Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

math investigarions

who's talking here?

4nTX 2
Zionist NightOwl 1
Bellarue 1
Hard working Mom 1
SleightOfHand 1
justcat 1
Mommyto3kiddos 1
RedMulch 1
Forever family x2 1
kapoocheeno 7
LitlJay 9
justforku 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Hard working Mom --- 15 years ago -

Reading the comments it appears there are enough parents to present to the humble isd board. They meet once per month on a Tuesday either first or second week. Get as many people to this meeting and one person represents all. We just did this at the end of the year. They wanted to change the grading system to 4,3,2,1 we can make a difference if we speak up. 

4nTX --- 15 years ago -

Let's do it! Who is a born leader and speaker? 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

Somebody ought to investigate Math. It's the cause of more nervous breakdowns than anything i know of........especially algebra 

justcat --- 15 years ago -

IDK...DS is doing great in 6th grade honor math. He was in the first group to do the IM..He did learn his multiplication table, they did minute min quizzes on it all the time..
I am not saying its the best by any means. DH and I questioned it when it was first introduced. But we saw the results and the lights really started clicking for DS when it was introduced. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 15 years ago -

lol @ RedMulch. I hear math also ensures that there will always be prayer in school. 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

My wife and I spent some time "investigating" investigations math today and are appalled.

Our daughter is in 1st grade and I don't want this feel-good bilge displacing her God-given talent at math! I will be contacting her campus (Woodland Hills Elem.) and if they have implemented this program, you can count us in.

We have 3 small children, so we can't both attend the board meeting, but she wants me to go.

She also wants me to volunteer to speak for the group because I am very good at public speaking. I will just need help assembling the argument so I can make the case.

J 

Forever family x2 --- 15 years ago -

My children are at WHE as well and my oldest is in 4th and has been doing investigations since Kinder. He is a straight A student and is faster than me at math. My 1st grader is just getting started but has not had any trouble with it yet, other than being bored because it is to easy.

It is a district wide program and I do not see them getting rid of it because a few parents complain. 

kapoocheeno --- 15 years ago -

I don't want this feel-good bilge displacing her God-given talent at math!

I'm curious... why exactly do you describe it this way? 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

Your oldest has gotten A's on Investigations tests. It's not a fair assessment of how he has learned, even though he is clearly bright.

A more honest assessment would be comparative tests between a large sample of students using investigations and traditional math.

This has been done, a la standardized testing and investigations has failed miserably every time. 

kapoocheeno --- 15 years ago -


This has been done, a la standardized testing and investigations has failed miserably every time.


I haven't seen this data but I'd like to. Please share. 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

I'm curious... why exactly do you describe it this way?

Her talent or the curriculum? :-)

quoting one of many sources:
The creators of IM (cambridge pointy-heads, it seems) recommend a text to teachers called "Beyond Arithmetic". In this book it says traditional elementary math
must be discarded because:
• Was "developed to meet the needs of the 19th century."
BA, Page 2
• Requires that students "memorize many facts,
procedures, definitions, and formulas." BA, Page 2
• "Focuses on learning a particular set of procedures for
addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division of
whole numbers, fractions, and decimals." BA, Page 2
• Results in "overpracticed students." BA, Page 3
• Ignores the fact that "today's students have an important
tool available to them: the calculator." BA, Page 77

The basic tenet of IM is that math should be discovered by the student at their own pace instead of "pushed" on them.

The world's most brilliant mathematicians would not have been so brilliant had they not been educated and instead been left to "discover" numbers and math. 

kapoocheeno --- 15 years ago -

So... because TERC recommends a book that contains those arguments, Math Investigations is "feel-good bilge"? 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

I haven't seen this data but I'd like to. Please share.

Here's a start.

There's lots more to be found if you do a little digging. 

kapoocheeno --- 15 years ago -

The basic tenet of IM is that math should be discovered by the student at their own pace instead of "pushed" on them.

The world's most brilliant mathematicians would not have been so brilliant had they not been educated and instead been left to "discover" numbers and math.


I responded before I saw your edit.

I think you overestimate the role discovery plays in the program. I'd suggest you sit down with your child's teacher or the math coach at your child's school and look over the materials. You might be surprised... 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

No, the idea that using bricks in the wall, your fingers, and stripes in the rug are a valid alternative to a pencil and paper is feel-good bilge.

The idea that a curriculum that has worked for scores of years and millions of children is no longer valid because it is harder for some than others is feel-good bilge.

IM is a natural progression from number sense, and I don't mind it being used. I don't want it displacing traditional math. I want my children to know their times tables. I want my kids to know how to count money and read a clock. 

kapoocheeno --- 15 years ago -

No, the idea that using bricks in the wall, your fingers, and stripes in the rug are a valid alternative to a pencil and paper is feel-good bilge.

The idea that a curriculum that has worked for scores of years and millions of children is no longer valid because it is harder for some than others is feel-good bilge.

IM is a natural progression from number sense, and I don't mind it being used. I don't want it displacing traditional math. I want my children to know their times tables. I want my kids to know how to count money and read a clock.


If this is what you think, then you should probably go visit your child's campus and look into it further. Like I said before, you might be surprised.

I'm just attempting to ease your mind some. :) 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

So far my daughter has been taught by the school to add horizontally. I had to teach her to stack the numbers.

I do intend to investigate the curriculum WHE is using fully before I become TOO enraged, but you can not convince me that IM, taught as it was intended to be taught, does not hinder students more than it helps.

This thread was started with the intention of organizing a protest to the school board.

Although the tone of the debate here has been excellent, it is off topic. There is a perfectly good debate about the evils and merits of IM here. 

kapoocheeno --- 15 years ago -


Although the tone of the debate here has been excellent, it is off topic.


Off topic? That sounds like a taunt.

0 

SleightOfHand --- 15 years ago -

Judging multiple states have tried then retracted math investigations, I do not see this as the ideal way of teaching our children 

Mommyto3kiddos --- 15 years ago -

I have been a teacher in 2 districts both of which strongly feel that being good at math is not simply being able to memorize tables but being able to explain why we arrive at the results we do. It's being able to solve formulas and being able to explain each step and being able to explain the why of how it works.

To many of our students just know how to get to an answer but have no freaking clue how or why the formula works and how it got them there.

Even worse is when you ask a child to solve a problem two ways. Most can't because they have been taught one way and one way only.

MI teaches fundamentals, and if you know the fundamentals you can not only solve the problem but know how you got there.

So who cares if my daughter can stack numbers and add? What's so wonderful about stacking? Who cares if she can tell time and know her tables if she does not know why or how numbers work.

I would really do your research before you complain about a program that teaches math from the bottom up. A program that takes a little longer but teaches our children fundamentals. It's no wonder we don't stack up to the rest of the world in math when we have parents who want our kids to just know how to stack numbers ,add and tell time, but who complain if our kids have to do some learning of the fundamentals.

Visit the school and see what great things the kids are doing with MI.

You say it should not replace traditional math, but correct me if I am wrong we are 20 something ranked worldwide in math??? Yes I see how well traditional math is working for us. Come on folks let's have our kids use their brains and let's stop being so scared of things that are not traditional. 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

At the risk of repeating myself, let me repeat myself:

"Although the tone of the debate here has been excellent, it is off topic. There is a perfectly good debate about the evils and merits of IM here."

Don't forget to watch the video of the little girl using IM to take 8 minutes solving a problem with no order of operations or method of organization or anything and get the wrong result, and then simply stack the numbers and get the correct result in one minute. 

kapoocheeno --- 15 years ago -

That video is misleading. I hate to repeat myself too, but if you really want to learn about what is going on at your child's school - go there and see for yourself. It's rather ridiculous to go to battle against a program you clearly don't understand. 

4nTX --- 15 years ago -

I don't get the logic there. There is no reason that a child can't understand why they are stacking certain numbers and why that works. Same for multiplication and division. Some of this "investigation" of math might be ok but not the whole program. And I don't see all the countries ahead of us (above #20) using math investigations. As a matter a fact, Singapore is the highest and their math program uses stacking and basic math. Mental math is a big part of their program too, as well as critical thinking and higher thinking skills. No math investigations there. 

Bellarue --- 15 years ago -

I have not scheduled a meeting with Wendy as of yet but will be willing to go if one is set up within our community. Please let me know. 

justforku --- 15 years ago -

Any math program that makes the children repeatedly make "tick marks" and arrays year after year so that they can visually see how multiplication and addition work is a waste of time. My children have wasted so much time making rows of dots in order to "show their work". There is no good basis for math facts, yet the kids are learning higher level geometry terms and calculating the area of rectangles in elementary school. Teach the basics first and go from there. 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

As I have already said, I am willing to lead the protest IF I JOIN IT. I have not decided to do as much. I am opposed to IM as it was intended to be taught by TERC. I need to see HISD's actual curriculum before I become too angry with them, so I have set up a meeting with my daughter's teacher and the school math lead this wed. 

LitlJay --- 15 years ago -

...and to the several PM'ers who have offered to babysit for us so that both my wife and I can go to the meeting: I REALLY appreciate the offers. They mean a lot to us! Unfortunately, 2 of our children are 14 months an 2 years in age. They may not do so well with a complete stranger cold turkey, even if you came to our house. Thanks for the offers, though! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground