Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is it time to think about outlawing this discriminatory organization?

who's talking here?

Rubicon 2
kingwood resident 1
genxer 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
JohnLynch 2
TheMasticator 5
LiveFreeOrDie 2
Dorothy Parker 3
Are we great again yet 2
stuck in the middle 1
pantherdadx2 3
Darkwaterarms 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

Father Marcel Guarnizo: 'I Did The Only Thing a Faithful Catholic Priest Could Do'
March 14, 2012

Editor's Note: On Feb. 25, at a funeral Mass at St. John Neumann Parish in Gaithersburg, Md., Fr. Marcel Guarnizo very discreetly denied Holy Communion to Barbara Johnson, the daughter of the deceased. Johnson had entered the sacristy before the Mass along with another woman whom she made a point of announcing to Fr. Guarnizo as her “lover.” Since the incident, Johnson has told her version of what happened to several news organizations. Until now, Fr. Guarnizo has remained silent.

Fr. Guarnizo is a priest of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Moscow, Russia—not of the Archdiocese of Washington, D.C., where he has been practicing his vocation in recent years. On March 9, the Archdiocese of Washington withdrew his “faculties” to administer the sacraments within its borders.

Here, for the first time, in a written statement, Fr. Guarnizo begins to tell his story.

Fr. Marcel Guarnizo’s Response to the Eucharistic Incident

I would like to begin by once again sending my condolences to the Johnson family on the death of Mrs. Loetta Johnson.

I also feel obliged to answer questions from my parishioners, as well as from the public, about the incident on February 25th.

Here are the facts: On Saturday, February 25th I showed up to officiate at a funeral Mass for Mrs. Loetta Johnson. The arrangements for the Mass were also not my own. I wish to clarify that Ms. Barbara Johnson (the woman who has since complained to the press), has never been a parishioner of mine. In fact, I had never met her or her family until that morning.

The funeral celebration was to commence at 10:30a.m.

From 9:30 to 10:20, I was assigned to hear confessions for the parish and anyone in the funeral party who would have chosen to receive the sacrament.

A few minutes before the Mass began, Ms. Johnson came into the sacristy with another woman whom she announced as her “lover." Her revelation was completely unsolicited. As I attempted to follow Ms. Johnson, her lover stood in our narrow sacristy physically blocking my pathway to the door. I politely asked her to move and she refused.

I understand and agree it is the policy of the archdiocese to assume good faith when a Catholic presents himself for communion; like most priests I am not at all eager to withhold communion. But the ideal cannot always be achieved in life.

In the past ten days, many Catholics have referenced Canon 915 in regard to this specific circumstance. There are other reasons for denying communion which neither meet the threshold of Canon 915 or have any explicit connection to the discipline stated in that canon.

If a Quaker, a Lutheran or a Buddhist, desiring communion had introduced himself as such, before Mass, a priest would be obligated to withhold communion. If someone had shown up in my sacristy drunk, or high on drugs, no communion would have been possible either. If a Catholic, divorced and remarried (without an annulment) would make that known in my sacristy, they too according to Catholic doctrine, would be impeded from receiving communion. This has nothing to do with Canon 915. Ms. Johnson’s circumstances are precisely one of those relations which impede her access to communion according to Catholic teaching. Ms. Johnson was a guest in our parish, not the arbitrer of how sacraments are dispensed in the Catholic Church.

In all of the above circumstances, I would have been placed in a similar uncomfortable position. Under these circumstances, I quietly withheld communion, so quietly that even the Eucharistic Minister standing four feet from me was not aware I had done so. (In fact Ms. Johnson promptly chose to go to the Eucharistic minister to receive communion and did so.) There was no scandal, no “public reprimand” and no small lecture as some have reported.

Details matter. Ms. Johnson was not kneeling when she approached for communion, she did not receive the cup as the press has reported she has stated. It is the policy of St. John Neumann parish never to distribute under both species during funerals.

During the two eulogies (nearly 25 minutes long), I quietly slipped for some minutes into the sacristy lavatory to recover from the migraine that was coming on. I never walked out on Mrs. Loetta Johnson’s funeral and the liturgy was carried out with the same reverence and care that I celebrate every Mass. I finished the Mass and accompanied the body of the deceased in formal procession to the hearse, which was headed to the cemetery. I am subject to occasional severe migraines, and because the pain at that point was becoming disabling, I communicated to our funeral director that I was incapacitated and he arranged one of my brother priests to be present at the cemetery to preside over the rite of burial.

Furthermore, as the testimony of the priest that was at the cemetery conveys, he was present when the Johnson family arrived, and in fact mentioned that being called to cover the burial rite is quite normal, as many priests for reasons much less significant than mine (rush hour traffic, for example) do not make the voyage to the cemetery. He routinely covers for them. This change in plans, was also invisible to the rest of the entourage. Regrets and information about my incapacitating migraine were duly conveyed to the Johnson family.

I have thanked the funeral director and the priest at the burial site, for their assistance that day. Mrs. Loetta Johnson was properly buried with every witness and ceremony a Catholic funeral can offer. I did not and would not refuse to accompany Barbara Johnson and her mother to the cemetery because she is gay or lives with a woman. I did not in any way seek to dishonor her memory, and my homily at the funeral should have made that quite evident to all in the pews, including the Johnson family.

I would like to extend again to Ms. Johnson and her family, my sincerest condolences on her mother’s death. I would never intentionally want or seek to embarrass anyone publicly or increase anyone’s emotional distress during such a difficult time. I did not seek or contrive these circumstances.

But I am going to defend my conduct in these instances, because what happened I believe contains a warning to the church. Such circumstances can and will be repeated multiple times over if the local church does not make clear to all Catholics that openly confessing sin is something one does to a priest in the confessional, not minutes before the Mass in which the Holy Eucharist is given.

I am confident that my own view, that I did the only thing a faithful Catholic priest could do in such an awkward situation, quietly, with no intention to hurt or embarrass, will be upheld.

Otherwise, any priest could--and many will--face the cruelest crisis of conscience that can be imposed. It seems to me, the lack of clarity on this most basic issue puts at risk other priests who wish to serve the Catholic Church in Washington D.C.

As to the latest allegations, I feel obliged to alleviate unnecessary suffering for the faithful at St. John Neumann and others who are following the case.

I wish to state that in conversation with Bishop Barry Knestout on the morning of March 13, he made it very clear that the whole of the case regarding the allegations of “intimidation” are circumscribed to two conversations; one with the funeral director and the other with a parish staff member present at the funeral. These conversations took place on March 7th and 8th, one day before the archdiocese’s latest decision to withdraw faculties (not suspend, since Cardinal Wuerl is not my bishop) on the 9th of March. I am fully aware of both meetings. And indeed contrary to the statement read on Sunday, March 11th during all Masses at St. John Neumann, both instances have everything to do with the Eucharistic incident. There is no hidden other sin or “intimidation” allegations that they are working on, outside of these two meetings.

The meetings in question, occurred in our effort to document from people at the funeral Mass in written form a few facts about the nature of the incident. We have collected more than a few testimonies and affidavits, testifying to what really took place during the funeral liturgy.

My personal conversation with both parties in question were in my view civil, professional and in no way hostile. I respect both individuals in question and really do not know the nature of their grievance.

On March 13, I asked Bishop Knestout about detail on this matter but he stated that he was not at liberty to discuss the matter. I would only add for the record, that the letter removing me from pastoral work in the Archdiocese of Washington, was already signed and sealed and on the table when I met with Bishop Knestout on March 9, even before he asked me the first question about the alleged clash.

In the days to come I look forward to addressing any confusion about the above conversations if the archdiocese or the persons involved wish to talk about it publicly or privately.

I am grateful for all the good wishes and prayers I have received. And sincerely, having lost my own mother not long ago, I again extend my condolences to the Johnson family. I finally wish for the good of the Universal Church, the archdiocese, my parish and the peace of friends and strangers around the world, that the archdiocese would cease resolving what they call internal personnel matters of which they cannot speak, through the public media.

I remain my bishop’s and my Church’s, and above all Christ Jesus’ obedient servant,

Very truly yours,

Father Marcel Guarnizo 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

She got the story and controversy she was looking for.. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

I am sick and tired of the Catholic Church getting away with this kind of bigotry!!!!

If they cannot work within the bounds of civilized society, we should make then do so or force them to disband. 

kingwood resident --- 14 years ago -

Hats off to Fr. Marcel for upholding the teachings of the church. This is not bigotry, there are guidelines all Catholics have to follow, no exceptions.
The problem with people like the Masticator is that anything goes and that attitude is what is running our entire country into the gutter. I for one am a strong advocate of upholding good morals and principles and like Fr. Marcel, I will not bend to political pressure. 

Are we great again yet --- 14 years ago -

masticate
(mas´tikāt´),
v 1. to grind or crush food with the teeth to prepare it for swallowing and digestion.
v 2. to chew.



*deleted* 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

Do you actually have a understanding of what you post , or are you like my dog?

LOL... I highly doubt I am like your dog. I don't crap on your floor or lick you in forbidden places... 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

The problem with people like the Masticator is that anything goes and that attitude is what is running our entire country into the gutter.


lol... You do realize his tongue is placed squarely in his cheek?? 

Are we great again yet --- 14 years ago -

his tongue is placed squarely in his cheek??

That's a good thing!
I had a *deleted- warning* that bragged about the same thing, plus she took her teeth out. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

I dunno, if priests can give communion to people in prison, why couldn't they give it to someone who is openly gay?

A sin is a sin, right? There's no guarantee that the person in prison is "right with God" and yet, they're given communion. The priest also doesn't ask each person in the communion line if they're right with God before they take it, that's on THEM, not the priest, he's only there to give it to the parishioners. He doesn't answer for their sins, therefore, he shouldn't be denying anyone communion.

jmo. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

jmo.

Are you Catholic?? 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

Yes...not practicing anymore, but baptized and confirmed Catholic. 

TheMasticator --- 14 years ago -

I dunno, if priests can give communion to people in prison, why couldn't they give it to someone who is openly gay?

I believe the point is that the woman told him just minutes before the mass that she was a sinning. The Priest is allowed to discriminate as he has direct knowledge of her sin.

He would be allowed to be just as hateful and vile if someone told him they were "...a Quaker, a Lutheran or a Buddhist, desiring communion had introduced himself as such, before Mass, a priest would be obligated to withhold communion. If someone had shown up in my sacristy drunk, or high on drugs, no communion would have been possible either. If a Catholic, divorced and remarried (without an annulment) would make that known in my sacristy, they too according to Catholic doctrine, would be impeded from receiving communion."


Disgusting? Heck yes.... The Priest should not be allowed to withold the sacrements in accordance with Catholic doctrine, just because he has direct knowledge that someone is not eligible.

THAT is why a higher power needs to step in and force them to abide by the laws of the State. 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Yes...not practicing anymore, but baptized and confirmed Catholic. 

so catholics have to practice? 

pantherdadx2 --- 14 years ago -

What seems to be lost in all this discussion is the following; Judge not lest ye be judged...Yes, I beleive I read that somewhere in the bible...Or this;Let he who is without sin cast the first stone...Yes, I beleive I read that somewhere in the bible also.Being gay is someones right as an individual, whether or not we agree with it. Personally I was raised beleiving it is immoral, but who am I to judge? That day's coming soon. But I will say this,If someone tries to force their gayness on my children,and Pantherdad finds out about it, Pantherdad's gonna serve them a big, steaming plate of WHUPA$$ 

JohnLynch --- 14 years ago -

Personally I was raised beleiving it is immoral, but who am I to judge?

you don't have to judge...God already judged the act of homosexuality as sin...all we have to do is recognize and believe what He said 

stuck in the middle --- 14 years ago -

When they refuse to give communion to a molesting priest(because you know that never happened)then they can refuse other who don't practice the catholic beliefs. 

Rubicon --- 14 years ago -

TLDR

Give me a break. You can't outlaw church practices. Remember separation of church and state?! If you don't like a churches teachings, you don't have to attend. 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

or lick you in forbidden places...

Dude, what kind of relationship do you have with your dog??? 

Rubicon --- 14 years ago -

Haven't you seen Road Trip. Kyle - "Because it's you dog." 

pantherdadx2 --- 14 years ago -

you don't have to judge..... coudn't agree with you more,I beiieve 

pantherdadx2 --- 14 years ago -

to Darkwaterarms response to "or lick you in forbidden places" I was wondering the same thing, wondering if this was the same guy they caught with his dog in Trailwood Village in the late 70's. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 14 years ago -

back to the thread-In many other churches (including mine)you can take communion, no questions asked-in this, and also not allowing priests to marry, are canon laws that should be changed, IMO- 

genxer --- 14 years ago -

I dunno, if priests can give communion to people in prison, why couldn't they give it to someone who is openly gay?


The Answer is you can be openly gay but you can not have sex outside marriage. This is a point that most people don't get when they try to paint the church as anti gay.

A gay person with a lover, a man and woman living outside marriage, or a remarried person who did not secure an annulment are all the same situation in the eyes of the church. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

The Answer is you can be openly gay but you can not have sex outside marriage. This is a point that most people don't get when they try to paint the church as anti gay.


So, how does the priest know the status of the men and women in prison? Is it a "don't ask, don't tell" policy?

If that's the case, WTH is the point? 

genxer --- 14 years ago -

I mean everyone on a communion line is on an honor system. But if you are so stupid to go up the the priest and tell them you are in violation of canon then you get what you get.

If you support abortion, your in violation of canon and don't belong on a communion line. If you use contraception you don't belong on a communion line. think the issues here is when you go fight about it with the priest you get kicked off.

I dont think this is being framed right personally. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground