Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

THE REAL TRUTH OF: THE WOMAN WHO STOOD UP TO JOE PATERNO

who's talking here?

JohnLynch 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

American Scapegoat: Joe Paterno - Part VI


Back in the mid-2000s, Paterno clashed with an administrator at Penn State, Director of Student Affairs Vicky Triponey.

She wanted control over football player discipline (student discipline was part of her job), and he wanted control over football player discipline (football player discipline was part of his job).

The ordeal reads like an escalating pissing match, with Paterno ultimately allegedly saying to Spanier - in an "I'll-take-my-ball-and-go-home" moment - either she goes, or I stop fundraising for the school.

This dispute became national news in November when the Sandusky scandal was exploding, The Wall Street Journal had obtained some emails (sound familiar?) of scathing, melodramatic rebukes of Paterno from Triponey, including one email to Spanier that said "please do something to stop this atrocious behavior before this team and an entire generation of Penn State students leave here believing that this is appropriate and acceptable behavior within a civil university community."

(link: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204443404577052073672561402.html)

Of course, this being open hunting season on Paterno, the Triponey conflict has been raised again, with some ignorant news sources acting like they are presenting this information for the first time.

A few things to keep in mind about this clash between Triponey and Paterno:

First, Triponey was a lightning rod for controversy due to her control-freak policy implementations at both Penn State and before that the University of Connecticut, in manners completely disconnected to football or student discipline. One Penn State-related website had even created "The Vicky Triponey Timeline of Terror," unrelated to her then-unreported dispute with Paterno (link: http://safeguardoldstate.org/the-vicky-triponey-timeline-of-terror/)

Second, Spanier clearly wanted the clash between Triponey and Paterno to happen, even caused it. Think about it: after nearly 40 years as head coach, Paterno suddenly is supposed to abdicate player discipline to someone he doesn't know, who just came to Penn State, and is disconnected from the football program? Spanier hired Triponey in 2003 knowing her background at UConn; he supported her actions vis-a-vis Paterno for a time; and the biggest clashes came after the 2004 season when Spanier had tried to strong-arm Paterno's resignation, or at least get Paterno to plan a retirement timeline. The team started winning again in the 2005 season, and after that Spanier appears to have stopped supporting Triponey, i.e. he gave up trying to get Paterno to retire. By 2007 Triponey was out at PSU.

Third, Triponey must have been ignorant or arrogant or stupid, or all three. In one email to Spanier in Sept. 2005 she wrote, "I do not support the way this man is running our football program.'' Um, whose football program, Dr. Triponey? It is a shockingly egocentric, unenlightened and undiplomatic comment. In sum, Triponey wasn't just someone trying to do her job who ran headlong into an obstinate, power-hungry old man. She had been set up, so to speak, by Spanier, and she was at least a little foolish and arrogant.

Fourth, there are two things about which all major college football coaches are in near constant conflict with school administrators: admission and eligibility.

Coaches of course want the best recruits they can get to matriculate at the school, i.e. they want the admissions department to let them in.

Every single major college football team - Stanford, Northwestern and Vanderbilt included - has lesser admission standards for football players than other applicants. (This of course doesn't mean all football players benefit from lowered admission standards, but many do.) It varies from school to school, but the coaches and admissions department everywhere clash over the admission of some recruits each year. It just doesn't make the news, with rare exception (Steve Spurrier famously blasted the University of Florida admissions department for denying a signed recruit in 2000 - he later apologized - and the player, defensive lineman Santonio Thomas, ended up at Miami.)

Coaches also want the players on the practice field and/or working out year-round, so keeping them academically eligible and also out of trouble is essential, too. And they want to discipline the players themselves, for many reasons, most relating to control: They want the player to know the punishment is coming directly from them, that their fate with the team and the severity of the punishment is controlled by the coach, and so forth.

(One local judge maintains Paterno never in any way meddled in the legal problems of his players: http://www.statecollege.com/mobile/news/columns/district-judge-never-once-any-sign-paterno-tampered-in-justice-system-988524/)

Coaches also want the punishment to be minimally destructive toward football, when possible, so they want a significant say in the form of punishment (which might explain why Paterno favored getting the entire team up early on Sunday mornings to clean the stadium, rather than, say, suspending several players for a couple of months). Not practicing and not playing is destructive. Practicing but not playing is a little less destructive to the team - the player stays "football ready" by practicing - and it still stings the player, because there are only 12 football games a year, and missing just a few of them is genuinely harsh punishment.

Regardless of all that, the purpose of publicizing the emails from the Triponey affair is of course to make Paterno look bad (has anybody read any stories recently about the legions of emails praising Paterno?) regarding player discipline, to look like a phony.

But 45 years of evidence, taken as a whole, tells the opposite story. Paterno was stricter than other coaches when it came to punishing his players for various transgressions. It's a fact that countless ex-PSU players - many who disliked Paterno, and many who liked him - have attested to hundreds of times over decades. It's part of the reason PSU football has been so successful academically.

Did Paterno cause Triponey's demise at Penn State? Almost certainly.

Could Paterno wield his clout forcefully? Yes.

Did Paterno have a reputation for using his power to fire people, or get them fired? No, he didn't. Just take a look at the incredible longevity of his staff. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

a statement was made..."I know Paterno has so much power that if he had wanted to get rid of someone, I would have been gone," one janitor told investigators. "Football runs this university."

nothing but supposition

"Did Paterno have a reputation for using his power to fire people, or get them fired? No, he didn't. Just take a look at the incredible longevity of his staff." 

page 1
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground