Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should insanity be a legal defense?

who's talking here?

Mr Mark 1
rEVOLution 9
JohnLynch 2
SighFiGurl 2
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 6
Puss In Boots 5
Mabs 5
In AbsentiaW 3
Dorothy Parker 2
TapRoot 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should insanity be a legal defense?

Should someone who commits murder be able to claim insanity? I mean really aren't all murders insane? I can't imagine that any human could intentionally take another's life without being insane. The only exception being self defense of course.

Yes, there are truly insane people who need psychiatric help not prison. Vote
 
 40.0% (8)
No, if your that sick you need to be locked up or killed. Vote
 
 60.0% (12)
Other Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Should someone who commits murder be able to claim insanity? I mean really aren't all murders insane? I can't imagine that any human could intentionally take another's life without being insane. The only exception being self defense of course. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

This is another area where political correctness has gone too far. Time and time again Dr.s are bought and paid for or just ignorant in testifying that someone is insane. Of course they are insane, they murdered someone and should be put to death themselves. I can't figure out how it's even a question when the trial is not about "Did they kill someone" but why they killed someone. In that situation, where it's unquestionable that they murdered someone, night night buddy. Insanity is no a murder for free card. Neither should age be an issue. If the intent is to kill, other than in self defense then mental capacity or age should not be a question. 

TapRoot --- 15 years ago -

It should not carry weight for a determination of guilt. But it should be considered during sentencing. 

In AbsentiaW --- 15 years ago -

Should insanity be a legal defense.
1) He voted for Obama
2) He was gay.
3) He was a Democrat.
Case close pure insanity.


Let's delete #2 and add Tipsyhic.
Gay = insane? Hardly.

Being a SA poster might be though. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

But it should be considered during sentencing.

How so?

I just don't see that keeping someone alive who has committed an obvious act of violence should be kept alive simply because some doctor categorized the person as crazy. Isn't it more humane to put them to sleep instead of locking them in a cage, medicated, locking their murders inside their heads for the rest of their life? Insane or not, those images of murder never leave their minds, locking them up and keeping them alive is not the politically correct humane thing to do IMO. 

In AbsentiaW --- 15 years ago -

Should insanity be a legal defense.
1) He voted for Obama
2) He was gay.
3) He was a Democrat.
Case close pure insanity.


Let's delete #2 and add Tipsyhic.
Gay = insane? Hardly.

Being a SA poster might be though. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

But it should be considered during sentencing. 


Do you think that some people who murder others are insane and others are not? 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Treating the mentally ill or those with sublevel intelligence the same as normal adults is a sure sign of barbarism. the mentally retarded or mentally ill should not be considered so morally culpable that they deserve the ultimate punishment. Those that deserve the severist punishment are those who are the most culpable criminals who commit the most heinous crimes.

Absolutely, true insanity should be considered in sentencing. If not, we are just players in a Mad Max kind of world, where the strongest and most cunning survive. 

In AbsentiaW --- 15 years ago -

Just what is the legal definition of criminal insanity? I always thought it was the inability to determine right from wrong at the time of the crime. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I just don't see that keeping someone alive who has committed an obvious act of violence should be kept alive simply because some doctor categorized the person as crazy. Isn't it more humane to put them to sleep instead of locking them in a cage, medicated, locking their murders inside their heads for the rest of their life? Insane or not, those images of murder never leave their minds, locking them up and keeping them alive is not the
politically correct humane thing to do IMO. 



I agree 100%. I think we say I am so sorry this happened to you and that you are so tormented but you cannot live with us anymore. We are going to give you something to help you sleep and make this all go away. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

My belief is that no sane person could or would intentionally murder someone. That makes all murderers insane. Do we house them all and pay for them to live for the next 50 years in a cage? Is that your definition of compassion? 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

".....But real barbarism begins when no one can any longer judge or know that what he does is barbaric."

~ Ryszard Kapuscinski 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

".....But real barbarism begins when no one can any longer judge or know that what he does is barbaric."



That kind of conflicts with your defense of the mentally ill. 

TapRoot --- 15 years ago -

Young kids that are mentally ill who commit murder should not receive the death penalty. This guy is older and the circumstances of the crime are abhorrent. He's a great death penalty candidate.

A mentally ill person being used by others to commit a murder would be circumstances that would not warrant the death penalty in my opinion. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

No it does not.

"No one" refers to society. And in this case means that a society which chooses to ignore its mentally ill or treat them on the same playing field as sane individuals....has already become barbaric, but doesn't know it yet. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

If they are so mentally ill that they murder someone it's bye bye time imo. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

My belief is that no sane person could or would intentionally murder someone.

What do we label the invasion of Iraq which to date has killed more than a million people in that region? It's documented that it wasn't in self defense, it wasn't national security. 

TapRoot --- 15 years ago -

I disagree with your premise revolution.

It was clear from the beginning that our decision makers were not 100% certain that Iraq had stockpiles of WMDs. But if that's the standard for a decision to use military force, we might as well have a defensive only military. No nation is truly transparent in their intentions. So decision makers have to rely on a preponderance of intelligence information. And that information from intelligence information from around the world was that it was highly likely he did have weapons of mass destruction. There was no theory that he had used them before - it is a historical fact. He used them against the Kurds, the Shia, and the Iranians.

He had a weapons program to make them. There's no doubt about that. Every nation has agreed to this point. The disagreement was about how far he had gotten in those programs. That is why inspections were imposed on him.

The oil for food scandal served as evidence that he was breaking out of the imposed limitations put on him. Shipments of WMD materials to Iraq were discovered as part of this scandal.

Clearly he was a bad guy with bad intentions and needed to be removed. He was not being contained. He was evading every attempt to contain him.

So your comparison of the mentally ill deserving the death penalty to the decision makers tasked with our national security deciding to go to war in Iraq is a glaring politically motivated tactic - and a poorly conceived one at that. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

I mean really aren't all murders insane?

nope, they aren't


and root, excellent post 

Mr Mark --- 15 years ago -

As long as there are crazy people doing crazy things as a result of being in a circumstance beyond their control, insanity is a legitimate plea. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

It was clear from the beginning that our decision makers were not 100% certain that Iraq had stockpiles of WMDs.

I wish I could agree with you because that was a good post, well said. We just see things differently is all.

I don't want to make this thread about that, I was just using it as an example. However, I have to disagree with what you said because we knew exactly what Iraq had, what they had used and what they had left because we not only sold them the weapons they had, we monitored their usage. What's even more sad about that is that some of them were used on our own troops in the first Iraq war. But what's killing most of our troops and anyone in the region right now is the United States deliberate use of Depleted Uranium munitions supposedly aimed at our enemies but tragically is killing our troops as well.As for a nation having WMD's there are unstable nations all over the world who have WMD's and we've done nothing to thwart their use of them. Because they don't have anything we need. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

I mean really aren't all murders insane?

nope, they aren't


Ditto. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

I do not believe everyone who kills someone is insane. Some are just plain EVIL, but their brain works just fine. 

JohnLynch --- 15 years ago -

because we knew exactly what Iraq had, what they had used and what they had left because we not only sold them the weapons they had, we monitored their usage.

not a true statement 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

And someone who is an intelligent and calculating serial killer isn't the same as a schizophrenic. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

[i]And someone who is an intelligent and calculating serial killer isn't the same as a schizophrenic.

Yep. Remember Ted Bundy? Good looking, sly as a cat, calculating and intelligent. Lived a double "normal" life apart from abducting and killing women all across the country. 

Dorothy Parker --- 15 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

because we knew exactly what Iraq had, what they had used and what they had left because we not only sold them the weapons they had, we monitored their usage.

not a true statement


Actually it is... U.S. officials, including Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld, played a leading role in building up Iraq's military in the 1980s when Iraq was using chemical weapons, a newspaper reports.

It was Rumsfeld, now defense secretary and then a special presidential envoy, whose December 1983 meeting with Saddam Hussein led to the normalization of ties between Washington and Baghdad, according to the Washington Post.

The cozy relationship was an effort to build a regional bulwark against America's enemies in Iran.

The newspaper says a review of a large tranche of government documents reveals that the administrations of President Reagan and the first President Bush both authorized providing Iraq with intelligence and logistical support, and okayed the sale of dual use items — those with military and civilian applications — that included chemicals and germs, even anthrax and bubonic plague.

Surely we wouldn't provide a nation with WMD's and then just let them run rampant with no oversight? Or would we? 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

Well, except that Son of Sam was supposedly a schizophrenic. I don't know if he wasn't caught because of luck, or because he had it together enough to cover his tracks. 

Exactly, there are all kinds of combinations and it is up to the system to correctly interpret these combos, unfortunately, like everything...the system is flawed. What to do, what to do. LOL. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Exactly, there are all kinds of combinations and it is the system to correctly interpret these combos, unfortunately, like everything...the system is flawed. What to do, what to do. LOL.

Create 40,000 new laws protecting us from insane people. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

You sure it's not 40,001? LOL. Aha! It's the system that's insane! Lock it up! Better yet, let's give it a lethal injection of something. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Actually it needs an injection of common sense, accountability, and humanity. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Rev....stop hijacking theads with your war rhetoric. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

Good luck with any of those three rev. They aren't collectively achieved imo. It starts with individuals, and I don't see it in the foreseeable future. Sad really. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Rev....stop hijacking theads with your war rhetoric.

Write your representative in Washington and have them create a law that would prevent me from speaking freely when and where I want and then re-post that. lol

Don't like my comments? Adam has provided each and everyone of us a "hide comments" button for those who are offended by others comments. My "hijacking" has relevance in this thread when it's exposing true insanity. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Nah. I am not offended by your hijacking. Just wondering why you don't have the cojones to start your own thread if you wish to discuss the topic.

I think you should visit the "Chihuahua" thread and talk about the Iraq war.

Then go to the "Need a good alterations person" and talk about fluoride in the water. 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

Nah. I am not offended by your hijacking. Just wondering why you don't have the cojones to start your own thread if you wish to discuss the topic.

Because my first mention of the war was to point out that the definition of "insanity" should never be used as a legal defense when those who are making the laws are themselves insane.

If you'd like to attack my manhood some more maybe a new thread should be created for that. lol 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

I saw on the news that Arizona has one the toughest insanity pleas. And Agitator, I always heard the same thing as you.

To be declared legally insane, you cannot know the difference between right and wrong at the time of the crime. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground