Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

English majors & teachers - grammar question (test question)

who's talking here?

likeke 1
Going off air 2
Mabbers 1
Eliza2 1
Sharpcat 1
Diamom 3
POTUS 2
zapper007 1
voice of reason 1
paintingstars 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Diamom --- 16 years ago -

My DD's assignment states:

A clause is a group of words with a subject & a predicate; it is used as part of a sentence. An independent clause can stand alone as a sentence. A dependent clause cannot stand alone as a sentence. Dependent clauses often begin with connecting words such as before, after, because, when & although.

Portion of the test says: Rewrite each item, adding either a dependent clause to an independent clause OR an independent clause to a dependent clause.

#1. "You will be freed from this prison"

My daughter added a phrase to make the sentence read - "You will be freed from this prison", the prince said to her.

My DH & I feel the first part was an independent clause and what my DD added was an dependent clause.

This was marked wrong. Why? 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Because they're both complete sentences. 

Diamom --- 16 years ago -

The prince said to her

That's a complete sentence all by itself? 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

The second part she added is not dependent as per the definition given.

In order for it to fit, you would have to be able to substitute the comma with "before, after, because, when & although" and still have the entire sentence make sense. 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

"You will be freed from this prison BECAUSE the prince said to her."

Doesn't make sense. 

paintingstars --- 16 years ago -

the prince said to her.

Ok...from my perspective....

This would actually be an independent clause, as this could stand on it's own as a sentence. Whereas, a dependent clause would not be able to stand on its own as a sentence.

What about-- You will be freed from this prison, after you knit a pair of socks for all the guards.

See... After you knit a pair of socks for all the guards....that could not stand alone as a sentence. But yours..
the prince said to her... although an awkward sentence, it could stand by itself. And one on those pesky transition words for the dependent clauses wasn't used.

Although, I do like your sentence much better! For me, knitting would be cruel and unusual punishment! :) 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

u r asking the wrong person


lolx12

have u seen my posts? 

Eliza2 --- 16 years ago -

further break down The=article prince=subject said=verb to her=prepositional phrase (maybe adverbial prepositional phrase because it modifies the verb) 

Sharpcat --- 16 years ago -

What about-- You will be freed from this prison; after you knit a pair of socks for all the guards.

Punctuation rule:
independent dependent
dependent, independent

You will be released from prison if you serve your time.

If you serve your time, you will be released from prison. 

paintingstars --- 16 years ago -

thanks Sharpcat...I knew that my punctuation was rusty! ;) 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

"You will be freed from this prison after he!! freezes over."
is a correct answer. 

paintingstars --- 16 years ago -

as well it should be for many criminals, voice of reason! 

likeke --- 16 years ago -

it wasn't in flocabulary 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

All i can say is...
ENJOY!!!

this is my fav vid
 

Diamom --- 16 years ago -

Yes, this is technically a complete sentence with a subject & verb but not a complete thought which is why I would consider it dependent 

zapper007 --- 16 years ago -

You will be freed from this prison, when everyone on KU likes everyone else...lol 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground