Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

*Obama and the pipeline debate.

who's talking here?

wayward1 3
rEVOLution 5
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
Infidel II 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

Obama says he's added pipeline 'to encircle Earth and then some'
By Andrew Restuccia and Amie Parnes - 03/22/12 12:36 PM ET

As gasoline prices continue to rise, President Obama on Thursday pushed back on attacks from Republicans that he is blocking the Keystone XL oil pipeline and is against drilling, arguing his administration has added enough new oil-and-gas pipelines to "encircle the Earth and then some."

Obama highlighted his support for the southern leg of the controversial Keystone pipeline, which would carry oil from Cushing, Okla., to refineries on the Gulf Coast.

Appearing before a backdrop of oil pipelines in Cushing, Obama said he was making construction a priority through an executive order issued Thursday that instructs federal agencies to expedite their review of the southern portion of the pipeline.

“Today, I’m directing my administration to cut through the red tape, break through the bureaucratic hurdles and make the project a priority,” said Obama, who earlier this year rejected a GOP bid to force construction on the full pipeline, which would stretch from Alberta to the Gulf Coast.

Republicans quickly dismissed the speech and the executive order as a public relations stunt.

“Today he's out in Oklahoma trying to take credit for a part of the pipeline that doesn't even require his approval. Now this is what I'm calling the Obama energy gap,” House Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio) said during a press conference at the Capitol.

“There's a big gap between what the president promises and what he talks about and the actions that he's taking."

The Cushing speech is the latest in a two-day, four-state tour meant to tout the president’s energy plan and undercut GOP attacks over high gas prices. The White House is trying to change the optics of the issue to the president’s advantage, putting Obama in front of a field of solar panels on Wednesday and oil piping on Thursday.

___________________________________________

OK, here's my two cents, or questions I guess.

1. Why don't we STOP pumping all this "said" money into oil production and invest it in entrepreneurial corporations who have already developed alternative fuels? HEMP being one of them. Henry Ford used HEMP as a biofuel when TV's were still black and white. (Was that racists?)

2. Can we even afford to pay people the salaries they need to survive in America to produce the amounts of oil that we CONSUME here in the US. In my opinion, us using our own oil would be the equivalent of us building our TVs trying to compete with foreign countries on cheap electronics. If we made our own TV's they'd cost three times as much because our employees can't survive here on $3.00 a day.

Republicans say "Drill baby drill" while Liberals say, "But what about the animals" when the reality is that we wouldn't be able to afford using our own oil. That's exactly why we export our own oil and buy it cheap from the middle east where it can be produced at a lower cost.

3. Lastly, this pipeline is NOT going to lower prices at our gas pumps and it's NOT going to create anymore jobs than it's going to destroy. We have to factor in all of the jobs it would be taking from trucking companies who currently drive this oil across the US instead of it being pumped through a pipeline. But there's also the land ownership aspect that the government come in and take people land from them to make this happen. 

wayward1 --- 14 years ago -

For the most part, the amount of oil we have is determined by oil companies. There is no "our" oil or American oil. The oil belongs to the person who drills it. We in the U.S. are only customers of Global oil companies.
Like most everywhere else, U.S. oil companies drill around the world and sell around the world. That's their right. Right now, they are selling off oil drilled here to Asia, because China and India are paying more for it. That's just the way it is.
I guess the good news is that we are finally an oil exporter again. First time since 1949. 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

Very good points wayward.

I do agree with you but I'm curious how these corporations got their "right" to drill and sell oil? What I mean is how do they get rights to oil that's under land that they don't own and then take that drilled oil and sell it to whomever they choose at the price they set?

I know they are powerful, but who gives them that power? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

when the reality is that we wouldn't be able to afford using our own oil. That's exactly why we export our own oil and buy it cheap from the middle east where it can be produced at a lower cost.

I've read all this, but WHY is it too expensive here? Some of this is total BS...What is a 'lower cost'?? Are we just talking a little less profit or something truly illogical financially?

I have a very hard time swallowing the 'we can't do it' thing. My guess is, getting 'cheap' stuff from the middle East is what we are used to, complacency, business with little to no risk is tempting to turn down as opposed to risk. I also have a hard time believing all the new jobs it would create, maybe not the best wages, but jobs nonetheless, wouldn't be a darn good thing. Sheesh. 

wayward1 --- 14 years ago -

but I'm curious how these corporations got their "right" to drill and sell oil? What I mean is how do they get rights to oil that's under land that they don't own and then take that drilled oil and sell it to whomever they choose at the price they set?

I know they are powerful, but who gives them that power?


You purchase mineral rights. Ever since the gold rush days, we've had really lax and loose minining/drilling rights in this country. Foreign companies can basically come in and mine for minerals and take what they find as long as they purchase mineral rights. And it was British Petroleum that helped to spill all that nice oil on our beaches lot long ago.
Basically, if you dig it up, it's yours as long as its not radioactive or a Spanish shipwreck. 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

SagaciousSighFiGurl

What I meant was that because of the way our society is geared, economically speaking, Americans "will" not produce oil as cheaply as middle eastern nations do. We have a petrodollar treaty with the middle east. We build their refineries, they buy our US securities, TBills, and in turn they sell us cheap oil.

One reason the US military industrial complex murdered Saddam and Gadaffi was because they had threatened to sell their oil in exchange for either Gold or Euros because they knew where the dollar was headed. And they were right.

But back to the whole "we can't make it as cheaply here" of course we could if the employees working for the refineries could live on what the middle eastern nations do to refine the oil. But our workers can't survive in America with those wages. Therefore we have to charge more for the oil we produce here and that's why we don't use our own oil, it's worth more if we sell it overseas.

I'm not agreeing with it, that's just how it is.

Of course we could produce our own oil in the quantities we need for less than what we are paying at the pump now but that would cut into profit margins and we all know that's not going to happen.

So if we stop using over seas oil here in the US, we will have to pay what other nations pay to use our oil.

My problem isn't with the idea that we use oil as much as it is about who runs this system and what their agenda is. Plus the fact that there are alternatives out there, but we can't use them because it would cut into their profits too much. 

wayward1 --- 14 years ago -

The thing is, oil isn't divided up for use by nationality. There is no American oil. Exxon, for instance, drills all around the world. It ships that oil back here to Houston for refinement. Different oil (such as light-sweet crude from Libya) is used for certain products, whether that is plastics, gasoline, motor oil, industrial solvents, etc.
Different spots around the world produces different kinds of oil. And then all that oil from all those different nations, is all pooled together for different refinements to make the oil-based products we use every day. Exxon drills around the world because it wants to. They won't just drill here because that would limit their product offerings. They supply the WORLD with petroleum products. And that includes selling oil drilled in Texas to China. 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

1. Why don't we STOP pumping all this "said" money into oil production and invest it in entrepreneurial corporations who have already developed alternative fuels? HEMP being one of them. Henry Ford used HEMP as a biofuel when TV's were still black and white. (Was that racists?)

2. Can we even afford to pay people the salaries they need to survive in America to produce the amounts of oil that we CONSUME here in the US. In my opinion, us using our own oil would be the equivalent of us building our TVs trying to compete with foreign countries on cheap electronics. If we made our own TV's they'd cost three times as much because our employees can't survive here on $3.00 a day.

Republicans say "Drill baby drill" while Liberals say, "But what about the animals" when the reality is that we wouldn't be able to afford using our own oil. That's exactly why we export our own oil and buy it cheap from the middle east where it can be produced at a lower cost.

3. Lastly, this pipeline is NOT going to lower prices at our gas pumps and it's NOT going to create anymore jobs than it's going to destroy. We have to factor in all of the jobs it would be taking from trucking companies who currently drive this oil across the US instead of it being pumped through a pipeline. But there's also the land ownership aspect that the government come in and take people land from them to make this happen.


Dear R,

1. We live in a capitalist society, so the market determines where capital is employed, and the market is attractive enough to attract billions and billions of dollars into the exploration and production industry and the refining industry here in the U.S. Even if we had a centralized, government-controlled economy, the best use of some of our capital would be to produce the oil we have right here in the U.S., when compared to using that capital for less energy-efficient technologies. The cost per kilowatt of alternative fuels/technologies is still much higher than hydrocarbons (coal, natural gas, crude oil). It will be a long, long time before alternative fuels can compete without major subsidies, subsidies which would cost grandma a ton more money on her heating bill.

2. Oil is an international commodity, but it is produced economically here. In some regions in the U.S. (onshore), it may only cost $30-40/barrel to produce, while it may cost upwards of $55/bbl to produce it offshore. With current market prices at $105+, it is economic to produce domestic oil, even with the extra cost to refine it and to deliver it to the consumer. Jobs in the E&P business pay very well, substantially more than minimum wage, because finding and producing oil here is economic. See first sentence of No. 2. Finally, we do not export all of our oil. Most of it is consumed in refineries here in the U.S. We do export a significant amount of refined products (gasoline, natural gas liquids, like butane, propane and natural gasoline), but we also consume a substantial amount here. We are currently a net importer of oil, although, many predict that we can become a net exporter again by 2020 due to the new tight sands/oil shale boom going on in Texas and elsewhere, along with continued offshore, deep well drilling.

3. The pipeline will help to equalize prices in the Midwest from those on the Gulf Coast. Currently, there is a glut of oil in the Midwest (Cushing, OK) due to pipeline constraints. Because of that, oil is trading at a significant discount in the Midwest compared to the Gulf Coast. Construction of the pipeline would simply reduce the disparity, although it would probably not reduce costs in the aggregate in U.S. As for trucks, typically they do not truck the oil all the way from the Midwest to the Gulf Coast. A lot of it sits in the 52 million barrels of storage that's present in Cushing, OK, until it can be piped or sent out by rail, so no trucking jobs will be lost. With respect to landowners, you are talking about a strip of land maybe 50-75 feet in width for the pipeline easement--that's it. Most land is purchased by the pipeline owner from the landowner at mutually agreed upon prices. Eminent domain is used sparingly, and when it is used, the landowner still gets paid market price for their land. 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

I would add that the TV comparison is flawed, because the comparison implies that the electronics industry, which is labor intensive, is the same as the oil industry, which is technology intensive. You don't need a ton of people to find and produce oil, you need geologists to find it and drilling rigs to drill the wells and other equipment to case the wells. We (the US) are still at the leading edge in terms of technology and experience which is the key to oil and gas exploration and production, so we are more than able to compete internationally. But, we cannot compete in most labor intensive fields due to the willingness/need of workers in other countries to take much less in compensation for the same work. 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

Infidel II

Thank you for clearing that up and for taking the time to explain it all.

All I know for certain is that there are better ways of doing things and it does not seem to me that the government has our best interests at heart when they make their decisions. It seems that profits for their lobbyists comes first and foremost. 

Infidel II --- 14 years ago -

Dear R,

No problem. Obviously, I am in the O&G industry and am dealing with some of these issues.

As for the government, I agree wholeheartedly. I am an independent who is very sympathetic to libertarian principles, although maybe not a full-fledged member of the Libertarian Party. So, you are preaching to the choir on this one! In fact, I am thinking of voting for Obama just to show the Republicans that they can no longer take the libertarian/laissez-faire (sp?) independents for granted, because they refuse to put up a candidate who is conservative fiscally and moderate on social issues. I will not vote for Romney, because he stands for nothing. Santorum makes me want to puke--I mean the candidate. Whatever folks do in their bedroom with respect to the other "Santorum" is their own business! 

rEVOLution --- 14 years ago -

Santorum

LOL

I hear ya.

While I can't endorse you possibility of voting for Obama I completely understand why someone would do that. There's only one way I could ever vote and that's with my conscience and gut feelings and those are with Ron Paul. If I didn't vote for him I wouldn't vote at all. I know he's not the 100% perfect solution but his views, his voting history, his beliefs, check all my boxes.


Thanks again for taking the time to answer my questions. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground