Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

If you want to be mad at Obama here's a darn good reason

who's talking here?

LiveFreeOrDie 6
Defcon1 2
Pat Barry 1
Lets Be Fair 1
Darkwaterarms 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Pat Barry --- 14 years ago -

"...nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law." -- from the 14th Amendment

------

Spin it any way you want. Justify it, rationalize it, chalk it up to the exigencies of war. And at the end, the fact remains:

A United States citizen is dead and the United States government killed him. Without trial. Without due process. Without hesitation. And many of those who loudly deplored George W. Bush for smaller excesses seem content to allow Barack Obama this larger one.

No, I do not mourn the death of Anwar al-Awlaki. If anyone ever deserved to have a missile from a predator drone land in his lap, it was this New Mexico-born Muslim cleric, killed last September in Yemen, his ancestral homeland. American counterterrorism experts say he planned the failed 2009 bombing of a Detroit-bound airliner. Additionally, he is said to have inspired the Fort Hood Massacre of 2009 and the botched Times Square bombing of 2010. The world is a better place without this guy in it.

Still, the means of his dispatch from this world ought to give us pause.

Last week, Attorney General Eric Holder gave a speech in which he attempted to justify what the administration did. His reasoning was not compelling. In Holder's formulation, the U.S. government has the right to kill citizens if said citizens present an imminent threat of violent attack and if capturing them alive is not a feasible option. It can do this, said Holder, speaking at Northwestern University School of Law, without judicial oversight.

"Some have argued that the president is required to get permission from a federal court before taking action against a United States citizen who is a senior operational leader of al-Qaida or associated forces," he said. "This is simply not accurate. Due process and judicial process are not one and the same, particularly when it comes to national security. The Constitution guarantees due process; it does not guarantee judicial process."

What a flimsy rationale upon which to balance a decision as monumental and portentous as the killing of a citizen. Even granting that the demands of armed conflict sometimes make such things necessary, it is inconceivable that the White House would claim the right to kill without at least presenting its evidence before a federal judge in a secret hearing. To eschew even that safeguard -- there is precedent, in urgent cases, for a ruling to be handed down in hours or even minutes -- is to set Obama up as potential judge, jury and executioner of every accused terrorist.

So where is the outrage? Had Bush claimed the right to kill American citizens without judicial oversight, the resulting cries of protest would have been audible on the moon. Indeed, one of the protesters would likely have been Obama himself; he came into office on a promise to reign in the excesses of the Bush years, most infamously, the torture of so-called enemy combatants.

Now, Team Obama seeks to justify an excess Team Bush never did. Bush often said his job was to keep the American people safe. Not to diminish or demean that necessary goal, but it is worth noting that his oath of office actually says nothing of the kind. Rather, it requires him to "preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States."

It is difficult to see where torture -- much less, unilateral killing -- is consonant with that promise. And the people who decried Bush's excesses should also decry Obama's. Instead, he enjoys a measure of leeway and trust that Bush, whose overreach was much more habitual, never did. That forbearance is misplaced.

The leaders change, but the country is the country is the country -- and the principle at stake here is bigger than any one person's term in office. So no, Barack Obama does not deserve the leeway and trust our lack of outrage accords him.

No president does.

(Leonard Pitts is a columnist for the Miami Herald, 1 Herald Plaza, Miami, Fla., 33132.) 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

Yep I agree, the government has no right to target and assassinate an American citizen no matter where he is currently located.

Now is he happens to be with a terrorist group that was targeted. Well sorry about your bad luck. 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

I disagree. I think Holder's analysis is right on. (and I think Holder is generally an idiot...someone else had to come up with this one).

The Constitution guarantees DUE process, but not Judicial Process.

A very lawyerly distinction.

But one that is also accurate.

If not, then every person killed by police officers while committing a crime would have had their rights violated.

Pitts makes the mistake of assuming that al-Awlaki was JUST an American Citizen. IF that were the case, then I would say that this was an extra-judicial, or extra-procedural killing, and illegal.

HOWEVER, al-Awlaki was NOT JUST an American Citizen. He was NOT in Yemen taking in the sights. He was not heading down to the beach to get some sun. He was NOT concerned about any American's Constitutional rights.

He was a known terrorist. A mass murderer. An animal that deserved one thing and one thing only...to be put down.

He was in fact a "regional commander" of Al Queda. And that makes him an combatant. In case you forget, Al Queda is an organization that has stated goals against and used violence against the United States and its citizens.

al-Awlaki may not have pulled the trigger on an AK-47 or RPG, he may have never carried or even seen a bomb. But when he was killed, he was armed and dangerous. The weapons he had was his brain and terrorists willing to fight (and die) at his command.

In fact, in late April, 2010 Representative Charlie Dent (R-PA) introduced a resolution urging the U.S. State Department to issue a "certificate of loss of nationality" to al-Awlaki. The resolution was passed.

Unfortunately, the U.S. actually has no law allowing citizenship to stripped from someone serving in a terrorist organization. I think that's something that should be changed.

But I don't get the State Dept.s reasoning on this. Simply participating in violent warfare against the United States is one way in which one can lose one's citizenship. Isn't planning and instigating violent events a form of participation? Maybe one actually has to pull the trigger, in which case, the law is wrong. Also, serving in a foreign military unit is another. While Al-Queda isn't officially affiliated with any nation, I would think that it still qualified as a foreign military unit.

In the end, this will wind up in courts and we'll see what happens.

ME? Personally. Kill them all. If they're Al Queda or the Taliban, put a bullet in their heads and be done with it.

Where's the outrage??? Find us someone we can be outraged about. al-Awlaki certainly isn't that person.

I personally don't see it any different from when we shot down Adm. Yamamoto. Or the Navy SEALS killing of Osama bin Laden for that matter. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

If not, then every person killed by police officers while committing a crime would have had their rights violated.


The police do NOT have the right or authority to sniper hit a suspected or known killer. 

Defcon1 --- 14 years ago -

Once they do it the first time they will surely do it again. 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

The police do NOT have the right or authority to sniper hit a suspected or known killer.

You sure about that? Then why do Police have snipers? 

Lets Be Fair --- 14 years ago -

There are many reasons to be upset with Obama. 

Defcon1 --- 14 years ago -

Then why do Police have snipers?

For hostage situations? 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

For hostage situations?

yes, that's one reason. But if a cop shoots a hostage taker, has he violated that person's rights because they did not get JUDICIAL process?

NO. The Due Process clause has been satisfied because that person was a threat and the officer has a right to use deadly force in defense of others.

The same can be said of our military or in this case the CIA. They used deadly force on a "citizen" (and I put that in quotations because I really don't agree that he was one) who as the leader of a terror organization, was an immediate threat to the welfare of American Citizens. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

But if a cop shoots a hostage taker, has he violated that person's rights because they did not get JUDICIAL process?

No, he is in the process of an illegal threatening and hostile act.

Now If he is just sitting in his home, they do not have the right to take him out from the roof across the street as he is having dinner. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

who as the leader of a terror organization, was an immediate threat to the welfare of American Citizens.


That's a very scary road to go down.

Do you trust your government and every future government to determine what citizen, or group of citizens, is a "threat to the welfare of American Citizens". 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

That's a very scary road to go down.

Yeah, I know, it's a scary frakkin world.

The difference between the hostage taker and the terrorist leader?

The hostage taker is only dangerous (mostly) when he has hostages.

The terrorist leader is dangerous 24/7. Thus we should kill him 24/7. Whether he's assembling a bomb, plotting an attack, driving in his car, or sitting on the can (I call that one...giving him an Elvis).

It's a completely different threat level. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

I added this while you were posting so I'm going to ask it again..


Do you trust your government and every future government to determine what citizen, or group of citizens, is a "threat to the welfare of American Citizens".  

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

Do you trust your government and every future government to determine what citizen, or group of citizens, is a "threat to the welfare of American Citizens".

I don't trust anyone.

But in THESE particular circumstances, I think that the right action was taken.

In a different scenario, with different facts. I might think otherwise. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 14 years ago -

But in THESE particular circumstances, I think that the right action was taken.

In a different scenario, with different facts. I might think otherwise.



You can't have it both ways, I agree in this case the scum bag needed to go, but tomorrow with a different Government the bad guy may just be you or me. 

Darkwaterarms --- 14 years ago -

You can't have it both ways

Of course you can. Different situations require different action. As intelligent people, we can decide that course of action, whatever it is.

the bad guy may just be you or me.

Oh, I expect that at some point I will be considered part of the problem, not the solution (if this isn't so already).

But the simple solution, don't be the bad guy. And certainly don't be as bad as this bad guy.

And to avoid having a bad government, quit putting bad people in office.

Obama's incompetent, Bush was moron, Romney will be a place-holder like Bush 1 was, God help us all if Santorum actually got into office the man may as well be Taliban. Gingrich is a hypocritical old philanderer...the very idea that any conservative would support him is ludicrous. And my libertarian heart really, really WANTS to like Dr. Paul, BUT every my moderately intelligent brain thinks he's a crackpot.

I miss Ronald Reagan AND Bill Clinton.

Gary Johnson for President - 2012! (as if that's going to happen) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground