Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Why we like Atlas Shrugged

who's talking here?

ukchristine 1
wayward1 2
Hiro Protagonist 1
Warren Peace 4
voice of reason 1
JohnLynch 3
Work in Progress 10
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
LiveFreeOrDie 3
Mabs 1
Dorothy Parker 5
horseymomma 1
BiggieSmalls 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Since there seems to be some confusion, I'm going to quote from Atlas Shrugged some of the ideas that resonate with people:

“...the United States. This country was the only country in history born, not of chance and blind tribal warfare, but as a rational product of man's mind.”
— Francisco d'Anconia

“...through all the generations of political extortion, it was not the looting bureaucrats who had taken the blame, but the chained industrialists, not the men who peddled legal flavors, but the men who were forced to buy them; and through all those generations of crusades against corruption, the remedy had always been, not the liberating of the victims, but the granting of wider powers for extortion to the extortionists. The only guilt of the victims, he thought, had been that they accepted it as guilt.”
— Hank Rearden



“Wealth is the product of man's capacity to think.”
— Francisco d'Anconia

“...no human being can hold on another a claim demanding that he wipe himself out of existence.”

“...the man who damns money has obtained it dishonorably; the man who respects it has earned it.”

“...when men live by trade... it is the best product that wins, the best performance, the man of best judgment and highest ability...”
— Francisco d'Anconia

“Money is made... made by the effort of every honest man, each to the extent of his ability. An honest man is one who knows that he can't consume more than he has produced.”
— Francisco d'Anconia

“When one acts on pity against justice, it is the good whom one punishes for the sake of the evil; when one saves the guilty from suffering, it is the innocent whom one forces to suffer.”
— Hank Rearden

“The only proper purpose of a government is to protect man's rights, which means: to protect him from physical violence... The only proper functions of a government are: the police, to protect you from criminals; the army, to protect you from foreign invaders; and the courts, to protect your property and contracts from breach or fraud by others, to settle disputes by rational rules, according to objective law.”
— John Galt 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

How do you feel about her stance on abortion and atheism?

and altruism for that matter... 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

How do you feel about her stance on abortion and atheism?

and altruism for that matter...


Of course I'm against abortion and I'm not an atheist. And I ABSOLUTELY believe in altruism.

I'm not an objectivist, not even close. But I did agree with her views on capitalism and the basic problems inherent in a "looting" mentality within a nation. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

I think she's kinda sexy.

0 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

I just find it ironic and sorta hypocritical for the people who are singing her praises for a fiction book to ignore who she actually was as a person.

A lot of folks laugh at the L. Ron Hubbard followers, and yet, to me, this is the EXACT same thing. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

and altruism for that matter... 

Altruism is not the same as government welfare if that is what you are thinking, pure altruism is giving without regard to reward or the benefits that recognition of the giving may bring. 

voice of reason --- 15 years ago -

I'm not an objectivist, not even close. But I did agree with her views on capitalism and the basic problems inherent in a "looting" mentality within a nation.


'atlas shrugged,' an homage to capitalistic greed. funny how the teabaggers hold ayn rand as 'it's' heroine, unknowing or uncaring that she was a staunch atheist, advocate for abortion and sexual hedonism. quite the role model for the so-called 'religious right.' lol

i always find it amusing that the right is all for a concentration of the majority of the nation's wealth in the hands of a few. just like the middle east. especailly when we are currently seeing how that economic setup has worked for them. rave on. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Why is it ironic or hypocritical to agree with ideas in her book? She laid out her philosophy (or more accurately, beats the reader over the head with it)in Atlas Shrugged.

You can accept or reject any of the ideas therein. That does not make one a hypocrite. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

quite the role model for the so-called 'religious right.' lol

lol...i see that you're still spewing that false info

That does not make one a hypocrite.

they don't understand what a hypocrtie is...they misunderstand or don't know the definition 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

Why is it ironic or hypocritical to agree with ideas in her book? She laid out her philosophy (or more accurately, beats the reader over the head)in Atlas Shrugged.

You can accept or reject any of the ideas therein. That does not make one a hypocrite.


If someone has a strong stance against something like abortion, yet, their poster child for captialism was a staunch supporter for abortion, that just doesn't seem right to me. 

BiggieSmalls --- 15 years ago -

JohnLynch --- 1 min ago - quote - hide comments

i see that you're still spewing that false info


Yeah like you've never done that before yourself? Oh wait; you have....nevermind. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

If someone has a strong stance against something like abortion, yet, their poster child for captialism was a staunch supporter for abortion, that just doesn't seem right to me. 


She definitely is not the poster child of capitalism.. (that would be George Washington) but even a broken clock is right twice a day!! 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

If someone has a strong stance against something like abortion, yet, their poster child for captialism was a staunch supporter for abortion, that just doesn't seem right to me.

It would only be hypocritical if someone made her the "poster child" for the pro-life movement. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

It would only be hypocritical if someone made her the "poster child" for the pro-life movement.

be careful...you don't want to confuse her 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

And a quote from a looter:

"It's your sin if I suffer! It's your moral failure! I'm your brother, therefore I'm your responsibility, but you've failed to supply my wants, therefore you're guilty!" James Taggert 

ukchristine --- 15 years ago -

Does captialism and abortion always go together? Aren't they different things? 

wayward1 --- 15 years ago -

Rand's views are tantamount to libertarianism. Its concepts seem attractive to some until you see the challenges that come with it. Major government dis-involvment means: No gun control, no opposition to abortion, few employment laws, few environmental laws, gays can marry, etc. This is why these people are not more popular. This is why Ron Paul get's the least camera time at a debate. People want SOME of libertarianism, but they don't want ALL of libertarianism. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

People want SOME of libertarianism, but they don't want ALL of libertarianism.

Very true. But I MIGHT be able to live with some of it to simply make government less powerful. MIGHT be able to. I have to think about it. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 15 years ago -

"It's your sin if I suffer! It's your moral failure! I'm your brother, therefore I'm your responsibility, but you've failed to supply my wants, therefore you're guilty!"


Dear lord that's trite. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Dear lord that's trite.

Her writing left a lot to be desired. That's very true. I've heard that Fountainhead is better with its subtlety, but I haven't read it. 

horseymomma --- 15 years ago -

Fountainhead doesn't ring as true as Atlas Shrugged does. And yes, I've read both; I've read all of her works, actually. At times, I threw Atlas Shrugged at the wall because I disagreed with some of the points so much that I just had to be violent in some way.

Just because you support some of Ayn Rand's theories doesn't make you pro-abortion or even an objectivist.

On the same note, being a Libertarian doesn't mean you support ALL of Libertarian ideals; just as a Republican does not have to support all Republican ideals.

~Who is John Galt?~ 

wayward1 --- 15 years ago -

On the same note, being a Libertarian doesn't mean you support ALL of Libertarian ideals; just as a Republican does not have to support all Republican ideals.

Well, yes. Libertarianism isn't about taking sides on the issues we all take sides on. It's more about not having issues for the government to be involved in. Libertarians have personal views on say, abortion or gun control. But they don't think the governmnent should be involved in them. Their issue is to not have issues for the government. The people should work out these details, not a central government. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

Well, yes. Libertarianism isn't about taking sides on the issues we all take sides on. It's more about not having issues for the government to be involved in. Libertarians have personal views on say, abortion or gun control. But they don't think the governmnent should be involved in them. Their issue is to not have issues for the government. The people should work out these details, not a central government.

I could MAYBE get on board with the liberatarians except for abortion. I DO think that it is murder of another person's body, therefore government SHOULD make it illegal.

And I'd have to REALLY think about drugs and legality. I haven't been convinced that simply making them legal would help anything. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

On the same note, being a Libertarian doesn't mean you support ALL of Libertarian ideals; just as a Republican does not have to support all Republican ideals.


I don't get how that is so hard for people to deal with and understand. People are individuals and I doubt any party represents anyone 100%. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

I don't get how that is so hard for people to deal with and understand. People are individuals and I doubt any party represents anyone 100%.

But do you ever get the feeling that some people change their views to be more in line with their political party?

For instance, there is no denying that both parties are becoming more progressive, just at different speeds. Are people buying into progressivism, not because they actually believe in it, but because their party tells them to?

The tea party seems to be the backlash against the progressive movement within both parties. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

But do you ever get the feeling that some people change their views to be more in line with their political party?


Yes I do feel that people feel certain ways because their party tells them too and that for me explains the support for abortion. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

that for me explains the support for abortion.

I've often suspected that as well. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

People want SOME of libertarianism, but they don't want ALL of libertarianism. 

Very true. But the older I get, the more libertarian I become. I used to hate libertarian candidates because they had so many strong ideals, yet they came across as kooky with their drug legalization advocacy. I never imagined I would support such a thing. But I've now arrived there. Most people who try drugs do not become addicts. They try it out of curiosity and realize the benefits are neither valuable nor sustainable. But the crimes associated with an illegal drug trade are out of hand and there's no indication that winning a drug war is even possible. We're flushing resources and lives down the toilet and have to try something else.

I'm now of the opinion that the most productive tactic seems to be decriminalizing drugs to take the profit off the streets where rules and agreements are enforced with guns. Decriminalize it, legalize it, regulate it, and tax the hell out of it.

But back to the topic - I think Ayn Rand is not the best poster child for libertarian viewpoints. She deserves a spot among the heroes of the movement, but a more significant figure is economist Milton Friedman. He was a better writer and stuck with non-fiction. For anyone interested, his top two works are Free To Choose, and Capitalism and Freedom. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

Libertarianism isn't about taking sides on the issues we all take sides on. It's more about not having issues for the government to be involved in. Libertarians have personal views on say, abortion or gun control. But they don't think the governmnent should be involved in them. Their issue is to not have issues for the government. The people should work out these details, not a central government. 

I mostly agree, but I'd like to tailor the explanation a bit differently. Libertarians firmly believe that each person has the right to live their life in any way they choose so long as they respect the equal rights of others. This means that some government intervention is necessary to resolve the grievances that occur when this line is crossed. This is also why libertarians are divided on abortion. Some believe it's a personal freedom, while others believe it infringes on the rights of the baby.

There is room for God among libertarians because they believe in natural rights - rights that exist before governments were created.

Some examples of the line where government intervention is necessary would be the need for government run law enforcement and courts that enforce contracts and criminal laws. Another example is traffic laws. You may have the natural right to speed through an intersection, but not when it comes at the cost of risking the safety and health of others. To provide for safety and security of the people, a strong military is also a must.

But taking from the rich to give to the poor is disrespectful to the notion of individual liberty. Libertarians see that as theft.

It should be clear, libertarians aren't necessarily opposed to taxation, they just oppose certain uses of tax money. A strong libertarian is more economically conservative than most Republicans. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

But do you ever get the feeling that some people change their views to be more in line with their political party?


Yes I do feel that people feel certain ways because their party tells them too and that for me explains the support for abortion.



Most people I know, support things because of their own personal beliefs, not because of a political party.

I've always had a liberal streak, but, the older I get, the more experiences I have, the more liberal I become.

I wasn't political at all before 2004...and I turned 18 in 1991. So, that's a lot of years of not really getting involved in any debates or worrying about what was happening or which party was doing what.

That being said, I've always been pro-choice. Before I had kids and after. It has nothing to do with my political leanings. I believe that the choice to have an abortion is just that...a choice and when someone makes that choice, it's none of my business. 

LiveFreeOrDie --- 15 years ago -

People want SOME of libertarianism, but they don't want ALL of libertarianism. 


When it comes to national politics I am very Libertarian. I think our government was set up that way.
"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."

But when it comes to State politics I become very much a "conservative republican."
(states rights)

A true libertarian believes in very limited government interference even at the state level. 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

That being said, I've always been pro-choice.

Is this the primary issue that results in defining yourself as a liberal?

What about on economic issues? More liberal or more conservative? 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

That being said, I've always been pro-choice.

Is this the primary issue that results in defining yourself as a liberal?

What about on economic issues? More liberal or more conservative?


What about it? You're quoting my response to WhyWhyWhy and Cruella....lol. Like I said, my being pro-choice isn't political.

I define myself as liberal because I disagree with the Republicans on many core issues.

I don't agree with huge defense spending and tax cuts for the rich. I don't believe privatizing everything under the sun is in the best interest of the people of this country. Look at how medical care is done because of that.

I don't agree that marriage has to be "defined"...if two consenting adults are in love, why shouldn't they be able to marry regardless of gender?

I don't agree with many right wingers views on religion. I don't believe we are a "Christian Nation"....I believe we are a nation made up of MANY beliefs and cultures and not one of them should be put before another, regardless of the "majority."

I believe in a single payer system...I'd rather pay the high premium we pay now in taxes and have everything covered as opposed to the BS you go through with insurance companies and constant contract changes...it sucks.

I'm not a fan of the death penalty or locking away someone who had marijuana on them for life! I think the whole "war on drugs" debacle needs to end and we need to become proactive instead of reactive...

Have I provided enough examples or would you like more? 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

That being said, I've always been pro-choice

you're not really pro-choice...you're pro abortion used as birth control...pro-choice doesn't give anyone the right to harm someone else

I'm not a fan of the death penalty

but you have no problem with giving an unborn child the death penalty...and they don't even get a trial...that is what is called a hypocritical stance 

Warren Peace --- 15 years ago -

Have I provided enough examples or would you like more? 

That's sufficient to convince me you may be more of a libertarian than you thought you were.


I don't agree with huge defense spending and tax cuts for the rich.

Neither do libertarians. They want a tax rate that's fair for all income earners. In fact, Ron Paul advocates to do away with the income tax altogether. Instead he seems to favor consumption taxes rather than productivity taxes. Makes sense to me. Candidates like Ron Paul favor lowering defense spending by shutting down unnecessary military bases and resisting the temptation to get involved in their domestic issues. Neither Republicans or Democrats share this position of yours.


I don't believe privatizing everything under the sun is in the best interest of the people of this country. Look at how medical care is done because of that.

Our medical care system is better described as corporatism and has not been subject to market forces in my lifetime. They've bought out our politicians and there's no reason to believe that true private sector market forces which rely on competition are at play.


I don't agree that marriage has to be "defined"...if two consenting adults are in love, why shouldn't they be able to marry regardless of gender?

Agreed. Most libertarians would agree as well. What you believe is perfectly aligned with libertarian principles.


I don't agree with many right wingers views on religion. I don't believe we are a "Christian Nation"....I believe we are a nation made up of MANY beliefs and cultures and not one of them should be put before another, regardless of the "majority."

You're again siding with libertarians here. You might want to start looking at their principles with an open mind.


I believe in a single payer system...I'd rather pay the high premium we pay now in taxes and have everything covered as opposed to the BS you go through with insurance companies and constant contract changes...it sucks.

As do I. But I believe the single payer should be the consumer, not a collective group of taxpayers who subsidize the unproductive and unhealthy lifestyles of others. I have room in my heart to give handouts to the helpless, but I have no room for subsidizing the clueless. Rates for healthcare should vary by risk factors. Alcoholics for example should pay more for liver transplants than non-alcoholics.


I'm not a fan of the death penalty or locking away someone who had marijuana on them for life! I think the whole "war on drugs" debacle needs to end and we need to become proactive instead of reactive...

If you're open to allowing States to decide for themselves whether or not to allow these things, you just might be a libertarian. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground