Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Politician Pay and Allowances.

who's talking here?

wayward1 5
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
Ogre13 10
Beachbum 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

I'm going to start some trouble.

I've been thinking about how the politicians are always cutting social services, shutting down the governments, cutting military pay and benefits, and yet, they never suggest that they themselves take a pay cut.

So I've developed something, and I want input on it: it will never pass, it's just an idea - maybe something for my manifesto should ever get around to growing a long straggly beard and buying a shack in some remote place and writing one.

It is a new structure for paying our politicians, and it's still rough.

Here we are, let's call it;

Presidential and Congressional Fair Pay Adjustment Act

Congress keeps speaking about cutting costs, how about we cut costs from two of the most contentious and least effective branches of government? The Executive and Legislative Branches.

Tie their pay to performance.

The President currently earns $400,000.00 a year during his term in office.

A U.S. Senator earns between $174,000.00 and $230,700.00 per year.

A U.S. Congressman earns between $174,000.00 and $223,500.00.

This law would change the structure to a base salary + bonus + performance system.

Base salary for the executive branch would be the median income of the entire United States. As of Sept 2013, that would be $51,017.00 base salary. Now, there is a penalty involved here, and that is the unemployment rate, which at this time is 7% - the President LOSES that money. So $51,017 x .07= $3571.19. So the President’s base salary is $51,017.00 – 3571.19 = 47,445.81. He gets THAT no matter what.

That would leave a total of $348,983.00 as a potential bonus for the President to earn. Take the potential bonus, divide it by 12 = $29081.92. That is his monthly bonus potential. Take that number and multiply it by his approval rating - December was 49% - $29081.92 * .49 = $14250.14. THAT plus his base salary is his take home. I'm thinking that we should double tap them on unemployment as well so that getting AMERICANS jobs becomes a focus. Not doing the math, but you get the idea.

Do effectively the same thing with the legislature; only base it all on state stats.

This would of course need more details, but I do think you should get the idea.

Whatdoyathink? 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 12 years ago -

Whatdoyathink? 





I think no one with half a brain would sign up to do the job unless they were already filthy rich and that seems to be an excluding factor for many voters. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

I don't disagree. But there are still people attracted to the power that political office holds, thus you have Texas State Senators and Congressmen making....$7,200 per year I think it is... unless it's changed. 

Beachbum --- 12 years ago -

When have they ever cut social services? 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Well the house republicans passed a bill to cut food stamps in Sept. after rejecting a bill that would have cut $20bn from the program saying that it didn't cut deep enough.

They have recently cut Federal Work-Study programs by $51m. That was in Nov. Many students rely on those programs to get through college.

The Sequester cut everything...except of course their pay...across the board.

I can go on. 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

We don't need to cut pay, just cut the employee. We never seem to vote our Congressmen out. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Agree with that too, Wayward, but what about doing THIS as well? 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

It would tie politicians to metrics they are both not responsible for and can't easily manipulate. Congress doesn't control unemployment. And if they numbers are good and you reward Congress, you're giving them credit for it. Their job is to run the legislature. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Doesn't matter. It would refocus their attention on domestic job growth which they SEEM to want to constantly take credit for anyway(or alternatively blame the policies of the opposing party for unemployment). SO make it part of their performance 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

Hmmm. Congress is usually pushed up (from us the people) into legislation. Think lobbyists, special interest groups, etc. If you tie their pay to performance, you get Congress thinking up and passing laws for their OWN gain. Not driven by or in the best interest of, the people.
It would also force government more into business affairs, which may not be good for either side. Now picture a Senator on the foreign relations or intelligence committee trying to create some legislation to somehow boost business hiring. It would be forced. What they'd end up doing to trying to boost government hiring to alter the numbers because they could control that. Bigger government, more money, less unemployment. Give'em a big fat raise. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

BTW.. I'm pretty dead set on the unemployment metric because of their bragging/blaming about it.

But the other, we could make it as complex a metric as we want as long as it's something real and not just voodoo mathematics.

Popularity was just the first thing to come to mind as I was riding the bus into downtown today. And since right now at least, Congressional popularity is more about their behavior than about anything they've actually passed or not passed, I do think that judging them based on that is appropriate.

Frankly, I'm surprised Obama's popularity is as high as it is.

We'd probably have to find some independent research group to do the numbers, I'm not really talking about using popular figures from the press (although, one could use an aggregate of all the press polls I guess..dunno).

And the act would also make it a felony to fiddle with or have fiddled with the numbers....25-life in federal prison, loss of everything, etc, etc, etc. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

Bigger government, more money, less unemployment

That's easy to fix, make the numbers about PRIVATE business employment rates, you could even treat government employment rates as a negative in some way. That way you reward for creating policies that grow private business and punish for making government larger. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

you get Congress thinking up and passing laws for their OWN gain.


That's what the Supreme Court is for. That sort of thing has been tried before, as far back as John Marshall's court (I.e. Thomas Jefferson's administration) and the SCOTUS has generally fell on the side of the Constitution. 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

No politician will want to cut government spending if you tie their performance to a metriced unemployment number.
If you cut gov. spending it does one of two thing. You lay off public sector workers or you cut a contract with a business(s) that then must cut workers as a result of losing its government contract. Either way, people lose their jobs when the government tightens its belt. If you punish politicians for this, they'll go out of their way to make sure the government spending never gets cut. In fact, they'll grow the government and add jobs there to keep unemployment even lower. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

"No politician will want to cut government spending if you tie their performance to a metriced unemployment number."

it is a conundrum, but I do think that it could be worked out. Just details.

As I said above though, make growing the government a negative metric and that prevents them from doing so willy-nilly. Make creating policies that make PRIVATE job creation a positive metric rewarding so that the focus becomes more on retaining jobs at home.

I'm also specifically thinking of the banking bail out... we gave all that money to the banks, and what did they do? They horded it, they laid people off, they exported jobs overseas. Did they use it to create jobs here? Not so much.

Same with the car bailout, and the upcoming insurance bailout. (and possibly the student loan bailout when that bubble finally bursts). 

wayward1 --- 12 years ago -

When we gave money to banks, or airlines or auto manufactures, we did so primarily for them to stay alive and keep their workers employed. It makes people uncomfortable and is mostly only used for emergencies. I'm afraid your idea would promote giving money to business a lot more as a means of investment in hiring new workers, as Congress would be 100% now committed to lowering the unemployment rate. Congress would seek out businesses to invest in (with tax payer money) to help them retain workers and/or hire new ones. It would turn into a focus outside of their realm of both comfort and knowledge. 

Ogre13 --- 12 years ago -

"...and keep their workers employed."

We failed at that.

"...I'm afraid your idea would promote giving money to business a lot more as a means of investment in hiring new workers"

But that's just a detail, Wayward. What's the fix?

"Congress would seek out businesses to invest in (with tax payer money)"

no, not if they are not allowed to do so. Again, a detail. Plus don't they do that already with their sweetheart deals for their favorite government contractors (I.e. a $600m website that's rubbish)?

Remember, this was thought up in about ten minutes on a bus. Instead of giving me roadblocks, give me solutions.

This Congress and President ARE NOT EARNING THEIR MONEY. We need to have a way to make them do so. I'm no economist, I'm a historian with loads of legal training.

The goal here IS to turn their focus away from their own, and their special interests belly buttons to the people whose lives they are (mostly negatively) affecting and take into account THEIR needs and not just the needs of Big Business, the NRA and the AARP. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground