Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Moore Capitalism

who's talking here?

planemom 2
maverick 1
NoNameNoLastName 3
david 4
justforfun 4
~sassy~ 1
Meme2my5 1
Wilstar77 2
Warren Peace 7
Ogre1 1
ladyjane 1
JohnLynch 1
Wynter 1
jamie 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Warren Peace --- 17 years ago -

I know this thread won't be for everyone. For those that don't care, don't come back to it. There's enough real estate on the message board for sharing. But Michael Moore is a divisive character with a very influential role. Some folks love his movies and are lead by them. Others like myself watch his movies for other reasons. I think Michael Moore expects us to take him seriously and to take his films seriously. Yet his films tend to have half-truths, questionable supporting evidence, and often contradictory evidence. For me, the artistry of his works is the way he presents quotes and footage out of context and use despicably dishonest editing tricks to create an impression that helps steer some viewers into his way of thinking. I wanted to see his new film called Capitalism: A Love Story for several reasons. The whole incongruity of Moore making an anti-capitalist movie reminded me of the Dave Chappelle skit of Clayton Bigsby - a blind, black Klansman pontificating about hating black people, because it never occurred to him that he was black. There aren’t many countries in the world where the son of an auto worker could grow up to be one of the wealthiest propaganda film-makers in history. To do this, Moore needed to be born into a social and economic system that grants folks the freedom to build off their decisions, sacrifices, investments, and reputation to freely work and negotiate with others to build his wealth. There’s no way he believes his claim that capitalism is evil. Surely he would practice what he preaches, right? So I wanted to see this movie to find out how this artist would make an economic system that embraces freedom better than any present alternatives - appear to be less desirable than those alternatives according to the criteria of his choosing. I also wanted to review how he supports his claims that “capitalism is evil” But I wanted the full effect of watching while immersed as much as possible in the socialist subculture, so I decided to attend a showing in the lion’s den - an independent film center (Angelika) on opening day. I expected the theater to be packed. By my estimates, it was about 50% full/empty. I'll try to post some of what he presents in his movie in this thread, as well some obvious information he chose to leave out. It may take some time to plug in everything worth sharing, but doing it this way will create a place-holder for it. Others are welcome to contribute their own thoughts or take any position for or against Moore and this movie 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

I was watching him last night and he comes across as a joke. All he wants is money and doesn't care how he gets it. If he doesn't like capitalism why does he choose to live here and make multimillion dollar films lying to the people? 

Warren Peace --- 17 years ago -

The film briefly touches on seemingly unjust practices such as employers that take out life insurance policies on employees, as well as the take-home pay of pilots. These were odd insertions to the larger storyline which seemed to focus on the relationship between large banking institutions and politicians. But my first comment will focus on one of his minor segments. One of the seemingly offensive practices he presented is something called “dead peasant insurance”. I had never heard of it before this film, but had heard of employers being able to insure employees. Makes sense to me that businesses should consider employees their most valuable assets especially if they show special skills or talents that are hard to find. When an employer attaches a value of $70,000 on the value of an employee at Walmart, that employee should feel honored in my mind. But when they die and the policy pays up, it sure doesn’t look good, depending on what happens with that money. If the family doesn’t get to share in the payout, that certainly doesn’t look good regardless of whether or not there are tax laws that prohibit it. That’s the part Moore exploits and presents half truths. In the body of the film, Moore makes it seem that Walmart (trendy evil corporation) routinely engages in this practice in order to profit from the deaths of their employees. Moore tells us that it is illegal for us to take out an insurance policy against someone else’s home with us as the beneficiary, therefore it should be illegal for an employer to do the same. But this comparison is a typical example of one of Moore’s half truths. Someone else’s home may not be valuable to me. But an employee may be very valuable to me. I may suffer tremendous losses if a valuable employee dies. It may be similar to, but not equal to what a family member does. So why shouldn’t the family approach be permitted in the workplace? It turns out it is permitted. In fact, it is used worldwide and is more widely known as “key person insurance”. But that wouldn’t play as well in an anti-capitalism movie. Instead, the much older phrase “dead peasant insurance” matches up much better with his agenda. Oh, and one other important nugget - Walmart discontinued this practice 10 years ago due to their well-intended approach backfiring on them with negative p.r. But you wouldn’t know that from watching this film. To protect himself from obvious claims of libel, this skilled propaganda artist buried this fact in the back-end of the film’s credits with a phrase that reads, “Walmart no longer uses dead peasant insurance” (as if Moore’s expose’ had anything to do with it). For more detailed information on Walmart’s use of these policies that didn’t fit with Moore’s agenda are provided here: LINK So does this serve as even partial proof that "capitalism is evil"? I don't think so. It doesn't appear to me that anyone is harmed by this practice. The most harm is risked by the employer. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

Moore did say "Capitalism Did Nothing For Me" 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Moore did say "Capitalism Did Nothing For Me" Let him go to Cuba or somewhere like that and see how much he is allowed to make. He would think differently. 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

All you guys need is Maverick to comment on this thread so you guy can begin stroking each other. 

david --- 17 years ago -

All you guys need is Maverick to comment on this thread so you guy can begin stroking each other. wilstarr can you explain why moore is against capitalism yet is making millions off capitalim, sounds like a hypocrite to me jmho 

jamie --- 17 years ago -

All you guys need is Maverick to comment on this thread so you guy can begin stroking each other. Hmmm....he hit the nail on the head with that one! 

david --- 17 years ago -

Hmmm....he hit the nail on the head with that one! so jamie explain why moore is making millions off the very thing he calls evil? 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

In regards to employers buying insurance policies on their employees: Does he feel Hollywood should quit doing this too? Aren't many stars insured during the filming of a movie or if they are regulars on sitcoms? 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Hmmm....he hit the nail on the head with that one! so jamie explain why moore is making millions off the very thing he calls evil? I want to hear the answer to that. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

as well as the take-home pay of pilots. The economy is taking care of this problem. Pilots today will not see the pay that pilots used to receive. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Soon everyone will be working for minimum wage for the government. How fun and exciting that will be. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

sn't care how he gets it. If he doesn't like capitalism why does he choose to live here and make multimillion dollar films lying to the people? Well said sister! 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

His movie is a flop. No one is buying what he's selling.. 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

From what he said in his Larry King Interview is that he's only against this form of capitalism. In the old days, people made money by making things (in his case he makes movies). Now a days, wall street makes money on money. They place bets on the outcome of money then bet the other side, then make money on insurance for either outcome. It's proven it can fail. He asked another great question. Would Jesus be a "Capitolist"? Would he approve of this practice? I haven't seen his movie, I'll probably wait until it comes out on video. 

Warren Peace --- 17 years ago -

He asked another great question. Would Jesus be a "Capitolist"? Would he approve of this practice? A great question? I don't recall ever reading anything about Jesus's study of economics. He was tasked with building spirituality, not gross domestic product. But if we want to go there, surely Jesus would embrace an economic system that embraced freedom. True spirituality means that your life's choices influence your outcome, regardless of your starting point. If Jesus studied economics in this era, he would notice that nothing overcomes poverty more than the creation of wealth. He would notice that the economic and social system that made the US the wealthiest nation in the world has also made the US more generous than any other. Jesus would be unable to name a single nation that has done more to overcome poverty and starvation than the system of capitalism operating in the US. Jesus would probably notice that in the majority of nations poverty equals starvation. But oddly in the US, what we refer to as poverty somehow equals significantly higher obesity rates. We call this - a nice problem to have. Unfortunately even nice problems to have come with trade-offs. In this case, it is our higher obesity rates which contribute to much of our healthcare costs. Jesus would also notice that in 1971, only about 32 percent of all Americans enjoyed air conditioning in their homes. With the US form of capitalism, 76 percent of poor people had air conditioning within 30 years. In 1971, only 43 percent of Americans owned a color television. With the US form of capitalism, 97 percent of poor people owned at least one within 30 years. In 1971, 1 percent of American homes had a microwave oven. Within 30 years, 73 percent of poor Americans had one. Forty-six percent of poor households own their homes. Only about 6 percent of poor households are overcrowded. The average poor American has more living space than the average non-poor individual living in Paris, London, Vienna, Athens and other European cities. But wait, there's more Jesus would notice. Nearly three-quarters of poor households own a car; 30 percent own two or more cars. Seventy-eight percent of the poor have a VCR or DVD player; 62 percent have cable or satellite TV reception; and one-third have an automatic dishwasher. How many of the world's poor would LOVE to have the standard of living of the US's "poor". So to entertain your thoughts inspired by Michael Moore's comment, If Jesus were to inject economics into his spirituality, I'm pretty certain, Jesus would be preaching about how empowering people and businesses to market conditions and market signals is the better approach. Governments that impose price controls do not get the benefit of these market signals. Instead, they spend their careers fighting the effects of their own limited knowledge. Those effects hurt the poor much more than the wealthy. With an understanding and interest in economics, Jesus would be preaching that poverty is not static for people willing to work. Perhaps one of the Books of the 2009 era New Testament Redux would be a University of Michigan study which shows that only 5 percent of those in the bottom fifth of the income distribution in 1975 remained there in 1991. What? Read that again to make sure you caught that. Now ask yourself what happened to them. They moved up to the top three-fifths of the income distribution (middle class or higher). Three out of 10 of the lowest income earners in 1975 moved all the way into the top fifth of income earners by 1991. Those who were poor in 1975 had an inflation-adjusted average income gain of $27,745 by 1991. Those workers who were in the top fifth of income earners in 1975 were better off in 1991 by an average of only $4,354. What other economic system offers this scale of income mobility? Please name that system and the country that uses it. I'll be waiting for your answer. The bottom line is yes, the rich are getting richer. But so are the poor, thanks to the US version of capitalism which encourages its people to be the best you can be. It's a system that empowers the individual with alternatives to overcome hardships. With this body of evidence, Jesus would absolutely be preaching the freedom based tenants of capitalism. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

I think Michael Moore expects us to take him seriously and to take his films seriously. I take him seriously. The same way I take day-time talk shows seriously. 

Warren Peace --- 17 years ago -

Getting back to the film... Moore presents worker-owned companies as a model of success and a much better alternative to getting paid based on your relative productive value to the company. In his one or two examples, he features CEOs who earn the same wage as their bottom level employees. Interesting concept, isn’t it? I wonder why Michael Moore doesn’t use this model for his own film-making business? Doesn't "Put Your Money Where Your Mouth is 101" dictate leading by example? Perhaps some savvy camera man will interview Michael Moore's film crew, or the guy that gets paid to enable Moore's gluttony by fetching him bottomless milkshakes to inquire whether they get paid the same as their boss. What are the chances that these low level employees earn the same millions that Moore does? I'm guessing there are 2 chances: slim and none. 

maverick --- 17 years ago -

All you guys need is Maverick to comment on this thread so you guy can begin stroking each other. Hmmm....he hit the nail on the head with that one! I have no need to comment on this, Warren is handling it nicely, while you two mumble in the back of the class. Now this is priceless - In his one or two examples, he features CEOs who earn the same wage as their bottom level employees. Interesting concept, isn’t it? I wonder why Michael Moore doesn’t use this model for his own film-making business? Doesn't "Put Your Money Where Your Mouth is 101" dictate leading by example? Perhaps some savvy camera man will interview Michael Moore's film crew, or the guy that gets paid to enable Moore's gluttony by fetching him bottomless milkshakes to inquire whether they get paid the same as their boss. What are the chances that these low level employees earn the same millions that Moore does? I'm guessing there are 2 chances: slim and none. Bravo!!! 

Warren Peace --- 17 years ago -

Michael Moore did earn kudos for declaring that Congress was responsible for the banking failures of 2007 and 2008. But I was disappointed that he handed them an excuse in this film. Moore interviewed several guilty members of Congress who subject us to remarks of, “but they (Treasury officials) told us we HAD to do this or the economy would crash”. Even Moore himself does a brief narration about how this is not really the fault of the Congress because they were fooled, just like the Iraq War vote. It might be a silly question, but does anyone honestly believe he would have been this soft on Congress if there had been a majority of Republicans casting their votes this way? Where do we draw the line for holding Congress accountable? Does it really depend on political party? Of course we know the answer. Is there any act that Congress should be held accountable for? But a question Moore forgets to ask is - If those evil, mostly Republican capitalists were responsible for misleading these poor, ignorant Democrats who care for the people far more than their Republican opponents, why did Republican Senators oppose it in such larger numbers than Democrats? (only 18% of Democrats voted against it while 31% of Republicans opposed it). Why did 73% of Democrat House members vote in favor, while the majority Republicans (54%) voted against it? Why did I have to Google that rather than expect Moore to be honest about who the real villains were? 

ladyjane --- 17 years ago -

Would Jesus be a "Capitolist"? Would he approve of this practice? Since his earthly father made his living with his carpentry business, I am quite sure he would honor that kind of enterprise. Otherwise, I guess we'd hear about him going home to lecture Pops on how he should be giving his skills away. And the Bible describes the woman "more precious than jewels" as a business person and in very favorable terms. 

Warren Peace --- 17 years ago -

This movie did have some accuracies (yes, many of his movies do contain some difficult truths). One of them is Moore’s praiseworthy effort to paint Senator Christopher Dodd as a key villain. But this is also where he had a challenge with creating a hero. Because Moore's hero (Surprise - it's Obama!) can be seen in easy to obtain videos going out of his way to tell the public that Dodd was NOT a villain. But that wouldn't have helped sell Obama as the hero, so Moore's propaganda film left that part to the choice of viewers with Google skills to seek out. But surely this isn't something Obama and Moore worshippers are likely to Google anyway, right? Painting Obama as the hero was also made tough by Obama's support for another villain. An odd insertion was Moore’s presentation of Timothy Geithner. If a viewer were going strictly by Moore’s movie, it would be easy to assume that a very dumb and incompetent Geithner was appointed by Bush. Moore paints Geithner as one of the corrupt bad guys of this economic crisis. So why did he “forget” to tell us that Geithner was appointed by Obama with much opposition from the right based on Geithner’s failure to file and pay taxes. As stated, Moore ends the movie by presenting Obama as the hero. Yet where was the easy to obtain C-Span footage of then Senator Obama trying to persuade his colleagues that they must vote for this very bill that Moore now says is the epitome of government corruption and greed? Why did Moore conceal from us that Obama voted for the bailout bill that Moore focuses on as epitomizing what is wrong with politics today? The thunderous applause from the Obama/Moore worshippers in the theater suggested to me that they had no independent knowledge of such things that Moore did not address. Finally and more importantly, why did Moore not accurately paint this bill as corporate socialism? Following the tenants of capitalism, these institutions should have experienced the consequences of their actions. That is what capitalism looks like. But the historical record shows that we did not let capitalism do what it does. Instead, with some artistic effort of propaganda, the effort of our politicians to use socialist solutions was presented as a bad effect of capitalism. I was stunned as the audience in the theater erupted into wild applause, but seemed clueless as to how Moore just deceived them. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Given the proper discount (which is required when watching Moore's films), "Capitalism" does touch a few interesting points: 1. Our government (democrats and republicans alike) no longer represents the people - only corporations. 2. Our best minds are no longer producing "stuff that other people want to buy", but working on "let's create wealth out of recycling existing wealth". 3. Capitalism works at its best when guided by ethics. Unfortunately, ethics is in short supply lately. 4. It's up to us to change things. 

Wynter --- 17 years ago -

All he wants is money and doesn't care how he gets it. You,justforfun, are really clueless. You, NoName, are not. Great post. 

david --- 17 years ago -

Nnnln or wynter care to respind to warrens message about moore making the same as his lo lever employees 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Nnnln or wynter care to respind to warrens message about moore making the same as his lo lever employee I did not read them, and no, I don't care to "respind" about "lo lever employee". I watched the film yesterday, and unlike republicans who only focus on negatives, I'm focusing on the interesting points Moore makes. If you want to debate those, I'm happy to do it. After the movie, I walked from the Angelika to the Verizon theater to see Alice Cooper. That was a nice cap for the night. 

david --- 17 years ago -

Didn't figure you woukd want to admit the hypocrite that moore is by praising one person yet doing the opposite himself. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Didn't figure you woukd want to admit the hypocrite that moore is by praising one person yet doing the opposite himself.  I don't let the messenger influence the opinion I have of the message. But I know this is a completely foreign concept for you. 

Warren Peace --- 17 years ago -

I think the better lesson from Moore's film (if he had fully explored it) is the philosophical fallacy that our politicians must do something for every unpleasant occurrence. We would not have this economic crisis today if politicians had simply found it acceptable that many renters could not afford to buy homes. Without creating an incentive for banks to begin changing their lending standards of requiring loan applicants to make a 20% deposit or a 33% debt to income ratio, we would probably continue to be enjoying an unemployment rate around 5%. Afterall, without an abundance of risky loans, there would not have been an incentive to create bundled mortgage backed securities. There would not have been an incentive for banks to shop around among debt ratings agencies to obtain a rating for a fairly new financial instrument that debt ratings agencies lacked a historical knowledge of in order to rate accurately. Capitalism works best when decision makers are allowed to experience the consequences of being wrong. If only politicians would be subject to this notion. I would love to see our politicians debate bills based on incentives that are created rather than their intentions. Yet it always seems their good intentions gets the public's attention. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news
politics
rant


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground