Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Contractors with criminal record

who's talking here?

sunshine1881 1
I Kissed Frogs 1
Rubicon 1
FANCY PANTS 1
Laurabeth 1
tinman 7
mom2dx 1
idontplaynice 2
itstxdaddy 4
SagaciousSighFiGurl 2
Its Mygirl01 2
sheddy 1
kwgraniteguy 3
MoreToLife 1
Just stuck 1
Emperor of Kingwood 1
Smoochie and The Bean 1
CherokeeChick 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

idontplaynice --- 13 years ago -

Do you do background checks when you hire a contractor for remodeling? 

CherokeeChick --- 13 years ago -

I would .. You can't trust anyone these days .. and sometimes background checks aren't enough. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Haven't hired one but I would pay to get a good thorough one done...not that expensive and worth every dime. Way too many horror stories... 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

As a contractor, if someone wanted to run a background check on me as a condition of working for them, I would politely decline.

My references and standing with the BBB should be good enough. My personal background is really none of anyone's business.

Also, as a contractor, I can tell you that whomever you choose to work on your house is taking just as big a risk as you are.

Anyone who has ever been a contractor can tell you five hours worth of stories about being under paid or completely stiffed.

Would you, as a homeowner, be willing to have your background checked as well as your credit? I mean, you're asking that contractor to take a chance on you but you don't want to take a chance on him?

I know as a homeowner I wouldn't want a contractor digging into my background anymore than a contractor wants a homeowner digging into his personal background.

As a homeowner, you should expect the contractor to begin work without a down payment and you as a homeowner should be willing to agree on a draw schedule based on time and percentage completed.

Good reputable contractors have credit accounts and don't need your down payment in order to purchase materials to begin.

This arrangement protects both parties equally. 

Rubicon --- 13 years ago -

Interesting perspective, tinman.

I've never done a background check on a contractor or have been asked for one by a contractor. 

mom2dx --- 13 years ago -

It never crossed my mind to do a background check on a contractor but I do always run their names through the list of registered sex offenders and Google to see if anything comes up. 

Smoochie and The Bean --- 13 years ago -

No, seems a bit extreme to me 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I know as a homeowner I wouldn't want a contractor digging into my background anymore than a contractor wants a homeowner digging into his personal background.


I completely disagree. Have you applied for a regular job lately? They give you a colonoscopy...credit check-even tho it has zero to do with your job, SS#, work background, education, personal and professional references, and Face Book/Twitter, you name it. It's the American way for them to thoroughly turn you inside out...I don't see how or why contractors should be any different. You have to give them access to your greatest asset, your home, and the industry is ripe with scam artists..

If someone objected to a thorough check, I'd cross him off the list. Just as any legit candidate for a job has to submit to the employment background process, so should the contractors. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

If someone objected to a thorough check, I'd cross him off the list. Just as any legit candidate for a job has to submit to the employment background process, so should the contractors.


You certainly have the right to ask, but you're also going to find out that the ones worth hiring are the ones that are going to tell you which side of the road to jump off on.

I really fail to see the correlation between hiring a contractor to do work on your home and having to submit to a background check as a matter of employment.

If you know going in that you have to have a background check, then you decide whether or not you would like to apply for the job.

I suppose that if a homeowner told me up front that a background check was going to be required as a condition of them signing a contract, then I could see that as being equitable. I still would say no. But at least I would be saying no before I committed my time and resources in showing up for the walk through and the time spent preparing the estimate. All of those things cost money too.

I can't stress enough how big a leap of faith it is for a contractor to begin a job for a stranger. I understand that the road goes in both directions, but, there still is a matter of faith in any transaction your enter. Be it used cars, home contracting, or basic repair services. 

kwgraniteguy --- 13 years ago -

As a contractor, ditto what Tinman said. 

MoreToLife --- 13 years ago -

It might insult some good contractors but the con artist are out there. Out of all the services I have had done at any of my homes, hiring a contractor is by far my least favorite.

If you hire a contractor, google his name, if he is bad it will show up. No need for a background check.

Also a contractor can lie about where he lives. At least if a homeowner doesn't pay you, they aren't hard to find. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

Also a contractor can lie about where he lives. At least if a homeowner doesn't pay you, they aren't hard to find.



An old mentor of mine once told me that there is always going to be a gap between reality and expectation.

Homeowners are always going to have a vision about what the job should look like and the contractor's opinion is always going to be grounded in reality.

So, if a homeowner doesn't pay, what are my options? A lien on the house? That works until you try to foreclose. How about a lawsuit? That works too. But usually, the lawsuit costs more to pursue than the debt is worth. Again, with both of those options, you are still left with a debt owed to you and a long road ahead to collection.

Having said that, the contract is what governs that transaction. When properly constructed, the contract protects each of the parties from each other, and also allows for a more open discussion of how the job should be performed and what should and should not be included.

If it makes you feel better, then by all means, you should google the guy in question. But remember this. Unless you are absolutely sure that the info you have been given is genuine, then you really have no way of knowing if the google search is yielding good info or false info.

Any contractor who is out to take your money and disappear is also going to be able to plant false info so as to keep prospective clients off of his trail. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 13 years ago -

I learned just this month that just because contractors have a good record with BBB that means absolutely nothing. I hired a contractor from my insurance companies "Premier Service Providers" list and the company has an A rating with BBB. I prepaid my deductible and the difference for the work I wanted done. They were horrible and after having them redo stuff 3 times I had to fire them. It wasn't me being picky; it was them subcontracting the job out to a guy that had no clue what he was doing. The insurance adjuster had to come out and view the work before I could fire him and he agreed it was the worse work he had ever seen and that I would have a leak in my shower along with it being a major mold problem with how they built it plus the electrical they did could have caused a problem. Unfortunately the contractor kept my down payment and claim they did that much work even though I had to have it ripped out and redone. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

It wasn't me being picky; it was them subcontracting the job out to a guy that had no clue what he was doing.


I certainly sympathize with your situation. Not knowing both sides of the story puts me at a disadvantage.

However, I can tell you this. If you had written language into your contract that stipulated that no subs would be used except for the major MEP work, then you would have avoided this mess in the first place.

I'm not trying to win this argument, I am trying to illuminate what home owners can do to protect themselves.

Instead of spending two or three hours trying to dig up dirt on the prospective general contractor, try spending that time educating yourself on how to write the contract, what questions you should ask your contractor and what you should normally expect out the experience.

Those pieces of information will do more to protect you that any info you can get off of the internet concerning anyone's background. 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

wow.

tinman...your strong aversion to agree to a background check has made me decide that if i do need a contractor, i will have one done.

what's the issue? i had to have one to be hired for my job, what is the problem with having one done on a contractor who is in your home, around your family, etc...to do their job?

the reward far outweighs the risks in this situation. any contractor not willing to agree to the background check would appear to have something worth hiding.

the BBB rating is completely worthless these days.

writing a proper contract doesn't protect someone's family or belongings from being compromised. 

Laurabeth --- 13 years ago -

Sorry.....I'm all for background checks! If you are going to be in my home and around my family....yes a back ground check for criminal history is in the works....sorry, but just my honest opinion. I would not want to hire a convicted thief or rapist or other sort to be in my home.

And a contractor would be just as welcome to conducct a criminal background check on me if they wish before coming into my home! 

Just stuck --- 13 years ago -

^^^^^^^ ditto what Laurabeth said! Unfortunately Tinman the bad people out there in your line of work makes everyone suspicious of hiring reputable contractors. Yes there are some, but lately it seems the scammers out number the good.
People get on here to tell their horror stories, but most people don't give credit where credit is due. 

Emperor of Kingwood --- 13 years ago -

It would depend on the nature of the charge, and length of time since last conviction. For example, I could care less if someone had a pot charge 10 years ago. 

sunshine1881 --- 13 years ago -

I'm surprised most contractors don't provide the background check information on request.

When I was helping my ex-father-in-law run his painting/home repair business, we kept print outs of the Public Data background checks on him and anyone who was working with him in a file that he carried in the van. On more than one occasion people asked about background checks when he went to do bids, and he was always happy to show them the printouts. No problem. We did background checks on anyone we hired to work with him, so why not just print them and have them available? 

Its Mygirl01 --- 13 years ago -

If someone has access to the inside of my home, where I would have to be here alone with them (and have my dog put up for thier safety) then yes I'd like to know if they have a violent criminal past or are sexual predator. If they are working on the outside and never would be alone with me then it really doesn't matter, my Rigdeback and my 9mm are suffient to keep me safe in my home. 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

I think they are a good idea. I have never thought to ask for one, but these people come into your home, usually when you are not there, and are around your family. I think if I asked for one and the contractor refused, I would think there was a reason they said no. 

kwgraniteguy --- 13 years ago -

While y'all make some valid reasons for wanting to perform a back ground check I as the checkee am curious as to what info would be needed. Am I putting myself at risk of identity theft? I am not opposed to the check as much as I am about providing personal details. My record is clean so no worries from that aspect. 

idontplaynice --- 13 years ago -

I know a contractor (guy with crew) who has three counts of marijuana possession (not a deal killer IMO), and one count of 2nd degree burglary in his past.

As a homeowner, wouldn't you want to know that, or is it irrelevant as long as he does good work? 

FANCY PANTS --- 13 years ago -

As a contractor, if someone wanted to run a background check on me as a condition of working for them, I would politely decline.

If I needed a contractor and He did not want to have a background check as a condition of working for me, I would know he was hiding someone. If someone is going to work for me in my home I would have to know that he could be trusted. That person must have something to hide. It is no different than hiring a maid, nanny, yard man, or butler. Wouldn't you want a background check on anyone that was going to be in and around your home. 

kwgraniteguy --- 13 years ago -

If I needed a contractor and He did not want to have a background check as a condition of working for me, I would know he was hiding someone.

I assume you mean something and not someone, lol. In my case, NO, I have nothing to hide, not so much as a speeding ticket since 1996. Again my concern is providing personal data for a short term job, not a company I might work for for 30 years. I understand your concerns of bringing an unknown into your home but what data is needed for a background check? If it does not involve info that could be used for credit fraud then ok, if not I'll pass I have worked to hard for my score. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

I really do get that folks are interested in wanting as much info about who they have into their homes as possible.

In fact, if you can find someone who is willing to do that, then I say that's a very smart thing to do.

I'm just saying that I would not be willing to do that.

Will each of you be doing a background check on the a/c guy that comes to fix your a/c?

How about the plumber? Yard guys?

You see, the person who owns the company that is working at your home has a responsibility, in my opinion, to perform background checks on all of the employees that will be coming to your home. I think that should be enough.

I also think that the info on the guys working at your home should be made available, at a certain level, to prospective clients prior to going to work in their homes.

I am not interested in you, as a homeowner, knowing about my personal past. It's just not relevant, in my opinion, to what ever business transaction we are proposing to conduct.

Having said that, I can certainly see where home owners are looking for a certain level of security when dealing with strangers.

While this situation is tricky, I can't help but think it's also very easy to circumvent if I am a contractor.

This topic, along with many, many, many others is precisely why I decided to go to the commercial side of construction and get away from residential. When there is a set of plans and specs to work from, the chances of misunderstandings is reduced greatly.

Only one other contractor has responded to this thread and he, in principle, has agreed with my stance. I really can't help but think that other contractors will feel the same.

So, I'll ask this question again. If I, as a residential contractor, am asked to submit to a background check, would you, as the homeowner, be willing to submit to the same check in terms of credit worthiness and pay history? 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

You see, the person who owns the company that is working at your home has a responsibility, in my opinion, to perform background checks on all of the employees that will be coming to your home. I think that should be enough.

if one of my children gets hurt, stalked, etc...his "responsibility" doesn't matter. i am more interested in preventive maintenance, not reactive. once something has happened, you cannot take it back. again, reward far outweighs the risk.

When there is a set of plans and specs to work from, the chances of misunderstandings is reduced greatly.

do you really think we are talking about some contractual misunderstanding? i want to know if the person in my home around my children has ever been in any kind of trouble whereby they have acted inappropriately with any child. i want to know if i have agreed to allow someone in my home that could put my children or family at risk. you can never know all, but i believe a background check, at the very least, can give me information i can use.

If I, as a residential contractor, am asked to submit to a background check, would you, as the homeowner, be willing to submit to the same check in terms of credit worthiness and pay history?

why wouldn't I? i have to submit to a credit check to get hired, get a credit card, a car, a house...no big deal, but if that is a prerequisite, you as the contractor are paying for it, just as i am paying for the background check. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

why wouldn't I? i have to submit to a credit check to get hired, get a credit card, a car, a house...no big deal, but if that is a prerequisite, you as the contractor are paying for it, just as i am paying for the background check.


Then you would be someone I would have loved to worked for.

The point I was trying to make is that the contractor is taking chances working for you just as you are taking chances having him into your home.

If I were still in that business, I would definitely have every person working for me submit to a background check. You can never be too careful.

But, if the homeowner is not willing to be as transparent as he/she is asking me to be, well, that road goes in both directions.

I understand that the contractors lurking over this thread are going to be very hesitant to wade in on it. I would be too. 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

The point I was trying to make is that the contractor is taking chances working for you just as you are taking chances having him into your home.

the chances the contractor takes is not getting paid and maybe some other ancillary chance.

the chances a homeowner takes by allowing a stranger in their home, could be molestation/rape/kidnap of a child or family member, theft, etc...you can't "unmolest" someone. once it's done, it's done.

i think the homeowner is taking the bigger "risk".

to wade in on it.

the water is a bit chilly...lol. 

Its Mygirl01 --- 13 years ago -

I think of Elizabeth Smart when allowing a stranger around my family! Her family hired a man to do work around the home and he came back to their home broke in, kidnapped thier 14 year old daughter then "married" her so he could continually rape her and kept her hostage for 9 months! That is the reason we need background checks because this could happen to any family!!

If I were a contractor I'd consider having a yearly background check preformed on myself to share with copies made available to potential clients if requested. That way no personal (identy theft potential) would be handed over. 

itstxdaddy --- 13 years ago -

If I were a contractor I'd consider having a yearly background check preformed on myself to share with copies made available to potential clients if requested. That way no personal (identy theft potential) would be handed over.

i think this is a great idea. as long as the copany performing the check was reputable...i would gladly accept that. 

tinman --- 13 years ago -

I would be very interested in finding out if anyone was successful in getting a residential remodeler to submit to a background check.

As is all items pertaining to threads on here, all I am giving is my opinion backed up by what I know I would do in a given situation.

I know that I would not submit to a background check as a condition of entering into a contract with a prospective client.

However, back in the day, I was vehemently opposed to seat belts and any other form of control over my actions.

I learned over the years that sometimes being made to do something is a way to save yourself from yourself. This topic could very well fall under that category. Thankfully, I will never have to find out if that's the direction that the industry is going in.

But if it did go in that direction and I had to decide whether or not I wanted to "toe the line", then I would probably agree to "toe the line".

I'm not too stubborn to admit when I need to change. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground