Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Kroger's Corporation supports discrimination against the Military

who's talking here?

GCan 1
JDB2 3
JerseyGirl 1
randyjet 8
Justwatching72 1
rose8304 4
Joybell 1
ShortyMama 1
Brennan 1
firsttimemom 5
AFWife 8
OH SNAP! 3
ladybughomeschool 3
POTUS 2
zapper007 2
JohnLynch 1
james osterberg 1
Cowboys Wife 1
Snake1235 1
Todd 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Todd --- 17 years ago -

My 22 yr old son visits from out of state. His first visit was on July 4th, where he stopped at Krogers NorthPark to purchase some food and beer for our cookout. Krogers refused to accept his Drivers License as it was issued out of state and then they refused to accept his Military ID. He was told that he "looked young" hence they would not accept his ID's. I wrote to Krogers National HR Dept. where they informed me that the Krogers Corporation supports this position. This happened again this Labor Day. I went back to the Store with my son and spoke with the Store Manager (James McLin) who informed me that in his opinion, my son looked too young regardless of his Military or State issued Driver License. Now my son refuses to go to Krogers for anything. What disturbs me most is that both of these are legal ID's and they have refused due to his "looks". No other reason could they give - only they didn't agree with his looks. They have essentially employed a discriminatory policy through the sujective determination of someones "looks". If the Store or Krogers Corporation doesn't agree or like your looks they have reserved the right to refuse you the same service (discriminate) they offer the general public that they believe looks right. If you agree with me that this is wrong, (ethically and legally) please let Krogers know. I will be pursueing this through every legal channel I am able to. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

I will be pursueing this through every legal channel I am able to. I can understand your frustration. What are your actually damages ? I am sorry , I just do not understand how monetary gain on your part is going to set this straight. I am glad that stores like Kroger enforce laws that attempt to help the problem of underage drinking. I am sorry that you feel discriminated against. My dh always looked young and was carded until he was 30. Did ya'll get your beer or have to do without ? 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

Also, did they discriminate because he looked young or because he was in the military. it sounds like military had little to do with it. 

ShortyMama --- 17 years ago -

I don't think we are talking monetary gain, just that their policy be changed. My brother is also military and they refused him service to buy beer also. I don't understand how Kroger can deny 2 forms of legal i.d. My brother also had an out of state i.d. I could possibly see it if they only had the state id and no military id. 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

My point is that we cannot have it both ways. Kroger sells beer so they are responsible for selling only to those of legal age. I would be much more upset if they were lax on their policies than if they are too rigid about the forms of ID. You are free to buy beer anywhere, just go down the road a bit and get the beer . 

Justwatching72 --- 17 years ago -

"If you look under 35 prepare to be carded." I see that sign all over the place. Kroger also has the right to refuse out of state and military id's because they have no way of knowing if they are fake or not. They have nothing to compare them to. It sucks, but not much you can do. 

AFWife --- 17 years ago -

I can understand being carded, the problem is you have to show multiple forms of identification to get a military id which also contains your SS#. Most people do not understand what this ID means therefore chalk it up to poor training. I never showed my out of state id's when visiting...only my military ID but have never had a problem. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

I think the title of this thread is very misleading. He was discriminated against because he looks young and has an out of state license. Sucks, but it has nothing to do with the military. I do agree that the checkers could use better training, though. 

zapper007 --- 17 years ago -

They NEVER have to sell you anything. An ID cannot ever force a sale of any product. Sorry to frustrate you, but this is life. The store assumes all the risk if they sell to a minor... 

zapper007 --- 17 years ago -

Kroger's Corporation supports discrimination against the Military Please change the title of this article. Whappened to your son has absolutely nothing to do with Kroger's discriminating against anybody. That was a very cheap shot against Kroger's...jmho 

firsttimemom --- 17 years ago -

Kroger doesn't allow cashiers to accept out of state ID, or military ID because of it being fake. Kroger employees people to come in and test the cashiers. You have to ID everyone under 40. If you get caught not iding, selling to out of state customers you will be terminated and possibly fined. There are signs hanging over the beer that gives a number to complain about the sale of alcoholic beverages. If someone is carded because you card up to the appearance of 40 and has an out of state id the manager then makes the choice as to whether to sell the product. If the look to be in there 20's the are going to be declined, but if they look to be in there 40's then it will be accepted. You don't know if the customer is really TABC or not. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

An ID cannot ever force a sale of any product. An ID cannot but the LAW can. This is rank discrimination and it is ILLEGAL! Since he has a legitimate Federal ID, that is quite sufficient to prove his bona fides. Think that you will get to refuse the FBI or other police agency since it is NOT a state of Texas ID? I had the same problem when I can back from overseas and I was in the military. Only my state drivers license had NO picture on it and they would not take my military ID either. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

Like I said, the cashiers probably need a clarification on that issue. If I was in the position of getting fired or fined if I accidentally accept a fake ID, you better believe I'd err on the side of caution. If Kroger accepts military IDs, they need to make the cashiers specifically aware of it and train them on what a legit military ID looks like. I know people who have been denied entrance into clubs with a passport. It happens. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Krogers DOES have an obligation to educate its employees who sell alcohol so that they DO know what a valid military ID looks like and how to spot fakes. Otherwise they are disrespecting those who make a sacrifice for all of us. I think that is the very least that they can do. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

You don't know if the customer is really TABC or not. By the way, if TABC tries to use s fake military ID, THEY WILL go to jail! You CAN be damn sure that if somebody presents a military ID that it is real and not a setup, or it will be a fake that can be easily spotted. THEN Krogers can call the FBI and have them arrested. 

firsttimemom --- 17 years ago -

The only id that will be 100 % accepted is a valid Texas ID. That is what all cashiers are trained to accept. You can call the complaint number that hangs over the beer if you want clarification on the policy of the TABC. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Whappened to your son has absolutely nothing to do with Kroger's discriminating against anybody They ARE discriminating against the military since they will NOT accept their ID. They also discriminate against out of state drivers licenses too. The members of the military are moved around constantly from state to state, and cannot get drivers licenses from all of those states. Thus the only thing that they have to rely on for proof is their military ID. By refusing to honor that, Krogers is putting ANOTHER burden on our troops. THAT is UNFAIR and DISCRIMINATORY! 

firsttimemom --- 17 years ago -

The law does provide a statutory defense to the charge of selling an alcoholic beverage to a minor when the seller has asked for and examined an apparently valid DPS issued Texas DL or ID card which contains a physical description consistent with the presenter's appearance and shows the presenter to be 21 years of age of older. For that reason, since store clerks, wait staff, and bartenders can be held criminally liable for selling alcohol to a minor, they often require a Texas Driver's License or Texas Identification Card issued by the Department of Public Safety, to prove that the person really is 21. A store, bar or restaurant might or might not sell alcohol to a person with an out-of-state driver's license, military ID, or passport. What's acceptable in any establishment is a matter of that establishment's private business policies. 

firsttimemom --- 17 years ago -

Military personnel who are living in Texas temporarily may obtain an official Identification Card from the Texas Department of Public Safety without giving up their out-of-state driver's license. They can obtain one for $15. 

firsttimemom --- 17 years ago -

Mail the completed complaint form to: Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission Enforcement Division P.O. Box 13127 Austin, TX 78711 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

Question-are you allowed to carry ID other than military when in the service? A kid in his uniform ahead of me in line at a exxon wanted a lighter. the cleark would not accept his Military ID. I started bit*Hing her out and gave the guy both may lighters and bought one for myself. The country sometimes forgets about what the soldiers are even doing from day to day.all caught up in the politics. 

AFWife --- 17 years ago -

All that they had to do was look at date of birth...like I said.."uneducated" My military ID carries a full description of me, SS#, my dh's SS# (he is the "sponser") & if you are active duty they most likely have the CAC card, you cannot mistake this for any other type & it cannot be forged. 

JDB2 --- 17 years ago -

You CAN be damn sure that if somebody presents a military ID that it is real and not a setup, or it will be a fake that can be easily spotted. THEN Krogers can call the FBI and have them arrested. are you serious rj? 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

At one time, my mom only had her military ID and she use to get a lot of grief from cashiers saying it wasn't valid. The problem was often that they did not know the correct key sequence for their registers. They were just use to pressing the sequence for TDL. It's not surprising since we're not a military town. 

AFWife --- 17 years ago -

Update to TABC laws: Law Updates Prior to June 2009, a person who sold a minor an alcoholic beverage had a defense available if the minor provided a fake Texas driver’s license or ID card that showed the minor was 21 years old. As a result, many retail locations in Texas require that young-looking customers provide a Texas driver’s license or identifi cation card, and refuse to accept any other form of ID as proof of age. Senate Bill 693 fi led by Senator Leticia Van de Putte extended the defense to any photo ID issued by a state or the federal government, including out-of-state driver’s licenses, military ID’s or U.S. passports. Govenor Rick Perry signed the bill on June 19, 2009, and the new law went into effect immediately. SB693 Creates New Defense for Retailers Selling to Minors Section 106.03 of the Alcoholic Beverage Code now states that a person who sells a minor an alcoholic beverage does not commit an offense if the minor falsely represents himself to be 21 years old or older by displaying an apparently valid proof of identifi cation that contains a physical description and photograph consistent with the minor’s appearance, purports to establish that the minor is 21 years of age or older, and was issued by a governmental agency. The new defense is available to a person regardless of when the offense was committed but only for trials commencing on or after June 19, 2009. TABC will be notifying retailers of the new law, updating the website and asking seller training schools to update their curriculum. 

JDB2 --- 17 years ago -

it is always better safe than sorry, the price of making a mistake (selling to a minor) is too high. 

Joybell --- 17 years ago -

TABC will be notifying retailers of the new law, updating the website and asking seller training schools to update their curriculum. ...and so you've got to give the retailers some time to implement this curriculum AFTER you give TABC enough time to update their website, training, etc. C'mon, people, it's BEER. We're not talking about life-saving medication that was withheld. SHEESH. 

AFWife --- 17 years ago -

Yeah, but your talking not just "some" card...and yes, it was beer but it's sad if your Mom has to come buy your beer! here is the wiki description (easier lingo than CAC/Homeland Security) The CAC is used as a general identification card as well as for authentication to enable access to DoD computers, networks, and certain DoD facilities. It also serves as an identification card under the Geneva Conventions.[1] The CAC enables encrypting and cryptographically signing email, facilitating the use of PKI authentication tools, and establishes an authoritative process for the use of identity credentials. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

it is always better safe than sorry, the price of making a mistake (selling to a minor) is too high. Since the law HAS been changed, Krogers has NO defense against discrimination charges if they present a military or out of state ID. THAT is a FACT. It is as though they refused to sell to a black guy. That person would have a cause of action against Krogers. I think some folks should let Kroger know that some lawyers would like to talk to their lawyers, and I bet it gets changed quickly. 

JDB2 --- 17 years ago -

I think rj should file suit against the mother....if she hadn't discriminated against the military, she'd have gotten the beer for her son.... yep, I'm kidding, but that is how silly you guys are. If Kroger's cannot be sure the id is unaltered, they have the right to not accept it. You guys would be just as upset if they sold it to a minor with a fake id and he/she had a fatal accident....you are being completely unreasonable....and btw, I am a veteran that looked very young...I had the same problem. It isn't a big deal, go to the next store. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

So now Randy is an expert on Kroger's alcohol sales policies and the TABC? =D 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

It isn't a big deal, go to the next store. too simple of a solution for many people 

AFWife --- 17 years ago -

yep, I'm kidding, but that is how silly you guys are. If Kroger's cannot be sure the id is unaltered, they have the right to not accept it. You guys would be just as upset if they sold it to a minor with a fake id and he/she had a fatal accident....you are being completely unreasonable....and btw, I am a veteran that looked very young...I had the same problem. It isn't a big deal, go to the next store. Point is...stores need to update their so-called training for personnel regarding types of ID cards. If you don't recognize a type of identification & you work for a customer-service type job then educate yourself. Hard to go to the next store when they don't know what they are doing either. 

Cowboys Wife --- 17 years ago -

Oh hell, send him over here. I have a nice Pinot. I can see both sides here. Sticky situation. But surely not one to get your undies in a wad over. 

Brennan --- 17 years ago -

"If you look under 35 prepare to be carded." I see that sign all over the place. Kroger also has the right to refuse out of state and military id's because they have no way of knowing if they are fake or not. They have nothing to compare them to. It sucks, but not much you can do. that is wrong i know when i worked for HEB we were given a sheet of all state card, there was one at each register and i know working for randals years ago they did the smae thing. if the cashier had a concern of the id it shoudl have been taken to a manager for further ruling out. 

rose8304 --- 17 years ago -

An ID cannot but the LAW can. This is rank discrimination and it is ILLEGAL! Since he has a legitimate Federal ID, that is quite sufficient to prove his bona fides. Think that you will get to refuse the FBI or other police agency since it is NOT a state of Texas ID? Have you ever taken a TABC class? Once you have, you are personally responsible if you sell alcohol or cigarettes to minors. Personally responsible. That means jail. TABC gives the ID checker the right to refuse any ID that they are not sure of which includes any ID that is not a Texas ID. I wouldn't risk my job so you could have beer no matter what kind of ID you showed me. That's not discrimination. If the cashier hasn't personally taken the TABC class, then the store is held responsible. It has nothing to do with the military or military IDs or whether they can be forged or not. It has to do with the cashier doing her job. How was she supposed to know that an ID that she isn't familiar with isn't fake? 

rose8304 --- 17 years ago -

if the cashier had a concern of the id it shoudl have been taken to a manager for further ruling out. Not if the cashier was TABC certified. Being certified makes it a personal liability. If the manager says the ID should be accepted but then it goes on the record that I sold to a minor, that's on me. Not worth my job. 

AFWife --- 17 years ago -

Not if the cashier was TABC certified Well then keep up with the new laws as stated above. 

rose8304 --- 17 years ago -

Well then keep up with the new laws as stated above. Yes, they should've been up to date with all the rules. That was wrong. It wasn't discrimination though. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Have you ever taken a TABC class HAVE YOU READ THE LAW? It states that there is NO LIABILTY for accepting a fake ID! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground