Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

GIVE ME A BREAK - MINOR car accident and now everyone in the car has neck problems!!!

who's talking here?

ukchristine 1
AFWife 1
SleightOfHand 4
FANCY PANTS 3
RedMulch 1
Gigix4 1
Defcon1 1
sheddy 1
mispissy 1
snowprincess 3
mynewid 1
JAMS 2
emptynester 3
mutton 1
MalevolentWitchesClub 1
Oregonian 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

emptynester --- 12 years ago -

My insurance adjuster just called me for a statement about an accident I was involved in and told me that everyone in the car has neck pain. Now here is the story: we were at a red light there were cars in front of her and behind me all going straight, I was watching the lights and saw the left turn light turn green so I took my foot off the brake and may or may not have hit the gas (just not really sure it happened so fast, I could not have been going 2 or 3 mph)then hit the brake again, I did hit her van (it was totally my fault). We pulled over got out and I wanted to call the police (family members are police and say ALWAYS call) she said she didn't want to because they were going to a basketball tournament out of town and needed to get on the road. I said are you sure, is everyone OK, she said yes to both. while she was getting a pen to write her info, I asked the two children (ages 14 &16) if they were sure they were OK and they said "yes we're fine". We exchanged info the driver said she would call the ins when she gets back on Monday, I said well I will call them today. Before she left I told her I needed to take a picture of her bumper and she wanted to know why, I said to protect myself if you get hit again. She was a very sweet lady and was nothing but kind to me. I am just in AWWW that 8 hours later she is telling the adjuster they are all experincing neck pain and want to go to the Chiropractor on Monday (3 days from now)after her son finishes his tournament !!!! I want them to get medical treatment if it is needed, but I think it is just a little suspious they are waiting until after the tournament to get it. If my child was injured in a car accident I would not allow him to participate in a tournament before he saw a Dr. or Chiroprator. We all pay a lot of money for ins and it is continually increasing due to circumstances like this. Please don't bash me by saying well maybe their necks started hurting later in the day, because if that is the case go to the DR TODAY, don't let your son play basketball and wait three days to take him (or your other child & yourself) to the Dr. Am I wrong for feeling this way! 

mutton --- 12 years ago -

Your ins company will be interested in the tournament... 

RedMulch --- 12 years ago -

No...but remember...never EVER say it is all your fault at the scene even if it is. If they are that way, it is gonna be bad. I'd never bash you...i have been there before. 

Gigix4 --- 12 years ago -

It is possible to have some neck/back issues ... after the fact and may not show up until some time later. However, playing in a basketball tournament after and accident sure sounds suspicious to me. 

mynewid --- 12 years ago -

I had a very similar type accident happen. My fault - very low speed - no damage at all to my vehicle and very little to her bumper. She actually looked down, saw my wedding set on my hand then very deliberately said, "oh good, I bet you have great insurance". Sure enough she claimed injuries. I wanted to fight but the insurance company wasn't interested in fighting it. 

FANCY PANTS --- 12 years ago -

Please don't bash me by saying well maybe their necks started hurting later in the day, because if that is the case go to the DR TODAY, don't let your son play basketball and wait three days to take him (or your other child & yourself) to the Dr. Am I wrong for feeling this way!

Make sure the ins. co. knows that the kids are playing in a BB tournament. It sure sounds fishy to me that they all want to wait till Monday to see the Chiropractor. I think they want an adjustment after a long hard weekend/tournament. If my kids and I were in an accident and had neck pain I would go to see a dr. right away. I would not wait to see my Chiropractor on Monday. 

FANCY PANTS --- 12 years ago -

I think they are trying to scam you and the ins. co. 

Oregonian --- 12 years ago -

She thinks you are the goose that is going to lay a golden egg. Good luck. Did you have a witness with or for you?
Never, never say anything about who is at fault. She could have backed into you at the light? 

Oregonian --- 12 years ago -

She thinks you are the goose that is going to lay a golden egg. Good luck. Did you have a witness with or for you?
Never, never say anything about who is at fault. She could have backed into you at the light? 

sheddy --- 12 years ago -

I'd get to the tournament and take some pictures of the kids playing ball if I had to sit there all day long. 

snowprincess --- 12 years ago -

How bad was the damage to the van? 

mispissy --- 12 years ago -

That is one argument for going to no-fault insurance like many other states have done. I have mixed feelings on whether or not no-fault insurance is "right" or "fair," but it sure would cut down on people claiming injuries that may or may not be related to the accident. 

MalevolentWitchesClub --- 12 years ago -

mispissy

i like your name 

AFWife --- 12 years ago -

I've been burned once so any little thing that has ever happened with our cars I call the police. I know they have better things to do but you cannot trust people at all nowadays. 

ukchristine --- 12 years ago -

If they really had neck pain they would see a doc for relief. They would not be able to continue normally.

OTOH.....they continual with their original plans but believe they will all be all have neck pain on Monday. Brilliant they can see into the future.

Video of them this weekend acting normally esp the kid playing basketball would be great. After all they have revealed their plans already so something that shows problems not in evidence might be useful. 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

It's not at all suspicious.
Physical pain can sometimes take hours, even days, to begin after an accident.
I was slammed into from behind and didn't begin to feel pain until the next day; the accident resulted in a nice 5 figure settlement from the at fault driver's insurance company.
I was driving my Camaro, and there appeared to be virtually no damage, but when the at fault driver' insurance company came to inspect my car the next day, they showed me where the convertible fabric ripped away from the window and both sides of the car were rippled. It took months of physical therapy, a chiropractor, MRI, and lots of pain medication for my back to feel better. However, the accident didn't stop me from enjoying life, which included riding and training my horses.

A dear friend in CA was involved in a serious auto accident a week ago that she walked away from with barely a scratch. The last two nights she's spent crying from the pain she's now experiencing in her ribs and back, to the point it's difficult to breathe.

YOU are at fault here, and it's good that you recognize that, but pain isn't always immediate.
It's very normal to be sore and feel pain after the fact. 

emptynester --- 12 years ago -

Thanks for the feed back and I am so glad to see most of you took this the way it was intended. I have learned to ALWAYS call the police even if it is your fault, to protect everyone ivolved, yes even the ins co.
JAMS - I guess you didn't read my whole post, I acknowledge that pain may come later. My point was her son was playing in basketball tourament later that day. Now I see, that his team played AFTER she called the ins co and told them they all had neck pains, so if he had neck pain before the game why would you let him play in the game? If he gets hurt in the game, do you think ins should still be liable to cover that too? Also,she is the one that tod the ins co. about the basketball tournament. Again, if my child said "mom my neck is hurt" after an accident I would take them to the Dr or the ER right away, even if I was out of town. To me it is not about how much money will be paid out it is about doing the right thing. 

SleightOfHand --- 12 years ago -

2-3 mph does not provide nearly enough kinetic energy to cause injury to someone in another vehicle sitting in their seats. This is bull crap 

FANCY PANTS --- 12 years ago -

emptynester---

What was the damage to your car? 

snowprincess --- 12 years ago -

emptynester refuses to give details on the damage, so it probably was at a higher speed than 2-3 mph. 

emptynester --- 12 years ago -

SORRY, I was busy an hadn't een back. There is NO damage to my car and I have already sent pictures of my car and hers to the ins.
SNOWPRINCES - PLEASE do not assume bc just because I did not respond sooner that I am not telling the truth. We were sitting at a red light just exactly how fast do you think I could have been going?? 

snowprincess --- 12 years ago -

Depends how hard you hit the gas. 

SleightOfHand --- 12 years ago -

"Depends how hard you hit the gas"

At a car lengths distance from a vehicle in front, even if you floor it, you will not exceed 5 mph 

JAMS --- 12 years ago -

Even at speeds of 5 miles, physical occurrences to the body can occur.
I believe the threshold is around 2-3 miles for human injury.
There are studies on the web you can view.

While physically you may not be able to see damage from a low speed collision, that doesn't mean the damage isn't there. A professional needs to make that determination by checking out all aspects of the car, especially the undercarriage.

As I mentioned, my Camaro did not appear to have any damage to the untrained eye (there wasn't a visible scratch or dent) but sustained thousands of dollars worth of damage. 

SleightOfHand --- 12 years ago -

"Even at speeds of 5 miles, physical occurrences to the body can occur.
I believe the threshold is around 2-3 miles for human injury.
There are studies on the web you can view."

A direct rear end collision forces the body back into the seat. The kinetic energy will be absorbed by the striking vehicle, the struck vehicle, the foam in the seats, the fluid in the body, etc. A 3200 pound vehicle traveling at 3 mph only generates 900 something ft/lbs of energy. Combine that crashing into another 3200 lbs car with people properly seated in seats, there will be very minor force applied to the occupant's body. 

SleightOfHand --- 12 years ago -

And before you start attacking me, keep in mind that the same 3200 lbs car generates 10,389 ft/lbs of kinetic energy at 10 mph, still a relatively low speed for a collision. 

Defcon1 --- 12 years ago -

I got rear ended by a 1994 Chevy Silverado. He was doing an easy 30-40mph and I was STOPPED.

I felt perfectly fine that whole evening but the next morning I woke up with a gnarly headache that dropped down into my shoulders.

I felt jacked up for a week or more. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground