Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The United States of Inequality

who's talking here?

2131MR 1
AuthorMan 1
Donkey Hodie 5
david 1
justforfun 1
~sassy~ 1
Warren Peace 5
Mark 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

http://www.slate.com/id/2266025/entry/2266026/?GT1=38001

In 1915, a statistician at the University of Wisconsin named Willford I. King published The Wealth and Income of the People of the United States, the most comprehensive study of its kind to date. The United States was displacing Great Britain as the world's wealthiest nation, but detailed information about its economy was not yet readily available; the federal government wouldn't start collecting such data in any systematic way until the 1930s. One of King's purposes was to reassure the public that all Americans were sharing in the country's newfound wealth.

King was somewhat troubled to find that the richest 1 percent possessed about 15 percent of the nation's income. (A more authoritative subsequent calculation puts the figure slightly higher, at about 18 percent.)

This was the era in which the accumulated wealth of America's richest families—the Rockefellers, the Vanderbilts, the Carnegies—helped prompt creation of the modern income tax, lest disparities in wealth turn the United States into a European-style aristocracy. The socialist movement was at its historic peak, a wave of anarchist bombings was terrorizing the nation's industrialists, and President Woodrow Wilson's attorney general, Alexander Palmer, would soon stage brutal raids on radicals of every stripe. In American history, there has never been a time when class warfare seemed more imminent.
Advertisement

That was when the richest 1 percent accounted for 18 percent of the nation's income. Today, the richest 1 percent account for 24 percent of the nation's income.
 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

So they earn 24% of the nation's income yet pay almost 40% of all income tax revenues collected by the government.

Is it realistic to expect equality? What's the wisdom in trying to socially engineer equality? 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

So they earn 24% of the nation's income yet pay almost 40% of all income tax revenues collected by the government.

Is it realistic to expect equality? What's the wisdom in trying to socially engineer equality?


If that's the message you get from reading the entire article, along with the slideshow, then wow. Wow. That's all I have to say. 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

Does reading the article obligate me to be a mere chearleader for what appears to be a one-sided judgement about wealth, or am I permitted independent thought? 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

I just thought that there is a lot more to comment on and think about than the tired old attack on progressive income tax, especially when in real dollars (as opposed to a percentage) that progressive tax is now smaller than ever for the super rich. But go ahead and keep on attacking something (progressive tax rates) that nobody sane is arguing against. 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

Attack on the progressive income tax? You may have misread. I'm adding some levity to the attack on the wealthy common among journalists pretending to understand the economy.

Using income tax statistics to attack the wealthy for their role in this nation's economy is hardly a winning tactic when you consider that 74% of the top bracket income tax filers are all small businesses.

What's the wisdom in raising the cost of doing business, especially when the predictable result is fewer jobs created?

My comments weren't an attack, I was adding to the conversation by questioning whether it was even right to expect equality in the first place? Care to comment? 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

I'd much rather discuss the growing income disparity between the super rich and the rest of the country, and why it's a bad thing. 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

Ok, how about recognizing that a growing income disparity is inevitable based on math alone?

Every year, the bottom income will always be $0. If 100 years ago, the top 1% wage earners averaged, $200,000 per year, and both increased by the same rate of inflation, would you expect the gap would always be $200,000 or would you expect that the top salary would increase while the bottom would stay the same? If the top income wages grow while the bottom stays at zero, of course the gap will always be growing. That's what a healthy, growing economy looks like!

Of course it's the latter. The bottom will always be zero. So do you want stagnant wages, or do you want growth? Or are you one of these people who believes that if every income bracket fails to grow at the same rate, then this is a symptom that something is wrong? 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I'd much rather discuss the growing income disparity between the super rich and the rest of the country, and why it's a bad thing.


Class envy is getting old.

The more you bring to the table, the more you earn, the further you go.

Are you suggesting employers pay an uneducated janitor the same as a college graduate? 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

Class envy is getting old.

Is it class envy when I'm in the top 10%?

Are you suggesting employers pay an uneducated janitor the same as a college graduate?

No, but I think it's a good idea to pay CEOs only 20 or 30 times the salary of middle management, instead of 200 or 300 times. 

david --- 16 years ago -

No, but I think it's a good idea to pay CEOs only 20 or 30 times the salary of middle management, instead of 200 or 300 times. 

why ...CEO pay should be have a base of there bonus should be based on how the company performs, no limit on the amount... Now with that being said if a CEO runs a company in the ground or doesn't meet wall street expectations There bonus should be 0. 

Mark --- 16 years ago -

Lets say the top one percent only holds one percent of the nation’s wealth. Would the nation be what it is today? (Say, without the industrial revolution) IMHO it’s the drive and dreams of that other 99 percent in trying to acquire a piece of that pie that continues economic growth. 

2131MR --- 16 years ago -

" I'd much rather discuss the growing income disparity between the super rich and the rest of the country, and why it's a bad thing.
"

Economic inequality creates social instability. Where do you think socialism and unionism came from in the first place.
The math that created today's inequality may be simple, but it certainly wasn't inevitable. Today's inequality has largely been fed by the economic decisions we have made over the last few decades. These have resulted in a 400% increase in income for the wealthy, accompanied by a 50% tax reduction. 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

Bet I can put a smile on lib's face!

Why not fix it to where everyone in the country makes the exact same wage.

Now, if that statement made you smile....

shame on you! 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

Bet I can put a smile on lib's face!

Why not fix it to where everyone in the country makes the exact same wage.

Now, if that statement made you smile....

shame on you!




Isn't that what Obama is trying to do? To reward failure and punish those who strive to do better. 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

Any idea why the world's Carnegies, Rockefellers, Fords, Waltons, and Gates, among others are mostly American? Does anyone think this was by accident?

I'd suggest we needed a capitalistic system that rewards wealth creation. The best way to succeed at the levels these folks did is to innovate efficiencies that no one else has an incentive to produce.

If we have income inequalities, that's an acceptable trade-off to the efficiencies produced.

It's also not an accident that our lower income wage earners have probably one of the highest standards of living in the world. Generations ago it would have been unheard of for poor people to live in a home with central air and heat, have one or more color TVs, own a car, and so on. It has not been socialistic nations that redefine poverty upwards like we do in the US. It has been capitalistic systems. Wealth creation is the most successful cure to poverty there is.

Third world nations looking for the recipe to success to lift their country out of poverty need only review an American history book. It's all there for the taking.


Economic inequality creates social instability. Where do you think socialism and unionism came from in the first place.

I disagree. The pretense of having "solutions" to income inequality inherent in free enterprise can be more dangerous than the "problem" of income inequality. It is precisely because of well-intended but ill-advised political "solutions" that we have socialism and unionism. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground