Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

*Fake terror plots, paid informants: the tactics of FBI 'entrapment' questioned.

who's talking here?

rEVOLution 3
Warren Peace 2
Quixote 2
Dr Aborto 3
itstxdaddy 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
Freckles00 5
One Nation Under God 1
MavMan 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Fake terror plots, paid informants: the tactics of FBI 'entrapment' questioned.

Critics say bureau is running a sting operation across America, targeting vulnerable people by luring them into fake terror plots

FBI
The FBI has drawn criticism over its apparent use of 'entrapment' tactics. Photograph: Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

David Williams did not have an easy life. He moved to Newburgh, a gritty, impoverished town on the banks of the Hudson an hour or so north of New York, at just 10 years old. For a young, black American boy with a father in jail, trouble was everywhere.

Williams also made bad choices. He ended up going to jail for dealing drugs. When he came out in 2007 he tried to go straight, but money was tight and his brother, Lord, needed cash for a liver transplant. Life is hard in Newburgh if you are poor, have a drug rap and need cash quickly.

His aunt, Alicia McWilliams, was honest about the tough streets her nephew was dealing with. "Newburgh is a hard place," she said. So it was perhaps no surprise that in May, 2009, David Williams was arrested again and hit with a 25-year jail sentence. But it was not for drugs offences. Or any other common crime. Instead Williams and three other struggling local men beset by drug, criminal and mental health issues were convicted of an Islamic terrorist plot to blow up Jewish synagogues and shoot down military jets with missiles.

Even more shocking was that the organisation, money, weapons and motivation for this plot did not come from real Islamic terrorists. It came from the FBI, and an informant paid to pose as a terrorist mastermind paying big bucks for help in carrying out an attack. For McWilliams, her own government had actually cajoled and paid her beloved nephew into being a terrorist, created a fake plot and then jailed him for it. "I feel like I am in the Twilight Zone," she told the Guardian.

Lawyers for the so-called Newburgh Four have now launched an appeal that will be held early next year. Advocates hope the case offers the best chance of exposing the issue of FBI "entrapment" in terror cases. "We have as close to a legal entrapment case as I have ever seen," said Susanne Brody, who represents another Newburgh defendant, Onta Williams.

Some experts agree. "The target, the motive, the ideology and the plot were all led by the FBI," said Karen Greenberg, a law professor at Fordham University in New York, who specialises in studying the new FBI tactics.

But the issue is one that stretches far beyond Newburgh. Critics say the FBI is running a sting operation across America, targeting – to a large extent – the Muslim community by luring people into fake terror plots. FBI bureaux send informants to trawl through Muslim communities, hang out in mosques and community centres, and talk of radical Islam in order to identify possible targets sympathetic to such ideals. Or they will respond to the most bizarre of tip-offs, including, in one case, a man who claimed to have seen terror chief Ayman al-Zawahiri living in northern California in the late 1990s.

That tipster was quickly hired as a well-paid informant. If suitable suspects are identified, FBI agents then run a sting, often creating a fake terror plot in which it helps supply weapons and targets. Then, dramatic arrests are made, press conferences held and lengthy convictions secured.

But what is not clear is if many real, actual terrorists are involved.
Fort Dix Five The homes of the Fort Dix Five were raided by the FBI. Photograph: Joseph Kaczmarek/AP

Another "entrapment" case is on the radar too. The Fort Dix Five – accused of plotting to attack a New Jersey army base – have also appealed against their convictions. That case too involved dubious use of paid informants, an apparent over-reach of evidence and a plot that seemed suggested by the government.

Read the rest of the story here:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/nov/16/fbi-entrapment-fake-terror-plots?fb=native&CMP=FBCNETTXT9038

Just like Operation Fast and Furious is being questioned because some Government agencies were busted selling American Guns to Mexican Drug cartels.

I just hope that some day soon everyone will understand that within our great government, we have horrible and power hungry people who have no problem using our tax dollars to instill fear in us all. 

MavMan --- 15 years ago -

FBI bureaux send informants to trawl through Muslim communities, hang out in mosques and community centres, and talk of radical Islam in order to identify possible targets sympathetic to such ideals.


I am glad they are doing this. Anyone who would even have a passing thought of hurting this country or it's citizens should be shot in the head on the spot. No sympathy here. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

I am glad they are doing this. Anyone who would even have a passing thought of hurting this country or it's citizens should be shot in the head on the spot. No sympathy here.

That's almost the exact definition of Tyranny.

We were meant by design to be a Constitutional Republic but since we have become a Democracy there can only be half the country happy with the way things are going. That leaves a whole lot of people disgusted with having their riches (despite value) stolen and given to those who have not earned. That also leaves a lot of people angry with the United States Military Industrial Complex policing the world and murdering whom ever they choose with little or no accountability. We are told that our USMIC are being sent to these nations in the name of "Freeing the people and installing Democracy" but in doing so our USMIC has killed more people than the dictators we are overthrowing allegedly murdered. We are also leaving behind a wasteland of radioactive natural resources such as water and soil in the areas we are bombing.

If anyone from those nations or that have lost loved ones in those nations form the bullet or bomb used by our USMIC then there is no doubt they would feel hatred towards this nation.

That being said there are very few people who would be willing to be killed by that same USMIC in effort to get vengeance.

It is our Government's own Foreign Policy that is breeding hatred for our beloved United States of America. If anyone wants to do harm to us it's not because we are free, it's because we elect without accountability, leaders who are easily manipulated by Private Banks and Power hungry Corporations.

Almost if not all "terror" plots against the US have been found to be tied directly to our own government, meaning that those who do actually wish to harm us obviously either don't have the motive or the ability to do us harm without the help of our own government agencies. 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

I am glad they are doing this. Anyone who would even have a passing thought of hurting this country or it's citizens should be shot in the head on the spot. No sympathy here.


There are plenty of AMERICANS that are terrorists as well... you know, the kind that wants to blow up America.


Like it or not, these terrorists aren't stupid and if we pin point and focus all our energy on one religion or race or what we think "looks" like a terrorist they are going to use that against us. They are going to recruit people we least expect and then something terrible is going to happen again, because we were too busy raiding every mosque in America. 

MavMan --- 15 years ago -

That's almost the exact definition of Tyranny.



Don't care. If they have the thought of hurting this country or it's citizens, shoot them in the head. Does not matter how it was found out they had those thoughts or inclinations, just the fact that they did. Glad they are getting rid of them.

meaning that those who do actually wish to harm us obviously either don't have the motive or the ability to do us harm without the help of our own government agencies.


It does not matter. The fact that they actually wish us harm is reason enough for them to be shot on the spot. 

MavMan --- 15 years ago -

There are plenty of AMERICANS that are terrorists as well... you know, the kind that wants to blow up America.

Yes and they should be killed on the spot. I made no mention of what race. Anyone wishing to harm this country or it's citizens should be shot. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

That's almost the exact definition of Tyranny.

Yeah, Tyranny against the people wanting to commit crimes and murder. 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -


It does not matter. The fact that they actually wish us harm is reason enough for them to be shot on the spot.


There are plenty of Americans who wish any and all Muslim people harm (innocent women and children as well) much like the Islamic terrorists who wish all Americans harm... Does that make them terrorists and deserve to be shot? Or is it ok because they like America? JW.



ETA: My posts are coming across more accusatory than I meant them to. I am honestly just wondering. 

MavMan --- 15 years ago -

Does that make them terrorists and deserve to be shot

Maybe I was not clear.

Anyone wishing to harm this country or it's citizens should be shot.  

itstxdaddy --- 15 years ago -

i see no problem with it.

if i were approached with this situation, i would politely decline and call the police. see...do the RIGHT thing, no problem. 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -


Maybe I was not clear.

Anyone wishing to harm this country or it's citizens should be shot.



Maybe I wasn't clear.

There are plenty of Americans who wish any and all Muslim people harm (innocent women and children as well) much like the Islamic terrorists who wish all Americans harm... Does that make them terrorists and deserve to be shot? Or is it ok because they like America? JW.



I said there are AMERICANS who wish harm on any and all Muslim people .... as in citizens of other countries as well...

I'm talking about Americans hating and wishing harm on other countries

not americans wishing harm on americans.

What your opinion on that? 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

if i were approached with this situation, i would politely decline and call the police. see...do the RIGHT thing, no problem. 

I was thinking the same thing. "Hey dude, you wanna rob a bank?" "SURE!" Come on, who says that? 

MavMan --- 15 years ago -

if i were approached with this situation, i would politely decline and call the police. see...do the RIGHT thing, no problem.

Exactly. If you have to go forward with what is being offered to you because you need money, or it is giving you the chance to fulfill some sick dream of yours, then yes, you should face the harshest punishment.



I'm talking about Americans hating and wishing harm on other countries

not americans wishing harm on americans.

What your opinion on that?


It would depend on the country. There are some countries that deserve to be hurt because of how they treat their own citizens. 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

It would depend on the country. There are some countries that deserve to be hurt because of how they treat their own citizens.


There are innocent men, women, and children who live in countries like Iraq and Iran and Afghanistan who in my opinion are just unlucky to have been born there. They do what they have to for their families and there are plenty of people who do not hate Americans.

There are Americans who wish any and all Muslims harm... IMO they are just as bad as these terrorists who wish all Americans harm.

It seems to be less evil for someone to hate and wish harm on all Muslims (or whoever) but when it's Americans that are the target it's despicable.


It's sad, in my opinion. We are all human beings and there are good and bad in every group. If those wishing America harm should be instantly put to death than so should any American wishing harm to citizens of other countries... right?

If we have the right to put people to death for hating our country and our way of life than should other countries have the same right to kill americans who wish them harm as well? 

MavMan --- 15 years ago -

You have your opinion, I have mine.

No one said we had to agree.

If we have the right to put people to death for hating our country and our way of life than should other countries have the same right to kill americans who wish them harm as well?


Now you are just putting words in my mouth. I never said we have the right to. I said I think we should.

FTR: I do not really care what other countries do until it affects my country. 

Freckles00 --- 15 years ago -

You have your opinion, I have mine.

No one said we had to agree.



So we can hate and wish harm on whoever we want and that's cool but when someone does it to us they deserve to die?

ok, just so we're clear.

Agree to definitely disagree I suppose. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

So we can hate and wish harm on whoever we want and that's cool but when someone does it to us they deserve to die?

That's why so many people dislike Ron Paul's ideas. His ideas are that of a Constitutional Republic. America has become so "Democratic" (where 51% over rule the other 49%) that one groups ideas are the only way and if you disagree you are considered being against the fringe.

A perfect example is Libya. US tax dollars were spent in an effort to outright murder Libya's leader, leaving the nation now under the control of Al Qaeda. (Yes Al Qaeda, if you don't believe it just google search Al Qaeda + Libya.) There are many people who are going to want to do us harm because we are seen as allowing murders to do what ever they want.

Another example is the Christmas Tree bomber is Portland last year. The kid involved was not seeking out to destroy America, he was Recruited by the FBI and other agencies, given his materials and his instructions. Then all the FBI had to do was show the world that the Muslim wanted to blow up America which wasn't exactly the case.

Another example was the Oklahoma city bombing involving an American Timothy McVeigh. It was later found after his death the FBI did the same thing with him that was done with the Portland Bomber. It was reported the morning of the bombing that there were two other bombs found inside the building. There's no way that McVeigh could have done any of that without the help of the FBI. These are not just my opinions there are hours upon hours of research available that show that he was working with the FBI.

As I've said before there are many examples of our government working with patsies to instill fear in the hearts of Americans. Other nations are waking up to this fact but Americans continue to remain focused on Sports, Entertainment, and work instead demanding accountability when their government is caught selling guns to terrorists and blaming our Constitution for the problems. Meanwhile taking our rights and freedoms protected to us in that Constitution.

Without the Constitution, we are a Tyranny not a Free Republic.

A little fact that most people don't realize is that with the Patriot act and a bill that G Bush passed after 9/11, anyone the government claims is a threat can be confined and held without trial. I can't remember the bill number right now but it is law. Also keep in mind that the target of several government agencies lately have been people who sell raw foods and raw milk. Who will be next? 

Quixote --- 15 years ago -

Merely affording an opportunity to commit a crime is not entrapment. However, soliciting the commission of a crime is a whole different matter and a very slippery slope. 

Dr Aborto --- 15 years ago -

Without the Constitution, we are a Tyranny not a Free Republic.

So every country in the world without OUR Constitution is living in Tyranny? 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

This is amazing to me. You mean we are running sting operations to catch potential terrorists? I'm baffled. DON'T WE HAVE ENOUGH REAL ONES TO KEEP OUR INTELLIGENCE AGENCIES BUSY? 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

Am I the only one noticing a HUGE gaping hole in this story? Somehow we get from

Williams also made bad choices. He ended up going to jail for dealing drugs. When he came out in 2007 he tried to go straight, but money was tight and his brother, Lord, needed cash for a liver transplant. Life is hard in Newburgh if you are poor, have a drug rap and need cash quickly.

to

Instead Williams and three other struggling local men beset by drug, criminal and mental health issues were convicted of an Islamic terrorist plot to blow up Jewish synagogues and shoot down military jets with missiles.

The story is obviously leaving out important details of what Williams was convicted of doing. It seems pretty clear that this omission was intentional solely to paint Williams as a victim and the FBI as a villain...after all, poor David Williams was simply trying to help his brother Lord (we couldn't just be informed that it was his brother, we had to be told of his Christ-like name as well) with a liver transplant. 

One Nation Under God --- 15 years ago -

There are plenty of AMERICANS that are terrorists as well... you know, the kind that wants to blow up America.



Yeah...and there all at the occupy wall street gatherings! Maybe we should send the FBI to infiltrate them??? 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

It took looking elsewhere to learn that poor David Williams who was only trying to help his dear brother, actually not only agreed to serve as a lookout for one of his peers while the friend planned to blow up synagogues in the Bronx with remote-controlled bombs (killing people) and shoot down cargo planes at the Air National Guard base in Newburgh with heat-seeking missiles (thereby killing people), but he actually involved himself in the execution of what he believed was an actual terror plot against innocent people.

Williams didn't just think about these acts when enticed by his friend, he committed acts in furtherance. For example, agents arrested the men in 2009 after they planted the devices — fakes supplied by the FBI – in Riverdale — while under heavy surveillance.

In one of several videos played at trial, the men (including poor David Williams) were seen inspecting a shoulder missile launcher in a bugged warehouse in Connecticut two weeks before the planned attack. At the end of the tape, Cromitie, two of his cohorts and the informant bow their heads in prayer.

Laughably in this article, their defense attorney tried to make the case that Williams deserved leniency because, "they were under the spell of a paid FBI informant posing as an Islamic extremist and promising a big payday, and that they never posed an actual threat."

Under a spell?

I'll file this under "Things that would never happen to me"

Why should we feel sorry for people who actually agree to murder fellow Americans solely for some cash? I'm thankful the FBI has tools to identify such threats without costing us actual lives. 

Quixote --- 15 years ago -

No doubt he's a dirtbag and needs to be off the streets. One down and a bunch to go. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground