Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Bible is Pro Choice?

who's talking here?

JohnLynch 8
RedMulch 5
☼ 11
Himura Hitokiri 1
a4130692uu 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

☼ --- 13 years ago -

Just wondering, because God seems to be all about the parent choosing whether or not the child should live.
Citing Abraham choosing whether or not to sacrifice his son, Solomon overseeing the near tearing in half of a baby, and Jesus - all are examples of a parent getting a choice in the life or death of their child, with death usually being considered the moral option, better for everyone involved.
So why is it that people get upset about abortion, and give it a religious spin? 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

Just wondering, because God seems to be all about the parent choosing whether or not the child should live.

your characterization is incorrect 

RedMulch --- 13 years ago -

Yes, Abraham did not want to kill his son...........this was a test of his faith. And in the end.....his son was spared. Your post is so far removed from abortion it is laughable.

As for the tearing in half of a baby....that was the indisputable love of a Mother.....for her child.

try again 

☼ --- 13 years ago -

John- is it, though? There is no specific phrasing that would say otherwise.

Redmulch- He didn't want to, correct. But it was his choice, was it not? As for the baby, it is presented as a Mother's choice to hold on or let it go. Again, a choice.

So since it's always presented as the parent's choice, does that not make the Bible "Pro Choice" by definition? 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

John- is it, though?

yep...

So since it's always presented as the parent's choice, does that not make the Bible "Pro Choice" by definition? 

God does give everyone a choice...it's called free will...but God does want us to CHOOSE CORRECTLY...and abortion isn't choosing correctly

btw...abortion isn't pro-choice...there is no choice for the baby...it's murder...

the use of the term pro-choice by abortion lovers is their attempt to soften the implication as to what is really taking place 

RedMulch --- 13 years ago -

Redmulch- He didn't want to, correct. But it was his choice, was it not? As for the baby, it is presented as a Mother's choice to hold on or let it go. Again, a choice.

It was not his choice. God told him to do it.............this is a hard thing to understand about God.....but have you ever made a hard choice..?......and he decided to put his faith in God althought it brought him great grief........but in the end, his faith was proven to God.....and he sent a Lamb to be sacrifice in the son't place........much like he did for us many many years later......this stuff is so thrilling......I am hoping you are understanding........
and yes, actually, the mother chose to let her baby live rather than have him killed.......the love of a real mother......it was her choice.......

both choices.......to choose a God, and to chose a child......to willingly give them up so they can live.......

Do I see a pattern here? 

☼ --- 13 years ago -

I'm not sure that Isaac was really given much say in the matter, either.

If a mother truly believed that what she was doing was in both her best interest, or the best interest of her child, is that not free will? Is there a Bible verse that says otherwise? Obviously the commandment prohibiting murder, but I'm struggling to find a passage that prohibits the parent choosing to end the life of the child. I can find all kinds of passages that describes a man's right to treat his chattel goods as he sees fit, and in modern society does that right not extend to the female head of household as well?

I'm legitimately curious, because there seems to be all sorts of Biblical precedence beyond what I've brought up here.

Those are mostly all your opinions, John. That you know the character of God well enough to judge my characterization is laughable on the face of it, doubly so with no scriptural backing provided by you. 

a4130692uu --- 13 years ago -

so, let me get this straight, Parents should have the choice to kill, but children should not have the choice to live? Keeping in mind, your references are all to living breathing children, not the unborn, it sounds like you are looking for some justification for the murder of the born rather than the unborn and trying to cloak it in some sort of abortion argument? Try again. 

☼ --- 13 years ago -

Redmulch - That really isn't a pattern, per se. Abraham chose God's will over his child. The mother chose her child over the will of her King (and God). Both are still solid examples of the Bible giving explicit control of a child's life to a parent.

(It's also interesting to note that God deanded the sacrifice of a lamb, a juvenile sheep. What was sacrificed was a RAM, noticed by Abraham to be caught by it's horns in a tangle. A Ram with horns has progressed on past the juvenile state, and so was not technically what God ordered.) 

RedMulch --- 13 years ago -

I'm legitimately curious, because there seems to be all sorts of Biblical precedence beyond what I've brought up here.

You need to start a Bible study. and i think you won't find a mention of abortion in the Bible clearly, cause it didn't exist then. You are pregnant, you give birth.....that's it.....and it was me, not John, that said the comparison was laughable....... 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

Those are mostly all your opinions, John.

and you are incorrect

That you know the character of God well enough to judge my characterization is laughable on the face of it, doubly so with no scriptural backing provided by you. 

and again...you are incorrect

If a mother truly believed that what she was doing was in both her best interest, or the best interest of her child, is that not free will?

yep...it is free will...but free will doesn't necessarily constitute CORRECT CHOICE

Obviously the commandment prohibiting murder, but I'm struggling to find a passage that prohibits the parent choosing to end the life of the child.

it's called the sixth commandment

also...you should look at Genesis 9:6...

"Whoso sheddeth man's blood, by man shall his blood be shed: for in the image of God made he man."

you also need to look at Exodus 21:22-23...

"If men strive, and hurt a woman with child, so that her fruit depart from her, and yet no mischief follow: he shall be surely punished, according as the woman's husband will lay upon him; and he shall pay as the judges determine. And if any mischief follow, then thou shalt give life for life,"

CLEARLY SHOWS THE PENALTY FOR AN ABORTED PREGNANCY 

☼ --- 13 years ago -

Parents should have the choice to kill, but children should not have the choice to live?

"“Oh, rebellious children…who carry out a plan, but not mine; who make an alliance, but against my will, adding sin to sin” (Is. 30:1)."
I fail to understand how could Scripture get any clearer than that regarding the wishes of the child.

Redmulch - There are several examples of children not being carried to term.

Ex 21:22-25:
"If men strive, and hurt a woman with child, so that her fruit depart from her, and yet no mischief follow: he shall be surely punished according as the woman's husband will lay upon him; and he shall pay as the judges determine."

So if a woman's fruit departs from her, and no "mischief" has been done, and the father is ok with it, the bible seems to be ok with it being a parent's choice. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

Ex 21:22-25:

how deceitful not to include verse 23...and 24 or 25

I fail to understand how could Scripture get any clearer than that regarding the wishes of the child.

lol...the "children" are the people of Israel...to young children

please use Scripture in context 

☼ --- 13 years ago -

John - CLEARLY SHOWS THE PENALTY FOR AN ABORTED PREGNANCY 

The penalty IS clear: whatever the woman's husband deems fit. 

a4130692uu --- 13 years ago -

You should really stop bastardizing the Scriptures while you're ahead, you only make yourself look foolish when you do. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

The penalty IS clear: whatever the woman's husband deems fit. 

nope...God determined the penalty..."And if any mischief follow, then thou shalt give life for life" 

☼ --- 13 years ago -

You should really stop bastardizing the Scriptures

Please, inform me as to how he shall be surely punished according as the woman's husband will lay upon him is in any way a paraphrase?

Shows very clearly that the parent's are in control of the punishment for abortion. If they deem that no punishment is necessary, how is this a violation of scripture?

Please keep answers civil, I am honestly seeking civil discourse. I'm not trying to inflame anyone's delicate sensibilities, only providing scriptural basis for the question originally posed. 

☼ --- 13 years ago -

John - And who exactly determines if mischief has occurred?

he shall be surely punished according as the woman's husband will
Looks to me as though the parents get to choose whether or not any mischief has taken place. 

a4130692uu --- 13 years ago -

Nothing in that scripture refers to the voluntary killing of the unborn by the mother of the unborn. You are taking scripture completely out of context to try and fit your argument. That is not civil discourse, that is deceitful obfuscation. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

Please, inform me as to how he shall be surely punished according as the woman's husband will lay upon him is in any way a paraphrase?

that is ONLY if no death occurs

Shows very clearly that the parent's are in control of the punishment for abortion.

nope...it doesn't...it shows it is the parent's choice if the live delivery is early...mischief indicates DEATH

John - And who exactly determines if mischief has occurred?

pretty easy to recognize the death of a baby 

Himura Hitokiri --- 13 years ago -

JL and his ilk = 0 

☼ --- 13 years ago -

John - that is ONLY if no death occurs
nope...it doesn't...it shows it is the parent's choice if the live delivery is early...mischief indicates DEATH


Also John, from previous post you also need to look at Exodus 21:22-23...

"If men strive, and hurt a woman with child, so that her fruit depart from her, and yet no mischief follow: he shall be surely punished, according as the woman's husband will lay upon him; and he shall pay as the judges determine. And if any mischief follow, then thou shalt give life for life,"


It seems to me that the eye for an eye part of this refers to the husband, not the abortionist. The first part clealy states that the punishment for loss of the fruit of the womb is determined by the husband, not contesting that. But the second mention of mischief relates to death caused by the husband's punishment.

Per scripture, it is only mischief if the husband deems it so, and if he does, he should not seek to harm the wrongdoer, because that causes further problems. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

It seems to me that the eye for an eye part of this refers to the husband, not the abortionist.

lol...your reading comprehension needs some work 

RedMulch --- 13 years ago -

lol...your reading comprehension needs some work

their life comprehension needs some work as well........ 

☼ --- 13 years ago -

I think it's doing just fine, but I'll try and simplify my point for you.

"...so that her fruit depart from her, and yet no mischief follow...

Please tell me how that part right there is not indirectly stating that an action by a man that causes loss of child is not itself "mischief". The loss of the child is just stated as a stand alone condition, with no morality attached to it. It is up to the husband to determine if any punishment is due - if the actions causing that loss are to be punished. If he does, the wrongdoer shall "...shall pay as the judges determine...".

Your argument seems to be based on your personal assessment that abortion is morally wrong. I understand your opinion. The Bible seems to have a "Pro Choice" stance on the matter, and so please do not bring any counter that is born of your personal opinion. I'm all for hearing any other (rational) debate or counter examples. 

JohnLynch --- 13 years ago -

Please tell me how that part right there is not indirectly stating that an action by a man that causes loss of child is not itself "mischief".

are you serious?...her fruit departing from her isn't indicating death...because no mischief was the result

It is up to the husband to determine if any punishment is due - if the actions causing that loss are to be punished.

it is obvious that you need to reread the Scripture passage...

"What, then, is the passage teaching? Simply this. If two fighting men injure a pregnant woman, causing her to give premature birth, yet no harm follows – to either mother or child – a fine will be levied as a penalty for such carelessness. However, if any harm followed, to mother or babe, justice was to be meted out commensurate with degree of damage. Both the mother and unborn child had equal protection under the law."

The Bible seems to have a "Pro Choice" stance on the matter,

it only seems that way to you because you are either intentionally perverting what the Scriptures say...or you are confused as to what you are reading 

RedMulch --- 13 years ago -

We will just leave this thread and let you think you have won. Not a problem.......it's obvious you don't know the Bible....and I just don't have the time...

Love you and will pray for you......... 

☼ --- 13 years ago -

John -If two fighting men injure a pregnant woman, causing her to give premature birth, yet no harm follows – to either mother or child

You cannot be serious. Wherever you quoted that from obviously has some research to do. It's the last bit that caused me to aspirate some coffee- no harm follows to the child?

You seem to be arguing my point. No harm comes to the child by being aborted?

Please, do think before you post total nonsense. A little is fine, you're just wrong, but that level belies a true and stunning level of ignorance. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children
politics
polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground