Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Hardwood or laminate?

who's talking here?

Carla 1
whatchamacallit 1
june 1
Fallon 1
My 3 and Me 1
Mom's Taxi Service 1
Scottie's Hottie 1
Nightstorm 1
Paige Paige 3
JusticeForAll 2
jtcitrus 1
ladyjane 1
Shenanigans 1
Grumpy 1
Aah Grasshoppa 1
needrnr 1
Work in Progress 4
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
~ MARY C ~ 1
dk156 1
midland 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Okay, I need some opinions. Perhaps a realtor could weigh in?

We really need to replace the carpeting in the house, but I don't know whether to go with real hardwood or if we could get away with laminate, or perhaps engineered hardwood. We are not moving any time soon, but we want to make all changes in light of resale value.

We are in a very modest sized home. If the sale price matters, pm me for that.

Also keep in mind that we have two small boys who will be rough on whatever flooring we decide to go with.

I'm hoping that laminate is ok, because it is sooooooo much more affordable, and I could use what we save to update other parts of the house. 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

Alli, I am not a realtor and I don't have laminate or wood floors. I have been stalking HAR and looking at houses for a year. I will begin that project again after the holidays.

Every single thing I have looked at, even new, has had laminate. I have yet to see an actual wood floor. Even the new patio homes we looked at in Graystone Hills were laminate and they were well over 300K. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

real wood has a better resale value, but, it is SOOO expensive!

We have engineered oak in our house and I love it! It doesn't look like laminate (some laminates are REALLY cheap/cheesy looking) but, it's cheaper than real wood. It was in the house when we bought it and considering we have 5 kids and two dogs, it's held up pretty well!

There are some really nice laminates out there, you just have to look...if choosing laminate frees up money to update other areas, I'd say go with laminate. The biggest areas people want remodeled are bathrooms and kitchens...(and if you have linoleum flooring in either area, replace it with tile...that is a HUGE selling point for folks!)

Good luck with everything! I love home projects! :) 

midland --- 16 years ago -

DO NOT GET REAL WOOD! It dents in with pets and and especially with kids! You will not see your $$ returned, not here in Kingwood. There are high end laminate that will show just as well. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

The engineered wood is amazing stuff.

I would go with that.

You do not want to over upgrade for your area. Doesn't matter what you put in your house, a house is only worth x amount of dollars. Got to take in location, neighborhood, etc.

So if you can upgrade with engineered wood, you have a great upgrade, but aren't pricing yourself out of your area. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Good point, Fallon. You definitely don't want to put more into the house than you'll get back...

but, upgrades, even in mediocre locations, make a difference.

Alli, if you're in Kingwood or Atas., you'll be able to get a decent price when the market gets back on track. Both areas have good schools and nice homes. :) 

whatchamacallit --- 16 years ago -

DO NOT GET REAL WOOD! It dents in with pets and and especially with kids! You will not see your $$ returned, not here in Kingwood. There are high end laminate that will show just as well.


Yes, real wood is a pain, however, so is laminate, at least the kind we have. We have Pergo and anywhere it gets wet, close to the seam, it buckles!!! I thought Pergo was a good quality but it has not been good to us. Why not tile? I have been wish-washing back and forth between saltillo and slate for a couple years! 

Mom's Taxi Service --- 16 years ago -

We're trying to decide between the wood/laminate versus slate tile for some floors we'll be re-doing in the coming year. I thought I had my mind set on laminate, but then I had a few people tell me about buckling issues they have had.

Good luck on your search! I'm glad you asked this question, I'm learning about these choices as well! 

Aah Grasshoppa --- 16 years ago -

Laminate is the way to go but don't do it yourself. Wears much better and looks great. 

dk156 --- 16 years ago -

I have laminate and love it have it for a year now and looks as good as it did when it was put in. I agree I would never do it myself we had showcase in Kingwood do the job and they did great. It is hard to put down, you have to prep the floor and make sure it is even. If it does not lay right it will be horrible. 

My 3 and Me --- 16 years ago -

We had the engineered hand scraped wood put in over the summer. It does not look cheap at all. I absolutely love it.

We got it through Carpet Connection in Humble for a great deal, $8.99 ft installed. 

Grumpy --- 16 years ago -

My Mother put laminate in her house. The kind that goes over a thin piece of Styrofoam. It never did lay flat, sort of slight scalloped look and she had an A/C leak that required replacing a lot of it plus the area she spilled stuff on.

I put an engineered real wood in my formal dining room. You know, that room you only use 2 times a year, so it has held up nicely. Cheaper than 100% real wood, looks nice, still a problem with water spills. 

midland --- 16 years ago -

Yes, real wood is a pain, however, so is laminate, at least the kind we have. We have Pergo and anywhere it gets wet, close to the seam, it buckles!!! I thought Pergo was a good quality but it has not been good to us. Why not tile? I have been wish-washing back and forth between saltillo and slate for a couple years!


We had bamboo flooring in our old house...my high heels would dent the wood, when we moved to Kingwood we ended up putting in tile for all of our main living areas. MUCH easier to maintain and better with kids/pets. ;) 

midland --- 16 years ago -

I just don't think the $$ for real wood floors or the effort to maintain is worth it with such good laminate products. I can see if we lived in an area that had lots of old homes with beautiful real wood floors...but we don't, so if YOU don't care, then I just don't feel it's worth the money. BUT, in the end, what would you want? If money is a little tight and a laminate is what you can afford...DO IT and enjoy it for how ever long you are in your home. It will still be better than old carpet when it comes to selling it. ;) 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

We got it through Carpet Connection in Humble for a great deal, $8.99 ft installed.

That's waaaaaayyy more than I want to spend. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

Slate, wears great, looks great, wears great did I say looks great. About the same price. 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

It all depends on your home Alli. If your neighborhood sales are showing wood floors your grade of your home may need it as well. Try lumber liquidators for all three wood,engineered, and laminate.

We have slate, and it is hard on your feet, back and knees. It is durable. 

Nightstorm --- 16 years ago -

DO NOT GET REAL WOOD! It dents in with pets and and especially with kids! You will not see your $$ returned, not here in Kingwood. There are high end laminate that will show just as well.


I disagree.

Real wood over laminate for resale value......each and every day.

As for slate, the key is porousity. (sp?) Find out how porous it is. Highly porous slate is a pita to maintain. Avoid it at all costs. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Real wood over laminate for resale value......each and every day.

I'm pretty sure that I wouldn't make back the amount it would take to put in hardwood. 

Carla --- 16 years ago -

Alli,

Ask Nightowl about this because she has done a lot of research on it.

From what I have read, real wood isn't recommended for our area with the humidity and our concrete slabs. I can't remember the exact reasons though. I was told to go with the engineered with the real wood on top and the composite or whatever it is underneath.

There's nothing like the feel of real wood though. It's like it gives off its own energy. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

If you have the budget for wood. go for the real thing. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

byrt 

Scottie's Hottie --- 16 years ago -

We were dead set on wood UNTIL we talked to a flooring expert and realized two things. The price and the durability. We have engineered wood floors. My DH did the install himself and we spent about $2200 for a 900 sq ft area. Real wood would have had to be professionally installed and cost about $6500! No thank you!! 

ladyjane --- 16 years ago -

Please, somebody with real live dogs weigh in on this topic! I'm not talking poodles, let me hear about all-out dogs, lol. The flooring guy I talked to completely discouraged me about getting anything but real wood when he heard about my darlings, one of which is quite hefty. 

Paige Paige --- 16 years ago -

We have the real deal... All wood. And, we have a lab, Lady Jane :-). It has been wonderful for us. However, like anything there are different grades and qualities. I also like that when the time comes they can easily be refinished. I am not sure you could refinish laminate? However, if you are only hanging around a year or so who really cares, right? 

Paige Paige --- 16 years ago -

Allie... If you are thinking of cheap laminate you may reconsider. My friends top layer actually scratched off. So, there were whitish spots. Not scratch marks, but the part that looked wood actually was worn off. 

Paige Paige --- 16 years ago -

So jealous of you Scotties! I wish my dh would lift a finger for house projects! 

june --- 16 years ago -

We had engineered wood installed in dining, office. Real wood is in the kitchen, breakfast room. It was already here when we bought the house. I would have never put wood in a kitchen, but we have been here almost 20 yrs and it looks awesome still. The original owners did leave some extra pieces and years ago we had a dishwasher leak that required 4 or 5 boards to be replaced. It was a simple process. We have had kids, teens, dogs, cats, grandchildren put some pretty good wear on these floors and they have all held up beautifully. It was explained to me that the only difference in the durability of real wood vs. engineered wood is that engineered wood can be sanded down 2 or 3 times, real wood more times...but we have had the wood for 20 yrs and have never had to have it sanded so that being said--the engineered wood will give you many many years of use before needing to sand-if ever. The wood/engineered wood just "sounds" and feels better than laminate if you can swing it. Engineered wood goes on sale often and is cheaper than real wood..just as durable we have found though. The most durable, easy maintainance free floor ever though is tile we put in our den. With area rugs to warm it up, it looks great and never needs care. Just a damp mop. 

Shenanigans --- 16 years ago -

I would do laminate, but get a high quality laminate installed professionally. It's still cheaper than hardwood, but looks great if it's done right. We have laminate with two toddlers and two dogs and it's been great. It's easy to maintain and looks good. It also fits well in our price bracket so I know we haven't overspent :) 

midland --- 16 years ago -

Please, somebody with real live dogs weigh in on this topic! I'm not talking poodles, let me hear about all-out dogs, lol. The flooring guy I talked to completely discouraged me about getting anything but real wood when he heard about my darlings, one of which is quite hefty.


I stated earlier...with dogs and kids, real wood dents and scratches a lot easier than the laminate. Yes, you may have to replace some boards here and there but it's alot cheaper than in the long run than getting real wood. I have a 75 pound INSIDE dog! =) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground