as the great deceiver
Assuming, the earth is less than 10,000 years old, and assuming the entire scientific community is using good sound reason and science, but arriving at the incorrect answer. For both of these to happen the data that the sciences are using must have been intentionally arranged by the creator to lead good scientific reason and logic, applied over hundreds of years, by multiple disciples, to an incorrect conclusion. And this incorrect conclusion is in the order of magnitude of millions upon millions of years.

I do not see any of those as plausible, therefore I do not believe Proposition 1, the world is less than 10,000 years old to be true. 

Big D --- 12 years ago -

LOL. Nonsense!

LOL. This just proves you don't know anything about science!

LOL. What you posted is not in the bible therefore it is false! LOL. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

For both of these to happen the data that the sciences are using must have been intentionally arranged by the creator to lead good scientific reason and logic, applied over hundreds of years, by multiple disciples, to an incorrect conclusion.

That is one of the biggest pieces of garbage that I've ever read. It surely didn't come from anyone who understands science.

I do not see any of those as plausible, therefore I do not believe Proposition 1, the world is less than 10,000 years old to be true.

We already know that you don't believe God. I guess it means nothing to you that Jesus quoted Genesis 1 since He deemed it to be true.

I just don't understand how people can actually believe that they are born again when they believe the ASSUMPTIONS of fallible men over the words of Jesus. 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

AM - I know its fun to poke the puppy, but this topic is not worthy of serious conversation. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

CS - Not trying to poke. Just an attempt to separate what we believe true due to faith and what we believe true due to reason.

And those two concepts can co-exist, with a belief in God.


As an example - Jacobson's comments

I just don't understand how people can actually believe that they are born again when they believe the ASSUMPTIONS of fallible men over the words of Jesus.

perfectly says it all, he has a set of beliefs, that are matters of faith, that no amount of reason or evidence can trump. And there is nothing wrong with that. Just, like he just did, call it what it is, faith. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

I think the Pope came to the same conclusion. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

I think the Pope came to the same conclusion.

He did, but it was Pope Pius XII, in the mid 60's I think. 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

I can tell you that young earth/old earth is one of the many reasons why I came to doubt Christianity in my youth. (The main one being that I was engaged in a few activities that I could not justify with my christian convictions, and it was very convenient for me to use my doubt as license to continue said activities guilt free.)

I had trouble with what I perceived as the "holes" in Genesis until I studied the holes in evolution (and I realize this wasn't about evolution but it still part of the same argument of whether Genesis is true), and there are many holes in evolution.

But I had neglected the PURPOSE of each account. The Bible is concerned with the purpose of creation--a God's eye view, if you will, of how man came to be. And the RELATIONSHIP between God and man.

Evolution is concerned with the mechanics.

Evolution is the best theory we have to date, based on historical science, which depends on what can be interpreted from what is actually observed. Many things will have to be worked out in it just as in any science. It's a working hypothesis.

But here's the thing:

When my son, who is 4, asks me how he came to be, I tell him the truth. I tell him that Mommy and Daddy loved each other so much that we got married and prayed for children and that God blessed us with 2. It tells him our purpose--a desire to raise a family in the Lord. It tells him that he was created on purpose for a purpose, and that he is wanted, loved, and secure as a member of our family. And it tells him about the relationship! About Mommy's relationship to Daddy. Our relationship to our son, and all of our relationships to God.

Later, when he is ready for it, I will explain the mechanics, which is also the truth.

But see, what if, let's say, that his experience was limited to what happened in the womb (if he were an adult thinker with the ability to observe from conception up to the point right before birth.)

That would be a very mechanical description of sperm meeting egg (a Big Bang of sorts), traveling through the Fallopian tube, implanting in the uterine wall. . .

What would that observer know of mom or dad? Of the love and desire we had to create him? Of the purpose of his existence? Of the hopes we had of his birth and us meeting face to face?

For that, that observer would need some sort of message from the outside that could tell of these unimaginable things, and nothing about the mechanics would point to that. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Evolution is the best theory we have to date, based on historical science, which depends on what can be interpreted from what is actually observed.

I have to disagree with you WIP. There has been nothing concerning the lame hypothesis of evolution that has ever been observed.

Also, evolution isn't concerned with the actual mechanics. All it is concerned with is getting people to doubt the existence of God. 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

That's why I put interpretation of what is "actually observed." Both creationists and evolutionists work with the same observations but come to different interpretations of that raw data. And they can poke holes in each other's theories all day. Much as, to stick with my metaphor, two cognizant twins in the womb might debate what happened in the beginning to make the sperm hit the egg in the first place, and chances are, they would disagree. Especially if one was arguing the purpose of existence and the other was arguing the mechanics of existence. And neither one would have ANY idea about what was really going on at that moment! 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

WIP - the way I was interpreting your first message, I agreed with almost all of it.

However, my intent on a structured argument, was just that to keep if somewhat structured.

For my argument to be bad, either my facts are bad, or there is a logical way to combine the 2 facts, and a young earth as true.

The other alternative is my conclusion is wrong, because one of the theory options is true.

You are a smart and honest woman, I would be very interested on your thoughts on the argument. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

For my argument to be bad, either my facts are bad

They are.

The other alternative is my conclusion is wrong,

It is. 

Work in Progress --- 12 years ago -

I think that the above options based on premise one were too limited, and that there are other options. 

Texan65 --- 12 years ago -

Through science we arrive at an age for the Earth based on the rate of processes and working back to a starting point.

Each of these processes are essentially clocks that point to a time when the process started

Unfortunately these clocks all hold times greater than 6000 years. 

Texan65 --- 12 years ago -

It's possible God created all the clocks with times set to four billion years-6000 years ago 

Texan65 --- 12 years ago -

Possible. But unlikely 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Each of these processes are essentially clocks that point to a time when the process started

Absolutely incorrect.

Through faulty science we arrive at an age for the Earth based on assumptions, and some of those assumptions are based upon the idea that if evolution were to be true, it would take millions or billions of years. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

WIP - there may be other scenarios, but I can't think of any others where , the facts that each scientific discipline, independently arrives at an universe that is millions of years old, and they are in error.

The odds that on this one issue the physicists get the physics wrong, and the geologists get the geology wrong, and the paleontologists get the paleontology wrong, and the biologist get the biology wrong, etc etc seems astronomical.

I did this off the top of my head, but I can't think of any other scenarios where the 2 fact above are true, and the earth is less than 10,000 years old. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

The odds that on this one issue the physicists get the physics wrong, and the geologists get the geology wrong, and the paleontologists get the paleontology wrong, and the biologist get the biology wrong, etc etc seems astronomical.

Nah, not when they all have the same "prince of the power of the air" guiding them.

The physicists, geologists, paleontologists and biologists that get it correct are the ones that believe God.

You put way too much faith in fallible men while ignoring God, whom you say you love.

God has no agenda, but the fallible men do. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Nah, not when they all have the same "prince of the power of the air" guiding them.

I am interested in this scenario, that evil, or satan, is the answer that reconciles fact 1 & 2, and the world is less than 10,000 years old.

Not being snarky, can you write it as a complete though. I would be interested in understanding how you would see this operating. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

I am interested in this scenario, that evil, or satan, is the answer that reconciles fact 1 & 2, and the world is less than 10,000 years old.

No need to. The world is less than 10,000 years old regardless of what some physicists, geologists, paleontologists and biologists believe.

"The thief cometh not, but for to steal, and to kill, and to destroy"

Satan does all he can to keep people from God. Evolution is one of those tools. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground