Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Do you agree with Tom Brokaw?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 3
SoupIsGoodFood 2
SleightOfHand 1
sheddy 1
CitizenOnPatrol 1
OL AG 89 3
JAMS 2
BiteMe 2
Sandman 1
PhonicSimilarityIsNOTOffensive 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Do you agree with Tom Brokaw?

NBC’s Tom Brokaw said Thursday it’s “far-reaching” to think the American people need guns to fight back against the government. Brokaw said on MSNBC’s “Andrea Mitchell Reports” that one of the main arguments pro-gun advocates cite — that the Second Amendment is meant to protect against a tyrannical government — is pretty outlandish. He said he agrees with retired Army Gen. Stanley McChrystal who supports “serious action” to curb gun violence and said military-grade weaponry doesn’t belong in civilian hands. “The response to that was, ‘I have to keep my weapon because the government’s going to come and try to take it away from me, and I have to be able to fight back when that happens,’” Brokaw said. “Well that’s the most far-reaching thing you can possibly imagine.” He continued, “If we get to a stage where storm troopers show up on your doorstep, it’s about a lot more guns, by the way, it’s anarchy in this country.”

Yes I agree Vote
 
 33.3% (14)
No He is wrong Vote
 
 7.1% (3)
Typical Liberal ignorance Vote
 
 57.1% (24)
Stopping Gun violence is more important than worring about tyrannical government Vote
 
 2.4% (1)
PhonicSimilarityIsNOTOffensive --- 13 years ago -

NBC’s Tom Brokaw said Thursday it’s “far-reaching” to think the American people need guns to fight back against the government.

Brokaw said on MSNBC’s “Andrea Mitchell Reports” that one of the main arguments pro-gun advocates cite — that the Second Amendment is meant to protect against a tyrannical government — is pretty outlandish.

He said he agrees with retired Army Gen. Stanley McChrystal who supports “serious action” to curb gun violence and said military-grade weaponry doesn’t belong in civilian hands.

“The response to that was, ‘I have to keep my weapon because the government’s going to come and try to take it away from me, and I have to be able to fight back when that happens,’” Brokaw said. “Well that’s the most far-reaching thing you can possibly imagine.”

He continued, “If we get to a stage where storm troopers show up on your doorstep, it’s about a lot more guns, by the way, it’s anarchy in this country.” 

sheddy --- 13 years ago -

Maybe those storm troopers will be afraid to show up at our doors if we still have our guns! 

whatchamacallit --- 13 years ago -

We need a shotgun behind every tree! It is our job to protect ourselves!

I REALLY disagree with Brokaw, as usual! He is a tool. We need to protect ourselves from criminals, a government gone into hyperdrive AND what about China? What do you think they plan to do when we can't pay them back all those billions? A possible invasion would certainly be easier if we are unarmed. Maybe that's the real Obama plan.

Remember WWII? "You cannot invade the mainland United States. There would be a rifle behind every blade of grass." is a quote by Isoroku Yamamoto, Commander-in-Chief of the Imperial Japanese Navy during World War II. Of course it was originally stated in Japanese, this is the English translation.


It is in our collective best interest to remain an armed militia. 

BiteMe --- 13 years ago -

Serious question, you don't think the government is a little bit better equipped for war than the average citizen? I think we'd lose either way. 

whatchamacallit --- 13 years ago -

Serious question, you don't think the government is a little bit better equipped for war than the average citizen? I think we'd lose either way.


Better to go out with a bang than a wimper. At least we could get rid of a some of them along the way. Beside, just how many of those military men would actually shoot on their own? We would have more equipment and operators than you think. 

CitizenOnPatrol --- 13 years ago -

I think we'd lose either way.

So what is going to protect you from a tyrannical government then??

You are just sitting back hoping it will never happen?

That doesn't seem smart to me.

Serious question, you don't think the government is a little bit better equipped for war than the average citizen?

We've been through this numerous times. The government is a bit better equipped for war than radical islamists like the taliban, but they haven't beat them yet.

On another note... semi-automatic rifles aren't exactly "military-grade"....

It's not "far-reaching" to believe that a tyrannical government could take hold and try to kill you or take your weapons away.... Uh.... Syria anyone?? North Korea??

Some folks are just ignorant; it happens every day in other countries. It CAN happen here. 

Sandman --- 13 years ago -

OK, I will admit that when it comes to politics, I probably have not educated myself as well as others. I think it is fair to say though that most people have no problem with the second amendment and a U.S. citizen having the right to bear arms and protect themselves. I think the real problem is the ease in which guns can be bought and the type of weapons that are so easily available to the public. I don't think that you should need a semi automatic rifle with a clip that can wipe out a small village to protect your home. If you're in the military and on the battle front day in and day out, that is one thing, but a weapon for home protection is another. Whatchamacallit, do you really think that we live in the same world today that we lived in during WWII? My bet is that China has already found ways to kick our butts when it comes to technology advancements and economic warfare more so than wanting to invade our land. It scares me to think that my kids walk the same streets as you because you sound like someone just looking for a reason to become a household name. 

PhonicSimilarityIsNOTOffensive --- 13 years ago -

So what is going to protect you from a tyrannical government then??

They will never answer this question... At least I have yet to hear an answer, they will only repeat, in a mocking tone, how a citizen army could never hope to defeat the regular army.. blah, blah, smart bombs, blah, attack helicopters, blah, tanks...... 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Sometimes I wonder if any of you have interesting lives, hobbies outside of guns and fearful paranoia, or if you ever do anything outside of the house to better your community and the people in it. I'm sure I know the answer though...

Carry on. 

whatchamacallit --- 13 years ago -

[i]Whatchamacallit, do you really think that we live in the same world today that we lived in during WWII? My bet is that China has already found ways to kick our butts when it comes to technology advancements and economic warfare more so than wanting to invade our land. It scares me to think that my kids walk the same streets as you because you sound like someone just looking for a reason to become a household name.


HOLY COW!!!!! I AM A TERRORIST! lol

The world is not so different than it was in WWII. People still want to control other people and it is still easier to control those that are unarmed. China is so over populated that our country must look very inviting to them. Remember, we are talking about people that are so over populated that they can only have one child and all others are forced to be aborted?!?!? Fear me if you must but I am the least of your worries. 

BiteMe --- 13 years ago -

Just wanted to know yall's opinions on that. Thanks for those who didn't give a a-hole answer! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

Until someone can define what "military grade" and "assault weapon" are, then you're just blowing talking points out your back end.

I've had an discussion on FB about this with one generally ignorant liberal gun grabber who claims WalMart sells "automatic military grade" weapons. When challenged to prove it, he did as most of you gun grabbers here on KU do. Flee the argument. 

OL AG 89 --- 13 years ago -

JAMS --- 3 hours ago - quote - hide comments
Sometimes I wonder if any of you have interesting lives, hobbies outside of guns and fearful paranoia, or if you ever do anything outside of the house to better your community and the people in it. I'm sure I know the answer though...

Carry on. 

Jams,
Realizing your just aTROLL IS THE FIRST INTERESTING THING I DID THIS EVENING.
Oh and then I got my XDs out and cleaned it after shooting this weekend, then I went out into the shop and did a little lite welding on my old car....
Of course I had my XDs on my hip in case someone tried to sneak up on me...... 

SleightOfHand --- 13 years ago -

"Sometimes I wonder if any of you have interesting lives, hobbies outside of guns and fearful paranoia, or if you ever do anything outside of the house to better your community and the people in it. I'm sure I know the answer though...

Carry on."

____________
What do you do for our community? Nothing most likely.... carry on (Sacking groceries at HEB does not count) 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

I don't do anything for your community Sleight.

I'd never be caught in the slums of Kingwood.

;) 

OL AG 89 --- 13 years ago -

To each his own.....
The "slums" of kingwood are what you make them. But be careful you may get run over by one of the Lamborghini's or Maserati's while visiting the lower east side. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 13 years ago -

I smell tommy boudreaux. 

OL AG 89 --- 13 years ago -

So back to the original question.
I think Brokaw is a TOOL, he no longer reports the news without bias or opinion interjected into almost all of his stories. I realize he probably doesn't write his on air stories, but as a true journalist, I would expect him to at least maintain allegiance to his profession.

But then I read the following...

Tom Brokaw dropped out of The University of Iowa, where he says he majored in "beer and co-eds" before receiving his B.A. degree in Political Science from the University of South Dakota in Vermillion in 1964.[7] 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground