Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

what do you think? right or wrong?

who's talking here?

Empty Nest 1
whatchamacallit 1
ambergris 1
quiettype 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
OH SNAP 2
doglady 1
RedMulch 1
Nebucasneezer 3
sweetscreaminmonkey 2
Rollinglettuce 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 15 years ago -

Was CPS justified in taking kids from shed?
Some say it was safer than area homes, but others disagree
By ANITA HASSAN
HOUSTON CHRONICLE
July 8, 2011, 9:24AM




As a family law attorney, Julie Ketterman has worked countless cases in which Child Protective Services took children away from parents for reasons that range from a family using an outhouse instead of indoor plumbing to keeping clothes in boxes instead of dressers.

Ketterman said CPS caseworkers deem those instances as unsafe and cramped living conditions, which is grounds for removal by the agency's standards.

"But to me, they are being picked up because they are poor," she said.

Legally, CPS cannot cite poverty as a reason to remove children from parental custody.

"But do they do it? Absolutely, all the time," said Ketterman, who has worked as a defense attorney in CPS cases in Houston for more than five years.

The case of Prince and Charlomane Leonard and their children is similar to many Ketterman said she has handled. Last month, CPS removed the couple's six children after agency caseworkers said that the small storage shed in east Houston the family was staying in contained unsafe living conditions.

The family lived inside the 12-by-25-foot shed for nearly four years, outfitting it with a wood-burning heater, AC unit and compost toilet while fetching water from a nearby spigot.

Recommendations
CPS officials say the Leonard children, ranging in age from 2 to 12, were not removed because of poverty reasons. But CPS spokeswoman Estella Olguin on Thursday would not provide a more detailed explanation of why the agency removed the children. Olguin would not say why caseworkers believed the Leonards' home was deemed unsafe.

An attorney assigned to the children could not be reached for comment. A court hearing in the case is scheduled for Aug. 15, when CPS is expected to recommend what the parents should do to improve their living conditions.

The Leonards, married for 14 years, said they were given a petition citing allegations that their children were being physically abused because the couple was not providing them with a clean or stable living environment.

The parents said while their home was not ideal, their children were happy, healthy and loved.

Facing economic hardships, the family felt forced to save money by living in the shed instead of on the street or in a shelter.

When children are removed from their parents' homes, CPS must provide evidence the children are in imminent danger, Ketterman said.

"If there was no safety issue to their health, then there is no legal reason to take them away," she said.

Chris Branson, a Houston family law attorney who primarily deals with CPS cases, said the Leonard children should not have be taken away because they were living in conditions others might not find fit for themselves.

"If it is simply a case in which these people were poor and did not meet the standards of a caseworker, it is just flat wrong," he said.

Olguin said the agency strives to work with parents in need and to make changes in homes where kids are removed so the children can go back. Prince Leonard and his wife say CPS caseworkers visited their home once without offering the family any help.

Ketterman said CPS often wrongly removes children from homes and places them in what might seem like a better environment. She said this often leads to children not wanting to go back home if their parents regain custody.

"It's really putting a wedge between some of these kids and their parents," Ketterman said.

'Not a home'
But not everyone agrees that CPS erred in its decision.

Robert M. Gilmore Sr., president of Real Urban Ministry, a Houston agency committed to helping the needy, said while it is unfortunate the children were taken away from the Leonards, CPS was justified.

"This (storage facility) is a business establishment," he said. "It is not a home."

Toby Hill, who owns the boat and RV storage facility where the Leonards live, said the shed was almost a better option for the family than anything in the neighborhood.

"Even though it's not the Taj Mahal, it's safer for these kids," said Hill, who grew up in the neighborhood and moved his family after he said crime became rampant in the area.

He said the Leonards were good parents who raised their children to be smart and respectful. While Hill didn't completely endorse the family living in the storage shed, he said it was unfair that their children were taken.

"They were such a close-knit family, and all they knew was each other," Hill said.

Misses singing to kids
Charlomane Leonard said it pains her every day to be away from her children — Sabrina, 12; Prince Leonard II, 10; Raheem, 8; Saleem, 7; Abdullah, 4; and 2-year-old Jamil. The children have been placed with her parents.

Thursday was especially hard because it was Saleem's birthday.

The couple said they used some of their alloted six hours per week to see the children to deliver their son a present and birthday cake. Charlomane said she missed her usual routine of singing and kissing her children on the morning of their birthdays, which she has never missed for any of her kids.

"I hope they (CPS) do something soon," she said. "Because I know there is another birthday coming up."

anita.hassan@chron.com



Read more: http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/side/7644302.html#ixzz1RYWtqHcL 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

to keeping clothes in boxes instead of dressers.

OMG.....i threw out my dresser and got shelves with baskets for my clothes (socks, undies, tshirts, etc) Will i be removed from my home?? LOL

Yes, she is wrong in my opinion. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

Ugh. This is why CPS is dumb. Maybe instead of yanking the kids away from the parents, they could have found them temporary housing TOGETHER. It's not like the parents were living in a nice house and making the kids sleep in the shed. This family obviously needs help. These parents seem to really love their kids and vice versa. They shouldn't have been split up, and to only give the family 6 hours a week to be together is just cruel. 

Empty Nest --- 15 years ago -

Absolutely wrong! 

Nebucasneezer --- 15 years ago -

They are certainly better off with their parents in a shed (as long as it is sanitary) than with a stranger in a mansion. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 15 years ago -

see that is what i am thinking too.. help the parents dont tear them away.. the parents are trying.. they are not homeless or abused kids.. they were a happy family.. i thought it was sad when i first read it... 

whatchamacallit --- 15 years ago -

Just another case of the government deciding what is best for the citizens, at the citizens peril! 

Nebucasneezer --- 15 years ago -

Just another case of the government deciding what is best for the citizens, at the citizens peril!

Dang right!! Copulate the gubment! 

Rollinglettuce --- 15 years ago -

This is awful. These children were obviously loved and cared for. 

Nebucasneezer --- 15 years ago -

The government would rather you be dependant on them!! 

ambergris --- 15 years ago -

AN UPDATE:

Good Samaritan/Family of 6 kids 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

I just saw that article. How wonderful of someone to do that. I love happy endings! 

quiettype --- 15 years ago -

That is awesome! What a wonderful person to do this for the family. 

doglady --- 15 years ago -

How nice of this person to donate the home for them! And how terrible for someone to take their children away, who are obviously loved and cared for by their parents! Wonder why they can't see the people that are cheating on food stamps and having 6 kids just to get more money! They are the ones that need to lose their children.
I am very happy for this family and wish them well!!! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 15 years ago -

terrible decision, but thankfully a happy ending-as a side note, though, it's too bad people with no money have 6 children- 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground