Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Water Heater: 40 Gallon vs tankless

who's talking here?

SleightOfHand 2
jtcitrus 5
Gigix4 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
sheddy 1
FabFive 1
Charli 1
kwgraniteguy 1
Edgar Po Wong 1
Not KU 1
MissPris 1
PinehurstMom 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Water Heater: 40 Gallon vs tankless

So, I need a new water heater that will run off of [b]propane[/b]. Should I go Tankless or 40 Gallon? What are the pros/cons I should consider beyond price differences (tankless is 50%+ more expensive. Thanks!

40 Gallon Vote
 
 33.3% (4)
Tankless Vote
 
 66.7% (8)
other Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

So, I need a new water heater that will run off of propane.

Should I go Tankless or 40 Gallon? What are the pros/cons I should consider beyond price differences (tankless is 50%+ more expensive.

Thanks! 

Edgar Po Wong --- 13 years ago -

Tankless is more efficient. 

FabFive --- 13 years ago -

Propane is super expensive now. Our hot water heater runs off propane but our next one will be tankless. It will pay for itself in the long run. 

Gigix4 --- 13 years ago -

If I ever have to replace mine, I'm considering a tankless to service my kitchen and laundry room, but regular gas tank for the rest of the house.

The water heater is on the complete opposite side of my kitchen and laundry room and during the winter, it takes forever to get hot water in those rooms.
JMO 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

With tankless, you will have to get a plumber to run a much larger gas supply line then add a larger exhaust tube through the roof. That alone can cost over $1000. There are as many cons regarding tankless as there are with tanks 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

My neighbor put in a tankless and it ended up costing a lot of money to move it and run lines. I have read that it never pays for itself unless you put it in a new home. 

MissPris --- 13 years ago -

As much as I wanted to go tankless, the ROI just isn't there. Placing them in older homes can mean a lot of demo depending on space issues. I agree with Sheddy, not cost effective or even Eco-neutral if installing them in an older home. 

Charli --- 13 years ago -

attics, Texas heat and tankless water heaters were not the best combination a couple of years ago. Texas heat was causing malfunctions with mother board censors...it was a big mess. Check to make sure those issues have been worked out. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

to clarify some points:

I have a small house with a 28" tall crawl space (I can sit up under it), I've run PEX tubing all under the house (Pipe going into the fixtures is copper).

Also, the existing natural gas water heater is in a little closet next to the kitchen.

So swapping it out wouldn't be a problem. and wouldn't cost much more than swapping out a 40 gal. 

kwgraniteguy --- 13 years ago -

Go Tankless, just know that all tankless are not created equal. Seems Bosche and Aquistar are better rated units.there are Some cheapies on the market that wont hold up. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 13 years ago -

Tankless and you can put it outside. We have one at out lake house it's been outside for 6 years with no problems. It's on the wall next to the Ac units and is not taking up space in the house. I had a taness put in my last house and My next house will be tankless too. 

Not KU --- 13 years ago -

MissPris --- 11 hours ago - quote - hide comments

As much as I wanted to go tankless, the ROI just isn't there. Placing them in older homes can mean a lot of demo depending on space issues. I agree with Sheddy, not cost effective or even Eco-neutral if installing them in an older home.


How old of a house is "older home"? Not to digress but my home was built in 2000. Would you say its "older"?

But I think tankless is a great way to go. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

How old of a house is "older home"? Not to digress but my home was built in 2000.

My house was built in 1930... 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

If you are going propane, I guess go tankless, it's just more expensive to install. Why not electric? 

PinehurstMom --- 13 years ago -

It may be beneficial to get advice from a plumber. I had read recently that the minerals and such that are in the local water can cause more problems for tankless systems. I don't know how true that is, but it might be worth researching. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

If you are going propane, I guess go tankless, it's just more expensive to install. Why not electric?

I'm taking a harder look at going electric.

[ahem... that's what she said :-/ ]

according to a couple of sources there's an efficiency deficit of ~15% on propane vs electric. Then I did some math...

propane costs about 10 cents per kW/h (in terms of BTU equivalents)
tack on the efficiency loss vs electric and all the savings are gone when compared to 11-12 cents per kW/h for electricity (for example).

so, there is little efficiency gain to be had. 

jtcitrus --- 13 years ago -

I had read recently that the minerals and such that are in the local water can cause more problems for tankless systems. I

I've read that too. that the systems are more maintenance. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground