Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Climate Science is not "Settled"

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 1
RiteWingKing 8
WatchOut 2
LitlJay 1
Wolfram 2
Emperor of Kingwood 1
DVaz 1
Commoner Sense 1
jacobson 8
Wicked 1
satsuma 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

satsuma --- 12 years ago -

Climate Science Not Settled

"The crucial scientific question for policy isn't whether the climate is changing. That is a settled matter: The climate has always changed and always will.

Nor is the crucial question whether humans are influencing the climate. That is no hoax: There is little doubt.... The impact today of human activity appears to be comparable to the intrinsic, natural variability of the climate system itself.

...the crucial, unsettled scientific question for policy is, "How will the climate change over the next century under both natural and human influences?" Answers to that question at the global and regional levels, as well as to equally complex questions of how ecosystems and human activities will be affected, should inform our choices about energy and infrastructure.

...

Society's choices in the years ahead will necessarily be based on uncertain knowledge of future climates. That uncertainty need not be an excuse for inaction. There is well-justified prudence in accelerating the development of low-emissions technologies and in cost-effective energy-efficiency measures.

...

Any serious discussion of the changing climate must begin by acknowledging not only the scientific certainties but also the uncertainties, especially in projecting the future. Recognizing those limits, rather than ignoring them, will lead to a more sober and ultimately more productive discussion of climate change and climate policies. To do otherwise is a great disservice to climate science itself." 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

I'm still waiting for the ice age they promised us in the 70's 

satsuma --- 12 years ago -

Nice piece. With some really relevant points for discussion at the link.


Generalizing a bit:

No matter how well you can fit your model to data generated by a highly complex and highly non-linear system, no matter how confident you can be of causal relationships derived from that data, neither your closeness of fit nor soundness of inference necessarily translate into a meaningful (non-spurious) forecast of the data to come. 

WatchOut --- 12 years ago -

Climate Science is not "Settled"


Per the extreme right wing rag, Wall Street Journal. I haven't put any validity into their opinions for eons. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 12 years ago -

Per the extreme right wing rag, Wall Street Journal. I haven't put any validity into their opinions for eons.

Thats obvious. 

WatchOut --- 12 years ago -

Nor yours, doofus. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

.Climate Science is not "Settled"

Actually, it is settled. It's just that some people aren't settled to the truth.


The impact today of human activity appears to be comparable to the intrinsic, natural variability of the climate system itself.

That is absolute nonsense 

satsuma --- 12 years ago -

That is absolute nonsense?

I'll take the opinion of the CalTech physicist who's worked for both BP and President Obama over your unsupported assertions, conspiracy theories, and young-earth creationist nonsense.

Actually, it is settled.

Actually it isn't: there are a lot of mechanisms we don't understand. The physical properties of CO2 are settled. how average temperatures and temperature differentials affect weather patterns and storm formation aren't. 

satsuma --- 12 years ago -

Per the extreme right wing rag, Wall Street Journal. I haven't put any validity into their opinions for eons.?

did you read the article?

Which of the criticisms of climate modeling (and using those models to forecast) do you find objectionable? 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

I'll take the opinion of the CalTech physicist who's worked for both BP and President Obama over your unsupported assertions, conspiracy theories, and young-earth creationist nonsense.

And I'll take the Word of someone infinitesimally more intelligent than your CalTech physicist, a physicist who is motivated by payola.

Actually it isn't

Actually, it is still settled, regardless of the nonsense you post. 

LitlJay --- 12 years ago -

Global warming/climate change is the ONLY discipline of science in thousands of years to outright reject any form of peer review, expecting everyone to have utterly complete and blind faith in what they are told about the field.

Sounds like a religion or a cult to me. A false one.

Peer review would expose the field for the bunk that it is instead of confirming the theses and conclusions as they are defended. Thus, peer review is prohibited with the claims that skeptics want dirty air and filthy water. Legitimate debate can not be permitted on any level, lest global warming be exposed for the politically motivated junk science that everyone knows that it really is. 

satsuma --- 12 years ago -

Global warming/climate change is the ONLY discipline of science in thousands of years to outright reject any form of peer review

That's not true at all, BUT climate science is prey to the problem that has befallen nearly all sciences: the research has become so highly specialized that only a handful of people in the world are truly capable of giving meaningful peer review. This leads to one of two consequences: the reviewers don't know enough about the vagaries of the particular subject of research, or the reviewers and authors all know each other and can tell who said what (no anonymity). In both cases, the reviewers are left with skewed incentives. There's actually a lot of interesting research out now challenging the peer review process.

there's a lot of sensationalism, politicization, and money-politics at play. But there's good sound science behind it to.

CO2 is rising in the atmosphere, we're causing it to rise.
The affect on the energy content of the earth is well established physics. The timing and manner in which that extra energy will manifest itself in the future is not well understood, and not easily forecastable.

Legitimate debate can not be permitted on any level, lest global warming be exposed for the politically motivated junk science that everyone knows that it really is.?

But that's part of the problem. It's not ALL politically motivated junk. That's (mostly) just the forecasts. 

Commoner Sense --- 12 years ago -

So many of the most religious folks seem to be the ones most OK with destroying their god's creation. The irony of that position just baffles me. Even if you don't buy into the absolutely irrefutable truth that the planet is getting hotter and our introduction of excessively high levels of CO2 into the atmosphere is at the very least partially responsible for that, whats wrong with cleaning the planet up just for the sake of cleaning it up? What's wrong with leaving the place better off for those that will follow you? Consume consume consume consume...turn and burn. 

Wolfram --- 12 years ago -

The science they rely on is conjecture through computer modeling.

Is there any other area of science where it is believed the science of complex systems is settled through the use of computer conjecture? 

Wicked --- 12 years ago -

It does not matter if it is real or not. It does not give any of us permission to destroy our planet and consume so much fossil fuel. It is almost like this type of thing makes you feel good about being a bad steward to our planet and allows you to somehow rationalize that all the environmental poor choices you make are ok. Well, they are not ok. Stop driving your monster vehicle. Start recycling. Start buying food in packaging that you can recycle. Quit drinking bottled water! Make some small change in your personal life that can somehow decrease your own personal carbon footprint. I do it every single day. But, I need your help. 

Wolfram --- 12 years ago -

But, I need your help.

Nope, I do not want to help you. What are you gonna do about that? 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Even if you don't buy into the absolutely irrefutable truth that the planet is getting hotter and our introduction of excessively high levels of CO2 into the atmosphere is at the very least partially responsible for that

LOL, there is no truth to that statement.

It does not give any of us permission to destroy our planet and consume so much fossil fuel.

That sorta sounds like chicken little. No one is destroying the planet, and no one is consuming "too much" fossil fuel. LOL, "fossil fuel", one of the biggest misnomers ever perpetuated upon mankind. 

DVaz --- 12 years ago -

Didn't Earth have to be extremely warm for giant cold blooded reptiles like dinosaurs to not only survive, but thrive? 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

The crucial scientific question for policy isn't whether the climate is changing. That is a settled matter: The climate has always changed and always will. Geological and historical records show the occurrence of major climate shifts, sometimes over only a few decades. We know, for instance, that during the 20th century the Earth's global average surface temperature rose 1.4 degrees Fahrenheit.

Nor is the crucial question whether humans are influencing the climate. That is no hoax: There is little doubt in the scientific community that continually growing amounts of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, due largely to carbon-dioxide emissions from the conventional use of fossil fuels, are influencing the climate. There is also little doubt that the carbon dioxide will persist in the atmosphere for several centuries. The impact today of human activity appears to be comparable to the intrinsic, natural variability of the climate system itself.

I agree with his assessment. At this time we do not have enough information on the extent and impact on the climate that we are making.

The amount of CO2 we generate is about 5 times normal volcanic activity.

By emitting CO2 we maybe averting another ice age.

At this point we do not know. I think we should consider some items. Stop government subsidies of flood insurance on coastal building.

But a whole setup of a CO2 market place is too radical at this point. And to get the rest of the world to do the same and not cheat...that isn't going to happen.

I think we should spend resources to determine the extent of climate change and how it will affect future generations.

If we are going to cause major misery for future generations then we should be more aggressive. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

CO2 is rising in the atmosphere, we're causing it to rise.

LOL, a whopping 70 ppm - we're all going to die!!!

Comparison of Atmospheric Temperature with CO2 Over The Last 100 Years

Temperatures have increased by about 0.5° C over the last 100 years. Most of these increases occurred in the first 50 years of this time period.

Carbon dioxide (CO2) has also increased over the last 100 years-- from about 300 ppm to 370 ppm. Interestingly, the majority of these additions have occurred in the last 50 years, when temperature increases have been slowest.

Independent data from orbiting satelites have been continuosly measuring global temperatures since the 1970's and indicate that over the last 25 years there has actually been a slight decrease in overall global temperatures.

Assuming that at least part of the source of CO2 additions in the last 50 years is anthropogenic (man-made), the likely scenario is (at the level of additions involved) that CO2 concentrations in our atmosphere are an effect of temperature-- not the other way around. The perturbation of CO2 equilibrium has not had the proportional effect on temperature that greenhouse activists predict.

0

0

NOTE: All charts were plotted directly from composite data sets using Lotus 1-2-3.

0 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

Carbon dioxide (CO2) has also increased over the last 100 years-- from about 300 ppm to 370 ppm. Interestingly, the majority of these additions have occurred in the last 50 years, when temperature increases have been slowest.


That is about a 23% increase. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

The perturbation of CO2 equilibrium has not had the proportional effect on temperature that greenhouse activists predict.

Like the professor stated we need further studies. A better indicator would be ocean temperatures. But do we have long range data. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

That is about a 23% increase.

So what? At ppm levels, a 50% increase would be meaningless. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

So what? At ppm levels, a 50% increase would be meaningless.



Carbon dioxide is continuously cycling among the earth, plants and animals, the atmosphere and the ocean's surface, with the deep ocean serving as a gigantic long-term reservoir.

Up until the last two centuries, this carbon cycle had been in close balance for the last 10,000 years. But society has pushed atmospheric carbon dioxide levels from 278 parts per million at the start of the industrial revolution to 392 parts per million today, a 40 percent increase.

What's more, the bulk ? some 57 percent ? of carbon emitted from tailpipes and smokestacks is not even in the atmosphere. It has cycled into the ocean, and scientists generally agree that most of our carbon emissions will ultimately come to a rest in its deepest depths. But that will take centuries. In the meantime, those extra CO2 molecules will slosh around from earth to atmosphere to upper ocean and back, absorbing energy, acidifying the seas and changing the planet in profound and potentially unwelcome ways. In other words, CO2 emitted today will still be impacting the planet for hundreds of years 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

Claim: CO2 comprises less than 0.04 percent of the air.

Assessment: True but irrelevant in the global warming debate.

Nitrogen, oxygen and argon together make up close to 100 percent of the atmosphere. But all three are invisible to incoming "short-wave" radiation from the sun and outgoing "long-wave" radiation from the Earth's surface. They play no role in regulating the planet's atmospheric temperature.

But carbon dioxide and other trace gases in the atmosphere do absorb the outgoing long-wave radiation.

So while their concentrations are miniscule, their effect is anything but: If the atmosphere didn't have those trace amounts of greenhouse gases, New York City would be covered in ice sheets ? not sweltering ? on a typical summer afternoon. The globe's average temperature would be almost 60 degrees Fahrenheit lower.

Similarly, toxicity is not an issue in the climate change debate. Yes, crops need CO2. Breathing a little more of it while out on the links won't impair your golf game. But earlier findings that suggested higher CO2 levels could increase crop yields have been disproved by recent research showing that other nutrients are more often the limiting factor.

The relevant questions for climate science are how CO2 changes atmospheric temperatures and circulation and alters the oceans' chemistry and heat capacity. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

Above posts from:

http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-carbon-dioxide-is-greenhouse-gas/ 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Up until the last two centuries, this carbon cycle had been in close balance for the last 10,000 years.

LOL, even if the earth was 10,000 yrs old, they would have no way of knowing that. It's a computer modeling guess. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

LOL, even if the earth was 10,000 yrs old, they would have no way of knowing that. It's a computer modeling guess.

LOL - Can you say ice core samples. It appears you must since you used them in one of your posts. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

It appears you must since you used them in one of your posts.

Not to claim values from 10,000 yrs ago. 

RiteWingKing --- 12 years ago -

Not to claim values from 10,000 yrs ago.

I know because the planet was created in 7 days about 6,000 years ago.

The gas in you car is not derived from an organism that created chemical energy from sunlight millions of years ago. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

The gas in you car is not derived from an organism that created chemical energy from sunlight millions of years ago.

Hey, you finally got something right. Congrats! 

satsuma --- 12 years ago -

And I'll take the Word of someone infinitesimally more intelligent than your CalTech physicist, a physicist who is motivated by payola.

so... basically, you're taking the word of someone who is almost imperceptibly more intelligent? Who? A friend? Because if you're referring to God, then you either have a low opinion of god's intelligence or an amazingly high opinion of the physicist's intelligence.

I mean, if i'm taking you literally.
;)



Didn't Earth have to be extremely warm for giant cold blooded reptiles like dinosaurs to not only survive, but thrive??

"In fact, it seems more likely than anything.... Some dinosaurs could have been normal ectotherms, and some could have been endotherms. Yes, it's a messy issue. We'll close by listing the five main sides that paleontologists have taken since the issue began."
Top 5 current hypotheses: Dinosaurs, Warm or cold blooded? 

satsuma --- 12 years ago -

Oh,
and well done as per usual RWK!

I've been too busy characterizing gulf coast lease condensate saturation for bankers. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground