Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Run Keeper or Polar

who's talking here?

lizandmike 3
movedagain 1
Tylers Journey 1
Jpgirl 4
Pauly G 1
Texashley 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

lizandmike --- 13 years ago -

Which one tracks calories more accurately? This morning, I got 2 very different readings and I don't know which one to trust. 

Pauly G --- 13 years ago -

I have a two chest strap monitors and watches and have the same problem with readings. I just average the calories and use the watch thats more user friendly. 

movedagain --- 13 years ago -

try loseit.com 

Jpgirl --- 13 years ago -

Neither are that accurate. They estimate calorie burn by heart rate which is about as accurate measuring inches with a mile marker.
My HR monitor is a Garmin and allows for gender,age,weight, height and max HR ( not 220-age) which makes it very slightly more accurate. If you have no way of knowing your Max HR or you Basal metabolism rate it's all just estimating.
You can do a search for BMR estimates on line and fill it out and it'll give you a good estimate of your BMR. Start there for caloric intake- if you lose more than 2lbs per week your BMR might be higher.
As far as what you burn in exercise...if your unit allows changing personal settings-age,weight, height , max HR and activity level then subtract 30% of the total calories burned from the total. If you can't adjust for personal settings then take 40% off of the total. Yep I told you it was inaccurate!! Most people underestimate the calories they eat and overestimate the calories they burn. Despite what the experts say- you really are not going to burn 1,000 cal/ hour doing cardio. Those claims are based on young very fit people! I run and/or ride ( road biking) and teach indoor cycling, lift weights and do yoga and on average I burn about 400 calories an hour ( despite that my Garmin says Im burning 600-700 calories. Getting old sucks 

lizandmike --- 13 years ago -

Both allow me to enter age, height, weight. The polar goes by hr. The run keeper app goes my distance covered and speed. It asks what activity you are doing also. I walked about 6 miles at a 12 min/mile pace this morning. My polar said I burned 500 calories. My run keeper said 1009!
I don't necessarily increase my caloric intake to offset calories burned with exercise, but if I burn enough today, I may have an adult beverage this evening :) 

Jpgirl --- 13 years ago -

Double post 

Jpgirl --- 13 years ago -

0undefined I don't know your statistics but I know for me the 500 cal would be more accurate. That's about my pace and calorie burn when I deduct the 30%.
Also the GPS on the app is notoriously inaccurate too. I have issues with my GPS app when I run the greenbelt. Dh said the trees interfere with the phone. I can run the same pace and on certain routes the phone app will be off from the Garmin.
You say you walked 6 miles- how long did it take you to complete that course and are you sure of the mileage? 

lizandmike --- 13 years ago -

I'm sure of the mileage. I double checked it with the car. It took about an hour and 15 minutes. I'm figuring the 500 is more reasonable. Would be nice if 1000 were accurate tho :). 

Texashley --- 13 years ago -

For about every mile you run you burn about 100 calories give or take based on BMR. 

Tylers Journey --- 13 years ago -

I use the polar H7 and the machines at the gym and my phone are almost the same. 

Jpgirl --- 13 years ago -

Regaurdless of what HRM you use you need to understand that calorie burn based on heart rate is grossly inaccurate. To get the most accurate caloric intake and expenditure you need to see an exercise specialist who can administer a VO2 max test and a test for BMR. Last time I checked a VO2 max test was about 200.00. Since I'm not an elite athlete I choose to deduct 30% off of my total caloric expenditure for exercise. I've nailed down the BMR fairly well with hit and miss trials. Trial and error works for me- I just know not to live and die by the numbers especially when it comes to exercise 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground