Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

On Judging others - warning - contains religious views - don't open if you don't want to

who's talking here?

Donkey Hodie 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 4
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
Joe Blow 6
jacobson 12
AMDG 7
Monkey Butt 1
Big D 4
The Eyes Have It 2
FNHO 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

I am sensitive to the hijacking of threads into religious debate, so thought I would give this its own space, if anyone wanted to comment of this.

On any number of times on the board there has been a routine discussion where someone states that Christians are instructed not to judge and which quickly gets countered by someone telling them they are wrong. IMO - neither side of these quick flash positions is making the point very well. So here is an attempt at building a bridge between these two positions.

Disclaimer - much of this is compiled from many teachings, but this is all just my humble opinion.

My take -

What can we judge

There is a major difference between judging actions as sinful and passing judgment on what is in someone's heart or heaven forbid the state of their soul. More specifically actions can be judged. But actions are not people, and people are not actions. Not speaking against actions that we know to be against the will of God, that are injurious to the soul of our brothers and sisters, is a sin of omission on our part. We are not judging the person, we are judging the action - Catholics call this "fraternal correction"

What we can?t judge

Having said all that, there is a big difference between judging another's behavior and judging the eternal state of his soul. The latter judgment belongs only to God. We do not know what is in the heart, or the mind, or the soul of others. Those judgments are God's alone.

Why we judge

Love, charity, mercy, and it is our Christian responsibility. There cannot be any other motivation to engage in fraternal correction. Any other motive is sinful. In general, we are very sensitive to the idea of charity and caring about the physical and material well-being of others, but almost completely silent about our spiritual responsibility towards our brothers and sisters, this fraternal correction is to show love, charity and mercy toward our brothers and sisters, and fulfill our Christian responsibility to them. I know I'm a sinner. I have many faults to work on myself, but if we just let people walk down the road to perdition without trying to divert them we are failing them.

How we judge

Here is what Jesus tells us -

Go and tell him his fault, between you and him alone. If he listens to you, you have gained your brother. But if he does not listen, take one or two others along with you, that every word may be confirmed by the evidence of two or three witnesses. If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church; and if he refuses to listen even to the church, let him be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector. (Matt. 18:15-17)

How not to judge

In Jesus? own words, we must start by taking the logs out of our own eyes-by making sure we are doing the best we can to live lives of good example. We must also strive to form our consciences correctly so that we know sin when we see it. Finally, we must not jump to conclusions about another's culpability in sin. We are sinners as well and we must not be hypocritical in our correction.

The Catholic teaching on this goes even further:

Respect for the reputation of persons forbids every attitude and word likely to cause them unjust injury.

He becomes guilty:

of rash judgment who, even tacitly, assumes as true, without sufficient foundation, the moral fault of a neighbor;

of detraction who, without objectively valid reason, discloses another's faults and failings to persons who did not know them;

of calumny who, by remarks contrary to the truth, harms the reputation of others and gives occasion for false judgments concerning them.

To avoid rash judgment, everyone should be careful to interpret insofar as possible his neighbor's thoughts, words, and deeds in a favorable way: "Every good Christian ought to be more ready to give a favorable interpretation to another's statement than to condemn it. But if he cannot do so, let him ask how the other understands it. And if the latter understands it badly, let the former correct him with love. If that does not suffice, let the Christian try all suitable ways to bring the other to a correct interpretation so that he may be saved."

So in summary -

you can correct the act, if your motivation is pure.

You can't judge the person.

You should remember that you are a sinner and ensure your correction is not hypocritical.

You should always try to correct in private first.

And finally you should give every benefit of the doubt to your brother and sister and take great pains to ensure your very correction does not cross over from fraternal correction to sinful judgment. 

FNHO --- 12 years ago -

Pretty funny that the christians can't even agree. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Your catholic religious teachings are a little skewed. We don't have final judgment on the eternal resting place of a person's spirit, but we CAN judge where they currently are.

Pretty funny that the christians can't even agree.

That's because you don't understand that not all who profess to be Christian are Christian. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

Just a warning to be respectful, no name calling either.

Thanks. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Your catholic religious teachings are a little skewed. We don't have final judgment on the eternal resting place of a person's spirit, but we CAN judge where they currently are.

Can you give an example ??? Not 100% sure what you mean. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Can you give an example ??? Not 100% sure what you mean.

Jesus tells us that "out of the abundance of the heart the mouth speaketh". So, according to what someone says in reference to God/Jesus, we can know whether or not Jesus is their Lord and Savior at that point in time.

Jesus also said, "Give not that which is holy unto the dogs, neither cast ye your pearls before swine". That also tells us that we can know where they are at that point in time. 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

Jacob's been drinking too much vino. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

So, as an example - you are standing next to someone who begins to spew every kind of vulgar profanity you can think of, would it, in your view, be proper to make some judgment on their salvation ? 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Methinks you are improperly using the word "proper".

I do believe that your scenario would speak to where their heart is. 

Donkey Hodie --- 12 years ago -

I don't have a problem with judging - everybody does it. Judge people to your heart's content! Do it! But once you open your mouth and let the world know of your judgement, then your behavior, and your expressed opinions are now also fair game for public commentary. Since most people are also pretty big hypocrites, the best thing is to just keep your yap shut. 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

Methinks



All your bible reading has got you talking in the first millenia terms. lmao 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

more like during Shakespearean times- 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

I do believe that your scenario would speak to where their heart is.

methinks maybe or maybe not - turrets? schizophrenic? just stubbed their toe - real bad ? 

The Eyes Have It --- 12 years ago -

You should remember that you are a sinner and ensure your correction is not hypocritical.

BINGO!!

Winner Winner Chicken Dinner 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

turrets? schizophrenic?

I guess you mean "Tourette's" not gun "turrets". They may blurt out a word occasionally, but they wouldn't "spew every kind of vulgar profanity you can think of", and neither would a schizophrenic. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

you forgot" pontificate" to your description- I know j, I don't know the meaning of that word- 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

Nope actually pre shakespearean. 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

On the other hand the Jacobean era is consistent with Shakespearen times. lmao 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

yes Tourette's - thanks the correction 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

You should remember that you are a sinner and ensure your correction is not hypocritical.

Bad theology. 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

They may blurt out a word occasionally, but they wouldn't "spew every kind of vulgar profanity you can think of", and neither would a schizophrenic.

seems to me like a touch of a shaky diagnosis to base a judgment on an others soul on. - not in any way how I would like to be judged 

The Eyes Have It --- 12 years ago -

You should remember that you are a sinner and ensure your correction is not hypocritical.

Bad theology.


Judgmental 

Monkey Butt --- 12 years ago -

AMDG, your first post was absolutely wonderful. I am so glad you took the time to post this discussion. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Judgmental

Hey, you got one of your judgments right. Congrats. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

not in any way how I would like to be judged?

We don't make the rules. 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

Removed


lmao! 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Let us not forget that jacobson is JDB the financial advisor. lmao!?

LOL, that's funny. 

Joe Blow --- 12 years ago -

"See, the problem is that God gives men a brain and a penis, and only enough blood to run one at a time." Robin Williams 

AMDG --- 12 years ago -

Monkey - thanks

Jacob - we could go back and forth a few more times, but maybe just faster to just agree to disagree on that point here.

Back to the bridge building -

Hopefully for some who have said we should never judge, maybe they can have some understanding on why that is not always true.

And for others who rush to judgment, maybe this might slow them down a touch. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

having the ability to reason is essential to coming to an understanding to agree to disagree- an open mind is also critical to a polite discussion- 

Big D --- 12 years ago -

I'm glad I'm not the only one that gets easily fed up with this guy jacobson's prickly responses. I just got iced over it.

What gets me is his defense of his prickish responses. He justifies it by saying he is only repeating God's words. So, if we argue with him then we really are arguing against God. He is only doing what God commands him to do. We are all idiots for not seeing that he is the voice of God. The arrogance of that cult leader screams mental illness. I have used some of my time to read the responses of this JohnLynch person you guys keep mentioning. Of course they are the same person. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

I'm glad I'm not the only one that gets easily fed up with this guy jacobson's prickly responses.

You've got that backwards Big D. Prickly describes the reaction of a person ready to take offense. You're upset because you resort to name calling when you are losing an argument, or your statements are shown to be false. In other words, you get prickly (ready to take offense).

He justifies it by saying he is only repeating God's words.

False statement since I don't always repeat God's Words.

We are all idiots for not seeing that he is the voice of God.

You would only be so if you think I've said that or if you believe it.

The arrogance of that cult leader screams mental illness.

LOL, I don't lead any group. FYI, arrogance is in the eye of the beholder.

Of course they are the same person.

Having the same belief in God doesn't make us the same person. If that were the case, my entire Bible study group would be John Lynch, and that's not possible.

Is every one on this forum that believes as you do the same person? If so, you have a lot of alts. 

Big D --- 12 years ago -

You've got that backwards Big D. Prickly describes the reaction of a person ready to take offense.

So you assume that's what I meant by prickly? 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

So you assume that's what I meant by prickly?

If it isn't, you didn't know what "prickly" means. 

Big D --- 12 years ago -

Lol 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

read a little closer, jacobson- lol 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

read a little closer, jacobson- lol?

LOL yourself. I don't need to read a little closer. Made up words with made up meanings mean nothing. 

Big D --- 12 years ago -

LOL yourself.

Laughing out loud yourself? What? That's your comeback?

That doesn't even make sense. Are 9 years old? By that I mean this many:

0

Maybe you can tell her she eats doodoo for your next comeback. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

Now we know how you count. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground