Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Which Dog Breed???

who's talking here?

QueenCassie 2
lizandmike 1
ukchristine 2
Homeschool mom 1
Rubicon 1
Jpgirl 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 2
blueherron4 5
doglady 4
BoxerMama 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
SailorTattoos 5
Odin 1
Gentlecurves 1
Gonefurgud 1
Lets Be Fair 2
RenMan 1
a3869397uu 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

RenMan --- 14 years ago -

We're getting a new family pet, and we've narrowed our choices down to either a Giant Schnauzer or a Mountain Airedale.

Does anyone on KU have experience with either of these breeds? 

Gonefurgud --- 14 years ago -

No but I have a beautiful blue heeler that I am fostering. Would love to introduce you to Lucy. :) 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

No, but I'd go Airdale between those two. 

doglady --- 14 years ago -

Of course I have to jump in and say this, but pleeezzzeee...google dog rescues, and see if their are either of the breeds you are looking for in a breed specific rescue. There are sooo many dogs that need homes, without buying one. 

BoxerMama --- 14 years ago -

I second that DL. I'm sure there are rescues for both of those breeds. All those sad puppy eyes that are needing a home just break my heart! 

a3869397uu --- 14 years ago -

Giant Schnauzer FAQ's

~Deb Stover

So...you THINK you want a Giant Schnauzer?

You saw one at a dog show or walking with their owner or on TV, and now you want one. You might name him/her Harley, or Lucy , or Max. You and your puppy will live happily ever after, and he will charm you forever with his intelligence and antics. Right?

Think again. Giants are not for everyone. Unless you have a LOT of time (lifetime of the Giant) to devote to your new Giant (whether puppy or adult) for the next 10 - 12 years, this breed is not for you.

Giants are NOT larger version of the Miniature Schnauzer. If I had a penny for everytime someone has said,"Oh, I have had minis and now I want a Giant" I would be a wealthy woman, lol! Thats like saying, "I've had Great Danes" One has absolutely nothing to do with the other. Having a Mini or Standard Schnauzer is not the same as a Giant. They are three distinctive breeds with three very different personalities and breed characteristics. Giants are very strong physically and very high energy, they are loud and demanding and need a lot of daily attention from you and daily exercise with you. This is not a breed you take to the dog park and turn loose. Giants WILL fight, they are dog aggressive, especially with the same sex. When your puppy reaches puberty you will begin to see a totally different dog and most of these traits will come out rather quickly. This is when many people figure out they are in way over their head and this is not the breed for them.

How does this happen? You did your "homework." No, you didn't otherwise you would know the truth about our breed and know that this is a breed that requires a massive amount of daily training, attention and exercise. Thinking this is just another breed and you can ignore this info will do nothing but result in yet another Giant in rescue because you chose not to listen to knowledgeable people in the breed or you thought, "I've had dogs all my life, this breed isn't any different than any other breed" or you think you can "atch your little kids and the giant all the time and no one will get hurt" These are all things the less than reputable breeders will tell you. They will tell you whatever you want to hear to make that sale.

The Giant Schnauzer is a working breed with a terrier temperment. Historically, they were specifically bred to guard herds against predators, protect their families and used as draft dogs to pull carts and small wagons. Add the terrier temperment and you have a large dog who is very prey driven. They will chase any fast-moving critter, burrow and dig, and bark furiously, to annoy that prey out of its safe haven. When the prey is frightnened out of safety it will lose it life. Thats what prey drive (Terrier temperment) is and you can't make it stop or "train" it out of a dog.

The very characteristics that make a Giant Schnauzer a Giant Schnauzer are the same characteristics that make it unsuitable for many families and individuals. They bark a lot and are and extremely loud and noisey breed. They are relentless when they want something. (Prey, food, a sock, a Barbie Doll's head, food off your counter tops, you get the idea.) They are extremely territorial, they often don't get along very well with other dogs, especially dogs of the same sex. And according to many sources, they will kill your cat. It may seem like the dog and cat get along beautifully, but there are many stories of owners coming home to find a rather gruesome scene. Remeber that prey drive?

Giants also need enormous amounts of exercise. The most common phrase echoed around the country from breeders, owners and trainers is "A tired Giant is a good Giant." An hour a day of running, playing chasing, swimming, digging is not remotely enough exercise for this breed. Ask any self-respecting Giant himself, and he will tell you three hours is more like it. Do you as a family have this much time to devote to just playing with your pet? Do you have a fenced yard to keep playtime safe? If you don't have time to play, your Giant puppy will invent his own fun; shredding your furniture, digging craters in your yard, chewing every sock, shoe and toy he can find laying around.

Are you prepared for a 70-100 pound dog to live in your house as a family member? Giants do NOT make good "yard/outside" dogs. They can bark loud enough to wake the dead when they are unhappy....and they WILL let you know if they are unhappy or NEED you to do something. They are relentless and and very demanding of your time.

Giant Rescue is a nationwide network of caring Giant owners & people who literally rescue Giants that owners cannot deal with. We will first encourage an owner to seek out behavioral training for the dog, to correct any problems, if that is unsuccessful, we will try to place the dog in a new home. As a last resort, they will take in and foster any dogs that are in danger of being "dumped," or dogs at shelters that have already been dumped.

Our adoption criteria is very strict; no children younger than 10 for first time GS owners adopting a rescue from a shelter (because we have NO history on the dog), no same sex dogs in one household, and we reserve the right to check on how your dog is doing for the rest of that dog's lifetime. But our motive is very simple; to place a dog in a permanent, loving, forever home. Adoption fees vary from organization to organization, from $250-$400, but for that fee you get a dog that is spayed or neutered, up to date on all shots, and heartworm tested. That fee may also include flea treatment and microchip identification. In comparison, a new puppy from a Back-Yard-Breeder or a Puppy Mill will cost you $500-$1500, just for the puppy, and that's whether it's a well-bred OR a poorly-bred puppy. THEN you go to the vet with your checkbook open.

According to most any Giant owner, most rescue dogs would make wonderful family pets, for families familiar with the breed. "Most of the dogs we get in rescue aren't given up because there is something wrong with them, but rather just because they're Giant Schnauzers and people didn't research our breed before purchase. The dog is FINE, it's the owner that should not have gotten this breed.

Giants are notoriously stubborn. Training is a MUST. Professional training, with a trainer who teaches YOU and your Giant is a must. Any antics that you find amusing in a ten week old puppy (oh, listen to that cute little snarl) and ignore, will most likely escalate into major problems later on. By the time you realize it's a problem, that dog has had YOU trained for quite a while. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

GREAT article-this applies to several other dog breeds-the bully dogs-ask Sailor, she an authority on this subject-she has stated that when she has her own rescue, she fully intends on completely checking out the potential family, to make sure none of the above happens- 

QueenCassie --- 14 years ago -

What traits do you find desirable in these 2 breeds? 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

QC, airdales couldn't be more different-they're very hyper as puppies, (2 years) but sweet and gentle- 

blueherron4 --- 14 years ago -

They are some beautiful dogs and (big). 

SailorTattoos --- 14 years ago -

I personally am a huge fan of the GS! Airedales just don't do it for me, and you have to deal with the terrier traits :)

Both dogs are very demanding breeds though so do your homework. GS is a working breed and not for novice owners, they are protective by nature and you can get in over your head very quickly. Check out the giant schnauzer breed club of America to find a breeder or rescue referral list. Same with the airedale. You will be sorry supporting a BYB with either of these breeds.


This video shows the GS I used to live with, she was a show champion. Awesome dog :)


 

Jpgirl --- 14 years ago -

My friend had a Mt Airdale- in a word Don't do it. Airdale are very head strong and hard to train. If you have a family, take this into consideration - they need TONS of time set aside for formal training and follow up. They are aloof and may attach to one person. I agree with the above posters- consider the pound and rescues. At the very least- find a real FAMILY dog
Good luck 

blueherron4 --- 14 years ago -

SailorTattoos you have some beautiful dogs. 

SailorTattoos --- 14 years ago -

Thanks, 2 of those are mine and the GSD was my foster dog. My roomie had the GS and other Doberman, he also showed a Chinese crested and a mini poodle that lived with us. There was never a dull moment! 

doglady --- 14 years ago -

Wow!!!a486----I had NO IDEA about any of that/that you posted! I hope these people do their research, and see what you posted. Guess they would be good for a very select few, but again, wow ....had no idea. Thanks for the info! 

SailorTattoos --- 14 years ago -

The giant in that video was a social butterfly at dog parks and was a big couch potato, she also got along fine with the other 6 dogs she lived with :) 

QueenCassie --- 14 years ago -

QC, airdales couldn't be more different-they're very hyper as puppies, (2 years) but sweet and gentle-

Oh, I wasn't insulting either breed- just asking the OP what traits of these breeds are desirable to them as a person/family. 

blueherron4 --- 14 years ago -

We have 3 rescue and then my oldes daughter dog. and 1 cat that was a rescue also. 

SailorTattoos --- 14 years ago -

Me with her at the humble Starbucks :)

0 

Homeschool mom --- 14 years ago -

What a sweet picture! 

blueherron4 --- 14 years ago -

She is BIG but beautiful I use to have a Blond Afghan Hound she was a mess. She had to have bows in her hair or she would cry.Big baby.That has been 20 years ago. 

doglady --- 14 years ago -

Sailor, what a cute pic. Must not be any of those wild traits in this particular one:) 

Odin --- 14 years ago -

Can we get back to talking about cat litter boxes? I'm bored. 

Gentlecurves --- 14 years ago -

We've had a regular schnauzer for almost 14 years. Great dog!! 

blueherron4 --- 14 years ago -

And some new photos and songs BeaverFreezer 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

Get a Golden Retriever. It is a perfect family dog and great with kids. 

Rubicon --- 14 years ago -

How about a yellow lab? I know someone who can't keep his any more. He's very sweet... 

ukchristine --- 14 years ago -

Our adult son adopted a 4 month mixed breed (golden/lab...or?????) from SPCA). she is wonderful. She was running the streets of Houston. Cute looking but very dusty. Can't bathe her yet as she was just fixed. She has the traits of a golden retriever which IMO is the BEST breed in the world. I just called a breeder who told me they just sold one for $1500....yikes. 

ukchristine --- 14 years ago -

We all (4 of us plus son) went with him to the pound............you can check out availability on line. We had gone to see some puppies but in the spec of HOURS they were already adopted. But we found LIlly and could not be more pleased. As my son said to her......"Lilly , you will never have to sleep outside again....unless we go camping" 

SailorTattoos --- 14 years ago -

OP has narrowed down their list to 2 breeds that interest them. If you have experience with those two breeds then please share. Why would you want a golden or a lab when you can have a giant schnauzer? That is no comparison in awesomeness!

OP, if you decide to go the breeder route, PM me bc I am pretty knowledgable about the ethical breeder world and know what to look for and what to avoid. Expect to pay around $1500 for a pet quality puppy from a good breeder. 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

Do you have to children? Ages? 

lizandmike --- 14 years ago -

Get a rescue dog! 

doglady --- 14 years ago -

Please look at the breed specific rescues! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground