Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Grounding kids from their hobbies?

who's talking here?

Punkalicious 1
~grandma again~ 1
planemom 1
I Kissed Frogs 3
Eliza2 1
Donkey Hodie 1
ghostpost 1
~Songbird~ 1
justcat 1
Jpgirl 1
MeriZephyr 1
Texasteach 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
Good Ole USA 1
Dorothy Parker 1
crazypinetrees 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
kapoocheeno 4
Smoochie and the Bean 1
Gonefurgud 1
77339 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

kapoocheeno --- 14 years ago -

When punishing your kids, do you ever ground them from the things they are passionate about? I don't mean toys they love, but rather their interests and talents. Drawing, reading, building... I have a student who has been "grounded" from a topic he loves - something he researches and dreams about - and my heart aches for him. :( I respect his parents and I know they are working hard to do what is right for him, but I still need help seeing this from their perspective. 

Eliza2 --- 14 years ago -

are you going to interfere with a parent's punishment? The only thing that works is taking away what they love. 

justcat --- 14 years ago -

I have never had to. But I have seen it done. And if I had to , I would. But it would have to be extreme. Even when mine is major punished. I don't punish him from reading, or practicing his violin, piano, guitar.
I guess if I had a child who wouldnt do anything...like clean his room, study, etc...and he just wanted to draw, yeah, I may have to try to crack down on it. It would be hard to do though, just logistically speaking. 

Donkey Hodie --- 14 years ago -

Sometimes you have to use whatever leverage you have available. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 14 years ago -

If researching and/ or doing his hobby is keeping him from finishing his responsibilities that might be the reason. Or it could be they have tried other punishments that had no impact because it didn't matter to him. 

~Songbird~ --- 14 years ago -

Sometimes you have to use whatever leverage you have available.

ditto 

kapoocheeno --- 14 years ago -

I would never interfere, but I would like to understand. 

77339 --- 14 years ago -

I DO NOT believe in grounding from hobbies/extra curricular's, etc...it's those things that build confidence, self esteem and many other skills. I had a teacher confront me once about my allowing my child to continue to do his extra curricular activity one week when that same week he had gotten in trouble at school. He got punished at school for that behavior...not gonna punish at home for it too....don't believe in double punishments. 

kapoocheeno --- 14 years ago -

Or it could be they have tried other punishments that had no impact because it didn't matter to him. 

That makes sense. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 14 years ago -

If it is something work related ( he isn't doing chores, homework or not studying) they maybe trying to teach him hobbies are a privilege you get after all the hardworking is done.  Teaching him the bottom line is your work ethic affects your well being.  When you grow up you have to work as many hours or jobs as it takes to make enough money to pay your bills and feed your family.  You don't get to say "I will only do a little hard work and a lot of play".  If the kid learns to apply himself fully now then maybe he will be able to get his dream job in the future,  but that takes discipline.  And right now the only way he can understand that is his hobby comes after everything else.  Teaching this might make him realize things in the future like you can't spend rent money on entertainment.   Of course, that is only if they are explaining it that way, etc.   

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

I totally believe in double and even triple punishment if the act is bad enough. The school is not my childs parent. If they do something that they receive punishment from the school you can bet you arse they are gonna get punished at home too. Possibly by myself and then separately by their dad. 

planemom --- 14 years ago -

If school work is suffering you can bet their extra-curriculars and hobbies will be taken away. 

kapoocheeno --- 14 years ago -

Thank you for your comments. This little guy has been in my thoughts and prayers all evening. I want him to have a better week next week than he had this week! I do appreciate what his parents are doing to help him. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 14 years ago -

The only time I wouldn't take away extra curricular activities is when they are a part of a team. I won't make the entire team suffer because of something my child did. I would find another punishment in that situation. Once the season ended I would reevaluate if they deserved to be on the team again. 

ghostpost --- 14 years ago -

He got punished at school for that behavior...not gonna punish at home for it too....don't believe in double punishments.

My children knew there were home consequences for their behavior at school. That is how we built in the message that there is a home-school connection.

Kapoocheeno, I have said this before..but you sound like a wonderful teacher that really cares about her students. I understand your worry and concern.

Keep an open dialogue with the parents and you might get more insight to what they are thinking in regard to punishment. As a team you might all come up with some creative ways to use positive reinforcement so that his passions and talents are part of the goals he works toward at home and school. 

I Kissed Frogs --- 14 years ago -

 

crazypinetrees --- 14 years ago -

Heck ive grounded mine from church. Yes church, it was more of a social weekly thing than a "get the message thing" so it was included in cuts when things got bad enough to warrant it.

Only happened once. Ive taken away the phone, internet, her favorite blanket.....all kinds of stuff. 

Gonefurgud --- 14 years ago -

Hopefully the message they were trying to make came through loud and clear for him and it won't become an issue again. Parenting is the toughest job on earth. 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Assuming they are good parents, gotta trust their judgement. They are seeing the big picture where as you only see the "student" side of him.

I'm sure they weighed this out and feel this is the most effective way to go. Teaching kids priorities is mandatory. If important/necessary things are not being tended to, time to reel them in for a priority adjustment. If verbal guidance isn't working, go to step 2. 

77339 --- 14 years ago -

Every child is different, just as every parenting style is different. Kids aren't perfect, parents aren't either. As parents we have to do what we think is best and hope that it is. I get much better response from my child when I give him positive praise. I have found I don't need to double punish him...I talk to him about his behavior at school...the choices he made and what he can do better next time. It works....guess I'm lucky. 

Texasteach --- 14 years ago -

I have had more than one child (different years) in my classes that all they did was read all day long. They ended up failing Math and Reading two 6 weeks in a row. Their parents punished them by taking away their books...broke my heart since I am an English teacher, but understandable too. 

Good Ole USA --- 14 years ago -

If it is something work related ( he isn't doing chores, homework or not studying) they maybe trying to teach him hobbies are a privilege you get after all the hardworking is done. I know students who read all of the time but don't do well in other areas or apply themselves. Children need to be taught how to prioritize and juggle the necessary and the passionate.

kapoocheeno --- I can tell you are a great teacher and care about your students :) 

Smoochie and the Bean --- 14 years ago -

I'm sure you can't give more detail given the circumstances but it would be hard for me to make a blanket statement on this topic. It would depend on what the child did, what corrective punishments work for the child, and what the hobby (topic) involves. 

Jpgirl --- 14 years ago -

Yes I have taken away hobbies- just as hobbies were taken away from me by my parents. That only happened to me once! Can't remember what I did but I remember that my parents grounded me and that also meant I was not allowed to go to track practice. That almost killed me- I LOVED track and field!! And talk about double punishment- we were only allowed to miss so many practices and then we were pulled from the next competition. Guess my parents knew that and grounded me just enough to miss that many practices! I had very mean parents who raised me to be a responsible adult. I had the title of being the Meanest Parent of Eternity. My dd recently thanked me as I did thank my parents! The child will regain his privilages, life will go on and if he is like me he will never risk losing his hobby again! 

Punkalicious --- 14 years ago -

If I'm paying for it, they're playing it...and doing something to pay me back if they get in enough trouble that it should be taken away. At school their punishment is getting their folder marked...really nothing...just that the parents will know, and my job is to do the punishing. 

~grandma again~ --- 14 years ago -

my parents never had to worry about taking anything from us. they whipped our butts and we remembered why so normally did not try whatever caused it again. i love them for it, too. it has made my life much easier. 

MeriZephyr --- 14 years ago -

y parents never had to worry about taking anything from us. they whipped our butts and we remembered why so normally did not try whatever caused it again.

Ditto. Those were the days,lol. 

Dorothy Parker --- 14 years ago -

I DO NOT believe in grounding from hobbies/extra curricular's, etc...it's those things that build confidence, self esteem and many other skills. I had a teacher confront me once about my allowing my child to continue to do his extra curricular activity one week when that same week he had gotten in trouble at school. He got punished at school for that behavior...not gonna punish at home for it too....don't believe in double punishments. 


Wow...I can honestly say I have never heard of that approach to punishment/consequences before.

If my child got into trouble at school, the punishment would definitely extend to here at home. I think to do otherwise undermines the teacher/principal as an authority figure and sends the wrong message. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground