Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Changes expected after outrage over book selection

who's talking here?

planemom 1
Fan4LSU27 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 3
Work in Progress 10
JustLivin 1
Dorothy Parker 8
jd44555 1
PeopleRPeople 2
Semper 4
Insurrection 1
jenarenna 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Semper --- 14 years ago -

I had to give my kid special permission to read certain books in his Advanced English Class because of the subject matter and "language".

It's my understanding that the main character in the book has CP and believes that his father would like to euthanize him.

Not sure that I would ban my kid from reading it. He's watched: Braveheart, Passion of the Christ, Saving Private Ryan, documentaries on crystal meth, illegal immigrant children hopping trains to come to America as well as children migrant workers. He's also read novels about Vietnam, WWII, bullying, etc. Everything that we permit is meant to provoke thoughtful discussion and discourse about the world past, present and future. If I have a major concern about subject matter, I will read the material first. 

jenarenna --- 14 years ago -

“Is a seventh-grader capable of reading a book like this and not being disturbed?"

This does not seem like the best question to ask when determining if a book is age appropriate. The creatures in "Where the Wild Things Are" could potentially disturb a 5 year old child, but this book is generally accepted as appropriate for children. By the time a child is in seventh grade they should be regularly exposed to a wide variety of concepts, some of which may be "disturbing" and some which may not be. What will disturb one person may not disturb another, and it is only through exposure to different topics that children can gain a better understanding of the world around them.

I do not agree with the teacher simply giving a test on the book without provoking a thoughtful discussion from the children in the class. Euthanasia is a heavy topic, but one I remember debating in 7th grade on the debate team. Without reading the book, I do not know how much the story discussed euthanasia, but it is possible that some of the students did not understand exactly what it was.

It is important to expose our children to topics that they may be disturbed by, but it is as equally important to discuss these topics with them. If the teacher failed to do so, shame on them. I would say this opens up an equally important opportunity to discuss these issues with your child as a family. While these conversations are not easy to have, I believe parents should have these conversations with their children to understand how their children feel about such subjects. We are not immune to having "tragic" situations hit our own families. I believe when we are faced with these situations, we are often amazed at our ability to adapt and cope to changes.

If you are not happy about your child reading books that discuss disabilities and euthanasia, discuss it with them. You are probably more disturbed by the situation than your child is, but you will not know if you spend all of your time talking to the school board instead of your child. 

Fan4LSU27 --- 14 years ago -

Here is a little bit more information as well - I am still on the fence as to whether I would find this appropriate or not. I think the decision ultimately should be up to the parent:
Humble ISD set to look at review policy for books 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

oh lord!!!

My son read that book and has had no long term or ill effects from it....lol.

Some people just look for reasons to be outraged. Sounds like Mr. Abbott needs to look into homeschooling...he needs to have more control, apparently. 

Semper --- 14 years ago -

Jena...your comment is spot on! I wish I could keep my kids isolated from all the evil, sadness and tragedy in the world. If I cannot isolate them, then it's my job to make sure to educate them and give them the necessary resources to understand their world. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

My son read that book and has had no long term or ill effects from it....lol.

What do you think the problem is with it according to this guy? Does it paint euthanasia in a positive light? 

Insurrection --- 14 years ago -

Do your kids ever catch parts of the evening news? That should have plenty of disturbing things to warp their delicate little psyches. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

What do you think the problem is with it according to this guy? Does it paint euthanasia in a positive light? 


I don't know...I never read it. I know it was assigned for my son to read, he read it and that was it.

However, on the subject of euthanasia, we have discussed that with our older kids. We used Terry Schiavo as an example. I've told my kids my views on Dr. Kevorkian and how some people agree and others don't. I discuss all sorts of topics with my kids...and I don't worry about reading material too much once they hit the teen years. Especially a book chosen by the school...I give the teachers and librarians credit to use good judgement when it comes to book selection and so far, I've had no issues.

I will say, I stopped my 4th grader from reading my 10th graders copy of "Lord of the Flies"...because it wasn't age appropriate. It also wasn't a book even remotely suggested for her age group by anyone at school or anywhere else.

I don't think (some) people give their kids enough credit for having a brain and the ability to have opinions and feelings on all sorts of subjects...they want to treat them like they're perpetually 5 years old. I don't understand that.

Commonsense...it's a lost art. :/ 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Do your kids ever catch parts of the evening news? That should have plenty of disturbing things to warp their delicate little psyches. 


Have you ever overheard the things middle schoolers say to one another? How about the things they view on iPhones? People are worrying about a fiction book to the point of fighting the school board, but I'd bet money those same parents children aren't the innocents they *think* they are....

We're talking about a real life subject...cerebral palsy. At what point would a child be ready to read about it? 18? Should they be an adult first? How sheltered are these folks kids'? 

JustLivin --- 14 years ago -

It's a great book. Read it. I would also suggest spending an entire day on a middle school campus before you judge the appropriateness of the book for 7th grader. What they act like away from their parents is vastly different than what you think. The teaching or lack there of should be the issue, not the content of the book. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I'm trying to figure out the line myself. It's true, we can't protect them from everything--they will be exposed to other viewpoints, and they will be exposed to evil. That's just the way it is.

What I have trouble with is the intent to purposely persuade my children towards a belief or an agenda. All books do that to some extent. . .the theme of the book is what to look for. Books are incredibly powerful vessels for changing people's views, as are movies and tv. Sometimes, those views are changed in a positive way--like Uncle Tom's Cabin, or To Kill a Mockingbird.

Sometimes, it can have a negative impact. Such as normalizing pre-marital sex and violence.

But it always the writer's or the director's intent to persuade you to their worldview--at least for the duration of the book or movie. It is what leaves you with that feeling of being totally engrossed in THAT reality, rather than your own (of being in a theater seat, or curled up on your bed reading).

And if that worldview is something that is morally wrong, or ethically wrong, ect., then it can be dangerous. Especially for impressionable young minds. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

WIP, I realize your children aren't in school yet, so, it may be easy to think what you will or won't do when they get to that age.

The important thing is to speak to your kids about the hot topics before other people do...don't assume they're these tiny, fragile, naive little angels at 13 years old. Because that will NOT be the case...lol.

Or, if you really feel that outside influences are too much for your kids to handle, homeschool them so you will have complete control over what they're exposed to and what opinions you think they should have toward things. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

I think any child that can watch "Passion of the Christ" can read almost anything-that movie had adults sobbing, and traumatized-it's graphic violence had my face covered for much of the movie- 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Remember that I taught middle school and high school--in Houston no less. So I'm aware that they are certainly not "angels" at that age. Maybe fallen ones!!!!

But it is a difficult line to navigate. In the past, the media pretty much upheld the same standards and values that we did. For instance, I remember watching The Cosby Show and Growing Pains with my parents. They promoted family values.

Now, what is there to watch with your kids? And I haven't read that particular book, so I don't know what is in it. But if it follows the recent trends of other teen novels. . .it could be bad. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I think any child that can watch "Passion of the Christ" can read almost anything-that movie had adults sobbing, and traumatized-it's graphic violence had my face covered for much of the movie-

Indeed. I'm still traumatized by it. But again, the beatings and crucifixion were treated as evil in that movie. The movie would be much more dangerous they were treated as good, or worse yet. . .funny.

The theme is what matters. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

true- 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

I've never looked at TV as a parenting tool or a gauge/reflection of society at large. So, I can't relate to that. We're not big TV people in our home. If it's on during the day, it's Nick Jr. If it's on at night, it's usually something sports related such as ESPN....since Randle is home. IF we want to watch a show that isn't age appropriate for our kids, we record it and watch it later.

I don't see current society as some sort of 'evil' that didn't exist before now. Evil has always been here...that's life. Good people have always been here, too. It's all in what you look for in life. If you focus on the negative, you'll definitely find it. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

gauge/reflection of society at large.

Of course it is. Art imitates life and life imitates art! It is immensely powerful.

But it sounds like you keep it to a minimum at your house. That's good! 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

gauge/reflection of society at large.

Of course it is. Art imitates life and life imitates art! It is immensely powerful.



I dunno...evil, horrible things were going on while 'Donna Reed' was on the air...so, I don't really buy that. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I dunno...evil, horrible things were going on while 'Donna Reed' was on the air...so, I don't really buy that.

Well media isn't the SOLE source of evil in the world. But it does have an effect. If it didn't, then why do companies spend millions in advertising? 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on this one. "Polite society" had its nasty underbelly that was much worse for some folks than anyone has it today...so, even though Donna Reed and June Cleaver were inspiration for housewives everywhere, there were plenty of women in abusive relationships that had nowhere to go. Child abuse was also ignored. Not too mention the obvious racial issues of that time period...

Like I said, it's all in how you look at things. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Ok. . .but none of those things were being PROMOTED by media. . .so I don't understand the point. . . 

planemom --- 14 years ago -

The friend of mine who had issues with it said she did drop the ball because she didn't know the content before the book was read. Her thought is, when dealing with a subject such as euthanasia the parents should be informed. That way if there is a problem they know where it is coming from and can address it.

From what she told me the book in question is written from the point of view of a child who is terminally ill. He can't speak but can understand what is going on around him. He is the person who would be euthanized. The book ends without telling the reader what decision the dad makes. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Ok. . .but none of those things were being PROMOTED by media. . .so I don't understand the point. . . 


The point is, no matter what TV show is on TV, society has never been this wonderful, utopian place. You're saying TV is a direct reflection of society and I'm saying, NO it isn't...TV in the 50's didn't truly reflect society. So, to complain that you can't sit down and watch TV with your kids because of the evil in the world, is bizarre to me. Evil has always been here, always will be...period. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

Ok, let me try again. In the past, the evil that was in the world wasn't packaged in a pretty little bow and sold to my children. If my children wanted to watch Donna Reed, then I would be safe to assume that what they saw promoted good values and decency.

Now, the evil in the world is glamorized and sold to children as if it is good. That's the difference. 

PeopleRPeople --- 14 years ago -

From what she told me the book in question is written from the point of view of a child who is terminally ill. He can't speak but can understand what is going on around him. He is the person who would be euthanized. The book ends without telling the reader what decision the dad makes.


I think what I would be upset with isn't the book but the fact that there was no discussion. The fact that there was no decision at the end of the book leaves the possibility of debate wide open. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

I'm guessing the trouble is with what the child from whose view the book is written thinks about it. Is he wishing FOR euthanasia? 

PeopleRPeople --- 14 years ago -

Is he wishing FOR euthanasia?


I don't get why that matters. I mean a good book opens discussions, presents a differing point of view and makes people think. I don't think they should have given kids the book to read w/o discussing it. The only thought is maybe the school thought the parents would discuss it with their children. 

Semper --- 14 years ago -

My kid is in 6th grade but has tested at college sophomore in reading comprehension. It is a challenge to find reading material that meets his academic level while not exceeding his level of emotional development, especially in works of fiction. Passion of the Christ was very difficult for the kids to watch but we personally felt that it was important subject matter. Same with movies about war, battles, politics, etc. It is part of becoming a discerning adult. 

Work in Progress --- 14 years ago -

My kid is in 6th grade but has tested at college sophomore in reading comprehension.

One thing to keep in mind with those test scores is that he is reading a sixth grade level text to the same ability that a college sophomore would. It does not indicate that he is capable of reading a college level text at that same level. I don't know if that makes sense or not.

But I understand the problem. I was the same type of kid. My parents weren't all that great at censoring what I was reading either. They didn't let me watch it on tv, but they were more lax about books. And I read all sorts of inappropriate things!

And I SURE wasn't going to talk to them about it! 

Semper --- 14 years ago -

I read Forever by Judy Blume in 6th grade. I would be horrified if my kid were to do the same now. My parents censored tv more than books too. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

I agree with Handmaid-there should definitely be some discussion after reading that book- as she says, a good book does make people think, and if not school, then parents should accommodate that- 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground