Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

*Possible study of anthrax vaccine’s in children (Updated 11-22-11)

who's talking here?

rEVOLution 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Possible study of anthrax vaccine’s effectiveness in children stirs debate
By Rob Stein, Published: October 24

The Obama administration is wrestling with the thorny question of whether scientists should inject healthy children with the anthrax vaccine to see whether the shots would safely protect them against a bioterrorism attack.

The other option is to wait until an attack happens and then try to gather data from children whose parents agree to inoculate them in the face of an actual threat.

A key working group of federal advisers in September endorsed testing, sparking objections from those who consider that step unethical, unnecessary and dangerous. The National Biodefense Science Board (NBSB), which advises the federal government, is to meet Friday to vote on its working group’s recommendation.

“At the end of the day, do we want to wait for an attack and give it to millions and millions of children and collect data at that time?” said Daniel B. Fagbuyiof Children’s National Medical Center in Washington, who chaired the group. “Or do we want to say: ‘How do we best protect our children?’ We can take care of Grandma and Grandpa, Uncle and Auntie. But right now, we have nothing for the children.”

The vaccine has been tested extensively in adults and has been administered to more than 2.6 million people in the military. But the shots have never been tested on or given to children, leaving it uncertain how well the vaccine works in younger people and at what dose, and whether it is safe. Unlike with measles, mumps and other diseases, the chance that children will be exposed to anthrax is theoretical, making the risk-benefit calculus of testing a vaccine on them much more questionable.

“It’s hard to believe that it’s something that makes a great deal of sense,” said Joel Frader, a pediatrician and bioethicist at Northwestern University’s Feinberg School of Medicine. “It would be difficult to justify testing it on kids simply on the hypothetical possibility that there might be an attack.”

Anthrax is a life-threatening infection caused by a toxin-producing bacteria long considered a bioterrorist’s likely choice because it is relatively easy to produce and distribute over a large area. A week after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, letters containing anthrax spores arrived at several media offices and two Senate offices, killing five people and sickening 17 others. The FBI eventually concluded that the letters were mailed by Bruce Ivins, a disgruntled scientist at Fort Detrick in Maryland who committed suicide in 2008, although some experts question the FBI’s findings.

As part of broad effort to better protect Americans against bioterrorism, the Pentagon began a controversial military anthrax immunization program in 1998 that was challenged in court over questions about the vaccine’s safety and reliability. Currently, the Pentagon requires the shots for personnel assigned to bioterrorism defense activities and some other special units, as well as those deployed 15 or more days in the Middle East and some nearby countries, and in South Korea.

The federal government has spent $1.1 billion to stockpile the vaccine to protect Americans in the event of an attack. Antibiotics would help protect those immediately exposed. The vaccine would defend against lingering spores, which is how the pathogen lurks in a dormant state. The vaccine is made from a piece of a strain of anthrax that doesn’t cause the illness.

In April, Nicole Lurie, the assistant secretary in charge of bioterrorism at the Department of Health and Human Services, asked the 13-member biodefense board to evaluate whether the vaccine should be tested in children. A federal simulation of an anthrax attack on San Francisco, called Dark Zephyr, raised quesions about how to handle children.

“If there were an anthrax release and we needed to administer anthrax vaccine, we have no experience with kids. It’s never been in the arm of a kid,” Lurie said. “I started asking myself, ‘Is this the right way to respond in an emergency?’ ”

Those concerns were heightened by the public wariness that had been shown toward the H1N1 influenza pandemic vaccine.

“There is a lot of skepticism on the part of the public about vaccines in general,” Lurie said. “If you had a situation where a vaccine has never been given to a child, it’s pretty hard to think what you could say to people about its safety and efficacy.”

But testing drugs and vaccines in children is problematic. Parents generally are allowed to let their children participate in studies only if they would face minimal risk or would be likely to benefit directly or indirectly in some way.

“With this, you’re putting children at risk for no clear scientific or medical benefit,” said Meryl Nass, a doctor in Bangor, Maine, who is one of the most outspoken critics of testing the vaccine in children. Nass and others maintain that there are serious questions about the vaccine’s effectiveness in adults as well as concerns about sometimes serious complications among those vaccinated in the military. A variety of complications have been reported, including nervous system and autoimmune disorders, Nass said.

“Really, the core question is ‘Why? Why test?’,” said Bruce Lesley, president of First Focus,
a Washington-based advocacy group for children. “We don’t want to be subjecting kids to risks needlessly.”

Some question the value of a study, saying that testing in animals indicates it will be difficult to determine what level of immune system response will be protective.

“What exactly are we going to learn?” said Vicky L. Debold, an associate professor of health administration and policy at George Mason University. “We’ll know what antibody levels these infants produce, but do we know those antibodies are going to protect against death due to anthrax exposure?”

After sifting through the scientific, social and ethical conundrums raised by this question, the eight-member working group concluded that it would be ethically justifiable to conduct a study, which would provide crucial information, such as whether the vaccine is safe and how many doses would be needed.

“A lot of things have happened that we didn’t think could happen. I think the threat is real, and we should be prepared,” said Fagbuyi, an assistant professor of pediatrics and emergency medicine at the George Washington University School of Medicine.

Fagbuyi and others dispute concerns about the vaccine’s safety, noting that the Food and Drug Administration, the National Academy of Sciences and many other independent authorities have concluded that it is as safe as other commonly used vaccines, producing serious complications very rarely.

“Our role is to protect children,” said John S. Bradleyof the University of California at San Diego, who advised the working group on behalf of the American Academy of Pediatrics. “If the military is telling us there is a credible threat, the best way to protect children is to have the data.”

If the board endorses the recommendation, Lurie will meet with counterparts at the FDA, the National Institutes of Health and other agencies to work out the details, including how many children would be studied, at what ages and doses, and how costs would be covered.

“Because it’s such a heated issue, I’ve tried hard to keep an arm’s length until the board makes a recommendation to me,” Lurie said. “To be honest, the safest and easiest thing to do would be to not make a decision and kick the can down the road. But it seemed to me it that would be socially irresponsible. I would hate for a lot of children to die because we didn’t have enough information for the public to feel comfortable getting vaccine.”

http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/possible-study-of-anthrax-vaccines-effectiveness-in-children-stirs-debate/2011/10/13/gIQAFWLdDM_print.html

 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Buuuuut, here are some interesting facts about "Anthrax" and where the real threat comes from.

James Corbett
Boiling Frogs Post
22 September, 2011

Earlier this month, the public was overwhelmed with saturation coverage of the 10th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks. From talking heads reinforcing the talking points and assumptions of the seemingly endless “war on terror” to unquestioning coverage of memorial ceremonies that actually banned the 9/11 first responders from attending, it would have been virtually impossible for any American, or indeed, most anyone around the world, not to have been reminded of those events in recent weeks.

What is not being reported on with anything near the same zeal, however, is that this September 18th marked another solemn milestone, the 10th anniversary of the start of the anthrax attacks that paralyzed an already fear-stricken nation and actually shut down the US House of Representatives, three senate buildings and the Supreme Court.

That the government and the media are largely silent on this anniversary is hardly surprising. Rather than reinforcing the war on terror narrative, the anthrax investigation leads directly back to the heart of the US military-industrial complex, and a secretive biowarfare program that most Americans never knew existed.

At the time, it was simply assumed that the attacks were part of an orchestrated terror campaign, and just as 9/11 had been immediately and unquestioningly pinned on Osama Bin Laden without evidence of any kind, so too the anthrax scare was being pinned on a Bush Administration boogeyman:

On October 18th, John McCain used a late night talk show interview to imply that the anthrax attacks “may” be connected to Saddam Hussein.

On October 21st, Colin Powell told Wolf Blitzer that the Bush Administration had its eye on Iraq in regards to the anthrax attacks.

On October 27th, ABC News’ Brian Ross reported that four well-placed sources had confirmed that a “chemical additive,” bentonite, had been discovered in the anthrax samples, which almost certainly tied the spores to Iraq. Although the report was contradicted by official sources before it even aired, ABC News continued to promote the story for five days before admitting that it was not true.

The association of the anthrax terror with Saddam Hussein became so firm in the public mind that it became a given for the Bush Administration when making its case for war on Iraq, long after all of the Iraqi ties to the anthrax attacks were shown to be false.

Perhaps it is not surprising that the attacks became immediately linked with Saddam Hussein in the popular imagination. After all, a bipartisan effort had spent years mythologizing the Iraqi government and its WMDs and its links to terror. And a senior-level national security exercise conducted just three months before the actual attacks envisioned a scenario in which a deadly biological attack on Oklahoma City was portrayed as coming from Iraq and Afghanistan.

What the public was much less conditioned to expect, however, was what actually turned out to be the case: that the anthrax were not from a foreign source, but from the government’s own labs.

Perhaps the public should have been familiar with this possibility. Just one week before 9/11, on September 4th, in a New York Times article by Judith Miller, the existence of a vast, secret biological weapons program was revealed. The secret research included Pentagon plans to genetically engineer a more potent strain of anthrax. Officials quoted in the article said they worried that the program, started under Clinton and expanded under Bush, was in fact an offensive weapons program in violation of treaties they had signed banning such activities.

The FBI knew as early as October 5th that the anthrax used in the attacks were derived from the Ames strain, a variety of anthrax commonly used in US military research, but did not publicly confirm this until October 25th. Yet on October 10th, five days after learning of the origin of the spores, the FBI allowed the original batch of Ames strain at Iowa State University to be destroyed, thus making their own investigation even more difficult.

What followed was an 8 year investigation of epic proportions, employing over 600,000 man hours in one of the largest investigations in the history of law enforcement. Yet despite this monumental effort, the investigation quickly began to focus on Steven Hatfill, a bioweapons expert who had worked with numerous government agencies and spent time as a civilian researcher at USAMRIID at Fort Detrick. Based on inuendo, unverified accusations, and pure speculation, Hatfill quickly became a “person of interest” in the case and the FBI spent years trying to pin the blame for the attacks on him.

Hatfill eventually won a lawsuit against the DOJ and FBI for violating his privacy and rdestroying his reputation, receiving 5.82 million dollars in a settlement with the government that was concluded on June 28, 2008.

By that time, the DOJ already had their sights set on Bruce Ivins, another USAMRIID researcher and someone with a history of mental problems. Within weeks of concluding their harassment of Hatfill, the FBI were preparing to make their case against Ivins. Ivins was barred from Fort Detrick and hospitalized as a potential threat to himself and others.

We are asked to believe that Ivins took his own life on July 27th, just two days before he and his attorney were to meet with FBI investigators. The cause of death is officially listed as overdose of Tylenol mixed with codeine, but there is no suicide note and no autopsy performed on his body.

The week after Ivins’ death, the FBI announced that they had achieved their “mission accomplished” moment and the case could be closed without them ever having to put the man they said did it on trial.

In the days after his death, a host of former colleagues went on record to say that they did not believe Ivins could have done it, and in subsequent years they were joined in their doubts by the editorial page of the Washington Post, prominent Maryland-based attorney Barry Kissin, and even US Senators Leahy, Specter and Grassley, who have all pointed out that the FBI’s case relies on circumstantial evidence and outright speculations, with nothing directly connecting Ivins to the crime.

In February of 2011, the National Academy of Sciences concluded a scientific investigation into the forensic case against Ivins, finding that the FBI had overstated the certainty that the anthrax used in the attacks came from Ivins’ flask.

Congressman Rush Holt even introduced a bill in Congress in 2009 to establish a congressional investigation into the attacks.

But despite the actual origins of the anthrax material in the heart of the American biowarfare industrial complex, and despite the widespread dissatisfaction with the way the FBI has declared the case closed, the anthrax attacks remain almost unmentioned in the war on terror narrative, and the 10th anniversary of these events pass almost unheralded in the media.

As law professor Francis Boyle, a bioweapons expert, told the Boiling Frogs podcast in 2010, this is because the anthrax attacks and their subsequent cover-up paint a very different picture about 9/11 and the war on terror than we have been led to believe.

Indeed, we must take an investigation into the nature of the anthrax attacks a part of a broader investigation into 9/11. Treated as one continuous crisis during that breathtaking month ten years ago, the anthrax scare helped to usher in a new era of bioterrorism and opened the door for the open development of a once covert biowarfare industry. That industry is now a multi-billion dollar program that has been grafted into the fabric of the defense budget, and spending on that program only continues to grow.

It was in the midst of the anthrax attacks, when Washington was paralyzed in responding to the threat of these deadly, weaponized spores, that the Patriot Act was passed, the single greatest evisceration of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights that has ever been passed at one time. Increasingly, we live in a police state whose noose is tightening around our necks, and all based on the charade of a mythical war on terror which has been constructed out of obfuscations, half-truths and outright lies.

And as we sit here 10 years later, we know precious little more about the anthrax attacks than we did at that time, except for the fact that the attacks originated not in a cave fortress in Afghanistan or in a mobile weapons lab in Baghdad, but from within the walls of America’s very own research labs. And for that very reason, the anthrax attacks will be relegated to a mere footnote in the war on terror, an also-ran of a story that just happens to be an openly admitted false flag attack, one that all sides concede was an inside job. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

It even made the mass media but we were all too preoccupied to ask the real questions.

 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

What? They want to test Anthrax vaccines on children? Wow, that's just nuts. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Dr. Meryl Nass is one of the leading experts on the anthrax vaccine, which is relatively obscure yet has an interesting history, with which Dr. Nass is very familiar.

Her interest in the anthrax vaccine goes back to 1988.

She was a member of Physicians for Social Responsibility (PSR) when students at the University of Massachusetts looking into the University's Pentagon contracts discovered a researcher who had previously worked at Fort Detrick and was doing work on anthrax.

"They thought this was probably germ warfare research and asked my group to look at it and help them understand it," she says.

She was tasked with the investigation.

"When I read the contract, I found even though it was titled a contract for improved anthrax vaccines, it actually had to do with some primitive genetic engineering of anthrax," she explains.

"I thought it was rather interesting and odd that the meaning of the contract had been hidden.

I thought I would just read a little bit more about anthrax and see what was going on with this government project."

Identifying Biological Warfare

Dr. Nass quickly made two discoveries that appeared important. One was that the anthrax epidemic that occurred in Rhodesia during its civil war (and had killed about 200 people) had completely different characteristics than all other anthrax epidemics.

The other was that the U.S. army actually had a mission statement, and had signed a treaty that specified the type of defense research allowed under the Biological Weapons Convention. Yet the army seemed to be transgressing its own mission statement and treaty… Dr. Nass felt these facts should be made public.

"I felt I had a responsibility to identify biological warfare," she says.

It seemed no one was really looking at epidemics to determine whether they were natural occurrences or deliberately caused. Dr. Nass believed there needed to be a methodology to make that determination in order to prevent biological warfare from being used.

"Up until then, if you used biological warfare nobody would be any wiser and you would get away with it without any consequences," she says.

So, in her spare time, she began creating a model for investigating epidemics. She eventually published a paper that dissected the Rhodesian epidemic, which she found was likely due to biological warfare. That paper also showed how you could look at different aspects of an epidemic to determine whether it was natural or not.

The Anthrax Vaccine

In 1997, the Defense Department announced it would vaccinate everybody in the military for anthrax. Dr. Nass, because of her familiarity with the anthrax literature, knew there were significant questions about the vaccine's safety and effectiveness. Animal studies had shown it to be rather ineffective. Questions had also been raised about its potential contribution to Gulf War Syndrome. Dr. Nass believes it's a viable candidate as one of the contributing factors.

As is typical, there were potential financial conflicts of interest at play, which Dr. Nass details in her interview, so to learn more, please listen to it in its entirety or read through the transcript.

Hundreds of military personnel began falling ill once the anthrax vaccine became routine, and many within the military began fighting the mandate. The movement culminated in no less than 13 congressional hearings on the various aspects of the anthrax vaccine program.

"In 2001, there was a memo going around the Pentagon for consideration of stopping the entire anthrax vaccine program because it had caused more problems for the military than they wanted to deal with at that point," she says.

Interestingly, anthrax does not appear to have ever been used against an army. There's evidence of it being used on civilian populations in at least three instances, but the vaccine itself is probably a far greater health threat to military personnel than the threat of being exposed to anthrax.



http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2011/11/22/dr-meryl-nass-on-anthrax-vaccine.aspx?e_cid=20111122_DNL_art_1 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground