Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Teachers carrying guns

who's talking here?

lizandmike 2
d:-] 1
Tylers Journey 1
Rubicon 1
hummer 1
reh6110 1
Red Heifer 3
Polly Ester 4
SleightOfHand 2
AngieKaye 18
yeahsowhat 1
RiteWingKing 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
Mago4058 1
LiveFreeOrDie 7
Clovis 1
Dorothy Parker 10
SagaciousSighFiGurl 4
Defcon1 7
FabFive 1
scipsekatattes 4
Lets Be Fair 14
kwgraniteguy 1
OL AG 89 5
kinz 1
Ezekiel 23 20 5
JAMS 2
Emperor of Kingwood 1
Trekk 3
DrRuth 1
khsbro 21

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

khsbro --- 13 years ago -

I can see the reasoning in this, but imagine, a police officer is called to school which is reporting a intruder situation, he gets in there and sees two adults pointing guns at each other, which do you pursue? not to mention that another weapon in this situation add the risk of a missed shot or ricocheted bullet with tons of kids around. 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

Also think of it this way.

If criminals knew that teachers could be armed dont you think they would think twice before going on a shooting rampage? 

Ezekiel 23 20 --- 13 years ago -

We'd be better off with sky-Marshall types at schools -- plain clothes and skilled at taking down aggressors in close quarters without collateral damage.

If security is important, it should be someone's full time job. Teachers should focus on teaching.
I'd rather have teachers focus on teaching, and 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

No, they wouldn't think twice.

Armed guards were at Columbine, and Eric and Dylan didn't let that stop them.

Granted, the arm guard did help prevent more deaths as he engaged the shooters, but 12 children still died, despite that armed guard. 

JAMS --- 13 years ago -

Khsbro,

Same mentality where GI Joes are convinced they could accurately shoot someone in a dark, smoky theater with total panic and chaos.

It's ridiculous to think that way. 

Ezekiel 23 20 --- 13 years ago -

Armed guards were at Columbine, and Eric and Dylan didn't let that stop them.



Weren't the Columbine armed guards in the parking lot trying to catch kids smoking?

Youll never get 100% security -- look what happened at Fort Hood.

The school marshals would focus only security. Nobody knows who they are so they could be anywhere. 

Ezekiel 23 20 --- 13 years ago -


Same mentality where GI Joes are convinced they could accurately shoot someone in a dark, smoky theater with total panic and chaos.


Wrong. Protecting your family doesn't make you Dirty Harry or GI Joe. 

khsbro --- 13 years ago -

If criminals knew that teachers could be armed dont you think they would think twice before going on a shooting rampage? 
no, people are stupid, people still rob banks when they know tons of video cameras are watching them. and having armed teachers would take a while to be involved in some situations. 

Ezekiel 23 20 --- 13 years ago -

Think of the worst teacher your kid has (thru the process of elimination, one of them will be the worst). Now think of that teacher armed with a loaded weapon. 

reh6110 --- 13 years ago -

As a teacher, I would rather not have a gun in my classroom. Instead of having one student making a plan and bringing a gun to school, you are giving 100s of students easy and near immediate access to dozens of guns. Say a student gets mad at their teacher one day, there would be a gun right there in the classroom for easy access. Many middle and high schoolers (and even some elementary 5th graders) could easily over power their teachers to obtain a weapon if they really wanted to. 

khsbro --- 13 years ago -

reh6110,

exactly!! 

Ezekiel 23 20 --- 13 years ago -


reh6110,

exactly!! 



Ditto! 

AngieKaye --- 13 years ago -

I would feel more at easy knowing my children would be protected if need be. We aren't talkin about the suicidal people that go on shooting rampages and take out as many as they can before they are taken out by suicide by cop. We are talking about criminals with guns that they either stole or what ever.

Maybe least arm the Prinipals and Office since they are first to see most coming into a school if the school locks down like they are supposed to. 

Mago4058 --- 13 years ago -

I agree with Reh, plus when I teach I am all over the room. I wouldn't be able to get to. Fast enough, I'd have to have it on me....and well in elementary that's not a genius idea since kiddos like to hug or etc. the real issues needs to be more funding to mental health etc type things then giving teachers a gun.... 

hummer --- 13 years ago -

In some ways it would make sense.
But, I'd be worried about how the teacher could secure the gun properly all day long. Loaded and ready to lay down their own life.
Other worries, Police responding and mistaking wrong shooter.
Teachers need to teach.
Maybe more training on how teachers respond to this threat. Procedure on how to slow down or minimize threat.
Safety room where they could flee.
Air type Marshall's would be good, but campus would still need to know who they are. Campus police would need to know.
This will cost LOTS of money. So, who is going to pay for it? More money out of classroom! 

Tylers Journey --- 13 years ago -

You don't have to step foot on school grounds to take a crap load of kids out. All you would have to do is pull up when all of them are on lunch break and get them on the playground. You could pull away before the police even show up. 

OL AG 89 --- 13 years ago -

When done right the teachers with guns is an excellent idea at this point. You all have suggested that everyone will know who has the weapons in the school, but that is not how this plan is being deployed.
A group of teachers throughout the school have access to a weapon, that is locked up until required. I do not imagine the teachers are walking through the hall packing .357 Magnums for all to see.
I think with the evolution of the plan, you will see a "sky Marshall" type development for this.

Let's look at another scenario. Everyone has been to Deerbrook in the past several months, did you notice all the additional security they have? OF course you didn't, because the guy walking beside you looks just like anybody else in the mall, but he's an undercover officer working loss prevention. 

scipsekatattes --- 13 years ago -

I think teachers should carry guns at the schools but only after extensive training. I don't think just taking a CHL is good enough in this scenario. There are hundreds of children to think about and they should be fully trained in how to handle that situation in mock trials of it at practice camps made up especially for teachers! Once they have been schooled, practiced enough and are prepared to conduct a safe defense for the children should an attack occur...then IMHO teachers having guns on them or close by to their "own" access is as good an idea as an officer standing duty. I believe they should also have the officers at every school too....that pace the halls and stand guard at doors when all the others are locked tight. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Horrible idea.

Trained armed security...yes. Teachers packing...no way. 

OL AG 89 --- 13 years ago -

DP......

FAIL!!!

You realize how many teachers in the Humble ISD are veterans?
Maybe those are the teachers who ALREADY have EXTENSIVE weapons training that are asked first.

I agree that you would just hand a new CHL holder the responsibility of protecting anybody. The CHL is not a weapons training course, it is a "rule of law" course.
The teachers also KNOW THE KIDS, armed guard may float from one school to another throughout the year, not really getting to know the kids they are protecting. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Armed security is there for just that...armed security. A teacher is there to teach and nurture children...not to be an armed guard. They have so much responsibility on them already and now we want them to have a loaded weapon to be responsible for too??


Please read the two teachers' posts on this thread who said they do NOT want to carry. Are they a "FAIL" too? 

scipsekatattes --- 13 years ago -

Armed security is there for just that...armed security. A teacher is there to teach and nurture children...not to be an armed guard. They have so much responsibility on them already and now we want them to have a loaded weapon to be responsible for too??


Please read the two teachers' posts on this thread who said they do NOT want to carry. Are they a "FAIL" too? 


It's not like an occurrence happens every day at every school...it's rare, more common in last years but still rare. A teacher 'carrying' is no different than a civilian carrying IF they are trained properly on how to use the firearm if in an attack situation especially with children all around them. There can be extensive training and that would be a 'good' idea yes. I agree that teachers have no good reason to be armed while teaching in the school unless they are fully trained for any situation that may occur and in that case they could save lives. I would much prefer to know my children (when they were school age) were in a classroom with a TRAINED and experienced armed teacher that could probably save their lives in the event some moron walked in with a gun to shoot them...of course. Anything can happen...he could shoot the teacher before she could get to her firearm...sure...BUT she/he could also have the firearm prepared once notice of an intruder in the school if there were one that would save the lives of the kids in their classroom too. There are so many scenarios to consider, but bottom line, at the end of the day, if they are prepared to take on an attacker with their weapon, it could save more lives than it could possibly take! 

Polly Ester --- 13 years ago -

so will teachers carry to the playground, the cafeteria, the bathroom breaks, the reading circle, etc? I think it is unrealistic thinking that a teacher could be the first line of defense just because she/he is armed. training teachers on how to handle the crisis just like the video someone posted on here a few days ago and leave the armed part to a guard or marshall makes more sense to me. my teacher friends are not comfortable adding this extra responsibility to their already long list of expertise they need to have. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

As REH pointed out in her post, the risks are huge and most teachers would not want that added responsibility. As a parent with school aged children, I do not want guns in the classroom. It's just an accident/tragedy waiting to happen.

Trained armed guards with protection and security being their only focus...yes. I would support that measure. 

scipsekatattes --- 13 years ago -

Well, I guess people just have to agree to disagree on this topic. When I taught school (was a sub but full time for years), had there been the instances there are today in the schools...I would have felt more comfortable being fully trained and armed knowing that I could protect my kids should something happen. Some teachers, heck some people in general just don't like even holding a gun, much less carrying it on them or having to use it, even for practice.

Again, if trained properly, comfortable with using it or an emergency situation where they could save lives then "those" teachers should have the choice to carry.

Of course there will always or should always be the parents right to choose if they want their child to be taught by a teacher carrying a weapon...this is true and if that were the case, there would be a lot of confusion and special efforts made that would be costly and cause a lot of difficulty placing students with teachers.

All in all, in "reality", even though I think teachers should carry, because there are DP's and Hissy's and other mothers and parents in the world that would feel uncomfortable with it....yes I guess I would have to say that AS LONG AS the provide 'enough' armed security or police per school to make it safe as possible...then let the teachers teach without being armed...yes. 

OL AG 89 --- 13 years ago -

From reh,

As a teacher, I would rather not have a gun in my classroom.

THEN YOU aren't who would be asked to provide the additional protection now required in our schools.

I am NOT suggesting all of the teachers are walking around packing pistols!
I am suggesting strategically placed "armories" in the school accessible to only a SELECT few, HIGHLY trained individuals that could be utilized as a last resort if the school is attacked.
If you understand modern holsters, you would also understand they are not your grandfathers "shoot out at o.k. Corral" leather pockets.
Some are even biometric lock capable, so no chance of loss of weapon if the wearer is overpowered. 

DrRuth --- 13 years ago -

Here lately we find teachers are criminal’s too...who says they would use the gun in a correct way. Let’s face it these teachers that are having sex with students are not adults I trust making a decision about safety! 

Rubicon --- 13 years ago -

I am suggesting strategically placed "armories" in the school accessible to only a SELECT few, HIGHLY trained individuals that could be utilized as a last resort if the school is attacked.


That makes more sense. I know not every teacher is going to want to carry a gun. No one should be forced to carry if they are not comfortable. 

Lets Be Fair --- 13 years ago -

It's interesting that the people who know absolutely nothing about guns are the experts here. When was the last time you experts shot a gun? 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

What happens if a disturbed student or group of students, gains access to the armory? Or what if a teacher was careless and a disturbed student got their gun?

Can you imagine the outrage when something like that happens and people are killed? What if a teacher freaks out and kills an innocent student?

Again, the risks of having teachers and staff armed, outweigh any benefits, imo.

If guns must be at the school...it should be by trained security only. 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Double post 

Trekk --- 13 years ago -

If guns must be at the school...it should be by trained security only.

Agreed ... 

Red Heifer --- 13 years ago -

Also think of it this way.

If criminals knew that teachers could be armed dont you think they would think twice before going on a shooting rampage?



These are really sick people who don't care if other people have guns and might actually prefer it that way. They are there on an irrational killing spree and expect to die. 

Lets Be Fair --- 13 years ago -

Dorothy, there are a lot of "What it's " in your post. Consider these and how frequently they happen:
What if a student gets prescription medicine out of a teacher's purse and takes it.
What if a student gets a nail file out of a teacher's purse and stabs another student.
What if a student gets a teacher's car keys and decides to drive it and gets in an accident. 

scipsekatattes --- 13 years ago -

Dorothy, there are a lot of "What it's " in your post. Consider these and how frequently they happen:
What if a student gets prescription medicine out of a teacher's purse and takes it.
What if a student gets a nail file out of a teacher's purse and stabs another student.
What if a student gets a teacher's car keys and decides to drive it and gets in an accident. 


Actually that did happen remember? A 5th grade student stole a teachers keys and he was already leaving the parking lot when she discovered it! 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Your "what if's" aren't even close to what a gun could do, and look silly by comparison.

Trained police officers struggle with shooting people and we want to put that kind of stress on our teachers?? Why? 

Lets Be Fair --- 13 years ago -

Dorothy, you look silly talking about gun safety and how incompetent and irresponsible teachers are. When was the last time you shot a gun? 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 13 years ago -

Trained police officers struggle with shooting people and we want to put that kind of stress on our teachers?? Why?


No one is trying to "put" it on anyone. Why do you guys keep twisting it that way??

We want it to be an option for those teachers who want to and qualify through extensive training. Why do you have a problem with that? 

Dorothy Parker --- 13 years ago -

Reh IS A TEACHER...read her post.

The kind of teacher who would want to be armed in a classroom full of children, is exactly the type who should never be armed. The George Zimmermans amongst us. No thanks. 

Lets Be Fair --- 13 years ago -

Sorry Dorothy, you are not an expert in this area so you have no credibility. Again, when was the last time you shot a gun? 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground