Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Why should the rich pay a higher income tax than others?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 4
JDB2 3
ladybeachbum 1
SoupIsGoodFood 2
AngieKaye 3
Hiro Protagonist 6
Warren Peace 4
jtcitrus 1
Mark 1
JohnLynch 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
u uic 2
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
CrazyDiamond 3
justforfun1 4
Nightshade 1
sheddy 1
CitizenOnPatrol 3
kwgraniteguy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

whatchamacallit --- 14 years ago -

If someone has a lot of money and is considered rich WHY should they pay higher taxes than those who have less?

If the money was earned thru smart business practices, inherited, lottery winner, just lucky, whatever, why should these people be penalized? I see no reason, as long as the money was made honestly, and no laws were broken, good for them!

It seems like those with less have a bad case of jealousy and simply want the rich to have to pay for their success by giving the less wealthy part of what is rightfully theirs.

The fairest thing to do is a flat tax, unless the income tax system was abolished and we collected taxes on purchases instead.

Please esplain why you think the rich should pay higher tax rate than you?

Not the lame reason that is often used, that they have more and it is easier on them to pay than on the less fortunate. A real reason that has to do with what is fair and right and not based in greed for others money and aimed at punishing those with more than you. 

ladybeachbum --- 14 years ago -

They shouldn't or it should be their choice to do so if they feel the desire. Most contribute with charities which is giving away some of their money. If I were rich, I'd want the choice to help the ones ready to help themselves. I don't like paying taxes that just helps people stay in the system. There's jobs if someone wants to work but if they have never held a job maybe not. 

CitizenOnPatrol --- 14 years ago -

Please esplain why you think the rich should pay higher tax rate than you?

The argument is because "they have a better ability to pay", but I don't see that as that great of an argument anymore. They DO believe that is fair and right.

See, that's what's funny about "fairness" and what's "morally right"; it's different for everyone.

All we have ever known is the "progressive" tax system where those with more money pay higher rates; so many kids grow up just gobbling the stuff up and not questioning whether it is really fair that nearly half the population pays nothing for income tax.

Everyone should have to pay something, even if it is 1% of your income. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Please esplain why you think the rich should pay higher tax rate than you?


That's the system we have now, in theory, right? We have a graduated percentage system based on income levels. So, theoretically the wealthy DO pay more currently...enter in tax loopholes, off shore accounts and other things. Then their tax liability goes way down, because IT CAN.

The only fair system is a flat or consumption tax, everybody pays the same amount, that is what is FAIR. No loopholes and no different standards or exemptions. It's not fair now, and we all know it. The middle class is towing the line b/c the poor pay nothing and the uber wealthy gots them some tax attorneys and accountants. And even tho the highest percentage of the top tier earners pay a good portion of the overall burden, it's still a flawed system. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

Everyone should have to pay something, even if it is 1% of your income.




I do too. Look at it this way, if you give a kid everything they want, they grow up never appreciating what they have. If they work and pay for it the opposite is true. 

kwgraniteguy --- 14 years ago -

Please esplain why you think the rich should pay higher tax rate than you?

This concept eludes me. In theory we pay taxes for the government to provide services and such. Do the wealthy get better services from the goverment?

Until recently I did not fully understand the concept of "tax credits", I assumed they were used to reduce the tax liability up, or down as the case may be to zero. Wrong, tax credits can take you not only below owing zero but actually increaseing your refund to more than you paid in. And income levels are exactly poverty levels in some cases. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

Why should the rich pay a higher income tax than others?

Because they have the money perhaps? Seems pretty simple to me. Quick math question for you, what is 20% of zero? 

CitizenOnPatrol --- 14 years ago -

Quick math question for you, what is 20% of zero?

Obviously if you have no income you can't pay income taxes Randle; no one here is talking about someone with no income.

Come on now.. 

u uic --- 14 years ago -

Leave it to randy not to see things clearly.

Nobody on this earth has ever been hired by a poor person.

Billionaires make millionaires
millionaires make thousandaires
Thousandaires make hundredaires


If your good at what you do you may become rich. Maybe then you will see your misguided thoughts. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

Obviously if you have no income you can't pay income taxes Randle; no one here is talking about someone with no income.

Come on now.. 



The point is the same. If you have hardly anything, a percentage of that is hardly anything, not to mention the fact that we have a consumer based economy. Poor people basically spend 100% of their income. Any money you take from someone that doesn't have much to spend, is less money that gets into the economy. If you have a lot of money your extra funds end up in savings, or investments, not infusing the economy with cash. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

Billionaires make millionaires
millionaires make thousandaires
Thousandaires make hundredaires



Yeah, too bad it's only their children. 

sheddy --- 14 years ago -

I like a flat tax or a consumption tax, but I realize that it is hard for someone who makes 20,000 to have to pay 10% of their income toward any kind of tax. I do think when you pay your fair share you appreciate what you get. 

CitizenOnPatrol --- 14 years ago -

The only fair system is a flat or consumption tax, everybody pays the same amount, that is what is FAIR.

Well, certainly no one could argue that it would not be EQUAL. Of course, for many people equality is fairness, and I think there's an argument for the flat tax being fair.


The point is the same.

No it's not. Someone who has no income can't pay income taxes. Someone who has income can pay income taxes; even if it's a little bit like 1%.

If you have a lot of money your extra funds end up in savings, or investments, not infusing the economy with cash.

Sorry; it's not your right to tell someone else what to do with their money. If someone else is saving or investing their money instead of infusing the economy with cash like you would want doesn't mean it should be taken from them.

If you have hardly anything, a percentage of that is hardly anything

Even if you took 100% of all of the "rich" people's money it wouldn't be "hardly anything" when compared to the amount of debt.

You could take all of the rich people's money for years on end and still not dent the debt.

Any money you take from someone... is less money that gets into the economy.

Any money you take from poor people -- or rich people -- is less money that gets into the economy and goes to the government.

Everyone with income should pay something; even if it's a symbolic 1%. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

You could take all of the rich people's money for years on end and still not dent the debt.


So true. The government cannot get enough money to pay the debt they have caused. The more they take the more they want. 

whatchamacallit --- 14 years ago -

Why should the rich pay a higher income tax than others?

Because they have the money perhaps? Seems pretty simple to me. Quick math question for you, what is 20% of zero?




I guess you forgot, we are talking about reasons the rich should pay hugher tax, that DO NOT have to do with jealousy or greediness on the part of those collecting and receiving the beneifit of said revenue. What gives you or me the right to benefit from anothers work or luck or inheritance? Not a darn thing! It is theft by coercion.
After all the rich, must pay or go to jail or lose their belongings. The tax man and our government has become nothing more than a well dressed thug stealing our money to do with as they wish. The rich get hit even harder because they are lucky enough to have more.
Is it less wrong to steal from someone that has lots of money than it is to steal from someone that is poor? NO, it is stealing, regardless of who you take it from, so I ask you again, why should the rich pay higher taxes than YOU? 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

You have a gov't that needs money. If you're smart you take some money from those that can afford to give it. The other option is you could just have all the poor be indentured servants or serfs like a feudal society. Oh, the good ole days!!!! 

u uic --- 14 years ago -

Randy you're always wrong. If I get poor enough I don't pay any taxes. If I can convince the right people I can get SSI. I am disabled I need to dip in the pot. 

whatchamacallit --- 14 years ago -

You have a gov't that needs money. If you're smart you take some money from those that can afford to give it. The other option is you could just have all the poor be indentured servants or serfs like a feudal society. Oh, the good ole days!!!!



So, we penalize the smart, productive part of society, the ones with the most disposable income and then whine when they move their factories away from here to save on taxes or when they use lawyers and accountants to keep from paying even more?

Really, it all boils down to the government acting as an enforcer, taking money from everyone, but more from those with the biggest pile. Now you know they are SUPPOSED to do things for the good of ALL with that money, but they don't.

So, so much of it is mis-handled and embezeled that only a small percentage is even left to do the things that government says they do.

It would be better to just give them the minimum, just enough to keep up infrastructure and the minimum in NECESSITIES. They have not proven to be good stewards of our money. Why would anyone want them to have even more to piss off?

So, again, I ask you, why should the rich pay higher taxes than the rest of us? Remember, no jealousy or greed can be involved in your motivation in your answer. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -


So, we penalize the smart, productive part of society,


1) It's not a penalty, they live here too. They benefit from the gov't as much as anyone else.

2) Taxes don't make co's leave. The effective corporate tax rate is about 27% which is basically on par with any other country. Co's leave for cheaper labor and benefit cost.

3) As I've stated before, increasing taxes on those that don't have much expendable income does not make sense. It just takes their money out of the system, since normally they would be spending it, not stockpiling it. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

Did anyone here really not have an idea of how this thread would turn out?

Doesn't this same question get asked on here everyday in one form or another.

Someone please post the pic of the person beating the dead horse. 

Warren Peace --- 14 years ago -

You have a gov't that needs money. If you're smart you take some money from those that can afford to give it. The other option is you could just have all the poor be indentured servants or serfs like a feudal society. Oh, the good ole days!!!! 

Do you have any concerns for what happens when you have the majority of the voting population living off the fruits of a minority rich who can always have their wealth voted away from them by those making less? In such a circumstance, who is it that's the real indentured servant?

0

As you can see, we're darn close to having the majority of the population receiving a government check of other people's money. Is that a good thing? Do you think it bodes well for our future? 

whatchamacallit --- 14 years ago -

1) It's not a penalty, they live here too. They benefit from the gov't as much as anyone else.

My point exactly! Why should they pay more for the same things you and I use
and haveaccess to at a much lower cost to us?

2) Taxes don't make co's leave. The effective corporate tax rate is about 27% which is basically on par with any other country. Co's leave for cheaper labor and benefit cost.

Not true, taxes figure into EVERYTHING any business owner does, including the bottom line of his business. Income taxes may, not but what about all the taxes they pay in property tax, and a billion other ways the government has come up with over the years to try to justify their creeping theft?

3) As I've stated before, increasing taxes on those that don't have much expendable income does not make sense. It just takes their money out of the system, since normally they would be spending it, not stockpiling it.

We are talking about higher taxes on the rich, nothing said about taxation of the poor, just what justifies higher taxation of the rich?

As for taking the poors money out of the system, that is just silly, taxes collected from them would spend just as well as money collected from someone rich? I agree that it would hurt a poor person more financially to pay 5% of their income in taxes than it would a rich man. The things is though that the poor will get more from the government too.

Rich people don't use many of the things that government supplies for the poor so really shouldn't the poor be paying more for the government services they use or receive than a person that NEVER has or NEVER will use or benefit from them?

On the other hand, when a rich guy drives down the street, it doesn't wear out the road any quicker than when a poor man does. So many other examples but you get the idea!

There really is no justifcation for higher taxation for the rich other than that they have more for the government to steal and misuse and pretend to redistribute to the poor. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 14 years ago -

As you can see, we're darn close to having the majority of the population receiving a government check of other people's money. Is that a good thing? Do you think it bodes well for our future? 


You know that number is BS. That number is including S.S. benefits, which is a large artificial inflation. They paid into it their entire lives. 

Warren Peace --- 14 years ago -

Randle,

One of the mistakes wealth confiscation advocates like you tend to make is you embrace the fallacy that confiscating other people's wealth results in increased revenues.

The reality is it only changes the investment behavior of those with wealth. Are you really willing to accept the unintended but utterly predictable consequences of advertising an intention to take more of a specific source of other people's money? The most successful way to take it is to not advertise the intention or source in advance and simply take it by force. Are you advocating that or do you want to advertise the intention and targeted source? 

Warren Peace --- 14 years ago -

You know that number is BS. That number is including S.S. benefits, which is a large artificial inflation. They paid into it their entire lives. 

It's not b.s. It does include social security. Most of what they paid their entire lives went to people who are now deceased. They paid for other people. It's the only legal ponzi scheme, right?

Social security epitimizes the concept of confiscatory wealth transfers. No one can opt out. It's obligatory that you pay for other people, regardless of how they lived their lives or squandered their earnings (if any). 

AngieKaye --- 14 years ago -

The rich pay more because "they didn't build their fortune the government did" So therefore the government wants their cut of the profit.

I feel we all are equal least last time I read the constitution it says. But because so many under the income of 200k get refunds because of children or what ever they have to get the money somewhere. This is why we all pay the "medicaid" tax on our income now. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

If you're smart you take some money from those that can afford to give it.

This is all part of the "Who's ox is getting gored" theory.

Taking money from the rich doesn't affect Randle, therefore he's all for fleecing the rich.

If he were the one getting fleeced, I'd bet he'd have a different opinion. 

AngieKaye --- 14 years ago -

we have been paying into SS and Medicare all our working lives. IRS is just keeping up with what our government spends!

Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) tax ( /ˈfaɪkə/) is a United States Federal payroll (or employment) tax[1] imposed on both employees and employers to fund Social Security and Medicare[2] —federal programs that provide benefits for retirees, the disabled, and children of deceased workers. Social Security benefits include old-age, survivors, and disability insurance (OASDI); Medicare provides hospital insurance benefits for the elderly. The amount that one pays in payroll taxes throughout one's working career is associated indirectly with the social security benefits annuity that one receives as a retiree.[citation needed] This has caused some to claim that the payroll tax is not a tax because its collection is tied to a benefit.[3] The United States Supreme Court decided in Flemming v. Nestor (1960) that no one has an accrued property right to benefits from Social Security.

The Federal Insurance Contributions Act is currently codified at Title 26, Subtitle C, Chapter 21 of the United States Code
 

AngieKaye --- 14 years ago -

So as WIKI states above, we dont pay for SS under our IRS payments. We pay as we go to get what is considered a savings account of our own. What we pay in is then used to determine what we get when and if we can retire. I know I have been paying in since I as 15, never took the tax exempt.

The "fines" we pay to the IRS is because we dont have enough taken out when we get paid. If you claim married with 9 kids almost nothing is taken out and you spend what isn't yours. IF you file married and 0 kids then you will probably get a refund if you have dependants.. 

Warren Peace --- 14 years ago -

Has anyone else noticed that those preoccupied with wealth confiscation typically show little to no attention to wealth creation?

Weird, huh? [/sarcasm] 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

If you're smart you take some money from those that can afford to give it.

This is all part of the "Who's ox is getting gored" theory.

Taking money from the rich doesn't affect Randle, therefore he's all for fleecing the rich.

If he were the one getting fleeced, I'd bet he'd have a different opinion.





See that's just the thing. Randle and others that think the rich should carry the burden of the poor can at any time pay more to the government. No one is stopping them but do you see them offering to do that, No, I didn't think so? 

Mark --- 14 years ago -

This country is doomed. A greater majority of people, plus those in power giving it out, need to keep receiving the payouts or society will fall.

As long as we keep our heads in the sand and be good little subjects. We get to keep just enough for vacations, etc.... wait until Europe and Asia stop oil trade in dollars. 

justforfun1 --- 14 years ago -

Has anyone else noticed that those preoccupied with wealth confiscation typically show little to no attention to wealth creation?

Weird, huh? [/sarcasm]




Crazy huh? 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 14 years ago -

Weird, huh?

Nope. It fosters the "victim" mentality.

It's much easier to play the "victim" than it is to actually succeed. 

Nightshade --- 14 years ago -

"Percentage of US Population living in a household receiving some government benefit"


First we would need that to be defined further.

In general, our homestead exemptions would be deemed a government benefit that we are receiving.

Now do you understand why your % is so high? 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

In general, our homestead exemptions would be deemed a government benefit that we are receiving.

that's nonsense...the nonsense caused by liberal thinking

allowing a person to keep more of their own money isn't a government benefit 

CrazyDiamond --- 14 years ago -

You know, I would like to be aboard for this type of WELFARE...Conditionally...

Do you promise to work hard for your welfare? Do you think you should pay a lower percentage of your earnings, simply because you make less ?

The 10/20% tax rate should be across the board. Why should a poor guy get a break, because he chose a crappier profession ? I did, too. I still pay in, and despise where the tax$ goes, but I will not tell a crappier-job-having-guy that he may pay less. All the same.

I make less than $100K, or $250K (what the media called rich) and still believe that "the rich" should pay the same rate we do.

Fair is Fair.

Pick the damn rate. 10, 20, 26 ? Who cares, pick it, make it for everyone, and be DONE.

Oh, and please, Gobbermint, pretty please - stop spending money like a cr(ack)edit addict. The Gov't is outta control. Crack/Credit.

Do any of us, besides me, pay our credit cards up to date, and not spend 100's, if not 1000's of times of times the limit, with absolutely NO WAY WHATSOEVER of paying it it full?... I know that there are many of us out there. Who is with me, that always pays the bills, without crying foul ?

Yeah. Great times. I never defaulted on as so much as a light bill. They reward the morons, that signed a terrible mortgage. They bailed out all of the unsuccessful businesses, for failing. Nice way to set an example...

Where was our Bailout ? Where is our bailout for having good credit, being a class act citizen ? Where is the reward for the people that keep their crappy job ? Where is the bailout for the guy that pays his bills on time, every time ?

NO. Give... Keep giving, you bleating Sheep... 

CrazyDiamond --- 14 years ago -

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tcRYdVlGXNQ 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

As long as the government forces rules on businesses and the so called wealthy those same people will find ways around it.

Businesses are starting hire part time people and doing more job sharing to avoid having to pay health benefits.

Who's gonna get hurt the most, the people the government is trying to insure. 

JDB2 --- 14 years ago -

If you're smart you take some money from those that can afford to give it.

if you're smart, you have everyone participate and you create a system where there is incentive for hard work and incentive for taking care of your family. You don't create a system full of dependents.

btw, EVERYONE can afford to participate. You make it sound as if everyone would die if they had to provide for themselves...that way of thinking is why we have a government that needs money and why we have all of the dependent folks in the first place...you are creating the good ole days as you call them and your guys have created a slavery system. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground