Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

World really is only 6,000 years old...

who's talking here?

SoupIsGoodFood 4
Red Heifer 1
zapper007 4
voice of reason 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 3
Aah Grasshoppa 1
Dorothy Parker 1
Defcon1 1
Edgar Po Wong 2
Ogre13 17
Prolix Raconteur 2
jacobson 6
MalevolentWitchesClub 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

zapper007 --- 12 years ago -

How else could Fox News continue to bring up Bengazi? 

Aah Grasshoppa --- 12 years ago -

Huh? 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Welcome to Non-Sequitor Theatre! 

MalevolentWitchesClub --- 12 years ago -

nonsense 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Must be sticking in your craw still, zapper.

It's not going away. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

4 dead in Benghazi
4489 American Soldiers dead and another 32,021 wounded in Iraq in a war started on lies.

I dunno... priorities maybe?

It's not like this sort of thing never happens. YES, this was the FIRST Ambassador killed in a while, but you know what? Sometimes the Foreign Service is DANGEROUS. I read a story once about a State Dept. Courier who lost an arm to a friggin LION while trying to get out of some Sh**tehole in Africa.

How about the 241 service members Ronald Reagan sent to Beirut who were killed in the bombing of Marine barracks in October 1983?

Or the 13 Embassy attacks that occurred under Bush? Why didn't they get the Neo-Cons all up in a fuss?

BY ALL MEANS Benghazi needs to be investigated. But the vast majority of what I've heard on this board and others has simply been armchair generalling. In other words, POINTLESS.

SOMETIMES, the ENEMY gets one over on you. I can't think of a war that I've studied where one side had a 100% success record. History is RIFE with examples of this. Sometimes it's simply a lack of intelligence on the enemy's actions, sometimes it's hubris. I think Benghazi is a bit of both. Benghazi is just one more example of why being in a war of any sort, but especially one of the sort we are today, is very, VERY dangerous. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Found it!

State Dept. Courier Story 

Prolix Raconteur --- 12 years ago -

it's more the assertion that there was a direct cover up or obfuscation by the administration due to the upcoming elections than the actual benghazi event itself i think...and the fact that despite assertions to bring the assailants to justice, nothing has happened...despite the fact that the lead suspect was giving interviews in libyan cafes the next month bragging about it... 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

that there was a direct cover up

Ya know, I've seen NOTHING that supports that. Admittedly, I don't have access to ALL the evidence. Just what the BIASED (one way or another) Press puts out.

But my question to that is...so what if it was? Is it at all possible that the administration wanted to keep it hush hush so they COULD go after this guy who is giving interviews?

This sort of thing really gets to me, it's like having a wingman who doesn't pick up on your cues and winds up screwing up your goal.

We, as private citizens, are NOT privy to all state secrets or covert ops. There is a contingent that seems to think that we should be. And I don't agree with that.

It's one of the reasons I still argue that Snowden is a traitor. Not because of WHAT he gave up, but because he gave up ANYTHING at all after taking an oath. (Also, if you didn't know the NSA has been spying on us for years, then you haven't been paying attention and should just shut up now). But then we're back to the old double standard of when Bush (or any neo-con) was doing it, it's patriotic, but when Obama (or any liberal) does it, it's nefarious. And that's just ridiculous. 

Defcon1 --- 12 years ago -

How do you joke about Americans losing their lives because a bunch of idiot democrats had better things to do than to send aid to fellow Americans under attack?

You want to make jokes about the people who died on 9/11 while you're at it? 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Like I said, armchair generalling. 

zapper007 --- 12 years ago -

Priorities for the REPUBLICATS (fat that is)!!! 

voice of reason --- 12 years ago -

lynchie in hiding since his simultaneous k.u./k.u.2 ice capades
thank the devil. 

zapper007 --- 12 years ago -

lynchie in hiding

YEA =- praised the lord!!! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Ya know, I've seen NOTHING that supports that.

You obviously haven't been looking...... or listening.

Has the Youtube video ruse already slipped your memory? 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

You obviously haven't been looking...... or listening.

I have been. But NOTHING that has been presented qualifies as "Evidence" which has largely been kept qualified.

What you have in the press and on "youtube" is supposition. That's all. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

Obviously not listening.

What say you to the ruse the Obama admin tried to peddle about the Youtube video?

You wouldn't define that as "obfuscation"? 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

What say you to the ruse the Obama admin tried to peddle about the Youtube video?

What makes YOU think the Administration did this?

Initial Intel may very well have indicated that what they initially said the video was was accurate. (That's very Chenyesque, I know...but say it slowly) It's called Fog of War.

Is it also not possible that this video was the impetus to provide the terrorists with a diversion to their real operation? That is the killing of an American diplomat? Because that's what I've always thought this was. A diversion. One that was particularly elegant.

It's not as if the CIA/NSA/DIA or other intelligence agencies are 100% successful in determining future events. The CIA didn't even know the Berlin Wall was coming down. They failed numerous times in taking out Castro (to humorous effect), They didn't predict the Iranian revolution. WHY COULD THEY NOT have been blindsided by a particularly elegant subterfuge by a terrorist cell designed to distract our attention and open the possibility of their successfully eliminating a high-value target?

After all, we'd seen riots over less (Can you say Muhammad Cartoon?) And this video, while particularly poorly done, was also particularly Islamaphobic. Of course, this leads to a bigger theory that the previous riots (the cartoon merely being one) were also subterfuge, possibly leading up to this event.

HISTORY is rife with examples of intelligence people,and if you think the terrorists do not have intelligence people you are sorely mistaken, playing the LONG game.

But you STILL do not present any REAL evidence that this was a Plot by the administration. Just an argument that it was with no supporting evidence whatsoever. That's just partisanship. NOT investigation.

In fact, is it not MORE likely that the Administration merely spoke about what they knew (i.e were told) at the time, and then continued with that message until they had greater confirmation of what was really going down, and by that time, as with most politics, changing the topic was considered verboten?

Either Obama is an incompetent boob who can't run a country, or he's an evil genius arranging for secret plots to be enacted all over the world and lying to us. Which is it? He can't be both. 

Prolix Raconteur --- 12 years ago -

Either Obama is an incompetent boob who can't run a country, or he's an evil genius arranging for secret plots to be enacted all over the world and lying to us. Which is it? He can't be both.

my money in on option #1 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

my money in on option #1

To be utterly honest, mine is too.

But I just don't buy the "evil empire" arguments that some people like to make. Incompetent? Yes. Nefarious? No, I don't think so. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 12 years ago -

What makes YOU think the Administration did this?

You're still not paying attention.

SUSAN RICE tried to peddle the story. You understand what her position is? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

I have to go with Ogre on this one- 100%- 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

What makes YOU think the Administration did this?

"The phrase 'Obama lied, people died' should ring out from every corner of the country now that we know 100% for sure that Obama knew full well that no "anti-Muslim Youtube video" caused the attacks in Benghazi, Libya that killed four Americans. Obama knew as it was happening that it was a terror attack but lied to America anyway.

Fox News recently uncovered a stash of documents that proves beyond doubt that Obama and his advisers knew just after the attacks began that it was terrorism.

Fox News correspondent James Rosen reported on January 14 that 450 pages of sworn testimony by America?s highest ranking military officers makes the case clearly about what the administration knew and when it was known.

"Minutes after the American consulate in Benghaz" Rosen reported, "the nation?s top civilian and uniformed defense officials?headed for a previously scheduled Oval Office session with President Obama?were informed that the event was a 'terrorist attack,' declassified documents show."

And yet, even as all Obama?s top advisors knew immediately that the attacks were terrorism, for weeks afterward Obama went to the nation and blamed it all on a Youtube video.

As the Heritage Foundation noted in 2012, "when the terrorist attack did take place, the Obama Administration peddled the ridiculous story that an offensive, amateurish, anti-Islam YouTube video was to blame in order to avoid characterizing the murders of four Americans as terrorism."

http://www.mrconservative.com/2014/01/30484-benghazi-transcripts-prove-obama-lied-that-youtube-video-caused-benghazi-attacks/ 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

hi, john! I love you! 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

This is the problem with zealots. They're told what to think, so they don't actually have to think and they think that's thinking.

As indicative by citing Fox News, www.mrconservative.com & the Heritage Foundation as some sort of unbiased source. They are NOT. They are organizations with agendas and no interest in finding TRUTH in an unbiased manner.

I DO MY OWN ANALYSIS based on a confluence of information from a variety of sources, friendly or otherwise. And IN MY EXPERT OPINION AS A RESEARCHER AND INVESTIGATIVE PROFESSIONAL - The Obama administration displayed a great deal of incompetence in handling the situation before, during and after the Benghazi event. AND NOTHING MORE. Admittedly I - LIKE EVERYONE ELSE OUT THERE - do not have access to ALL THE EVIDENCE. So this opinion is preliminary.

Susan Rice, then the National Security Adviser to the President claimed that the attacks on Benghazi were a result of spontaneous demonstrations. And initially, it was believed BY EVERYONE that was the case. To claim that anyone knew otherwise would be to ignore evidence and testimony of experts involved.

That particular assessment came from talking points prepared by the CIA AND was eventually proven wrong, and Rice was accused of being deliberately misleading.

But a former senior intelligence official has been quoted saying that the talking point that called the Benghazi attack spontaneous was precisely what classified intelligence reports said at the time.

But you can't accept that because you have a need for there to be some nefarious plot. You can't accept that our intelligence service is IMPERFECT and always has been.

Let's not forget that the Intel on Iraqi WMD's was WRONG as well. SOME argue that it was intentionally wrong. (I've seen no evidence either way).

As to whether Al Queda was involved in the events, well, I'm a firm believer that they were. BUT I also believe that the term Al Queda has been overused and has come to mean pretty much any group in opposition to the U.S. Foreign Policy.

In this case, there WAS a street protest that appeared to spontaneous, that is KNOWN. But that street protest, was NOT spontaneous, it was engineered and was a cover for an armed terror attack on US assets. In other words, THEY TRICKED US.

NOW, DO YOU as a private citizen have the right to know everything leading up and after that event? NO YOU DO NOT. Because that knowledge may very well effect operations to which we as private citizens are not privy. Saying the President lied is a false argument because guess what, about things like this.... ALL PRESIDENTS LIE TO THE PUBLIC. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

To claim that anyone knew otherwise would be to ignore evidence and testimony of experts involved.

"Gen. Carter Ham, who at the time was head of AFRICOM, the Defense Department combatant command with jurisdiction over Libya, told the House in classified testimony last year that it was him who broke the news about the unfolding situation in Benghazi to then-Defense Secretary Leon Panetta and Gen. Martin Dempsey, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. The tense briefing -- in which it was already known that U.S. Ambassador to Libya Christopher Stevens had been targeted and had gone missing -- occurred just before the two senior officials departed the Pentagon for their session with the commander in chief.

According to declassified testimony obtained by Fox News, Ham -- who was working out of his Pentagon office on the afternoon of Sept. 11 -- said he learned about the assault on the consulate compound within 15 minutes of its commencement, at 9:42 p.m. Libya time, through a call he received from the AFRICOM Command Center.

"My first call was to General Dempsey, General Dempsey's office, to say, 'Hey, I am headed down the hall. I need to see him right away,'" Ham told lawmakers on the House Armed Services Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigation on June 26 of last year. "I told him what I knew. We immediately walked upstairs to meet with Secretary Panetta."

Ham's account of that fateful day was included in some 450 pages of testimony given by senior Pentagon officials in classified, closed-door hearings conducted last year by the Armed Services subcommittee. The testimony, given under "Top Secret" clearance and only declassified this month, presents a rare glimpse into how information during a crisis travels at the top echelons of America's national security apparatus, all the way up to the president.

Also among those whose secret testimony was declassified was Dempsey, the first person Ham briefed about Benghazi. Ham told lawmakers he considered it a fortuitous "happenstance" that he was able to rope Dempsey and Panetta into one meeting, so that, as Ham put it, "they had the basic information as they headed across for the meeting at the White House." Ham also told lawmakers he met with Panetta and Dempsey when they returned from their 30-minute session with President Obama on Sept. 11." 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

You know what the best part about this "unclassified testimony" is, Jacobsen?

It's not found on the Congressional Testimony website. And therefore is suspect. If was declassified, it would be on the website and it's not. So once again, Fox is making stuff up.

US AFRICA COMMAND CONGRESSIONAL TESTIMONY

There are HOWEVER the full REDACTED transcripts of said testimony - which I'm simply not going through... these are HUGE files. The FIRST one is 87 pages long, the third is 156.

Ham does say in them though:

"...secure communications had been destroyed in the movement and the evacuation from Embassy Tripoli..." That alone could prevent effective operations.

Armed Services Committee

In fact the only declassified briefings I can find relate primarily to the matter of whether the security team was told to "stand down" or "hold in place" in Tripoli.

here is a quote from Ham from his ASC Testimony:

HAM: [L]eading up to the events of 11 September, watching the intelligence very carefully as all of us did and post attack having the opportunity to review the intelligence, I still don't find -- I have not found the intelligence that would indicate that an attack in Benghazi was imminent and that subsequent security should have been deployed.
Let me say that AGAIN,

"But leading up to the events of 11 September_, watching the intelligence very carefully as all of us did and post attack having the opportunity to review the intelligence, I still don't find -- I have not found the intelligence that would indicate that an attack in Benghazi was imminent and that subsequent security should have been deployed."

This is EIGHT months post event.

THIS IS THE DIFFERENCE between relying on FOX (or MSNBC) to do your research and doing it yourself. YOU GET AT THE WHOLE TRUTH. I highly recommend that anyone who is concerned about it actually read the testimony. I simply don't' have the time to give it the attention it deserves.

ONCE AGAIN, JACOBSEN - citing FOX News is NOT proof in any way shape or form. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 12 years ago -

amen, brother- 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Oh, and the idea that a General in the ARMY would think this was an attack first... well GOSH GOLLY...that's too absurd is it?

But what did OTHERS think it looked like?

Well, here's an article with pictures from Cairo. Cairo Riot

That doesn't look like an attack now does it? That looks like a protest.

I can't find any pics or video from Libya. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

One more thing before I sign off for the night.

Everyone seems hooked on this:

"Obama knew as it was happening that it was a terror attack but lied to America anyway."

My question to you all is... SO WHAT?

What does it matter?

HRC had it right. WHAT DOES IT MATTER???

You sound like a whiney child crying that the doctor told him it wouldn't hurt.

THE PRESIDENT, and no other politician is obliged to tell you the truth about ANYTHING. Much less on matters of National Security or Military operations, ESPECIALLY military operations that are currently under way. YOU ARE NOT A SPECIAL LITTLE SNOWFLAKE!!!

We are still finding out things about WWII that the Government hid or lied about. THAT IS THE WAY OF THE WORLD. Accept it and grow The F. Up.

The one question that I've never heard asked, and I may just have missed this one, but I don't think so. I think it will have to be asked AFTER Obama has left office for a few years is this;

WHY? Why did you say that IF you knew it wasn't a riot and you knew it was an attack?

I think he'll say that based on the accumulation of evidence that they had at the time, that it was ASSUMED that it was a riot based on that stupid video. That that information changed rapidly, but by the time the reality of the situation was known... KNOWN, not suspected, it didn't really make a difference. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

You know what the best part about this "unclassified testimony" is, Jacobsen?

It's declassified testimony. It's on the Armed Services Committee website. Granted, it's a Republican website, but no Democrat website would dare post it.

THE PRESIDENT, and no other politician is obliged to tell you the truth about ANYTHING.

They may not have to tell us classified information, but they need not lie. If you are going to volunteer information, it should be the truth. And yes, we should be able to expect the truth. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

The Armed Services Committee website is NOT a republican website. It is an AMERICAN Website.

IF you bother to care about FACTS, you'll note that it's divided, almost, but not quite evenly between Pubs and Dems.

ASC

but they need not lie. If you are going to volunteer information, it should be the truth.

What's it like to live in this fantasy world of yours? Hmmm?

I'm told that you're really John Lynch, and I believe it. The ignorance shows.

And NO, the testimony that Fox is talking about is NOT out there. They're liars, but the fact that THEY are liars doesn't bother you. That's called hypocrisy. 

zapper007 --- 12 years ago -

I am truly beginning to see the fruit of this post.

Carry on sheeple - and THANKS Ogre... 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

The Armed Services Committee website is NOT a republican website. It is an AMERICAN Website.

"About the Armed Services Committee

Thank you for visiting the website for the Republicans on the House Armed Services Committee."

http://armedservices.house.gov/index.cfm/about

Doesn't that show your ignorance about this topic?

I'm told that you're really John Lynch, and I believe it. The ignorance shows.

Maybe it shows your ignorance to believe things that aren't true just because you are told. You don't hold a candle to John, as shown by your uninformed and unintelligent posts.

Just face it. Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton and Susan Rice are liars. If you believe them, have fun being a sheeple. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Are you completely brain dead?

YES; http://armedservices.house.gov/index.cfm/about
IS the website for the REPUBLICANS on the ASC.

http://armedservices.house.gov/index.cfm/members
IS THE LIST OF MEMBERS FOR THE ENTIRE ASC. You'll NOTE that there are only FOUR more Republicans on the committee than Democrats. THIS is because of the structure of the House right now.

BUT to say the ASC is a Republican committee is WRONG.

John, you're not fooling anyone.

As to politicians... ALL POLITICIANS ARE LIARS. Grow up. 

Red Heifer --- 12 years ago -

This is like when Giuliani kept invoking 9/11 and Palin would always fall back on "support the troops". Yes, Benghazi was a mess. Just like similar events under GWB's administration. But come on, already, Benghazi is not the answer to everything you don't like. 

jacobson --- 12 years ago -

http://armedservices.house.gov/index.cfm/members
IS THE LIST OF MEMBERS FOR THE ENTIRE ASC.


I guess you don't understand what the website is. The list includes the names of all the members of the Armed Services Committee; however, the website is for the Republican members of that committee. 

Dorothy Parker --- 12 years ago -

Alright!!! John is double-dipping....sweet! 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

however, the website is for the Republican members of that committee.

Wrong. You're so stuck on your neo-con dogma, it's kinda pathetic.

The ASC is a JOINT Committee in the House. It is NOT a REPUBLICAN or DEMOCRATIC committee, it is a JOINT committee.

So get over yourself. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Of course, I do see what you're trying to claim. Because some lame web designer (probably some Congressperson's nephew or an intern) put something on their "about" page you think that it's overarching over the entire committee. In this case, the "about" page isn't really an "about" page. Bad web design does NOT establish policy. And you are ignoring WHAT the ASC really is to prove some point or another that is quite irrelevant.

YOU are trying to claim that the ASC is a REPUBLICAN committee, when in fact it simply is NOT.

The ASC is a JOINT standing committee within the House of Representatives. It is NEITHER Republican nor Democrat, but IS dominated by the current majority party (which ever one that may be). In fact from 2007-2011 it was controlled by Democrats with Ike Skelton as its chief.

Of course, this is a MINOR point of the discussion, one that has no bearing on the actual meat of the discussion which is that you don't know how to do research or even think clearly about complex topics without being told by some pundit what to think. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground